That's Your Evidence?: Using Mechanical Turk To Develop A Computational Account Of Debate And Argumentation In Online Forums
|
|
- Estella Barnett
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 That's Your Evidence?: Using Mechanical Turk To Develop A Computational Account Of Debate And Argumentation In Online Forums Natural Language and Dialogue Systems Lab Prof. Marilyn Walker
2 Debate and Deliberation: Key Human Activity Navy Research Lab funding IARPA, 3rd year of funding Identify subgroups on sides of issue
3 Persuasion and Argumentation on ConvinceMe
4 STANCE An overall position held by a person towards an object, idea or position (Somasundaran & Wiebe, 2009) Stance Groups: IARPA s subgroup (cells)
5 Stance Classification: Death Penalty Yes we should keep it I value human life so much that if someone takes one than his should be taken. Also if someone is thinking about taking a life they are less likely to do so knowing that they might lose theirs No we should not There is no proof that the death penalty acts as a deterrent, plus due to the finalty of the sentence it would be impossible to amend a mistaken conviction which happens with regualrity especially now due to DNA and improved forensic science
6 Dialogic Properties of Convinceme Every site offers different contextual affordances Convinceme provides three sources of dialogue structure Original post topic and responses on either side can be considered a response to the original post Rebuttal links explicitly link to a previous post on the other side Temporal context at the time of your post. What the page looked like, existing posts the user could see (is lost) Timestamps only by day, get partial order by day, plus order within day only via rebuttals No agree links
7 Death Penalty: Monologic Posts Yes we should keep it I value human life so much that if someone takes one than his should be taken. Also if someone is thinking about taking a life they are less likely to do so knowing that they might lose theirs No we should not There is no proof that the death penalty acts as a deterrent, plus due to the finalty of the sentence it would be impossible to amend a mistaken conviction which happens with regualrity especially now due to DNA and improved forensic science
8 Death Penalty: Rebuttal Chain RIGHT Studies have shown that using the death penalty saves 4 to 13 lives per execution. That alone makes killing murderers worthwhile. When Texas and Florida were executing people one after the other in the late 90's, the murder rates in both states plunged, like Rosie O'donnel off a diet... WRONG What studies? I have never seen ANY evidence that capital punishment acts as a deterrant to crime. I have not seen any evidence that it is ``just'' either. That's your evidence? What happened to those studies? In the late 90s a LOT of things were different than the periods preceding and following the one you mention. We have no way to determine what of those contributed to a lower murder rate, if indeed there was one. You have to prove a cause and effect relationship and you have failed.
9 How do humans do at this task?
10 1113 Debates, 4873 posts Topic Rebuttals P/A Cats v. Dogs 40% 1.68 Firefox vs. IE 40% 1.28 Mac vs. PC 47% 1.85 Superman/Batman 34% nd Amendment 59% 2.09 Abortion 70% 2.82 Climate Change 69% 2.97 Communism vs. Capitalism 70% 3.03 Death Penalty 62% 2.44 Evolution 76% 3.91 Exist God 77% 4.24 Gay Marriage 65% 2.12 Healthcare 80% 3.24 Marijuana Legalization 52% 1.55 Ideological topics always more than 50% rebuttals More author investment
11 Mechanical Turk Stance Siding
12 Data Preparation Natural Language and Dialogue Systems Lab
13 Map Debates into Topic sets Open Debates matching capital punishment Should Capital Punishment be Allowed? Mar 10 Do you agree with capital punishment? Sep 22 Open Debates matching death penalty Capital Punishment Feb 09 Should young adults who are convicted of extreme crimes, be issued the death penalty? Jan 28 Should death penalty be repealed again in the Philippines? Sep 15 Should the death penalty be brought back?why? Jun 24 death penalty Mar 14 Is the death penalty morally correct as it is SUPPOSED to be used in the United States? Aug 27 death penalty Mar 02 The Death Penalty should be legal Feb 04
14 ConvinceMe: 1113 Two Sided Debates Topic Rebuttals P/A Cats v. Dogs 40% 1.68 Firefox vs. IE 40% 1.28 Mac vs. PC 47% 1.85 Superman/Batman 34% nd Amendment 59% 2.09 Abortion 70% 2.82 Climate Change 69% 2.97 Communism vs. Capitalism 70% 3.03 Death Penalty 62% 2.44 Evolution 76% 3.91 Exist God 77% 4.24 Gay Marriage 65% 2.12 Healthcare 80% 3.24 Marijuana Legalization 52% 1.55
15 Mechanical Turk: HIT 9 annotators/post
16 Mechanical Turk: Human Topline
17 Human Topline for Stance Classification Class Correct Total Accuracy Rebuttal Non-Rebuttal Overall accuracy about 78% Harder for humans to classify stance of rebuttals Rebuttals are more context dependent Sometimes people post on wrong side Harder for humans to classify ideological posts 76% of ideological posts sided correctly, 85% non-ideological
18 Stance Classification & Rebuttal Classification Natural Language and Dialogue Systems Lab
19 Experimental Setup Stance Classification Within topic Remove cases where majority of annotators got it wrong But have additional NOISY data self-annotated (as posted) Explore the role of different feature sets 10 fold cross-validation Naïve Bayes, Jrip, SVM learners
20 Context Features: (naïve) IsRebuttal, Poster, Parent Post Features RIGHT Studies have shown that using the death penalty saves 4 to 13 lives per execution. That alone makes killing murderers worthwhile. When Texas and Florida were executing people one after the other in the late 90's, the murder rates in both states plunged, like Rosie O'donnel off a diet... WRONG What studies? I have never seen ANY evidence that capital punishment acts as a deterrant to crime. I have not seen any evidence that it is ``just'' either. That's your evidence? What happened to those studies? In the late 90s a LOT of things were different than the periods preceding and following the one you mention. We have no way to determine what of those contributed to a lower murder rate, if indeed there was one. You have to prove a cause and effect relationship and you have failed.
