Chapter 5. ç u % gesa Øks/k D;ksa vkrk gs\

Similar documents
Chapter 17. vius eu dks le>uk

Chapter 15. /kez. Religion

Chapter 15. ç u % jk{kl D;k gksrk gs\ gesa blls Mj D;ksa yxrk gs\

Chapter 8. egÿokdka{kk

Fear Chapter 2. Hk; ç u % nq[k D;k gs\

Chapter 14. iz u % lalkj esa jgrs gq, ge izxfr dsls dj ldrs gsa\

Chapter 4. v/;k; pkj. The Network of Thought Chapter 4 4th Public Talk Saanen 19th July 1981

laiknd izfke vuqhkkx vki D;k gsa\ eu dks le>uk

QUESTION BANK IN COMMUNICATIVE ENGLISH CLASS-IX (TERM-I) SECTION-D LITERATURE

ekufp= jktusfrd /kkj.kk,a gsa&&rf; ughaa % i`foh ^vkidh* ;k ^esjh* ughaa gs

From the Diaries of Josephites.

Media Coordinator s Office Jamia Millia Islamia. Prof. Faizan Mustafa addresses packed audience at JMI talks about Haji Ali Dargah verdict

AA Jh u`flag xk;=h ea= AA

okrkzyki&548] MsUVy ¼gfj;kuk½] rkfj[k& Disc.CD No. 548, dated at Dental (Hariyana)

okrkzyki ua- 322] Q:Z[kkckn] rk% Disc.CD No.322, dt at Farrukhabad

Admission Test (Sample Question Paper)

ACME NOVEMBER-DECEMBER 2017 TEACHER

Let Us March! esa vkt kkfur vksj usfrdrk ds bl ifo= eap ls osn ds ea= dks mppkfjr djrs gq, cgqr xksjkfuor gw A

le{k vnkyr Jh osn izdk'k 'kekz dk;zdkjh n.mkf/kdkjh] fugjh] rglhy fugjh] ftyk e.mh] fg0 iz0 cuke

okrkzyki&527 flgksj&2 ¼e/; izns k½ rkfj[k&

okrkzyki & 418] teew] rk & Disc.CD No.418, dated at Jammu

Founder s Day Flowers Show 2017

Regd. No. S 2227/63 64


Attitude of Muslim Parents towards Education of Their Girl Child : A Case Study of Jahangirabad Bhopal (M.P)

THE BISHOP S CANDLESTICKS

D.A.V. PUBLIC SCHOOL Sector- VI, Dwarka, New Delhi

okrkzyki lhmh ua- 480] iq.ks&1 ¼egkjk Vª½] rk% Disc CD No. 480, dated at Pune-1 (Maharashtra)

Dr. Kawarjit Kaur. Principal (Offg.) Message

70 Independence Day Celebrations at IMS Unison University

English Month Literature Course Grammar Book April The haunted house Day by day i float my paper boats (poem) Who did patricks homework

(1) lkald`frd iquqrfkkzu,oa Hkkjr fodkl ifj"kn~μ

THE MAN WHO KNEW TOO MUCH

NK Group. The only place for your place

n'kzu'kkl= PHILOSOPHY [ Hindi and English Medium ] ACADEMIC/OPEN (Only for Fresh/Re-appear Candidates)

ENGINEERING GRAPHICS. Class-XI CENTRAL BOARD OF SECONDARY EDUCATION 2, COMMUNITY CENTRE, PREET VIHAR, DELHI

Directorate of Secondary Education, Rajasthan, Bikaner. English. Class X. Study Material

eq[; leiknd dh dye ls----

1. Physical Health- Physical Health, free from physical diseases 2. Mental Health - Perfectly satisfied, happy & shock proof mind. 3.

RAMAKRISHNA MISSION ASHRAMA MORABADI, RANCHI 8. Ph.: , RAMAKRISHNA MISSION ASHRAMA MORABADI, RANCHI 8. Ph.

