Jacob s Ambivalent Legacy
|
|
- Myrtle Franklin
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Joel Whitebook 139 Joel Whitebook Jacob s Ambivalent Legacy This paper elucidates Freud s ambivalent and complex relation to Judaism, tracing it to the break with tradition that ran through the center of his father s life. Jacob Freud was a conflicted and transitional figure, with one foot planted in the parochial world of Jewish traditionalism and the other in the cosmopolitan world of European modernity. And he wanted his son to partake of these two legacies in equal degree. But Sigmund found the conflict untenable and chose in favor of science, atheism, and the Enlightenment. The point to be appreciated, however, is that he did not see his choice of the Aufklärung as a simple rejection of the Jewish tradition. Rather, by construing Moses as an Aufklärer, he was able he was able to define his project as an inner transformation of the Jewish tradition so that he could thereby to be a godless Jew, thereby confirming both his atheism and his cultural heritage. 1 What are we to make of Freud s provocative idea of a godless Jew? Is it simply a contradiction in terms that he uses to patch over an irresolvable and fundamental rift in his character and outlook? This is the position of those champions of Enlightenment universalism who want to inoculate Freud s science against any taint of ethnic particularity. They argue that the godlessness ought to be retained and the Judaism discarded. This is also the position of certain Jewish thinkers when they want to claim Freud as a prodigal son who ultimately returned to the tribal fold. 1 In this case, the idea is to drop the godlessness or at least radically attenuate it while holding onto the Judaism. I, on the other hand, will argue that the notion of a godless Jew is a coherent and meaningful concept. Explicating it will American Imago, Vol. 67, No. 2, by The Johns Hopkins University Press 139
2 140 Jacob s Ambivalent Legacy not only help us understand the genesis of Freud s thinking, but will also illuminate some of the inner dynamics of his position. To make my case, I will examine the origins of Freud s godless Judaism in the ambivalent legacy his father, Jacob, left to his second first-born son (Krüll 1979, 108), Sigmund. 2 The fault line created by the break with tradition runs through the center of Jacob Freud s life. He straddles the historical chasm: one foot planted in the narrowly circumscribed world of the traditional Judaism of the shtetl, and the other in the secular world of European modernity. The dislocating effects of modernization were, as Ernst Simon (1957) observed, particularly acute for Jews such as Jacob. Because of the rapid pace of assimilation, Simon writes, a modern Jew of Jacob s generation had to pass through an evolution of 300 years during his own lifetime, leaping from the Middle Ages to the modern age (295). 2 Jacob himself had received a traditional upbringing. Fulfilling his paternal duty to transmit the Jewish tradition to his son, Jacob s father, the reb Shlomo after whom Sigmund was named saw to it that his son received a thoroughgoing Jewish education. Emmanuel Rice (1990) reports that Jacob attended a Heder, the Eastern European Jewish equivalent to primary school, and then almost certainly moved on to a Yeshiva, which was a much larger Talmudic academy (30). The fact that Jacob, as an old man, could conduct the entire Passover service from memory and study the Talmud in the original Aramaic written in Hebrew letters attests to the depth of his Jewish education (Heller 1973, 355; Rice 1990, 93). At the same time, however, there is good reason to believe that Jacob was exposed to and strongly influenced by the Haskalah, the Jewish Enlightenment, which was particularly active in Tysmenitz, the Galician town where he grew up. This is not to say that Jacob was a full-blown maskil, a follower of the Haskalah, but only that the Jewish Enlightenment had a significant impact on him (Yerushalmi 1991, 62). We can assume, moreover, that, as a Wanderjude a wandering Jew, as the
3 Joel Whitebook 141 Austrian authorities categorized them a travelling salesman plying his trade in Moravia, Jacob had ample opportunity to observe the attractions of the larger modern world. And what he saw must have played an important role in his decision to move from Tysmenitz to Freiberg and exchange the encrusted world of the shtetl for the openness of modernity. Like Shlomo, Jacob wanted to pass his people s tradition on to his son. The unorthodox or post-traditional way in which he chose to do it, however, indicates that the continuity of The Great Chain of Tradition had already been broken. Jacob did not require Sigmund to spend long hours hunched over the Gamarah absorbing its teachings in the manner of an orthodox Yeshiva Bokhur. (Freud would, however, later spend long hours hunched over a microscope in Brücke s laboratory pursuing his modern scientific training.) Instead, when his son was seven, Jacob began to read to him from the family Bible something the precocious boy would soon be able to do on his own. That it was the Israelitische Bibel, published by the Philippson brothers, Ludwig and Phoebus, is of the utmost consequence for our story. The exposure to the rich content and Enlightenment orientation of this very singular edition of the Hebrew Bible had, as Freud recognized years later, an enduring effect upon the direction of [his] interest (1925, 8). The importance of these early experiences for Freud s emotional and intellectual development cannot be overestimated. We can imagine the aura of warmth, intimacy, and excitement that must have enfolded the precocious young boy and future bibliophile and his intelligent, adoring, and jocular father as they read the sacred texts together. In an admirable and sensitive piece of scholarship, Ana-Maria Rizzuto (1998, ch. 1) has demonstrated how deeply Jacob and the Bible were connected in Sigmund s emotional life. Not only does she show that Freud began collecting antiquities two months after his father s death as a way of working through the loss; she also shows that the figures he purchased often seem to have leapt off the illustrated pages of the Philippson Bible. In short, Freud was trying to re-create his father s presence in his consulting room by surrounding himself with the familiar figures whom they had studied together.
4 142 Jacob s Ambivalent Legacy Furthermore, twenty-nine years later, on Freud s thirtyfifth birthday, Jacob had the same Philippson Bible rebound in leather, inscribed an emotional appeal in it, and presented the book to his brilliant, successful and, we should add, atheist son. Thus, Jacob literally passed the Book (which contained the Pentateuch) on to him. Deciphering the countless messages contained in this act will help us understand the complex legacy that Jacob bequeathed to his son, and how Sigmund took his father s inheritance and made it his own. 3 3 The story of the Freud family Bible begins much earlier than Sigmund s thirty-fifth birthday. And Jacob s birthplace, Tysmenitz a town that was 50% Jewish plays an important role in it. Tysmenitz is located in Galicia, a multiethnic region that, until 1772, had been part of Poland. At that point, it was annexed by the Austrian Empire, where it remained until the end of the First World War; today it is part of Ukraine. Because many of the conflicting currents that were surging through Jewish life converged in Tysmenitz, Jacob Freud grew up in a town where the old traditions, and hence the organization of the Jewish community, were being fundamentally challenged (Krüll 1979, 78). Indeed, orthodox rabbinism, Hassidism, and the Haskalah all clashed there. To appreciate how unsettling the challenge to traditional authority would have been in this context, we must understand that the Judaism of that day was a thoroughly communal religion that encompassed every aspect of life. The cohesiveness of the group had the highest priority, with the result that the individual was under enormous pressure to conform to the regulations that governed almost every moment of the day. Furthermore, a challenge to the cohesion of this closed community, with its long-established theological and ritualistic system of thought and activity (Rice 1990, 87), not only constituted a threat to the collective identity of the group. The extreme poverty of the shtetls and the precariousness of life in general meant that mutual support and solidarity were absolutely essential for physical survival, for, as Rizzuto notes,