21 STANCE Classification Results MTurk Uni Best Best FeatSet Cats v. Dogs All, no context Firefox vs. IE LIWC, no context Mac vs. PC LIWC, no context Superman Batman LIWC with context 2nd Amendment Unigram with context Abortion LIWC with context Climate Change LIWC Comm vs. Capitalism LIWC with context Death Penalty Generalized Dep POS with context Evolution Unigram, no context Existence of God Generalized Dep POS with context Gay Marriage Unigram, no context Healthcare LIWC with context MJ Legalization All, no context Two topics unigram best Idealogical topics: context tends to help Need better context features
22 Compare Somasundaran & Wiebe 2010 Results range from 60 to 70% Arg + Sent statistically better than Unigram Their unigram baseline is higher Data doesn t contain rebuttals Domain (#posts) Distribution Unigram Sentiment Arguing Arg+Sent Overall (2232) Guns Rights (306) Gay Rights (846) Abortion (550) Creationism (530) Table 4: Accuracy of the different systems
23 Current Work: Incorporate Social Network Models Use information over whole discussion Graph-based algorithm Speaker always agrees with self (P/A ranges 1.28 to 3.91) Rebuttal indicates disagreement A, B both disagree with C, agree with each other Evolution Topic: now 71.5% accuracy (from 57%) Firefox vs. IE: no improvement Graph topology differences, under investigation now
24 QUESTIONS? Natural Language and Dialogue Systems Lab
25 Discourse Relation Recognition Rebuttal is a kind of discourse relation Initiative Response Recognition Wang & Rose 2009 Get about 70% accuracy, LSA-CART Don t distinguish rebuttals from other Feature Engineering for Discourse Relation Recognition Echahabi & Marcu 2002: cartesian pairs Pitler, Louis & Nenkova, 2009
26 convinceme/cme.php?totalhits=100&pagegroup=1
27 Related Work Stance Classification in (Ideological) Online Debates Somasundaran & Wiebe, 2009; 2010 Discourse Relations (in scope of concession) Argumentation Features Results range from 60% to 70% accuracy Debate Side Classification (congress or forums) Thomas et. al. 2006, Bansal, Cardie 2010, Mishne Glance, Murakami & Raymond 2010 Use Graph-based algorithms (Social Network structure via Mincut, Maxcut) Simple features for agreement/disagreement from text improve performance
28 Compare Somasundaran & Wiebe 09,10 Topic Posts OPPr + Discourse Feats Best Accuracy Firefox vs. IE % Windows vs. Mac % SonyPS3 vs. WII % Opera vs. Firefox 4 100% Domain (#posts) Distribution Unigram Sentiment Arguing Arg+Sent Overall (2232) Guns Rights (306) Gay Rights (846) Abortion (550) Creationism (530) Table 4: Accuracy of the different systems
29 Feature Sets Set Description/Examples Post Info IsRebuttal, Poster Unigrams Word frequencies Bigrams Word pair frequencies Cue Words Initial unigram, bigram, and trigram Repeated Punctuation Collapsed into one of the following:??,!!,?! LIWC LIWC measures and frequencies Dependencies Dependencies derived from the Stanford Parser. Generalized Dependencies Dependency features generalized with respect to POS of the head word and opinion polarity of both words. Opinion Dependencieion Subset of Generalized Dependencies with opin- words from MPQA. Context Features Matching Features used for the post from the parent post.
30 LIWC Lexical Categories Feature Anger words Metaphysical issues Physical state/function Inclusive words Social processes Family members Past tense verbs References to friends Causation Discrepancy Example hate, kill, pissed God, heaven, coffin ache, breast, sleep with, and, include talk, us, friend mom, brother, cousin walked, were, had pal, buddy, coworker because, know, ought should, would, could
31 Dependencies Dependencies Derived using the Stanford Parser Well, maybe the pistol and the hunting rifle, what do you need an automatic weapon? Have the deer gotten faster? 'amod(weapon, automatic)', 'dep:dobj(need, weapon)', 'dep:det(weapon, an)',...
