LIVING WELL TOWARDS OTHERS: The Development of an Everyday Ethics Through Emmanuel Levinas and Alfred Schutz

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "LIVING WELL TOWARDS OTHERS: The Development of an Everyday Ethics Through Emmanuel Levinas and Alfred Schutz"

Avis Megan Jennings
5 years ago
Views:

1 LIVING WELL TOWARDS OTHERS: The Development of an Everyday Ethics Through Emmanuel Levinas and Alfred Schutz Yvonne Haigh BA (Hons) Murdoch University This thesis is presented for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of Murdoch University, 2003

2 Abstract This dissertation is concerned with what it means to live well towards others. It develops a form of everyday ethics that emphasises how existing in the world and being ethical are entwined. To develop this approach to ethics this study employs Alfred Schutz s phenomenological descriptions of everyday world and Emmanuel Levinas s concept of the ethical. The purpose of the thesis is to develop an understanding of ethics that operates at the everyday level of human-to-human contact. This form of ethics is significant in that it indicates that being ethical is an important aspect of human life. My intention is to show that ethics is always more than simply the institution of codes of conduct that govern the way people act. The significance of the thesis is that it contributes both to ways in which ethics can be understood and to the manner in which ethics can be operationalised at an institutional level. My thesis has four specific aims. First, to examine the conditions and characteristics that constitute the everyday world as understood in Alfred Schutz s work. Second, to explore Emmanuel Levinas s understanding of the ethical. My third aim is to synthesise these theorists ideas through my heuristic device, Echoes of the Other. This device will allow me to extract the conditions for and features of an everyday ethics. My fourth aim is to point to an in situ illustration of this approach to ethics. This will be drawn from my observations at the Western Australian Police Academy. My argument is that synthesising Levinas s and Schutz s ideas will enable the development of an everyday ethics. This will highlight the ways in which ethics functions at the micro levels of human life. This study contributes to approaches to ethics, and specifically, ethics derived from Levinas s ethical relation. This approach can be of use to people interested in ethics, phenomenology, the works of Levinas and Schutz and those concerned with developing ways to live well towards others.

3 I declare that this thesis is my own account of my research and contains as its main content work that has not previously been submitted for a degree at any tertiary education institution. Yvonne Haigh

4 Acknowledgements I would like to thank Dr. Ian Cook of the School of Politics and International Studies at Murdoch University who provided me with guidance, encouragement and the capacity to believe in myself. Without his support I would not be the person I am today. I would also like to thank David Savat, my colleague and computer adviser. Over the course of four years David not only fixed every computer problem I encountered, he also provided me with support and some light relief when it was needed. I would also like to thank the wonderful group of polgrads, Jim, Stuart, Tauel and a few others who have come and gone. These people helped make this experience fun at times and supportive when it was necessary. Thanks must also go to Gaye Mckensie and Liz Boase for the coffees and the laughter. I would also like to thank Sargent Di Wilkins and Senior Constable Keryn Macey of the Western Australian Police Service for making me feel welcome and answering all of my questions. Finally, I want to thank my partner, Mario Schmack for understanding what it means to be driven.

5 INTRODUCTION 1 CHAPTER ONE - ALFRED SCHUTZ AND THE EVERYDAY WORLD 41 PART ONE: PHENOMENOLOGY OF THE EVERYDAY LIFE WORLD 44 PART TWO: THE CHARACTERISTICS OF THE EVERYDAY WORLD 55 PART THREE: THE STRUCTURE OF THE EVERYDAY WORLD 62 PART FOUR: EVERYDAY HUMAN RELATIONS 84 CHAPTER TWO - LEVINAS: ON BEING ETHICAL 101 PART ONE: THE PHENOMENOLOGY OF ETHICAL EXPERIENCE 104 PART TWO: THE HUMAN FACE OF ETHICS 129 PART THREE: THE ETHICAL COMMUNAL DIMENSION 155 CHAPTER THREE - SCHUTZ AND LEVINAS ECHOES OF THE OTHER 171 PART ONE: THE EVERYDAY AND THE ETHICAL 172 PART TWO: ECHOES OF THE OTHER 184 PART THREE: ECHOES OF THE OTHER SOCIAL STRUCTURES 189 PART FOUR: THE OTHER IN HUMAN RELATIONSHIPS 216 CHAPTER FOUR - LIVING WELL TOWARDS OTHERS 238 PART ONE: EVERYDAY ETHICAL CONDITIONS 239 PART TWO: AREAS OF CONSTRAINT AND EXPANSION 254 PART THREE: LIVING WELL TOWARDS OTHERS 268 CHAPTER FIVE - METHOD 289 PART ONE: WHAT IS PHENOMENOLOGY 291 PART TWO: PHENOMENOLOGY AS RESEARCH 297 PART THREE: PHENOMENOLOGICAL RESEARCH PROCESSES 301 PART FOUR: PHENOMENOLOGICAL RESEARCH METHODS 312 CHAPTER SIX - CASE STUDY: 320 THE WESTERN AUSTRALIAN POLICE SERVICE 320 PART ONE: THE RESEARCH PROCESS 321 PART TWO: POLICING AN OVERVIEW 324 PART THREE: PRESENTATION OF DATA 333 PART FOUR: A SUMMARY 383 CONCLUSION 388 BIBLIOGRAPHY 399

Architects of Hope Constructions and constructiveness in the theological worldviews of Jürgen Moltmann and Sergei Bulgakov

Architects of Hope Constructions and constructiveness in the theological worldviews of Jürgen Moltmann and Sergei Bulgakov Kerry George BA (English) Murdoch University BTheol (Hons) Murdoch University