5 Joel Whitebook 143 many Jews in the region died of starvation... in spite of community efforts (1998, 28). Despite strong opposition from orthodox rabbis, the Haskalah was able to establish a presence in the town and its surrounding region. Jacob may have been a Hassid as a young man, but at some point the Haskalah came to play a decisive role in his life. Because the Haskalah, which was inspired by the European Enlightenment especially the German Aufklärung was a broad and complex movement, comprising many heterogeneous tendencies, one must be careful in making generalizations about it (see Yerushalmi 1991, 62). This much, however, can be said: the Haskalah sought to advance the process of physical and spiritual de-ghettoization of Jews, begun with the Napoleonic reforms, by transforming the Jewish tradition in such a way as to achieve full participation in the wider modern world. This meant adopting not only the civic values of the host culture, but its manners and mode of dress as well. It is important to note that, while secular and progressive, the maskilim (partisans of the Haskalah) were not Yiddish-speaking philosophes, that is, were not anti-religious or anti-clerical per se. They were merely opposed to what they considered the atavistic elements in Judaism. This led them to oppose the rabbinical prohibition against secular learning and to advocate the teaching of European science, philosophy, and literature as well as European languages as part of a Jewish education. Rejecting the narrow Talmudism of orthodox studies, the Haskalah retained the Torah as a centerpiece of the educational process. The Bible, however, was often extolled as a text belonging to the humanist tradition, and its study was thought to promote Bildung the proper sort of cultured individuality which was one of the most cherished values of the Aufklärung. The Haskalah also rejected the emphasis on ceremonialism, and took Judaism s ethical teaching especially its emphasis on truth and justice as its essence. Moreover, it interpreted this ethical teaching in such a way that it coincided with the progressive values of the Enlightenment. Echoing Kant and his Jewish disciple, Moses Mendelssohn, the English translator of the Philippson Bible wrote that the intellectual cultivation of the Jewish population could not fail to bring about the rec-
6 144 Jacob s Ambivalent Legacy ognition of the right of private judgment that is, the right of critical thinking and the claims of individual freedom (Yerushalmi 1991, 40). 4 While there is, as Rizzuto (1998) observes, no documented information to help us understand the process that brought about the drastic change (41) in Jacob s outlook, one piece of evidence, concerning the outcome of that process, is rich with meaning. Jacob inscribed the date he purchased the Philippson Bible 1 November 1848 on the book s Gedenkblatt, that is, the commemorative page on which an individual s or family s important milestones were customarily recorded. Spurred on by the revolutions that swept through Europe in that year and the radical reforms that followed which heralded a new epoch for the Jews (95) Jacob may have purchased the bilingual text in order to participate in a Reading and Cultural Circle, dedicated to spreading the principles of the Haskalah, which had opened in Tysmenitz that same year (Krüll 1979, 88). As a result of the upheavals, the feudal system was abolished and Austrian Jews were de jure if not de facto granted their full political and civil rights. With the events of 1848, Galician Jews were confronted with a difficult existential choice, namely, of either integrating into an emancipated and educated bourgeoisie or retreating into a secluded, homogeneously observant Jewish community. Jacob s acquisition of that particular Bible in that particular year suggests that the wave of progressive developments led him to consolidate his choice in favor of the first option. Rizzuto (1998) writes that, as a student of the Torah he moved from the orthodoxy of the shtetl, with its Hebrew Torah, to the bilingual Hebrew and German edition of the Bible produced by Ludwig and Phoebus Philippson (33). The Philippson family played a prominent role in the German Haskalah and Reform Movement. In their case, it was Ludwig and Phoebus father, Moses the son of a poor peddler who stood at the same historical juncture as Jacob Freud: he too was a member of the first generation to have taken a first decisive step away from the orthodox Judaism
7 Joel Whitebook 145 of his ancestors (Robert 1974, 21). Moses Philippson, who received a traditional orthodox upbringing, became an adherent of the Haskalah as a result of his encounter with the work of Moses Mendelssohn and German literature. He pursued his new calling as a teacher at a recently founded Jewish school, where his subjects included Hebrew, religion, and arithmetic; and as an organizer of a number of bilingual publishing projects, he intended to promote enlightened thinking in the Jewish community. In the next generation, Moses youngest son, Ludwig who would become the moving force behind the Israelitische Bibel took it upon himself to perpetuate his father s ideals (Rizzuto 1998, 105). Ludwig was equally at home in the world of Judentum and Humanität, German Enlightenment humanism and its liberal values (Gresser 1994, 1). He received a Gymnasium education in Halle, obtained a doctorate in philology from the University of Berlin, and was as adept in classical literature as he was in Hebrew. After he had completed his studies in Berlin, the Jewish community of Magdeburg invited Ludwig Philippson to deliver a sermon to their congregation. They were so impressed with his performance that they hired him as their Prediger, or preacher German law forbade them from using the term rabbi. Though he was by no means a radical, one cannot miss the distinctively reform elements in Ludwig s approach (Gresser 1994, 106). Certain traditional parts of the service continued to be conducted in Hebrew, but the sermon was delivered and the songs were sung in German. These innovations along with the introduction of an organ into the synagogue were meant to draw members of the congregation into the service and help them achieve a better understanding of its content. To someone with our contemporary sensibility, Ludwig s most impressive innovation was perhaps his introduction of confirmation for both sexes; he did this to make women feel they were valued members of the community. In addition to his work with the Magdeburg Congregation, Ludwig Philippson also founded the Allgemeine Zeitung Des Judentums ( General Journal of Judaism ) in 1837, the first modern Jewish newspaper in Central Europe, which he continued to edit until his death in Throughout Ludwig s tenure, the
8 146 Jacob s Ambivalent Legacy journal which was called the mouthpiece of German Jewry (Gresser 1994, 106) continued to support the fight for Jewish emancipation, even during the periods of reaction that followed the revolutions of The publication of the Philippson Bible, which took sixteen years to complete, was a work of serious scholarship in the spirit of the Wissenschaft des Judentums movement (Gresser 1994, 25) 4 that is, the nineteenth-century movement that sought to apply the most sophisticated methods of contemporary scholarship to the study of the science of Judaism. A page of the new Bible could comprise the Hebrew text of the Old Testament on the right side, its German translation on the left, and, below that, extensive footnotes containing commentaries on the relevant passage. Not only did these footnotes present important works of Jewish and Christian exegesis, they also contained scholarly entries from such fields as anthropology, the history of the ancient world, comparative mythology and religion, medicine, and even the botany of the Near East all meant to expand the reader s appreciation of the Old Testament. More striking still, the Philippson Bible contained 685 illustrations meant to evoke the historical, cultural, and physical context of the biblical story. They depicted landscapes, towns, plants, animals, coins, utilitarian objects from everyday life, and even Egyptian gods that is to say, images of foreign deities. As Jacob Freud surely knew, all these elements of the volume he chose to purchase the German translation, the scientific commentaries, and especially the illustrations, which violate God s stern prohibition on using images (Gresser 1994, 41) would have been viewed as sacrilegious from the vantage point of the Orthodox world in which he had been brought up. While the Bible was wissenschaftlich, its intent was not to debunk. As opposed to some of the practitioners of the Higher Criticism, the Philippson brothers did not seek to use the weapons of modern scholarship to undermine the authority of the Bible. 5 And, unlike Feuerbach, they did not seek to invalidate religion through a reduction ad anthropos, an anthropological critique of its content. On the contrary, their aim was to enhance religious experience and deepen the understanding of the Bible by drawing on everything the general storehouse of human knowledge had to offer. They sought to integrate their