32 Generalized Dependencies (POS) Generalized Dependencies Generalized over POS of head word Well, maybe the pistol and the hunting rifle, what do you need an automatic weapon? Have the deer gotten faster? Joshi and Rosé 2009 show that semi-lexicalized dependency features are better than fully lexicalized or fully generalized 'amod(nn, automatic)', 'dep:dobj(vbp, weapon)', 'dep:det(nn, an)',...
33 Generalized Dependencies (Opinion) Generalized Dependencies MPQA opinion dictionary over each word independently Intended to approximate Somasundaran & Wiebe's opinion target but if I want to own a pistol, a shotgun, and some fancy automatic, well that's my right. 'dep_opinion: amod (automatic, positive)' dep_opinion:poss(positive, my)'...
TEXT MINING TECHNIQUES RORY DUTHIE
TEXT MINING TECHNIQUES RORY DUTHIE OUTLINE Example text to extract information. Techniques which can be used to extract that information. Libraries How to measure accuracy. EXAMPLE TEXT Mr. Jack Ashley
More informationI Couldn t Agree More: The Role of Conversational Structure in Agreement and Disagreement Detection in Online Discussions
I Couldn t Agree More: The Role of Conversational Structure in Agreement and Disagreement Detection in Online Discussions Sara Rosenthal Kathleen McKeown Columbia University 1 Motivation Detecting (dis)agreement
More informationIdentifying Anaphoric and Non- Anaphoric Noun Phrases to Improve Coreference Resolution
Identifying Anaphoric and Non- Anaphoric Noun Phrases to Improve Coreference Resolution Vincent Ng Ng and Claire Cardie Department of of Computer Science Cornell University Plan for the Talk Noun phrase
More informationOutline of today s lecture
Outline of today s lecture Putting sentences together (in text). Coherence Anaphora (pronouns etc) Algorithms for anaphora resolution Document structure and discourse structure Most types of document are
More informationWinning on the Merits: The Joint Effects of Content and Style on Debate Outcomes
Winning on the Merits: The Joint Effects of Content and Style on Debate Outcomes Lu Wang 1, Nick Beauchamp 2,3, Sarah Shugars 3, Kechen Qin 1 1 College of Computer and Information Science 2 Department
More informationReference Resolution. Regina Barzilay. February 23, 2004
Reference Resolution Regina Barzilay February 23, 2004 Announcements 3/3 first part of the projects Example topics Segmentation Identification of discourse structure Summarization Anaphora resolution Cue
More informationReference Resolution. Announcements. Last Time. 3/3 first part of the projects Example topics
Announcements Last Time 3/3 first part of the projects Example topics Segmentation Symbolic Multi-Strategy Anaphora Resolution (Lappin&Leass, 1994) Identification of discourse structure Summarization Anaphora
More informationCS224W Project Proposal: Characterizing and Predicting Dogmatic Networks
CS224W Project Proposal: Characterizing and Predicting Dogmatic Networks Emily Alsentzer, Shirbi Ish-Shalom, Jonas Kemp 1. Introduction Increasing polarization has been a defining feature of the 21st century.
More informationWhat can I do with philosophy?
What can I do with philosophy? Business / international business Marketing and management The government, foreign service, or the Peace Corps Counseling and Social Work Education Journalism / publishing
More informationLOUISIANA PUBLIC SQUARE
Home About How To Comment Interactives Topics View Louisiana Public Square! LOUISIANA PUBLIC SQUARE Main About Topics Current Topic Blog Resources Results Bios Contact Survey How closely would you say
More informationNPTEL NPTEL ONINE CERTIFICATION COURSE. Introduction to Machine Learning. Lecture-59 Ensemble Methods- Bagging,Committee Machines and Stacking
NPTEL NPTEL ONINE CERTIFICATION COURSE Introduction to Machine Learning Lecture-59 Ensemble Methods- Bagging,Committee Machines and Stacking Prof. Balaraman Ravindran Computer Science and Engineering Indian
More informationQuestion Answering. CS486 / 686 University of Waterloo Lecture 23: April 1 st, CS486/686 Slides (c) 2014 P. Poupart 1
Question Answering CS486 / 686 University of Waterloo Lecture 23: April 1 st, 2014 CS486/686 Slides (c) 2014 P. Poupart 1 Question Answering Extension to search engines CS486/686 Slides (c) 2014 P. Poupart
More informationRMPS Assignment. National 5/Higher. Name: Class: Teacher: My Question:
RMPS Assignment National 5/Higher Name: Class: Teacher: My Question: The Assignment The National 5 Assignment is out of 20 marks. This is 25% of your overall grade. The Higher Assignment is out of 30 marks
More informationArgument Harvesting Using Chatbots
arxiv:1805.04253v1 [cs.ai] 11 May 2018 Argument Harvesting Using Chatbots Lisa A. CHALAGUINE a Fiona L. HAMILTON b Anthony HUNTER a Henry W. W. POTTS c a Department of Computer Science, University College
More informationGCSE RELIGIOUS STUDIES A Paper 2A
GCSE RELIGIOUS STUDIES A Paper 2A Specimen 2018 Morning Time allowed: 1 hour 45 minutes Materials For this paper you must have: an AQA answer booklet. Instructions Use black ink or black ball-point pen.