INTELLECT INTUITION. Higher Than. Higher than intellect is intuition. Intuition gives some romance to

Guest Lecture Organized by School of Mass Communication. Farewell Party for MCA batch Page 2. Modern Education: Need of The Hour Page 3

New Series Vol. 1 No. 3 July Satya Sahitya, a Quarterly Newsletter of Shree Ramsharnam International Centre, New Delhi

LkEiw.kZ ru= kkl=ksa ds iz.ksrk Hkxoku kadj gh ekus tkrs

IN THE DIVINE PRESENCE OF SHRI BABUJI

tfku;s&czkgekakm ds ijksidkjd dks

20 uoecj] November, 2014

News Broadcasting Standards Authority Order No. 56 (2018)

The way we see the world, creates the world we see...

Young, Muslim and reflecting on Ayodhya "The Hindu" - Hindi Translation

ISSUE-4 f{kfrt The Horizon

txn~xq# Ñikyq ifj"kr~

Neel Nag. A quarterly publication of Kashyap Kashmir Sabha, Gurgoan. Volume : 6 January - March 2007

VIDYA BHARATI SCHOOL V.E.P. ( ) Grade V SUBJECT : ENGLISH

Lokeh foosdkuun dk osnkur&,d foospuk (1) & fd'kksj vxzoky

Vishal International School

It may make you smile, It may make you frown. Or in a sea of emotion, It may make you drown. Section: I From The School

bz oj ¾ God gs dez khy tho! rw vkse~ ¾ bz oj dk Lej.k dja O the doer of deeds! Recite and remember the name of God i.e. AUM.

Price: Promotion & Propogation of Kashmir Pandit (Indian) Culture (1)

f keyk] eaxyokj] 12 uoecj] dkfrzd] 1935 fgekpy izns'k ljdkj HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA NOTIFICATION

Revision Notes vaxszth

Azim Premji University. Kaleidoscope of Our Thoughts '16

gfj;k.kk fo/kku lhkk dk;zokgh 18 ekpz] 1982 [k.m 1] vad 4 vf/k r fooj.k

TEST PAPER - 01 uhfr'kkl= Ethics Riddhi - Siddhi Circle, Jaipur 1 Enroll No. : Candidate Name : Mobile No. : Total Marks : 200

23oka vf[ky Hkkjrh; cky ksf{kd JO;&n` ; egksrlo 23 rd All India Children s Educational Audio Video Festival 23 AICEAVF FESTIVAL DIRECTORY

POETRY THE FROG AND THE NIGHTINGALE

vkxkeh xfrfof/k;k Editorial Board

Wanderlust A Letter To My Mother

SAMIKSHA INSTITUTE, Gwalior cky fodkl

Media Coordinator s Office Jamia Millia Islamia. Jamia s Premchand Archives organises an exhibition on Qalam ke Sipahiyon Ko Salam

Roll No.. M.A. First Year Examination MAHI-01 World History-Medieval Society and Age of Revolutions fo o bfrgkl&e/;dkyhu lekt,oa dzkafr dk ;qx

,d iuus ds t+fj, dt+k&,&mejh uekt+ dk fglkc yxkus dk vklku vksj csgrjhu rjhdka

Satya Sahitya, a Quarterly Newsletter of Shree Ram Sharanam International Centre, New Delhi

Ñ.oUrks foüoek;ze~ Krinvanto Vishvam Aryam Make this world noble

Question Booklet / ç u i= iqflrdk Jharkhand State Field Clerk (Including Collectorate) Limited Competitive Examination (Basic Grade) 2017

Question Booklet / ç u i= iqflrdk Jharkhand State Field Clerk (Including Collectorate) Limited Competitive Examination (Basic Grade) 2017

dkuwu dh O;k[;k esa ehekalk fl¼karksa dk vuqiz;ksx

okrkzyki lh-mh- ua- 254] rkjh[k% ] Discussion CD No.254 dated at Aara, Bihar

DELHI PUBLIC SCHOOL. SAIL Township, Ranchi SECOND SEMESTER ( SESSION ) CLASS: IV DATE : SUBJECT:- General Science M.M.