9 Joel Whitebook 147 faith in God, Judaism, and the Torah with the advances of the Enlightenment to transillumninate the substance of the Scriptures... with the vision and the wisdom of the Aufklärung (Rizzuto 1998, 62). But whatever their intentions, by treating the biblical text as an object of Wissenschaft rather than merely of exegesis, the Philippsons contributed to the decentering of tradition (see Habermas 1981, 68ff.). It was not simply a lack of secular education that had kept Jews from reflecting on their fundamental beliefs before the nineteenth century. From within their closed worldview, such reflection simply did not make sense. For the orthodox, it was a thoroughly ingrained belief that the Torah and Talmud were of Divine origin and therefore immune to such critical scrutiny (Rice 1990, 89). A tradition is only traditionalist in the strict sense when its basic tenets cannot be reflected on, especially from an external standpoint. The structure of the traditional group s psychology is such that its fundamental idols are immunized from interrogation (see Castoriadis 1975, ; and Habermas 1981, 61). They are there, taken for granted and, to paraphrase Winnicott, the idea of calling them into question simply does not arise because it cannot. 6 Scientifically to objectify a people s tradition and belief system, as the Philippsons did with the Jews that is, to treat it as one social formation among many, formed by the contingent forces of history (see Yerushalmi 1989, ch. 4) is to deprive it of its strictly traditionalist character. 5 On the occasion of his thirty-fifth birthday, Jacob, as mentioned, had the family Bible rebound in leather, wrote an impassioned inscription in Hebrew on its Gedenkblatt, and presented it to his son as a gift. In addition to the year when he purchased it, there were two other earlier entries on the Gedenkblatt, written so close to each other that they might be mistaken for one. The first records the passing of Shlomo, who had died three months before Sigmund was born, and stresses the Reb s pious nature. The second commemorates the dates of Sigmund s birth and of his circumcision, that is, the day
10 148 Jacob s Ambivalent Legacy he entered the covenant. Jacob s meaning is clear: Sigmund should walk the straight course, that is, live a pious life like the grandfather after whom he had been named, and thus preserve the continuity of the generations. The inscription that Jacob entered on the Gedenkblatt on Sigmund s thirty-fifth birthday, long after his son had repudiated an observant way of life and had become an established scientist and confirmed atheist, amounts to an appeal. Reminding Sigmund how the Bible had moved him in his childhood, Jacob asks his son to renew his involvement in the Book of books enthusiastically with a song. Jacob s dramatic call to return to the Bible, to the originally shared values with the father constitutes, as Yerushalmi (1991) observes, his real mandate to his son (74). The third inscription has been the subject of intense scholarly debate. Through close readings of the text, participants have attempted to determine to what extend the Reform Movement and the Haskalah had transformed Jacob and to what he extent he remained orthodox and observant. 7 It is not clear, however, what these scholars believe would be accomplished if they could determine that Jacob was X percent secularist and Y percent traditionalist. If we take the long view on the developments under consideration, Jacob s precise location on the spectrum of heterodoxy or orthodoxy becomes a secondary concern. The more significant point is this: however pious those inscriptions may or may not be, they are recorded in a book, the Philippson Bible, which is itself situated on the far side of the break with tradition. The two-fold legacy that Jacob transmitted to Sigmund while reading to him from the Philippson Bible contained the seeds of its own subversion. The opposition between the pious appeal of Jacob s dedications, on the one hand, and the Enlightenment spirit sedimented in the book in which he inscribed them, on the other, defines the two poles of his ambivalent legacy. According to the inscription, Sigmund should in a way that was impossible for Jacob to specify be observant and committed to transmitting the tradition of his people, while at the same time enjoying the advantages of secular modernity its culture, prosperity, cosmopolitanism, political freedom, and, most importantly for our purposes, its science.
11 Joel Whitebook 149 Rizzuto (1998) observes that the Bible s illustrations themselves, which offered a broad view of many other nations, other peoples, and landscapes (118), must have served to produce cosmopolitan outlook in Freud that is, an anthropological, Herodotian, attitude, which transported him beyond the parochial confines of Leopoldstadt, the crowded Jewish district of Vienna where he lived. Jacob and the Philippsons believed that religious faith and Wissenschaft were compatible. They did not think that critical reflection would necessarily lead to the subversion of faith. However, in Freud s case, as in so many, a scientific examination of religion in fact led to its rejection. After all, it is not such a large a step from the Wissenschaft des Jüdentum to Feuerbach, whom, as Freud told his Rumanian friend Eduard Silberstein, he revere[d] and admire[d] above all other philosophers when he was at the university (Boehlich 1990, 96). What remained an inner tension for Jacob turned into an open conflict for his son. When Freud took what was his father s and made it his own, he extended the enlightened scientific outlook sedimented in the Bible that Jacob had handed down to him especially in its footnotes and turned it against religious belief in order to debunk it. Where Jacob tried to have it both ways, Sigmund recognized that this was impossible, which is to say that, where the father had been a transitional figure, the son became the full-fledged oxymoron, a godless Jew. 6 The story has often been told of how many prominent Central European Jews from recently emancipated families experienced an irreconcilable conflict between their Jewish origins and their allegiance to the ideals of German Kultur and Bildung an allegiance that Freud shared (see Gresser 1994). The conflict became so acute that it led a number of them Heine, Mahler, Kraus, and Schoenberg, for example to convert to Christianity. Now, it is true that, in addition to being a steadfast atheist, Freud could be embarrassed by and even contemptuous of the numerous Ostjuden who were moving into Vienna from the provinces. And it is also true that the dissociative episode
12 150 Jacob s Ambivalent Legacy he experienced on the Acropolis shows that he was highly conflicted about surpassing his father, a humble shtetl Jew from Galicia, in his acquisition of Western culture (see Freud 1936, 239). But Freud who was as home in his Jewish psyche as he was with his brethren at the B nai Brith never experienced a fundamental opposition between the Jewish tradition and the German Aufklärung. That is, there was for Freud no conflict between what he absorbed at his father s knee, reading the Philippson Bible and at the Jewish Volkschüle that he attended until the age of eight, one the one hand, and, on the other, the values of the classical education he internalized at the Sperlgymnasium. Furthermore, he never denied that he was a Jew or seriously entertained the option of conversion. Freud s selective reading of the Jewish tradition allowed him to overcome the fundamental dichotomy between Jüdentum and the Aufklärung, Judaism and the Enlightenment, which led many of his famous compatriots to convert. He ignored a multitude of other trends in Judaism and identified the Jewish tradition exclusively with the Mosaic tradition. Furthermore, Freud construed Moses who was himself the heir to Akhenaten s Egyptian Enlightenment 8 as an Aufklärer by virtue his monotheism, opposition to myth, magic, and sorcery (Freud 1939, 24), his commitment to truth, order, and justice (21), and, most importantly, his elevation of Geistigkeit (spirituality or intellectuality) over sensuality. 9 This view removed for Freud any essential opposition between Judaism and the Enlightenment. Moreover, like the modern-day Aufklärer Kant, Marx, and Freud himself Moses was engaged in critique, and more specifically, the critique of idolatry (see Yerushalmi 1991, 22). Indeed, I would maintain that (despite the familiar attempts to paint Freud as a mechanistic positivist) science or Wissenschaft in the fundamental sense of the term, is for him critique, methodical iconoclasm. Just as Moses attacked false gods in the name of the one true God who is immaterial and transcendent, which is to say, conceptual so the Aufklärer criticized illusory beliefs in the name of science. Even the Jewish joke can be seen as a form of democratic critique. Its aim is often to puncture the narcissistic pretensions of whoever is on the receiving end, especially those in positions of status and power.