More informationStoryTown Reading/Language Arts Grade 2
Phonemic Awareness, Word Recognition and Fluency 1. Identify rhyming words with the same or different spelling patterns. 2. Read regularly spelled multi-syllable words by sight. 3. Blend phonemes (sounds)
More informationWhite Paper: Innocent or Inconclusive? Analyzing Abolitionists Claims About the Death
White Paper: Innocent or Inconclusive? Analyzing Abolitionists Claims About the Death Penalty Michael Conklin 1 This is a brief analysis of the death penalty innocence issue, using the July 2018 book The
More informationInformation Extraction. CS6200 Information Retrieval (and a sort of advertisement for NLP in the spring)
Information Extraction CS6200 Information Retrieval (and a sort of advertisement for NLP in the spring) Information Extraction Automatically extract structure from text annotate document using tags to
More informationGW POLITICS POLL 2018 MIDTERM ELECTION WAVE 3
GW POLITICS POLL 2018 MIDTERM ELECTION WAVE 3 The survey was fielded 17 25, 2018 by YouGov with a sample of registered voters. This was the third survey in a four-wave panel design focusing on the 2018
More informationSB=Student Book TE=Teacher s Edition WP=Workbook Plus RW=Reteaching Workbook 47
A. READING / LITERATURE Content Standard Students in Wisconsin will read and respond to a wide range of writing to build an understanding of written materials, of themselves, and of others. Rationale Reading
More informationLesson 09 Notes. Machine Learning. Intro
Machine Learning Lesson 09 Notes Intro C: Hi Michael. M: Hey how's it going? C: So I want to talk about something today Michael. I want to talk about Bayesian Learning, and I've been inspired by our last
More informationGCSE RELIGIOUS STUDIES A Paper 2A
SPECIMEN MATERIAL GCSE RELIGIOUS STUDIES A Paper 2A Specimen Morning Time allowed: 1 hour 45 minutes Materials For this paper you must have: an AQA answer booklet. Instructions Use black ink or black ball-point
More informationPrentice Hall Literature: Timeless Voices, Timeless Themes, Silver Level '2002 Correlated to: Oregon Language Arts Content Standards (Grade 8)
Prentice Hall Literature: Timeless Voices, Timeless Themes, Silver Level '2002 Oregon Language Arts Content Standards (Grade 8) ENGLISH READING: Comprehend a variety of printed materials. Recognize, pronounce,
More informationPrentice Hall Literature: Timeless Voices, Timeless Themes, Bronze Level '2002 Correlated to: Oregon Language Arts Content Standards (Grade 7)
Prentice Hall Literature: Timeless Voices, Timeless Themes, Bronze Level '2002 Oregon Language Arts Content Standards (Grade 7) ENGLISH READING: Comprehend a variety of printed materials. Recognize, pronounce,
More informationDiscussion Notes for Bayesian Reasoning
Discussion Notes for Bayesian Reasoning Ivan Phillips - http://www.meetup.com/the-chicago-philosophy-meetup/events/163873962/ Bayes Theorem tells us how we ought to update our beliefs in a set of predefined
More informationDate of last example: Never Today/yesterday Last week Last month Last year Before the last year
e) I consciously attempt to welcome bad news, or at least not push it away. (Recent example from Eliezer: At a brainstorming session for future Singularity Summits, one issue raised was that we hadn't
More informationEssay Discuss Both Sides and Give your Opinion
Essay Discuss Both Sides and Give your Opinion Contents: General Structure: 2 DOs and DONTs 3 Example Answer One: 4 Language for strengthening and weakening 8 Useful Structures 11 What is the overall structure
More informationCONTEMPORARY MORAL PROBLEMS LECTURE 14 CAPITAL PUNISHMENT PART 2
CONTEMPORARY MORAL PROBLEMS LECTURE 14 CAPITAL PUNISHMENT PART 2 1 THE ISSUES: REVIEW Is the death penalty (capital punishment) justifiable in principle? Why or why not? Is the death penalty justifiable
More informationWhy do people commit injustice? What is pleasure?
Book I: The Speaker LESSON VII Forensic Rhetoric Why do people commit injustice? What is pleasure? EXERCISES FOR DAY 1: Read Chapter 10, section 1368b. Aristotle discusses the incentives for wrongdoing
More informationMs. Shruti Aggarwal Assistant Professor S.G.G.S.W.U. Fatehgarh Sahib
Ms. Shruti Aggarwal S.G.G.S.W.U. Fatehgarh Sahib Email: shruti_cse@sggswu.org Area of Specialization: Data Mining, Software Engineering, Databases Subjects Taught Languages Fundamentals of Computers, C,
More informationIs The Death Penalty Fair? (At Issue) By Mary E. Williams
Is The Death Penalty Fair? (At Issue) By Mary E. Williams Listing of California Death Row Inmates H - I - Pro Death Penalty Resource Community Mary Williams, In November 2001 Hoyt was convicted of first
More informationContemporary Social and Moral Problems in the U.S.