/kekzu/kksa dk ;t nh fdjnkj h

When I say celebrate, I mean become more and more sensitive to everything. In life, dance should not be apart. The whole of life should become a

lelr dk;kszza dh flf) gsrq lksun;zygjh ds dqn fof k"v iz;ksx Sumit Girdharwal

P-2. ijh{kkfkhz dk uke (cm+s v{kjksa es a)%... ijh{kk dsanz dk uke %... ijh{kkfkhz ds glrkk{kj %... d{k vurjh{kd ds glrkk{kj %...

FROM PRINCIPAL S DESK...

11 International Conference on Healthcare Systems and Global Business Issues

PM releases commemorative coins on Dr. B. R. Ambedkar

P-2. ijh{kkfkhz dk uke (cm+s v{kjksa es a)%... ijh{kk dsanz dk uke %... ijh{kkfkhz ds glrkk{kj %... d{k vurjh{kd ds glrkk{kj %...

Lo;EHkwLrks=k VIJAY K. JAIN. Svayambhûstotra. Adoration of The Twenty-four Tîrthaôkara. vkpk;z leurhkæ fojfpr. Âcârya Samantabhadra s

P-2. ijh{kkfkhz dk uke (cm+s v{kjksa es a)%... ijh{kk dsanz dk uke %... ijh{kkfkhz ds glrkk{kj %... d{k vurjh{kd ds glrkk{kj %...

Yoga Vijnana. The Science of Yoga. Editorial Board

Agricultural Land use Planning and Development of Dab Village in Akkalkuwa Tehsil of Nandurbar District

The Nature of Foreign Influence on the First Imperial Art of India : A Critical analysis of the Capital Sculpture of Sarnath

D.A.V PUBLIC SCHOOL (10 +2) PRATAP VIHAR HOLIDAY HOME WORK FOR CLASS- III SESSION- ( ) SUBJECT- ENGLISH

Approved & enlisted by UGC (Sr. No. 185, J.No ) ISSN : Vaidika V¹g Jyotiå

i k ¼lw=½ dfkk ¼ohj HkæU; dfkk½

From the Diaries of Josephites. In The Changing Era

Session: Class: III

(Assignment) Post Graduate Diploma in Yoga

1 Lokeh n;kuun ljlorh }kjk fueu fl)kurks eku;rkvks a dks osfnd /kez dš vuqdßy ekuk vksj izfrikfnr fd;k gs

#ekeâer. Volume VIII. December. Chief Editor. Editors : Ananda Mishra

Transcription:

Question: Why do we get angry? Krishnamurti: It may be for many reasons. It may be due to illhealth, to not having slept properly, to not having the right kind of food. It may be purely a physical reaction, a nervous reaction, or it may be much deeper. Because you feel frustrated, you feel caught, held, bound, and you have no outlet, you let off steam, you get angry. Anger is not just a matter of control. The moment you control, you have created a habit. You know, the so-called meditation of most people is the cultivation of habit; when they are meditating, they are cultivating a mind which will not be disturbed, which will function in habit, but such a mind will never find what is truth, what is God. If you merely control anger, the process is to cultivate a habit. Perhaps you do not understand what I am saying. Perhaps if the older people understand, they could explain this carefully to the children, not haphazardly, not impatiently, but explain the whole process of control, that it makes for habit and so makes the mind dull. They could explain why there is anger, not only the physical reasons, but also the psychological reasons; how the mind, which is sensitive, makes itself dull, insensible, through fear, through various forms of desires and fulfilments; and how such a mind can only think in terms of habit, control, suppression. A mind that is very alert, watchful, may lose its temper, but ç u % gesa Øks/k D;ksa vkrk gs\ Ñ.kewfrZ % blds dbz dkj.k gks ldrs gsaa LokLF; dh xm+cm+h ds dkj.k,slk gks ldrk gs] i;kzir uèn u gksus ls,slk gks ldrk gs] mfpr çdkj dk Hkkstu u djus ls,slk gks ldrk gsa ;g kkjhfjd çfrfø;k dk,d çdkj gks ldrk gs] mÿkstuk ds dkj.k lahko gs ;k bldk dksbz vf/kd xgjk dkj.k Hkh gks ldrk gsa pwafd vki fdlh dkj.k ls?kqvu dk vuqhko djrs gsa&&vki dqafbr] vo#)] ca/kk&ca/kk lk vuqhko djrs gsa] vksj vkidks mlls eqdr gksus dk jklrk ugha fn[kkbz nsrk gs blfy, vki ml ruko dks nwj djus dh ps Vk djrs gsa] vki Øksf/kr gks mbrs gsaa Øks/k dsoy fu;a=.k ls nwj ugha gksrka tsls gh vki bl ij fu;a=.k djus yxrs gsa vki,d vknr fufezr dj ysrs gsaa vkidks ekywe gs fd vf/kdka k yksxksa }kjk fd;k tkus okyk rfkkdffkr /;ku vknr Mky ysus dk gh,d :i gksrk gsa ftl le; os /;ku djus esa yxs gksrs gsa os,d,sls eu dk fuekz.k dj jgs gksrs gsa ftls ijs'kku u fd;k tk ldsssss] tks vknr ds <kaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaps esa dk;z djrk jgs] ijarq,slk eu ;g dhkh u tku ik,xk fd lr; D;k gs] bz'oj D;k gsa tc vki Øks/k ij ek= fu;a=.k ikus dk ;Ru djrs gsa rks ;g çfø;k vknr cukus dk gh,d :i gksrh gsa esa tks dg jgk gwa kk;n mls vki le> ugè ik jgs gsaa ;fn cm+s yksx bls le> ik jgs gksa] rks kk;n os cppksa dks blds ckjs esa lko/kkuh ls] lksp&le>dj] /khjs&/khjs I;kj ls le>k ldsaxsa os mugsa Li V dj ik,axs fd fu;a=.k djus dh çfø;k lewps :i esa D;k gksrh gs] vksj ;g vknr dk :i dsls ys ysrh gs] ftlds QyLo:i eu vlaosnu khy gks tkrk gs( os ;g le>k ldsaxs fd Øks/k D;ksa mriuu gksrk gs] mlds dsoy kkjhfjd gh ugè] ekufld dkj.k Hkh gksrs gsa( eu tks fd lahkor% laosnu khy gksrk gs] fdl çdkj Hk;] bpnkvksa vksj vusd izdkj dh rqf V;ksaa dh otg ls vius vki dks vlaosnu khy] ean cuk Mkyrk gs] vksj,slk eu fdl çdkj dsoy vknr] fu;a=.k vksj neu dh Hkk kk esa gh lkspk djrk gsa,d,slk eu tks vr;ar lrdz gs] ltx gs] og Hkh fdlh volj ij /ks;z NksM+ ldrk gs ij Talks with Students/f k{kk D;k gs Page 1