13 Joel Whitebook With these considerations in mind, let us return in conclusion to the matter of a godless Jew. By equating the Jewish with the Mosaic tradition, Freud could not only hold onto his atheism and assert his bona fides as Jew; he could also maintain that his psychoanalytic critique of religion remained within the bounds of Judaism indeed, that it in fact advanced Judaism understood as the Mosaic program of critique (see Yerushalmi 1991, 99). What is more, the Mosaic credentials that allow Freud to assert his Jewishness also explain his godlessness. For him, the inner logic of the critique of idolatry leads to the death of God. That is, the critique of false gods unfolds to the point that it is no longer a matter of the idolatrous nature of this or that particular religion; rather, a threshold is reached where critique shows that religion as such is, as it were, idolatrous false, illusory. In Freud s view, Judaism is further advanced than Catholicism by virtue of the fact that it is more disenchanted. Judaism remains rigorously monotheistic, but Catholicism s introduction of the trinity, the mother-goddess in the guise of the Madonna, and intermediate beings such as angels represents, for Freud, a regression to sensuality and polytheism (see Freud 1939, 88ff.). In another respect, however, Christianity constitutes an advance over Judaism. Through the sacrifice of Christ, Christians, Freud argues, implicitly acknowledge the murder of the primal father albeit indirectly and in a disguised form. This is something the Jews have not been able to do. And Judaism s disavowal of the murder of the father Moses and, behind him, the figure of the primal father is a serious shortcoming that leads to a proliferation of obsessional laws as a way of trying to cope with the unacknowledged and unconscious guilt. For Freud, Judaism is something like the truth in an untrue form. It is true by virtue of its disenchanted stance. It is untrue insofar as this process of disenchantment has not led Judaism to shed its religious form. It is also untrue and less advanced than Catholicism in that it disavows the murder of the primal father. The next step for the Mosaic program of disenchanting critique would be for the Jews to acknowledge the truth of the primal murder, which would mean to accept
14 152 Jacob s Ambivalent Legacy Freud s theory of the father complex and his account of the psychological origins of religion in terms of it. And at this point in the process of demythologization, Judaism would cease to be a religion and pass over into something else, namely, psychoanalysis. Freud appears to be suggesting, implicitly at least, that psychoanalysis is the heir to and perhaps fulfillment of the Jewish tradition understood as the Mosaic tradition of critique. It is therefore not as far-fetched as it may seem when Yerushalmi (1991) proposes that, just as Freud viewed himself as a godless Jew, he saw psychoanalysis as godless Judaism (99). Nor is it too far-fetched to infer that Freud saw himself as Moses, the great man who had created the psychoanalytic movement a movement that, as Freud was writing Moses and Monotheism, was about to be exiled from continental Europe and form a new Diaspora. For a long time there was a self-imposed ban among analysts, begun by Freud himself, on calling attention to the Jewish origins of the field. It was feared that psychoanalysis would be seen as a Jewish national affair and that its claim to universal scientific validity would be invalidated. The ban was lifted when Marthe Robert published From Oedipus to Moses (1974), and a number of authors began writing on the topic of Freud and Judaism. Then, however, a new difficulty arose. If earlier commentators had seen psychoanalysis as not Jewish enough, now certain authors were viewing it as too Jewish. A tendency has developed, with Rice (1990), for example, to construe Freud s taking up of the Moses legend in his latter years as a fulfillment of Jacob s mandate to return to the Book of books and a homecoming to his Jewish origins. And the claim is undeniably true. But this is only one half of the story. As Richard Armstrong (2005) points out, it seems brutally clear that Freud s return to Jewish tradition in Moses and Monotheism is no facile reconciliation, nor death-bed lapse into suitably modified form of piety (248). A man s creative achievements involve identification with the father and patricide in almost in equal measure (see Whitebook 2004, 85, 101). And this is certainly true of Freud s late masterpiece, Moses and Monotheism. It is not simply the case, as Yerushalmi suggests, that Freud found a happy solution, which allowed him to obey his
15 Joel Whitebook 153 father and maintain his independence from his father through his interpretation (78) of the biblical story at the same time; nor is it the case, as Rice (1990) maintains, that Moses and Monotheism represents Freud s attempt to come home again to his Jewish roots but on his own terms and in his own way (7). The notions of maintaining one s independence and on one s own terms and in one s own way are too tepid. Not only does Moses and Monotheism represent an act of deferred obedience to and with identification his father; it also represents an act of patricide against the religion of the fathers. Freud is aware of the patricidal element in his writing on Moses. Indeed, he begins the book with a well-known apology for the destructiveness he is directing against his people by depriving them of the man whom they take pride in as the greatest of their sons. But he justifies the injury he is causing by maintaining that a gain in knowledge should take precedence over national interests (1939, 7) something that would hardly be self-evident to a person who does not share his ethic of scientific truth. But there is a more crucial point. Freud admits (1935, 72) the Feuerbachian view of religion he had advanced in Future of an Illusion was too simple and did not do justice to the subject. And there is no denying that he shows a much deeper awareness of the depth and emotional power of religious experience in Moses and Monotheism. Nevertheless, though the new formula proceeds to explain the power of religion, it does nothing to restore its validity. Freud does not budge one inch on this question. The new thesis namely, that religion represents a historical rather than a material truth is as reductionist and deflationary as the one he advanced in Totem and Taboo (1913). Indeed, it is the same thesis: that collective psychology represents the dynamics of individual and familial psychology writ large, and that the meaning of religion can be traced to the murder of the primal father hardly propositions that a believer could find congenial. Columbia University Center for Psychoanalytic Training and Research 1051 Riverside Drive, Unit 63 New York, NY whitebookj@aol.com
16 154 Jacob s Ambivalent Legacy Notes 1. This point was made to me by Jill Salberg. 2 For an account of how an earlier episode of that break with tradition, namely, the one that occurred with the Marranos in the seventeenth century, helped to produce another great Jewish heretical thinker, Spinoza, see Yovel (1989). 3 In Totem and Taboo, Freud cites one of his favorite quotations from Goethe: What thou hast inherited from thy fathers, acquire it to make thine (1913, 158). 4 Philippson s journal in fact played a role in establishing and supporting the influential Lehranstalt für die Wissenschaft des Judentums (The Institute for the Science of Judaism). See Encyclopaedia Judaica Jerusalem (1971, 13:64). 5 Yerushalmi (1991) maintains that the attitude of the Philippson commentary toward biblical and later Jewish tradition is nothing but reverent and, indeed, conservative: The integrity of the sacred text is never questioned, the text is never emended, the central findings of the Higher Criticism are rejected, and the creation of the world in six days, as well as the traditional Mosaic authorship of the entire Pentateuch, defended (64). 6 Thus, even if individuals choose to retain the beliefs of a tradition after it has been critically objectified, the mode in which they adhere to these beliefs has been radically altered. Strictly speaking, one cannot choose to be a traditionalist. 7 See, for example, Bergmann (1976), Ostow (1982), Rice (1990), and Yerushalmi (1991, 64 67). 8 Schorske (1998) argues that one reason Freud presented Moses as the unwavering defender of Geistigkeit and ignored more sensual elements in the Egyptian tradition was political: For in Egypt, the Jews became a Kulturvolk that rescued the highest gentile civilization [which coincided with Akhenaten s reign] from the unholy alliance of priests and ignorant people, just as, in modern times, the Jews and cultured gentiles were, through exodus and exile, saving Europe s enlightened civilization from Hitler (209). 9 Bernstein (1998) focuses on the advancement of intellectuality/spirituality as the essential feature of Judaism. See also Assman (1997, chs. 1 and 5). References Armstrong, Richard H A Compulsion for Antiquity: Freud and the Ancient World. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Assman, Jan Moses the Egyptian: The Memory of Egypt in Western Monotheism. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Bergmann, Martin S Moses and the Evolution of Freud s Jewish identity. Israel Annals of Psychiatry and Related Disciplines, 14:3 26. Bernstein, Richard J Freud and the Legacy of Moses. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Boehlich, Walter, ed The Letters of Sigmund Freud and Eduard Silberstein, Trans. Arnold J. Pomerans. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Castoriadis, Cornelius The Imaginary Institution of Society. Trans. Kathleen Blamey. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, Encyclopaedia Judaica Jerusalem New York: Macmillan. Freud, Sigmund Totem and Taboo. S.E., 13: An Autobiographical Study. S.E., 20: The Future of an Illusion. S.E., 21: Postscript to An Autobiographical Study. S.E., 20: A Disturbance of Memory on the Acropolis. S.E., 22: Moses and Monotheism. S.E., 23: Gresser, Moshe Dual Allegiance: Freud as a Modern Jew. Albany: State University of New York Press.