Contemporary Social and Moral Problems in the U.S. Philosophy 2367 Fall 2013 Ohio State University Instructor: Dr. Lindsay Rettler, Time and Location: Wed/Fri 8:00-9:20 am, 259 Hagerty Hall Contact: rettler.2@osu.edu
More informationPredictability, Causation, and Free Will
Predictability, Causation, and Free Will Luke Misenheimer (University of California Berkeley) August 18, 2008 The philosophical debate between compatibilists and incompatibilists about free will and determinism
More informationMore See Too Much Religious Talk by Politicians
March 21, 2012 Santorum Voters Disagree More See Too Much Religious Talk by Politicians FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Andrew Kohut President, Pew Research Center Carroll Doherty, Michael Dimock Associate
More informationSEARCHING FOR ANSWERS
MONDAY, APRIL 16 SEARCHING FOR ANSWERS What does Detective Nye do in Las Vegas? What is Capote s purpose? (remember, purpose is not only how he is telling the story, but why he is telling it in this particular
More informationNew Testament Exegesis Outline Template by Rev. D. E. Norczyk
New Testament Exegesis Outline Template by Rev. D. E. Norczyk Sermon Set: Grace Providence Church Sermon Number: 2014 - Sermon Series: So That You May Believe Sermon Title: Sermon Text: John Sermon Date:
More informationpart one MACROSTRUCTURE Cambridge University Press X - A Theory of Argument Mark Vorobej Excerpt More information
part one MACROSTRUCTURE 1 Arguments 1.1 Authors and Audiences An argument is a social activity, the goal of which is interpersonal rational persuasion. More precisely, we ll say that an argument occurs
More informationClassroom Voting Questions: Statistics
Classroom Voting Questions: Statistics General Probability Rules 1. In a certain semester, 500 students enrolled in both Calculus I and Physics I. Of these students, 82 got an A in calculus, 73 got an
More informationThe World-Time Parallel: Tense And Modality In Logic And Metaphysics By M. J. Cresswell READ ONLINE
The World-Time Parallel: Tense And Modality In Logic And Metaphysics By M. J. Cresswell READ ONLINE If looking for the book The World-Time Parallel: Tense and Modality in Logic and Metaphysics by M. J.
More informationHere s a very dumbed down way to understand why Gödel is no threat at all to A.I..
Comments on Godel by Faustus from the Philosophy Forum Here s a very dumbed down way to understand why Gödel is no threat at all to A.I.. All Gödel shows is that try as you might, you can t create any
More informationAPwk4.notebook. August 23, Opener 8/27. Write a claim of fact, value and policy about capital punishment on the back of your opener
Opener 8/27 In your own experiences, when someone is trying to persuade you of something, what will automatically make you shut them down? Write a claim of fact, value and policy about capital punishment
More informationDoes the 2nd Amendment Cover Semi-Automatic Weapons?
Does the 2nd Amendment Cover Semi-Automatic Weapons? Of late, due to the horrific events surrounding the mass murders that took place in Las Vegas, there has been a renewed call regarding the restriction
More informationPortfolio Project. Phil 251A Logic Fall Due: Friday, December 7
Portfolio Project Phil 251A Logic Fall 2012 Due: Friday, December 7 1 Overview The portfolio is a semester-long project that should display your logical prowess applied to real-world arguments. The arguments
More informationPHI 1700: Global Ethics
PHI 1700: Global Ethics Session 3 February 11th, 2016 Harman, Ethics and Observation 1 (finishing up our All About Arguments discussion) A common theme linking many of the fallacies we covered is that
More informationFOURTH GRADE. WE LIVE AS CHRISTIANS ~ Your child recognizes that the Holy Spirit gives us life and that the Holy Spirit gives us gifts.