that is not important. What is important is to watch the mind, to see that it does not function in habit, that it does not become insensitive, dull, weary, and ready to die. Comment+: Stray thoughts prevent me from concentration, and without concentration, I cannot read. Krishnamurti: You do not read, not because of stray thoughts, but because you are not interested in what you are reading. You read a detective story or a novel; at that time your thoughts do not stray, do they? If you are interested in what you are reading, it gives you enjoyment; then you are not disturbed by any thought, are you? On the contrary, it is very difficult to let the book go. Do you read detective stories? Do you read novels? No? Then what do you read? What you are told to read in class? Naturally, you are not interested in those things, you are forcing yourself to read them. When you force yourself to read, your mind goes off which is wrong education. But if you;s from childhood, are given an opportunity to find out what you are interested in, then you will have natural, easy concentration without any effort to concentrate. But unfortunately, for the older students this has not been possible because they have been brought up in the old style, forced to read and to study. When your mind wanders, the problem arises: How can I control my thoughts? You cannot. Do not control your thoughts but find out what you are interested in. You have to pass your examinations, unfortunately. That is what is expected of you. But if you really mldk egÿo ugè gsa egÿoiw.kz ckr ;g gs fd eu ds çfr ltx jgk tk,] bl ckr ij /;ku j[kk tk, fd ;g vknr esa ca/k dj dk;zjr u gks] ;g vlaosnu khy] eaaaaaaan] Fkdk gqvk] e`rizk; u gks vksj ejus ds fy, jkth jgsa,d Jksrk % O;FkZ ds fopkj pyrs jgus ds dkj.k esa,dkxz ugha gks ikrk vksj,dkxzrk u gks ikus ls esa i<+ ugha ldrka Ñ.kewfrZ % O;FkZ ds fopkj pyrs jgus ds dkj.k vki i<+ ugha ikrs,slk ugha gs] cfyd vki tks dqn i<+ jgs gsa mlesa vkidh #fp ugè gksrh blfy, vki i<+ ugha ikrsa tc vki dksbz tklwlh dgkuh] ;k miu;kl i<+ jgs gksrs gsa ml le; rks vkids fopkj b/kj&m/kj ugha HkVdrs&&fd HkVdrs gsa\ vki tks dqn i<+ jgs gksrs gsa ;fn mlesa vkidh #fp gks rks dksbz Hkh nwljk fopkj vkidks rax ugha djrk&&;k djrk gs\ blds foijhr gksrk ;g gs fd ml iqlrd dks NksM+ ikuk gh dfbu gksrk gsa D;k vki tklwlh dfkk,a i<+rs gsa\ D;k vki miu;kl i<+rs gsa\ ugha i<+rs\ fqj vki D;k i<+rs gsa\ ogh ftls i<+us ds fy, vkils] vkidh d{kk esa dgk tkrk gs\ mu lkjh pht+kssa esa ;fn vkidk eu u yxrk gks rks,slk gksuk LokHkkfod lh ckr gs] vki mugsa i<+us ds fy, vius vkidks etcwj dj jgs gsaa tc vki i<+us ds fy, Lo;a dks ck/; djrs gsa rks vkidk eu mpv tkrk gs&&f k{kk dk ;g,d xyr rjhdk gsa ysfdu ;fn fcydqy cpiu ls gh vkidks bl ckr dk irk yxkus dk volj feyrk jgs fd vkidh #fp fdl ckr esa gs] rks vki,dkxzrk ds fy, iz;kl fd, fcuk gh] LokHkkfod :i ls] ljyrkiwozd,dkxz gks ldsaxsa fdarq iqjkus Nk=ksa ds fy, nqhkkzx;o k ;g u gks ldk D;ksafd mugsa iqjkuh fof/k ls i<+us vksj v/;;u ds fy, etcwj fd;k x;k] vksj ml jhfr ls mudh f k{kk&nh{kk gqbza vc] tc vkidk eu b/kj&m/kj HkVdrk gs] rc ;g lel;k vkrh gs % esa vius fopkjksa dks fu;a=.k esa dsls j[kaaaaaaaaaaawwwwwwwa\ vki,slk ugha dj ldrs gsaa vius fopkjksa ij dkcw ikus dh dksf k k er dhft,] cfyd bldk irk yxk,a fd vkidh fnyplih fdl ckr esa gsa nqhkkzx;o k vkidks viuh ijh{kk,a Hkh ikl djuh gsaa vkils bldh meehn dh tkrh gsa fdarq ;fn vki lpeqp Talks with Students/f k{kk D;k gs Page 2