17 Joel Whitebook 155 Habermas, Jürgen The Theory of Communicative Action, Vol. 1: Reason and the Rationalization of Society. Trans. Thomas McCarthy. Boston: Beacon Press, Heller, Judith Bernays Freud s Mother and Father. In Freud as We Knew Him. Ed. Hendrik M. Ruitenbeek. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, pp Krüll, Marianne Freud and His Father. Trans. Arnold J. Pomerans. New York: Norton, Ostow, Mortimer Discussion of Martin S. Bergmann s paper. In Judaism and Psychoanalysis, ed. Mortimer Ostow. New York: Ktav Publishing House, pp. # #. Rice, Emmanuel Freud and Moses: The Long Journey Home. Albany: State University Press of NY. Rizzuto, Ana-María Why Did Freud Reject God? A Psychodynamic Interpretation. New Haven: Yale University Press. Robert, Marthe From Oedipus to Moses: Freud s Jewish Identity. Trans. Ralph Manheim. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, Schorske, Carl To the Egyptian Dig: Freud s Psycho-Archaeology of Culture. In Thinking in History. Princeton: Princeton University Press, pp Simon, Ernst Sigmund Freud, the Jew. In Leo Baeck Institute Yearbook 2. London: East and West Library, pp Whitebook, Joel Hans Loewald: A Radical Conservative. International Journal of Psychoanalysis, 85: Yerushalmi, Yosef Hayim Zakhor: Jewish History and Jewish Memory. New York: Schocken Books Freud s Moses: Judaism Terminable and Interminable. New Haven: Yale University Press. Yovel, Yirmiyahu Spinoza and Other Heretics, vol. 1: The Marrano of Reason. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
18
Wandering Jews: From Galicia to Vienna
1 Wandering Jews: From Galicia to Vienna The Break with Tradition The break with tradition, the theme that preoccupied the great theorists of modernity Hegel, Nietzsche, Marx, Durkheim, and Weber was also
More informationSUMMER SERMON SERIES 2016 The Movements of Judaism and their Founders V: MORDECAI KAPLAN AND RECONSTRUCTIONIST JUDAISM.
Shabbat shalom! 1 SUMMER SERMON SERIES 2016 The Movements of Judaism and their Founders V: MORDECAI KAPLAN AND RECONSTRUCTIONIST JUDAISM August 5, 2016 My parents and especially my grandparents were very
More information1 Hans Jonas, The Imperative of Responsibility: In Search of an Ethics for the Technological Age (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1984), 1-10.
Introduction This book seeks to provide a metaethical analysis of the responsibility ethics of two of its prominent defenders: H. Richard Niebuhr and Emmanuel Levinas. In any ethical writings, some use
More informationDefender of the Faith? By MARK EDMUNDSON
Defender of the Faith? By MARK EDMUNDSON Late in life he was in his 80s, in fact Sigmund Freud got religion. No, Freud didn t begin showing up at temple every Saturday, wrapping himself in a prayer shawl
More informationStudent Number: Programme of Study: MSc Nationalism & Ethnic Conflict. Module Code/ Title of Module: Nationalism & Ethno-Religious Conflict
Department of Politics COURSEWORK COVER SHEET Student Number:12700368 Programme of Study: MSc Nationalism & Ethnic Conflict Module Code/ Title of Module: Nationalism & Ethno-Religious Conflict Essay Title:
More informationThe Vocation Movement in Lutheran Higher Education
Intersections Volume 2016 Number 43 Article 5 2016 The Vocation Movement in Lutheran Higher Education Mark Wilhelm Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.augustana.edu/intersections
More informationp , pp
Psychoanalysis was started by a Jew, Sigmund Freud. He was born in Freiburg in Moravia and lived from the age of 2 in Vienna but his parents were born in Galicia his father Jakob in Tzimenitz and his mother
More information(Please see the foot notes which are also reproduced at the end of this text.)
Haydee Faimberg (Paris) Presentation on the Panel on Memory Chaired by Ted Jacobs (Please see the foot notes which are also reproduced at the end of this text.) Disposing of 20 minutes and being very curious
More informationerscheint in G. Motzkin u.a. (Hg.): Religion and Democracy in a Globalizing Europe (2009) Civil Religion and Secular Religion
1 erscheint in G. Motzkin u.a. (Hg.): Religion and Democracy in a Globalizing Europe (2009) Lucian Hölscher Civil Religion and Secular Religion (Jerusalem, 2 nd of September 2007) Scientific truth is said
More informationRabbi Eliyahu Benamozegh -- Plato of the Italian Jewry Alicia Sisso Raz
Rabbi Eliyahu Benamozegh -- Plato of the Italian Jewry Alicia Sisso Raz Plato of the Italian Jewry, that is how Rabbi Eliyahu Benamozegh was called. He was an unusual orthodox rabbi: the intellectual leader
More informationResolutio of Idealism into Atheism in Fichte
Maria Pia Mater Thomistic Week 2018 Resolutio of Idealism into Atheism in Fichte Introduction Cornelio Fabro s God in Exile, traces the progression of modern atheism from its roots in the cogito of Rene
More informationReimagining God. The Faith Journey of a Modern Heretic. Lloyd Geering. Study & discussion guide prepared by Jarmo Tarkki
Reimagining God The Faith Journey of a Modern Heretic Lloyd Geering Study & discussion guide prepared by Jarmo Tarkki PART 1. The Starting Point Chapter 1. God and Me Lloyd Geering became a Christian as
More informationLudwig Feuerbach The Essence of Christianity (excerpts) 1 PHIL101 Prof. Oakes updated: 10/23/13 9:10 AM. Section III: How do I know? Reading III.
Ludwig Feuerbach The Essence of Christianity (excerpts) 1 PHIL101 Prof. Oakes updated: 10/23/13 9:10 AM Section III: How do I know? Reading III.6 The German philosopher, Ludwig Feuerbach, develops a humanist
More informationWHAT SHOULD A COMMENTARY COMMENT ON? Richard Elliott Friedman
WHAT SHOULD A COMMENTARY COMMENT ON? Richard Elliott Friedman Note: Professor Friedman gave the keynote address, which looked at what biblical commentary needs to address in this age. The following is
More informationPhil 114, Wednesday, April 11, 2012 Hegel, The Philosophy of Right 1 7, 10 12, 14 16, 22 23, 27 33, 135, 141
Phil 114, Wednesday, April 11, 2012 Hegel, The Philosophy of Right 1 7, 10 12, 14 16, 22 23, 27 33, 135, 141 Dialectic: For Hegel, dialectic is a process governed by a principle of development, i.e., Reason
More informationWhy Feuerbach Is both Classic and Modern
Ursula Reitemeyer Why Feuerbach Is both Classic and Modern At a certain level of abstraction, the title of this postscript may appear to be contradictory. The Classics are connected, independently of their
More informationIn Search of the Ontological Argument. Richard Oxenberg
1 In Search of the Ontological Argument Richard Oxenberg Abstract We can attend to the logic of Anselm's ontological argument, and amuse ourselves for a few hours unraveling its convoluted word-play, or
More informationEVIL, SIN, FALSITY AND THE DYNAMICS OF FAITH. Masao Abe
EVIL, SIN, FALSITY AND THE DYNAMICS OF FAITH Masao Abe I The apparently similar concepts of evil, sin, and falsity, when considered from our subjective standpoint, are somehow mutually distinct and yet
More informationTowards Richard Rorty s Critique on Transcendental Grounding of Human Rights by Dr. P.S. Sreevidya
Towards Richard Rorty s Critique on Transcendental Grounding of Human Rights by Dr. P.S. Sreevidya Abstract This article considers how the human rights theory established by US pragmatist Richard Rorty,
More information[JGRChJ 9 (2013) R28-R32] BOOK REVIEW
[JGRChJ 9 (2013) R28-R32] BOOK REVIEW Craig S. Keener, Miracles: The Credibility of the New Testament Accounts (2 vols.; Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2011). xxxviii + 1172 pp. Hbk. US$59.99. Craig Keener
More informationntroduction to Socialist Humanism: An International Symposium by Eri...