FOURTH GRADE RELIGION LIVING AS CATHOLIC CHRISTIANS ~ Your child recognizes that Jesus preached the Good News. understands the meaning of the Kingdom of God. knows virtues of Faith, Hope, Love. recognizes
More informationVisual Analytics Based Authorship Discrimination Using Gaussian Mixture Models and Self Organising Maps: Application on Quran and Hadith
Visual Analytics Based Authorship Discrimination Using Gaussian Mixture Models and Self Organising Maps: Application on Quran and Hadith Halim Sayoud (&) USTHB University, Algiers, Algeria halim.sayoud@uni.de,
More informationIntuitive evidence and formal evidence in proof-formation
Intuitive evidence and formal evidence in proof-formation Okada Mitsuhiro Section I. Introduction. I would like to discuss proof formation 1 as a general methodology of sciences and philosophy, with a
More informationthe Period, the number of trades within this period, called the Frequency and the In Frequency, meaning all specific dealing days
White Paper How to Define Trade Cycles This white paper addresses the following openfunds fields Subscription related fields OFST405521 Subscription Trade Cycle Period OFST405523 Number Of Possible Subscriptions
More informationEstablishing premises
Establishing premises This is hard, subtle, and crucial to good arguments. Various kinds of considerations are used to establish the truth (high justification) of premises Deduction Done Analogy Induction
More informationCAPITAL PUNISHMENT Text: Exodus 20:13; Numbers 35:30-31
CAPITAL PUNISHMENT Text: Exodus 20:13; Numbers 35:30-31 INTRO: One advantage the NKJ has over the KJV of 1611 is that much of the argument about capital punishment might never have come up if the KJV translators
More informationThe Fifth National Survey of Religion and Politics: A Baseline for the 2008 Presidential Election. John C. Green
The Fifth National Survey of Religion and Politics: A Baseline for the 2008 Presidential Election John C. Green Ray C. Bliss Institute of Applied Politics University of Akron (Email: green@uakron.edu;
More informationEvidence for evolution
Evidence for evolution Prior to the late 1700's biologists thought life to be unchanging Plato and the allegory of the cave platonic ideals (DOG vs dogs) Judaic/Christian/Islamic Biblical creation of organisms
More informationDarwinism on trial in American state (Sun 8 May, 2005)
WARM-UPS CHAT: In pairs / groups, decide which of these topics you are interested in, which do not look interesting and which look really boring: Kansas / scientists / Charles Darwin / the Theory of Evolution
More informationParts of Persuasive Writing
Making a Claim Parts of Persuasive Writing Good persuasive writing includes the following: 1. Claim - The writer s overall argument. 2. Support - The evidence that proves the claim. 3. Reasoning - The
More informationOverview: Application: What to Avoid:
UNIT 3: BUILDING A BASIC ARGUMENT While "argument" has a number of different meanings, college-level arguments typically involve a few fundamental pieces that work together to construct an intelligent,
More informationNPTEL NPTEL ONLINE CERTIFICATION COURSE. Introduction to Machine Learning. Lecture 31
NPTEL NPTEL ONLINE CERTIFICATION COURSE Introduction to Machine Learning Lecture 31 Prof. Balaraman Ravindran Computer Science and Engineering Indian Institute of Technology Madras Hinge Loss Formulation
More information(i) Morality is a system; and (ii) It is a system comprised of moral rules and principles.
Ethics and Morality Ethos (Greek) and Mores (Latin) are terms having to do with custom, habit, and behavior. Ethics is the study of morality. This definition raises two questions: (a) What is morality?
More informationECE 5424: Introduction to Machine Learning
ECE 5424: Introduction to Machine Learning Topics: SVM Multi-class SVMs Neural Networks Multi-layer Perceptron Readings: Barber 17.5, Murphy 16.5 Stefan Lee Virginia Tech HW2 Graded Mean 63/61 = 103% Max:
More informationRECOMMENDED CITATION: Pew Research Center, March 2014, U.S. Catholics View Pope Francis as a Change for the Better
NUMBERS, FACTS AND TRENDS SHAPING THE WORLD FOR RELEASE MARCH 6, 2014 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION ON THIS REPORT: Alan Cooperman, Director of Religion Research Greg Smith, Director of U.S. Religion Surveys
More informationStudying Religion-Associated Variations in Physicians Clinical Decisions: Theoretical Rationale and Methodological Roadmap
Studying Religion-Associated Variations in Physicians Clinical Decisions: Theoretical Rationale and Methodological Roadmap Farr A. Curlin, MD Kenneth A. Rasinski, PhD Department of Medicine The University
More informationProfessor: Matthew D. Kim Office: Library 124 Phone: Office Hours: TBD. I. Course Description
Professor: Matthew D. Kim Office: Library 124 Phone: 978.646.4077 Email: mkim@gcts.edu Office Hours: TBD I. Course Description Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary Hamilton PR601-HA Preaching: Principles
More informationECE 5424: Introduction to Machine Learning
ECE 5424: Introduction to Machine Learning Topics: (Finish) Model selection Error decomposition Bias-Variance Tradeoff Classification: Naïve Bayes Readings: Barber 17.1, 17.2, 10.1-10.3 Stefan Lee Virginia
More informationStoryTown Reading/Language Arts Grade 3
Phonemic Awareness, Word Recognition and Fluency 1. Identify rhyming words with the same or different spelling patterns. 2. Use letter-sound knowledge and structural analysis to decode words. 3. Use knowledge
More informationCommon Morality: Deciding What to Do 1
Common Morality: Deciding What to Do 1 By Bernard Gert (1934-2011) [Page 15] Analogy between Morality and Grammar Common morality is complex, but it is less complex than the grammar of a language. Just
More informationHoughton Mifflin English 2004 Houghton Mifflin Company Level Four correlated to Tennessee Learning Expectations and Draft Performance Indicators
Houghton Mifflin English 2004 Houghton Mifflin Company correlated to Tennessee Learning Expectations and Draft Performance Indicators Writing Content Standard: 2.0 The student will develop the structural
More informationScavenger Hunt For Church Youth Group
For Church Youth Group Free PDF ebook Download: For Church Youth Group Download or Read Online ebook scavenger hunt for church youth group in PDF Format From The Best User Guide Database Mar 23, 2014 -
More informationCS305 Topic Introduction to Ethics
CS305 Topic Introduction to Ethics Sources: Baase: A Gift of Fire and Quinn: Ethics for the Information Age CS305-Spring 2010 Ethics 1 What is Ethics? A branch of philosophy that studies priciples relating
More informationELA CCSS Grade Three. Third Grade Reading Standards for Literature (RL)
Common Core State s English Language Arts ELA CCSS Grade Three Title of Textbook : Shurley English Level 3 Student Textbook Publisher Name: Shurley Instructional Materials, Inc. Date of Copyright: 2013
More informationGCSE RELIGIOUS STUDIES 8061/2
SPECIMEN MATERIAL GCSE RELIGIOUS STUDIES 8061/2 CHRISTIANITY Mark scheme Specimen V1.0 Mark schemes are prepared by the Lead Assessment Writer and considered, together with the relevant questions, by a
More informationSkill Realized. Skill Developing. Not Shown. Skill Emerging
Joshua Foster - 21834444-05018100 Page 1 Exam 050181 - Persuasive Writing Traits of Good Writing Review pages 164-169 in your study guide for a complete explanation of the rating you earned for each trait
More informationPrentice Hall United States History 1850 to the Present Florida Edition, 2013
A Correlation of Prentice Hall United States History To the & Draft Publishers' Criteria for History/Social Studies Table of Contents Grades 9-10 Reading Standards for Informational Text... 3 Writing Standards...