want to understand the ways of your mind, the mind has to find out what it is interested in, vitally, for the rest of its life and not for ten days or for a few years. For such a mind, when it has found what it is interested in, there will be no problem of concentration; it naturally becomes concentrated. Question: What is the outcome of meditation? Krishnamurti: The outcome generally is what you want your meditation to be. You understand? If I meditate on peace, I will get peace. But it will not be real peace; it will be something which my mind has created. If I am a Christian, I meditate in a Christian way, and my mind will create a picture. If I am a Hindu devotee and I meditate, my mind will create an image, and I will see it as a living image. My mind projects whatever it desires, and sees the thing as living, but it is self-delusion. The mind deceives itself. If I am a Hindu;s I believe in innumerable things, and my beliefs control my thinking, don t they? Suppose I am a devotee and I sit down and meditate on Krishna, what happens? I create an image of Krishna, don t I? My mind, brought up in Hinduism, has a picture of Krishna, and on that picture I meditate, and that meditation is the process of my conditioned thinking. So, it is no longer meditation, it is just a continuous, habitual form of thinking. I might see Krishna dancing, but it will still be the result of my tradition. So long as I have this tradition, the real thing cannot be perceived. So, my mind must free itself from tradition. That is real meditation. vius eu ds rksj&rjhdksa dks le>uk pkgrs gsa] rks eu dks bl ckr dk irk yxkuk gksxk fd mls fdl ckjs esa fnyplih gs] dqn fnuksa ds fy, ;k dqn o kks± ds fy, gh ugè] cfyd thoui;zazaaaaaar xgjh #fpa tc eu dks ;g ekywe gks tk,xk fd bldh #fp fdlesa gs rks,dkxzrk dh lel;k ugha jgsxh( ;g LoHkkor%,dkxz gks tk,xka ç u % /;ku djus dk ifj.kke D;k gksrk gs\ Ñ.kewfrZ % bldk ifj.kke çk;% ogh gksrk gs tks ge blls pkgrs gsaa vki le> jgs gsa\ ;fn esa kkafr ds fy, /;ku djrk gwa rks eq>s kkafr feysxha ysfdu ;g kkafr oklrfod kkafr u gksxh] ;g,d,slh pht++ gksxh ftls esjs eu us fufezr fd;k gksxka ;fn esa,d bzlkbz gwa] ;fn esa bzlkbz dh rjg ls /;ku djrk gwa rks esjk eu,d izdkj dk fp= cuk,xka ;fn esa,d fganw HkDr gwa vksj /;ku djrk gwa rks esjk eu,d çfrek cuk,xk vksj mls esa,d thrh&tkxrh çfrek dh rjg ns[kawxka esjk eu viuh bpnk ds vuq:i dqn ç{ksfir djrk gs vksj mls esa thfor olrq dh Hkkaaaaaaaaaafr ns[krk gaw] ysfdu ;g vkre&leeksgu gh gsa eu vius vki dks gh /kks[kk nsus yxrk gsa ;fn esa fganw gwa vksj eq>s vla[; ckrksa ij fo okl gs] rks esjs fo okl gh esjh fopkj&çfø;k dks fu;aaaaaaaaaaaaf=r djrs gsa] djrs gsa u\ eku yhft, esa,d HkDr gwa vksj esa,d LFkku ij csb dj Ñ.k dk /;ku djus yxrk gwa] bldk D;k ifj.kke gksrk gs\ esa eu gh eu Ñ.k dh,d çfrek cuk ysrk gwaa fgaanqqro esa iyk&c<+k esjk eu Ñ.k dh çfrek ls vpnh rjg ls ifjfpr gs] mlesa Ñ.k dh dksbz Nfo gksrh gs vksj ml Nfo ij esa /;ku djrk gwa vksj og /;ku esjh laldkfjr fopkj/kkjk dh gh,d çfø;k gqvk djrk gsa vr% ;g /;ku ugè cfyd fopkj djus dh fujarj vknr gh gksrk gsa gks ldrk gs eq>s u`r; djrs gq, Ñ.k dk n kzu gksus yxs] ijarq bl rjg ls gksus okyk n kzu esjh ijaijk dk gh ifj.kke gsa tc rd esa bl ijaijk esa jgrk gaw rc rd eq>s ;FkkFkZ olrq dk cks/k ugha gks ik,xka blfy, esjs eu dks pkfg, fd og ijaijk ls vius dks eqdr dj ysa ogh oklrfod /;ku gsa Talks with Students/f k{kk D;k gs Page 3