ntroduction to Socialist Humanism: An International Symposium by Eri... 1 of 5 8/22/2015 2:38 PM Erich Fromm 1965 Introduction to Socialist Humanism: An International Symposium Written: 1965; Source: The
More information3. RELIGIOUS EDUCATION IN CATHOLIC SCHOOLS
3. RELIGIOUS EDUCATION IN CATHOLIC SCHOOLS What is Religious Education and what is its purpose in the Catholic School? Although this pamphlet deals primarily with Religious Education as a subject in Catholic
More informationInspiration Of The Bible Kelly's Idiot Notes from his New Analytical Bible with his own commentary
Inspiration Of The Bible Kelly's Idiot Notes from his New Analytical Bible with his own commentary The Bible remarkable book & its teachings are profoundly valuable Some do not consider these teachings
More informationAre Judaism and Evolution Compatible? Parashat B reishit 5779 October 6, 2018 Rabbi Carl M. Perkins Temple Aliyah, Needham
Are Judaism and Evolution Compatible? Parashat B reishit 5779 October 6, 2018 Rabbi Carl M. Perkins Temple Aliyah, Needham I m sure many of us have heard about the child who comes home from Hebrew School,
More informationComment on Martha Nussbaum s Purified Patriotism
Comment on Martha Nussbaum s Purified Patriotism Patriotism is generally thought to require a special attachment to the particular: to one s own country and to one s fellow citizens. It is therefore thought
More informationThe Paradox of the stone and two concepts of omnipotence
Filo Sofija Nr 30 (2015/3), s. 239-246 ISSN 1642-3267 Jacek Wojtysiak John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin The Paradox of the stone and two concepts of omnipotence Introduction The history of science
More informationPihlström, Sami Johannes.
https://helda.helsinki.fi Peirce and the Conduct of Life: Sentiment and Instinct in Ethics and Religion by Richard Kenneth Atkins. Cambridge University Press, 2016. [Book review] Pihlström, Sami Johannes
More informationd) The (first) debate about Pantheism
d) The (first) debate about Pantheism G. Valee (ed.), The Spinoza Conversations between Lessing and Jacobi T. Yasukata, Lessing s Philosophy of Religion, op. cit., ch. 7 F. Beiser, The Fate of Reason.
More informationA CONCEPTUAL ANALYSIS OF SECULARISM AND ITS LEGITIMACY IN THE CONSTITUTIONAL DEMOCRATIC STATE
A CONCEPTUAL ANALYSIS OF SECULARISM AND ITS LEGITIMACY IN THE CONSTITUTIONAL DEMOCRATIC STATE Adil Usturali 2015 POLICY BRIEF SERIES OVERVIEW The last few decades witnessed the rise of religion in public
More informationInterpreting the Bible in Our Times Lesson Two Caution: There are many, many variations of Biblical interpretation.
Interpreting the Bible in Our Times Lesson Two Caution: These basic views of how to interpret the Bible do not lend themselves to rigid categorization. Views below are sometimes cast in their extreme form
More informationAvatar Adi Da s Final Summary Description of His Dialogue with Swami Muktananda
A Selection from the Reality-Teaching of His Divine Presence, Avatar Adi Da Samraj An excerpt from the book The Knee of Listening Available online at KneeofListening.com or by calling 877.770.0772 (within
More informationKant and his Successors
Kant and his Successors G. J. Mattey Winter, 2011 / Philosophy 151 The Sorry State of Metaphysics Kant s Critique of Pure Reason (1781) was an attempt to put metaphysics on a scientific basis. Metaphysics
More informationGCE. Religious Studies. Mark Scheme for June Advanced GCE Unit G589: Judaism. Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE Religious Studies Advanced GCE Unit G589: Judaism Mark Scheme for June 2011 Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK awarding body, providing a wide range
More informationAn Interview with Alain Badiou Universal Truths and the Question of Religion Adam S. Miller Journal of Philosophy and Scripture
the field of the question of truth. Volume 3, Issue 1 Fall 2005 An Interview with Alain Badiou Universal Truths and the Question of Religion Adam S. Miller Journal of Philosophy and Scripture JPS: Would
More informationI, for my part, have tried to bear in mind the very aims Dante set himself in writing this work, that is:
PREFACE Another book on Dante? There are already so many one might object often of great worth for how they illustrate the various aspects of this great poetic work: the historical significance, literary,
More informationQUERIES: to be answered by AUTHOR
Manuscript Information British Journal for the History of Philosophy Journal Acronym Volume and issue Author name Manuscript No. (if applicable) RBJH _A_478506 Typeset by KnowledgeWorks Global Ltd. for
More informationRonald Dworkin, Religion without God, Harvard University Press, 2013, pp. 192, 16.50, ISBN
Ronald Dworkin, Religion without God, Harvard University Press, 2013, pp. 192, 16.50, ISBN 9780674726826 Simone Grigoletto, Università degli Studi di Padova In 2009, Thomas Nagel, to whom Dworkin s book
More informationTotem and Taboo (1913): The Fortunate Fall & the Primal Psychoanalytic Myth
1 Totem and Taboo (1913): The Fortunate Fall & the Primal Psychoanalytic Myth In 1912 I took up a conjecture of Darwin s to the effect that the primitive form of human society was that of a horde ruled
More informationUniversity of Toronto. Department of Political Science Department for the Study of Religion JPR 419 SECULARISM AND RELIGION SYLLABUS 2016
University of Toronto Department of Political Science Department for the Study of Religion JPR 419 SECULARISM AND RELIGION SYLLABUS 2016 Fall Term - Tuesday, 6:00-8:00 Instructor: Professor Ruth Marshall
More informationCan Christianity be Reduced to Morality? Ted Di Maria, Philosophy, Gonzaga University Gonzaga Socratic Club, April 18, 2008
Can Christianity be Reduced to Morality? Ted Di Maria, Philosophy, Gonzaga University Gonzaga Socratic Club, April 18, 2008 As one of the world s great religions, Christianity has been one of the supreme
More informationThe Glory of God Is Intelligence : A Note on Maimonides. FARMS Review 19/2 (2007): (print), (online)
Title Author(s) Reference ISSN Abstract The Glory of God Is Intelligence : A Note on Maimonides Raphael Jospe FARMS Review 19/2 (2007): 95 98. 1550-3194 (print), 2156-8049 (online) This article compares
More information[MJTM 17 ( )] BOOK REVIEW
[MJTM 17 (2015 2016)] BOOK REVIEW Iain Provan. Discovering Genesis: Content, Interpretation, Reception. Discovering Biblical Texts. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2015. ix + 214 pp. Pbk. ISBN 978-0-802-87237-1.