More informationEMBARGOED FOR RELEASE: Sunday, February 25 at 9:00 a.m.
CNN February 2018 The study was conducted for CNN via telephone by SSRS, an independent research company. Interviews were conducted from February 20, 2018 February 23, 2018 among a sample of 1,016 respondents.
More informationTHE DIGNITY OF HUMAN LIFE GENSIS 9:1-7. There is a sickness abroad in the land. One symptom of this sickness is the low value that we put
THE DIGNITY OF HUMAN LIFE GENSIS 9:1-7 There is a sickness abroad in the land. One symptom of this sickness is the low value that we put upon human life. There is evidence abroad everywhere reflecting
More informationFinal Paper. May 13, 2015
24.221 Final Paper May 13, 2015 Determinism states the following: given the state of the universe at time t 0, denoted S 0, and the conjunction of the laws of nature, L, the state of the universe S at
More informationPOST-DEBATE SURVEY OF ATTENDEES FROM THE 2017 LIBERTARIANISM v CONSERVATISM INTERN DEBATE
POST-DEBATE SURVEY OF ATTENDEES FROM THE 2017 LIBERTARIANISM v CONSERVATISM INTERN DEBATE AUGUST 3, 2017 N=226 Q1. Regardless of your own ideological preference, which team do you think won the debate
More informationWriting Module Three: Five Essential Parts of Argument Cain Project (2008)
Writing Module Three: Five Essential Parts of Argument Cain Project (2008) Module by: The Cain Project in Engineering and Professional Communication. E-mail the author Summary: This module presents techniques
More informationGCSE RELIGIOUS STUDIES A
SPECIMEN MATERIAL GCSE RELIGIOUS STUDIES A Paper 2B Specimen 2018 Morning Time allowed: 1 hour 45 minutes Materials For this paper you must have: an AQA answer booklet. Instructions Use black ink or black
More informationP G R. In This Issue. Pastor Gener al s Report. Church Administration... 2 Media Services... 2 Business Office... 3 Mail Processing...
P G R Pastor Gener al s Report In This Issue Church Administration... 2 Media Services... 2 Business Office... 3 Mail Processing... 5 Greetings, ministers and wives! John understood what a marvelous thing
More informationBuilding Your Framework everydaydebate.blogspot.com by James M. Kellams
Building Your Framework everydaydebate.blogspot.com by James M. Kellams The Judge's Weighing Mechanism Very simply put, a framework in academic debate is the set of standards the judge will use to evaluate
More informationWithout essay friend best writing my realizing it can (already). during m1 and service for although its definitely recommend asking you love from
How to market writing skills. A seminar is defined as a class in which papers are required hindi essay on global warming download distinguished from exams and a class in which each student. How to market
More informationNATIONAL: U.S. CATHOLICS LOOK FORWARD TO POPE S VISIT
Please attribute this information to: Monmouth University Poll West Long Branch, NJ 07764 www.monmouth.edu/polling Follow on Twitter: @MonmouthPoll CONTACTS: For commentary on poll results and the pope
More informationWilliam F. Cox, Jr., Ph.D. Regent University
William F. Cox, Jr., Ph.D. Regent University Hermeneutics refers generally to the overall process and principles of biblical interpretation. But also applies specifically to the subsequent act of interpreting
More informationPunjab University, Chandigarh. Kurukshetra University, Haryana. Assistant Professor. Lecturer
Ms. Shruti Aggarwal Assistant Professor Department of Computer Science S.G.G.S.W.U. Fatehgarh Sahib Email Id: shruti_cse@sggswu.org Area of Specialization: Data Mining, Software Engineering, Databases
More informationSUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS No. CR
SUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS No. CR 10-936 CLEVELAND EVANS, VS. STATE OF ARKANSAS, APPELLANT, APPELLEE, Opinion Delivered February 3, 2011 APPEAL FROM THE PULASKI COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT, NO. CR 2008-5049, HON.
