LAW OFFICES ARTHUR M. liastburn I'JI l-l ( )71 SAMUEL S. GRAY, JR OF COUNSEL: FRANK N. GALLAGHER KENNETH R. WILLIAMS

Transcription

1 LAW OFFICES ARTHUR M. liastburn I'JI l-l ( )71 SAMUEL S. GRAY, JR EASTBURN AND GRAY, P.C. 470 NORRISTOWN ROAD SUITE 302 RLUEIIELL, PA FAX: EAST COURTSTREET P.O. liox 1389 DOYLESTOWN, PA FAX: THOMAS F. J. MacANtFF DEREK J. RE ID* JOANNE D. SOMMER DAVID L MARSHALL G. MICHAEL CARR* WJIJJAM T. DUDEC'fv* KIMBERLY L1TZKE MARC D. JONAS JULIE L. VON SPRECKELSEN* ROBERT R. WATSON. JR. DEAN H. MALIK MICHAEL J. SAVONA SARAH A, EASTBURN* It. REX HERDER. JR. OF COUNSEL: FRANK N. GALLAGHER KENNETH R. WILLIAMS JOHN A. VAN LUVANEE D. RODMAN EASTBURN JOHN N. SCHAEFFER, 111 GRACE M. DEON* ROBERT M. COX* JUDITH A, ALGEO KELLIE A, McGOWAN* JUDY L. HAYMAN* MARK S. CAPPUCC10 HUGH J. ALGEO. IV* MICHAEL Ii. f'eters* ERIN N. KERNAN* JOSEPH E. BRESNAN CHARLES i l. DORSETT. JR. ERIC R.TOBIN JOSEPH E. BRESNAN. ESQUIRE E-MA1L:JBRESNAN@EASTBURNGRAY.C0M PLEASE REPLY TO: BLUE HELL OFFICE ALSO MlMITTKIl!N NHW Jt'.RSKY Rsemary Chiavetta, Secretary PA Public Utility Cmmissin Cmmnwealth Keystne Bldg. 400 Nrth Street Harrisburg, PA Rc: Pa. Public Utility Cmmissin Brugh f Ambler March PI TO -< cr CO cr CD - -1 rr? m Dear Secretary. Chiavetla: Attached fr filing is Ambler Brugh's Answer t Cmplaint in the abve-referenced prceeding. Cpies have been served per the attached Certificate f Service. Attachment

2 Pennsylvania Public Utility Cmmissin BEFORE THE PENNSYLVANIA PUBUC UTILITY COMMISSION CP --^ CP i - 1 Brugh Of Ambler- ANSWER AND NOW COMES, the Brugh Of Ambler - ("Brugh") and herein files its Answer t the Cmplaint filed by the Office f Cnsumer Advcate. The Answer is being filed pursuant t Sectin 5.61 f the Cmmissin's Rules f Practice. Further answering, Brugh states as fllws: 1. Admitted. 2. Admitted. 3. Admitted. 4. A. Admitted. B. The tariff speaks fr itself but this is believed t be an essentially accurate summary f the prpsed increase and is therefre admitted. C. Admitted. Ambler als serves custmers in the Brugh f Ambler, althugh this aspect f its service is nt regulated by the Cmmissin.

3 D. Admitted. E. Cmplainant's statements are cnclusins, bth factual and legal, that are errneus. The prpsed increase is fully supprted by the filing and therefre Cmplainant's cnclusins are all denied. 5. N answer is required t a prayer fr relief. Nnetheless, Ambler denies the need fr public hearings and denies that there is any basis t suspend peratin f the prpsed supplement. WHEREFORE, fr all f the freging reasns, the Brugh f Ambler respectfully requests that the Cmplaint f the Office f Cnsumer Advcate be dismissed. Respectfully submitted JpseptVErBresnan, Esquire ^tty ID Cunsel, Ambler Brugh Eastburn & Gray 470 Nrristwn Rd. Suite 302 Blue Bell, PA , fax

4 BEFORE THE PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION Pennsylvania Public Utility Cmmissin Brugh Of Ambler- I hereby certify that I have this day served a true cpy f the freging dcument, Ambler Brugh's Answer t Cmplaint, upn parties f recrd in this prceeding in accrdance with the requirements f 52 Pa. Cde 1.54 (relating l service by a participant), in the manner and upn the persns listed belw: Dated this 20"' day f March 2014 SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL. POSTAGE PREPAID Christine Malni Hver Office f Cnsumer Advcate 555 Walnut Street S 11 ' Flr, Frum Place Harrisburg, PA Dennis Kalbarczyk Utility Rate Resurces 910 Piketwn Rd. Harristuirg, PA Regina L. Matz, Esquire Bureau f Investigatin & Enfrcement Pa. Public Utility Cmmissin 400 Nrth Street Harrisburg, PA Jhn R. Evans, Small Business Advcate Office f Small Business Advcate Suite 1102, Cmmerce Building 300 Nrth Secnd Street Harrisburg, PA J&pM'Sit Bresrfan, Esquire ' ''Cunsel, Ambler Brugh Eastburn & Gray 470 Nrristwn Rd. Suite 302 Blue Bell, PA , fax