More informationproposal via our prediction markets at. Christ s Ventriloquist: How St. Paul Engineered the Hoax that Shaped Our World by Eric Zuesse The first-ever legal/forensic exegesis of Paul s letter to the Galatians,
More informationA Review on What Is This Thing Called Ethics? by Christopher Bennett * ** 1
310 Book Review Book Review ISSN (Print) 1225-4924, ISSN (Online) 2508-3104 Catholic Theology and Thought, Vol. 79, July 2017 http://dx.doi.org/10.21731/ctat.2017.79.310 A Review on What Is This Thing
More informationLesson 5: The Tools That Are Needed (22) Systematic Theology Tools 1
Lesson 5: The Tools That Are Needed (22) Systematic Theology Tools 1 INTRODUCTION: OUR WORK ISN T OVER For most of the last four lessons, we ve been considering some of the specific tools that we use to
More informationJosé Casanova Public Religions Revisited
International Conference Religion Revisited Women s Rights and the Political Instrumentalisation of Religion, Heinrich-Böll-Foundation & United Nations Research Institute for Social Development (UNRISD),
More informationFUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF THE METAPHYSIC OF MORALS. by Immanuel Kant
FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF THE METAPHYSIC OF MORALS SECOND SECTION by Immanuel Kant TRANSITION FROM POPULAR MORAL PHILOSOPHY TO THE METAPHYSIC OF MORALS... This principle, that humanity and generally every
More informationFuture of Orthodoxy in the Near East
Future of Orthodoxy in the Near East An Educational Perspective Introduction Georges N. NAHAS SJDIT University of Balamand September 2010 Because of different political interpretations I will focus in
More informationReading Questions for Phil , Fall 2016 (Daniel)
Reading Questions for Phil 251.501, Fall 2016 (Daniel) Class One (Aug. 30): Philosophy Up to Plato (SW 3-78) 1. What does it mean to say that philosophy replaces myth as an explanatory device starting
More information7/31/2017. Kant and Our Ineradicable Desire to be God
Radical Evil Kant and Our Ineradicable Desire to be God 1 Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) Kant indeed marks the end of the Enlightenment: he brought its most fundamental assumptions concerning the powers of
More informationTraditionalism. by John M. Frame. Part 2 of 2: The Results of Traditionalism and The Antidote: Sola Scriptura
Traditionalism by John M. Frame Part 2 of 2: The Results of Traditionalism and The Antidote: Sola Scriptura The Results of Traditionalism As one committed heart and soul to the principle sola Scriptura,
More informationHOW WE GOT OUR BIBLE And WHY WE BELIEVE IT IS GOD'S WORD
HOW WE GOT OUR BIBLE And WHY WE BELIEVE IT IS GOD'S WORD by W. H. Griffith Thomas Copyright @ 1926 edited for 3BSB by Baptist Bible Believer ~ out-of-print and in the public domain ~ CHAPTER EIGHT PROGRESSIVENESS
More informationAtheists and Their Fathers
Atheists and Their Fathers Introduction How does one become an atheist? Does a person s relationship with his earthly father affect his relationship with his heavenly Father? These are some of the questions
More informationWho is A Jew, One Perspective
1 Who is A Jew, One Perspective In a recent conversation with a Messianic Jewish friend of mine, we dealt with the performance of Bar/Bat Mitzvoth for adult members of Messianic Jewish Congregations. While
More informationDating the Exodus: Another View
Dating the Exodus: Another View Article by Gary Greenberg published in KMT: A Modern Journal About Ancient Egypt, Summer 1994 Return to Bible Myth and History Home Page Omar Zuhdi s article on dating the
More informationWilliam Morrow Queen stheological College Kingston, Ontario, Canada
RBL 06/2007 Vogt, Peter T. Deuteronomic Theology and the Significance of Torah: A Reappraisal Winona Lake, Ind.: Eisenbrauns, 2006. Pp. xii + 242. Hardcover. $37.50. ISBN 1575061074. William Morrow Queen
More informationThe Emergence of Judaism How to Teach this Course/How to Teach this Book
The Emergence of Judaism How to Teach this Course/How to Teach this Book Challenges Teaching a course on the emergence of Judaism from its biblical beginnings to the end of the Talmudic period poses several
More informationChapter Six. Aristotle s Theory of Causation and the Ideas of Potentiality and Actuality
Chapter Six Aristotle s Theory of Causation and the Ideas of Potentiality and Actuality Key Words: Form and matter, potentiality and actuality, teleological, change, evolution. Formal cause, material cause,
More informationDworkin on the Rufie of Recognition
Dworkin on the Rufie of Recognition NANCY SNOW University of Notre Dame In the "Model of Rules I," Ronald Dworkin criticizes legal positivism, especially as articulated in the work of H. L. A. Hart, and
More informationIntermarriage Statistics David Rudolph, Ph.D.
Intermarriage Statistics David Rudolph, Ph.D. I am fascinated by intermarrieds, not only because I am intermarried but also because intermarrieds are changing the Jewish world. Tracking this reshaping
More informationEvery Tree Is Known by Its Own Fruit
ALAN GOLDBERG Every Tree Is Known by Its Own Fruit Of Mormonism, Trinitarianism and Polytheism* ALAN M. GOLDBERG When Jerusalem fell, Rome was quite prepared to give the God of Israel a place in her Pantheon.
More informationPaul Sanders Protestant Theological University
RBL 05/2018 Jan Assmann From Akhenaten to Moses: Ancient Egypt and Religious Change Cairo: American University in Cairo Press, 2014. Pp. ix + 155. Hardcover. $34.95. ISBN 9789774166310. Paul Sanders Protestant
More informationJEWS IN THE MODERN WORLD: HISTORY OF JEWISH CIVILIZATION III Spring History 141/Jewish Studies 158/Religious Studies 122/NELC 053
JEWS IN THE MODERN WORLD: HISTORY OF JEWISH CIVILIZATION III Spring 2017 History 141/Jewish Studies 158/Religious Studies 122/NELC 053 INSTRUCTOR: Beth S. Wenger OFFICE: 320 College Hall OFFICE HOURS:
More informationCosmopolitan Theory and the Daily Pluralism of Life
Chapter 8 Cosmopolitan Theory and the Daily Pluralism of Life Tariq Ramadan D rawing on my own experience, I will try to connect the world of philosophy and academia with the world in which people live
More informationJudaism. Classroom: 201 Comenius Hall Office: 108 Comenius Hall, ext Class times: Wednesdays 6:30pm-9:30pm Office Hours: Tues/Thurs 1:30-2:30pm
Judaism Religion 126 Professor: Jason Radine Classroom: 201 Comenius Hall Office: 108 Comenius Hall, ext. 1314 Class times: Wednesdays 6:30pm-9:30pm Office Hours: Tues/Thurs 1:30-2:30pm E-Mail: radine@moravian.edu
More informationHabermas and Critical Thinking
168 Ben Endres Columbia University In this paper, I propose to examine some of the implications of Jürgen Habermas s discourse ethics for critical thinking. Since the argument that Habermas presents is
More informationDifference between Science and Religion? - A Superficial, yet Tragi-Comic Misunderstanding
Scientific God Journal November 2012 Volume 3 Issue 10 pp. 955-960 955 Difference between Science and Religion? - A Superficial, yet Tragi-Comic Misunderstanding Essay Elemér E. Rosinger 1 Department of
More informationWorld Religions. These subject guidelines should be read in conjunction with the Introduction, Outline and Details all essays sections of this guide.
World Religions These subject guidelines should be read in conjunction with the Introduction, Outline and Details all essays sections of this guide. Overview Extended essays in world religions provide
More informationReading Engineer s Concept of Justice in Islam: The Real Power of Hermeneutical Consciousness (A Gadamer s Philosophical Hermeneutics)
DINIKA Academic Journal of Islamic Studies Volume 1, Number 1, January - April 2016 ISSN: 2503-4219 (p); 2503-4227 (e) Reading Engineer s Concept of Justice in Islam: The Real Power of Hermeneutical Consciousness
More informationKantian Deontology. A2 Ethics Revision Notes Page 1 of 7. Paul Nicholls 13P Religious Studies
A2 Ethics Revision Notes Page 1 of 7 Kantian Deontology Deontological (based on duty) ethical theory established by Emmanuel Kant in The Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals. Part of the enlightenment
More informationUNSTOPPABLE IMPACT SESSION 6. The Point. The Passage. The Bible Meets Life. The Setting. The gospel of Jesus Christ can impact any culture.
SESSION 6 UNSTOPPABLE IMPACT The Point The gospel of Jesus Christ can impact any culture. The Passage Acts 17:16-18,22-23,30-31 The Bible Meets Life America is a very diverse country: cultures, ethnicities,
More informationBACKGROUND. Hillel. What does it mean to be whole?