More informationCatholics Divided Over Global Warming
NUMBERS, FACTS AND TRENDS SHAPING YOUR WORLD ABOUT FOLLOW US Search Religion & Public Life MENU RESEARCH AREAS JUNE 16, 2015 Catholics Divided Over Global Warming Partisan Differences Mirror Those Among
More informationA Scientific Model Explains Spirituality and Nonduality
A Scientific Model Explains Spirituality and Nonduality Frank Heile, Ph.D. Physics degrees from Stanford and MIT frank@spiritualityexplained.com www.spiritualityexplained.com Science and Nonduality Conference
More informationECE 5984: Introduction to Machine Learning
ECE 5984: Introduction to Machine Learning Topics: SVM Multi-class SVMs Neural Networks Multi-layer Perceptron Readings: Barber 17.5, Murphy 16.5 Dhruv Batra Virginia Tech HW2 Graded Mean 66/61 = 108%
More informationTheory of Knowledge. 5. That which can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. (Christopher Hitchens). Do you agree?
Theory of Knowledge 5. That which can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. (Christopher Hitchens). Do you agree? Candidate Name: Syed Tousif Ahmed Candidate Number: 006644 009
More informationconqueror QUIET TIME 3-4 one- year daily devotional for children in grades
conqueror QUIET TIME one- year daily devotional for children in grades 3-4 W o r d o f L i f e L o c a l C h u r c h M i n i s t r i e s Welcome! Quiet Time is a special time that you set aside each day
More informationA Correlation of. To the. Language Arts Florida Standards (LAFS) Grade 4
A Correlation of To the Introduction This document demonstrates how, meets the. Correlation page references are to the Unit Module Teacher s Guides and are cited by grade, unit and page references. is
More informationFreedom's Law: The Moral Reading of the American Constitution.
Freedom's Law: The Moral Reading of the American Constitution. By Ronald Dworkin. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1996.389 pp. Kenneth Einar Himma University of Washington In Freedom's Law, Ronald
More informationMinutes of the December meeting were approved.
The Journal of the Cascade Mountain Men January, 2010 Minutes of the Cascade Mountain Men December 15th, 2009 Meeting was called to order at 8:05 P.M. by Treasurer, Andy Williamson. Neither President Greg
More informationEMBARGOED FOR RELEASE: Sunday, November 27 at 8:00 a.m.
Interviews with 1,003 adult Americans conducted by telephone by ORC International on November 17-20, 2016. The margin of sampling error for results based on the total sample is plus or minus 3 percentage
More informationAmerican Election Eve Poll Florida - Latino, African American, AAPI, and White Voters
1. Thinking about the 2018 election, what are the most important issues facing your community that our politicians should address? Improve economy / create jobs 25% 25% 23% 34% 19% Income inequality /low
More informationSTATE OF MAINE CHRISTIAN NIELSEN. [ 1] Christian Nielsen appeals from a judgment of conviction entered in the
MAINE SUPREME JUDICIAL COURT Decision: 2008 ME 77 Docket: Oxf-07-645 Argued: April 8, 2008 Decided: May 6, 2008 Reporter of Decisions Panel: SAUFLEY, C.J., and CLIFFORD, ALEXANDER, LEVY, SILVER, and MEAD,
More informationWriting the Argumentative Essay
Writing the Argumentative Essay CHOOSING A TOPIC To begin an argumentative essay, you must first have an opinion you want others to share. Possible Topic Ideas Should boxing be banned? Should the driving
More informationHistory 2403E University of Western Ontario
History 2403E University of Western Ontario 2015 2016 Prof. J. Temple Class Times: Lectures: Monday 1:30 3:30 Tutorials: Various scheduled times. Office: TBA Office Hours: TBA Email: jtemple3@uwo.ca Course
More informationWho Says? Chapter 12: Authority. Dictionaries are like watches; the worst is better than none, and the best cannot be expected to go quite true.
Chapter 12: Authority Who Says? Dictionaries are like watches; the worst is better than none, and the best cannot be expected to go quite true. - Samuel Johnson Differences in recognition of authority
More informationCurrent Ethical Issues and Christian Praxis Introduction to Christian Ethics. Spring 2015 ET512-DA-t-D (3) #
Current Ethical Issues and Christian Praxis Introduction to Christian Ethics Spring 2015 ET512-DA-t-D (3) Th 6:30-9:20 pm Andrew S. Park United Theological Seminary aspark@united.edu #3714 529-2269 I.
More informationOSSA Conference Archive OSSA 8
University of Windsor Scholarship at UWindsor OSSA Conference Archive OSSA 8 Jun 3rd, 9:00 AM - Jun 6th, 5:00 PM Commentary on Goddu James B. Freeman Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.uwindsor.ca/ossaarchive
More information