Meditation is the process of the mind freeing itself from all conditioning, either of the Hindu or the Christian or the Muslim or the Buddhist or the Communist. Then, when the mind is free, reality can come into being. Otherwise, meditation is merely self-deception. Question: Why do we feel sorry for the beggar when he comes to us, and why do we feel angry when he leaves us? Krishnamurti: I am not sure whether you are putting the latter part of the question rightly. Perhaps you have a different meaning when you say you hate it when they leave. Do you get angry merely because he leaves the place, or because he leaves the place with a curse because you do not give? I go to you as a beggar, and you give me something, and in the giving, you feel happy, you feel that you are somebody because you have given. For the majority of us, there is vanity in giving, is there not? Suppose you do not give, what happens? The beggar curses you and goes away. He gets angry, and in return you also get angry. Perhaps you do not want to be disturbed, and so you get angry. I really do not understand this question. Is this what you are trying to say? You feel kindly when you see a person, a beggar, because your sympathies are aroused, and you feel it is good to have this natural sympathy, but at the same time, you feel disturbed because of his poverty and your being well off; you do not like to be disturbed, and so you get eu }kjk vius vkidks gj çdkj dh laldkjc)rk ls eqdr dj fy, tkus dh çfø;k /;ku gs] fqj og laldkjc)rk fgaaaaaaaaaaaaanw ;k bzlkbz] eqflye ;k cks) vfkok de;qfulv] fdlh Hkh ijaijk dk ifj.kke D;ksa u gksa rc] tc eu eqdr gks tkrk gs] oklrfodrk dk vkfohkkzo gks ikrk gsa vu;fkk /;ku dsoy vius vki dks /kks[kk nsuk gks tkrk gsa ç u % tc dksbz fhk[kkjh gekjh vksj vkrk gs rc ge mlds fy, nq[kh D;ksa gksrs gsa vksj tc og gekjs ikl ls tkus yxrk gs rks gesa Øks/k D;ksa vkrk gs\ Ñ.kewfrZ % eq>s bl ckjs esa lansg gs fd vki ç u ds nwljs fglls dks Bhd ls O;Dr dj ik jgs gsaa tc vki ;g dgrs gsa fd vkids ikl ls mlds pys tkus ij vkidks Øks/k vkrk gs rks kk;n vkidk rkri;z dqn v j gsa D;k vki mlds ogka ls pys tkus ij xqllk gksrs gsa ;k blfy, xqllk gksrs gsa fd vkils mls dqn u feyus ij og vkidks Hkyk&cqjk dgrk gs\ esa,d fhk[kkjh dh rjg ls vkids ikl vkrk gwa vksj vki eq>s dqn ns nsrs gsa vksj bl çdkj ls nsus esa vki çluurk vuqhko djrs gsa] vki eglwl djus yxrs gsa fd vki Hkh dqn gsa] D;ksafd vkius fdlh dks dqn fn;k gsa geesa ls T+++++++++++++;knkrj yksxksa ds fy, nku djuk xoz dh ckr gksrh gs] gs u\ eku yhft, vki mls dqn Hkh ugha nsrs gsa rks D;k gksxk\ og vkils # V gks tkrk gs vksj mlds QyLo:i vki Hkh # V gks tkrs gsaa kk;n vki ijs'kku gksuk ugha pkgrs blfy, vki Øq) gks tkrs gsaa vkids ç u dks esa lpeqp ugha le> ik jgka D;k vki ;gh dguk pkgrs gsa\ tc vki fdlh O;fDr dks],d fhk[kkjh dks ns[krs gsa rks vkiesa n;k dh Hkkouk vkrh gs] D;ksafd mlds çfr vkiesa lgkuqhkwfr mem+us yxrh gs vksj vki eglwl djus yxrs gsa fd,slh LokHkkfod lgkuqhkwfr gksuk,d vpnh ckr gs] ysfdu mlh le; vkidks my>u Hkh gksus yxrh gs] D;ksafd og nfjnz gs tcfd vki laiuu gsa] vkidks ;g Hkh vpnk ugha yxrk fd og vkidks ijs kku Talks with Students/f k{kk D;k gs Page 4