H I L L E L S J O S E P H M E Y E R H O F F CENTER FOR JEWISH EXPERIENCE Hillel BACKGROUND What does it mean to be whole? The word shalom is one of the first Hebrew words that many Jewish children learn;
More informationSaving the Substratum: Interpreting Kant s First Analogy
Res Cogitans Volume 5 Issue 1 Article 20 6-4-2014 Saving the Substratum: Interpreting Kant s First Analogy Kevin Harriman Lewis & Clark College Follow this and additional works at: http://commons.pacificu.edu/rescogitans
More informationby Reuben Zellman, 2008 given at the Metropolitan Community Church, San Jose, California on January 27th, 2008
No Longer Strangers? by Reuben Zellman, 2008 given at the Metropolitan Community Church, San Jose, California on January 27th, 2008 Good morning. I want to thank Pastor Ellard and Reverend Anderson, and
More informationUganda, morality was derived from God and the adult members were regarded as teachers of religion. God remained the canon against which the moral
ESSENTIAL APPROACHES TO CHRISTIAN RELIGIOUS EDUCATION: LEARNING AND TEACHING A PAPER PRESENTED TO THE SCHOOL OF RESEARCH AND POSTGRADUATE STUDIES UGANDA CHRISTIAN UNIVERSITY ON MARCH 23, 2018 Prof. Christopher
More informationCase Notes. Religious Schools and Equal Opportunity: Lessons from Goldberg v Korsunski Carmel School
Case Notes Religious Schools and Equal Opportunity: Lessons from Goldberg v Korsunski Carmel School Kate Offer, Law School, University of Western Australia The decision of the Equal Opportunity Tribunal
More informationThere is a gaping hole in modern thinking that may never
There is a gaping hole in modern thinking that may never have existed in human society before. It s so common that scarcely anyone notices it, while global catastrophes of natural and human origin plague
More informationContents. Guy Prentiss Waters. Justification and the New Perspectives on Paul: A Review and Response. P&R, pp.
Guy Prentiss Waters. Justification and the New Perspectives on Paul: A Review and Response. P&R, 2004. 273 pp. Dr. Guy Waters is assistant professor of biblical studies at Belhaven College. He studied
More informationVIEWING PERSPECTIVES
VIEWING PERSPECTIVES j. walter Viewing Perspectives - Page 1 of 6 In acting on the basis of values, people demonstrate points-of-view, or basic attitudes, about their own actions as well as the actions
More informationThe Mainline s Slippery Slope
The Mainline s Slippery Slope An Introduction So, what is the Mainline? Anyone who has taught a course on American religious history has heard this question numerous times, and usually more than once during
More informationPhilosophy in Review XXXIII (2013), no. 5
Robert Stern Understanding Moral Obligation. Kant, Hegel, Kierkegaard. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2012. 277 pages $90.00 (cloth ISBN 978 1 107 01207 3) In his thoroughly researched and tightly
More informationSpinoza: Does Thought Determine Reality? Thomistic Studies Week 2018 St. Isaac Jogues Novitiate Michael Scott, Nov
Spinoza: Does Thought Determine Reality? Thomistic Studies Week 2018 St. Isaac Jogues Novitiate Michael Scott, Nov Intro In the introduction of his book, God in Exile, Fr. Fabro lists five mandatory conditions
More informationBuddhist Psychology: The Mind That Mindfulness Discloses
Buddhist Psychology: The Mind That Mindfulness Discloses A review of Unlimiting Mind: The Radically Experiential Psychology of Buddhism by Andrew Olendzki Boston, MA: Wisdom Publications, 2010. 190 pp.
More informationThe title of this collection of essays is a question that I expect many professional philosophers have
What is Philosophy? C.P. Ragland and Sarah Heidt, eds. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 2001, vii + 196pp., $38.00 h.c. 0-300-08755-1, $18.00 pbk. 0-300-08794-2 CHRISTINA HENDRICKS The title
More informationWORLDVIEW ACADEMY KEY CONCEPTS IN THE CURRICULUM
WORLDVIEW ACADEMY KEY CONCEPTS IN THE CURRICULUM This list outlines the key concepts we hope to communicate at Worldview Academy Leadership Camps. The list is not an index of lectures; rather, it inventories
More informationRomans 10 : 5-15 Luke 4 : 1-13 Sermon
Romans 10 : 5-15 Luke 4 : 1-13 Sermon Today is something of a landmark day for me, and perhaps also for us as a congregation. For today 14 th February 2016, marks exactly 15 years since I started working
More informationMY PURPOSE IN THIS BOOK IS TO PRESENT A
I Holistic Pragmatism and the Philosophy of Culture MY PURPOSE IN THIS BOOK IS TO PRESENT A philosophical discussion of the main elements of civilization or culture such as science, law, religion, politics,
More informationConcepts of God: Yielding to Love pages 24-27
42. Responding to God (Catechism n. 2566-2567) Concepts of God: Yielding to Love pages 24-27 n. 2566.! We are in search of God. In the act of creation, God calls every being from nothingness into existence.!
More informationMoral Argumentation from a Rhetorical Point of View
Chapter 98 Moral Argumentation from a Rhetorical Point of View Lars Leeten Universität Hildesheim Practical thinking is a tricky business. Its aim will never be fulfilled unless influence on practical
More informationEichrodt, Walther. Theology of the Old Testament: Volume 1. The Old Testament Library.
Eichrodt, Walther. Theology of the Old Testament: Volume 1. The Old Testament Library. Translated by J.A. Baker. Philadelphia: Westminster, 1961. 542 pp. $50.00. The discipline of biblical theology has
More information6. The Industrial Revolution
6. The Industrial Revolution Friedrich Engels The history of the proletariat in England begins with the invention of the steam engine and of machinery for working cotton. These inventions gave rise to
More informationPhilosophical Approaches to Religion in the Perspective of the Concept of Human Essence 1 Nonka Bogomilova *
Проблеми на постмодерността, Том II, Брой 1, 2012 Postmodernism problems, Volume 2, Number 1, 2012 Philosophical Approaches to Religion in the Perspective of the Concept of Human Essence 1 Nonka Bogomilova
More informationCHARITY AND JUSTICE IN THE RELATIONS AMONG PEOPLE AND NATIONS: THE ENCYCLICAL DEUS CARITAS EST OF POPE BENEDICT XVI
Charity and Justice in the Relations among Peoples and Nations Pontifical Academy of Social Sciences, Acta 13, Vatican City 2007 www.pass.va/content/dam/scienzesociali/pdf/acta13/acta13-dinoia.pdf CHARITY
More informationTopic Page: Herder, Johann Gottfried,
Topic Page: Herder, Johann Gottfried, 1744-1803 Definition: Herder, Johann Gottf ried von from Philip's Encyclopedia German philosopher and poet. He believed human society to be an organic, secular totality
More informationJEWS IN THE MODERN WORLD: HISTORY OF JEWISH CIVILIZATION III Spring History 141/Jewish Studies 158/Religious Studies 122/NELC 053
JEWS IN THE MODERN WORLD: HISTORY OF JEWISH CIVILIZATION III Spring 2019 History 141/Jewish Studies 158/Religious Studies 122/NELC 053 INSTRUCTOR: Beth S. Wenger OFFICE: 320 College Hall OFFICE HOURS:
More informationNietzsche ( ) most influential after his death West has overemphasized rationality and stifled the authentic passions and animal instincts
1920 s Europe Nietzsche (1844-1900) most influential after his death West has overemphasized rationality and stifled the authentic passions and animal instincts that drive human activity and true creativity
More informationEric Schliesser Philosophy and Moral Sciences, Ghent University ª 2011, Eric Schliesser
826 BOOK REVIEWS proofs in the TTP that they are false. Consequently, Garber is mistaken that the TTP is suitable only for an ideal private audience... [that] should be whispered into the ear of the Philosopher
More informationHenry of Ghent on Divine Illumination
MP_C12.qxd 11/23/06 2:29 AM Page 103 12 Henry of Ghent on Divine Illumination [II.] Reply [A. Knowledge in a broad sense] Consider all the objects of cognition, standing in an ordered relation to each
More information7) Finally, entering into prospective and explicitly normative analysis I would like to introduce the following issues to the debate:
Judaism (s), Identity (ies) and Diaspora (s) - A view from the periphery (N.Y.), Contemplate: A Journal of secular humanistic Jewish writings, Vol. 1 Fasc. 1, 2001. Bernardo Sorj * 1) The period of history
More informationHEGEL (Historical, Dialectical Idealism)
HEGEL (Historical, Dialectical Idealism) Kinds of History (As a disciplined study/historiography) -Original: Written of own time -Reflective: Written of a past time, through the veil of the spirit of one
More information