5 LAW OFFICES ARTHUR M. EASTBURN SAMUEL S. GRAY, JR EASTBURN AND GRAY, P.C. 470 NORRISTOWN ROAD SUITE 302 BLUEBELL, PA FAX: EAST COURT STREET P.O.BOX 1389 DOYLESTOWN, PA () FAX: THOMAS F. J. MacANlFF DEREK J. REID* JOANNE D. SOMMER DAVID L. MARSHALL G. MICHAEL CARR* WILLIAM T. DUDECK* KIMBERLY LITZKE MARC D. JONAS JULIE L. VON SPRECKELSEN" ROBERT R. WATSON, JR. DEAN H. MALIK MICHAELJ. SAVONA SARAH A. EASTBURN* R. REX HERDER, JR. OF COUNSEL: FRANK N. GALLAGHER KENNETH R. WILLIAMS JOHN A. VAN LUVANEE D. RODMAN EASTBURN JOHN N. SCHAEFFER, III GRACE M. DEON* ROBERT M. COX* JUDITH A. ALGEO KELLIE A. McGOWAN* JUDY L. HAYMAN* MARK S. CAPPUCCIO HUGH J. ALGEO, IV* MICHAEL E. PETERS* ERINN. KERNAN* JOSEPH E. BRESNAN CHARLES II. DORSETT, JR. ERIC R. TOBIN JOSEPH E. BRESNAN, ESQUIRE E-M A 1L:J BR ESN AN@EASTBURNGRAY.COM PLEASE REPLY TO: BLUE BELL OFFICE Rsemary Chiavetta, Secretary PA Public Utility Cmmissin Cmmnwealth Keystne Bldg. 400 Nrth Street Harrisburg, PA MSO ADMITTI-D IK NEW JFRSKY March 20, 2014 Rc: Pa. Public Utility Cmmissin Brugh f Ambler Dear Secretary Chiavetta: Attached fr filing is Ambler Brugh's Answer t Cmplaint in the abve-referenced prceeding. Cpies have been served per the attached Certificate f Service. Respectful K^submitted, Attachment

6 Pennsylvania Public Utility Cmmissin BEFORE THE PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION Brugh Of Ambler ANSWER AND NOW COMES, the Brugh Of Ambler - ("Brugh") and herein files its Answer t the Cmplaint filed by the Office f Cnsumer Advcate. The Answer is being filed pursuant t Sectin 5.61 f the Cmmissin's Rules f Practice. Further answering, Brugh states as fllws: 1. Admitted. 2. Admitted. 3. Admitted. 4. A. Admitted. B. The tariff speaks fr itself but this is believed t be an essentially accurate summary f the prpsed increase and is therefre admitted. C. Admitted. Ambler als serves custmers in the Brugh f Ambler, althugh this aspect f its service is nt regulated by the Cmmissin.

7 D. Admitted. E. Cmplainant's statements are cnclusins, bth factual and legal, that are errneus. The prpsed increase is fully supprted by the filing and therefre Cmplainant's cnclusins are all denied. 5. N answer is required t a prayer fr relief. Nnetheless, Ambler denies the need fr public hearings and denies that there is any basis t suspend peratin f the prpsed supplement. WHEREFORE, fr all f the freging reasns, the Brugh f Ambler respectfully requests that the Cmplaint f the Office f Cnsumer Advcate be dismissed. Respectfully submitted seprv^ef Bresnan, Esquire 'Atty ID Cunsel, Ambler Brugh Eastburn & Gray 470 Nrristwn Rd. Suite 302 Blue Bell, PA , fax

8 BEFORE THE PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION Pennsylvania Public Utility Cmmissin Brugh Of Ambler - I hereby certify lhat I have this day served a true cpy f the freging dcument, Ambler Brugh's Answer t Cmplaint, upn parties f recrd in this prceeding in accrdance with the requirements f 52 Pa. Cde 1.54 (relating t service by a participant), in the manner and upn the persns listed belw: Dated this 20"' day f March 2014 SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL. POSTAGE PREPAID Christine Malni Hver Office f Cnsumer Advcate 555 Walnut Street 5" 1 Flr, Frum Place Harrisburg, PA 1710 M 923 Dennis Kalbarczyk Utility Rate Resurces 910 Piketwn Rd. Hairishiirg, PA Regina L. Matz, Esquire Bureau f Investigatin & Enfrcement Pa. Public Utility Cmmissin 400 Nrth Street Harrisburg, PA Jhn R. Evans, Small Business Advcate Office f Small Business Advcate Suite 1102, Cmmerce Building 300 Nrth Secnd Street Han-isburg, PA JtfCpiv^,: bresnan, I aire my ID 44017' "Cunsel, Ambler Brugh Eastburn & Gray 470 Nrristwn Rd. Suite 302 Blue Bell, PA , fax '.0 m CD c: m > cr r- 3*- r I rn m

9 cr.sti'jti"*; H> ''; ; ':*.y.?{". 170 N: t i'jiwi: :;:! Gtiile SO: ( sliseh.:'!. VA m?.:t Ct tu I O15H141O5Q00 $ /21/14 Hallnd Frm UJ O (f) CL tf) 3 CD rv* UJ Kscinr.ry OvavcHy, Sccr.'-Usiy I'A Vubiii: i.j'iiiiy Cir.nii^si- Cfr;rni!ivx;;i?^i KeyKw 'Huh* AOO N;-ll: S\rci:i Marrishuru, PA S00 =-'S C:CiC»Z= I.f.f lhflh,.l J j>..ll J jl i l.jll J. ii.ffj,]}».. JJ i.i> Iij. }