agitated. Is this what you mean? There are several things taking place the natural outgoing sympathy to give something; the feeling of anxiety; the feeling of anger, of irritation that you cannot do anything, that society is rotten and you cannot help; your own natural fears that you might catch his disease. I do not see what you mean when you say you get angry when the beggar goes away. Question: The habit of getting angry and the habit of getting vindictive are they different psychological processes, or are they the same, but varying in degree? Krishnamurti: Anger may be immediate, but it passes and is forgotten. I think vindictiveness implies the storing up, the remembering of a hurt, the feeling that you have been frustrated, that you have been blocked, hindered. You store that up, and eventually you are going to take it out on that person, you are going to be violent. I think there is a difference. Anger may be immediate and forgotten, but vindictiveness implies the actual building up of anger, of annoyance, of the desire to hit back. If you are in a powerful position, and you say harsh things to me, I cannot get angry because I may lose my job. So, I store it up, I bear all your insults, and when an occasion arises, I hit back. Question: How can I find God? djs] vr% vki Øq) gks tkrs gsaa D;k vkidk eryc ;g gs\ ;gka ij dbz ckrsa gks jgh gsa&&dqn nsus dh LokHkkfod lgkuqhkwfr dh Hkkouk dk ân; esa mbuk] O;kdqyrk eglwl gksuk( jks k dh] >qa>ykgv dh Hkkouk isnk gksuk D;ksafd vki dqn Hkh ugha dj ldrs gsa] ;g eglwl gksuk fd lekt lm+ jgk gs vksj vki dqn ugha dj ldrs] vkids vius gh LoHkkoxr Hk; fd dgha mldh chekjh vkidks u yx tk,a tc vki ;g dgrs gsa fd fhk[kkjh ds vkids ikl ls tkus ij vkidks Øks/k D;ksa vkrk gs rks blls vkidk D;k rkri;z gs esa ugè le> ik jgk gawa ç u % Øks/k djus dh vknr,oa çfr kks/k ysus dh vknr&&d;k ;s nks ijlij fhkuu euksoskkfud çfø;k,a gsa ;k eksfyd :i ls,d gksrs gq, Hkh mudh rhozrk fhkuu gksrh gs\ Ñ.kewfrZ % Øks/k rks rrdky gh dk;z djus yxrk gs] ijarq ;g tynh gh chr tkrk gs vksj bls Hkqyk Hkh fn;k tkrk gsa eq>s,slk çrhr gksrk gs fd çfr kks/k ysus dh ço`fÿk esa,d çdkj ds laxzg dk gksuk ns[kk tk ldrk gs] pksv igqapus dh Le`fr cuh jgrh gs] ;g vuqhkwfr Hkhrj cuh jgrh gs fd vkidssssssssssss jklrs esa ck/kk Mkyh xbz gs] vkidsssssssss jklrs esa #dkov Mkyh x;h gs] jksm+++++++++++ssssssss vvdk, x, gaaaaaaaaaaaasa mlh vuqhkwfr dks Le`fr esa tek dj j[kk tkrk gs vksj volj feyrs gh vki ml O;fDr ls cnyk ysus ds fy, rs;kj gks tkrs gsa] vki fgalk ij mrk: gks tkrs gsaa eq>s yxrk gs fd bu nksuksa esa Hksn gsa Øks/k rkrdkfyd :i ls mbrk gs vksj mls Hkqyk fn;k tkrk gs tcfd çfr kks/k ysus dh ço`fÿk bl ckr dh lwpd gs fd olrqr% Øks/k bdv~bk fd;k x;k gs] jks k,d= gksrk x;k gs] cnys esa pksv igaqpkus dh Hkkouk tek gksrh pyh xbz gsa ;fn vki eq>ls vf/kd rkdroj gsa vksj vki eq>ls dbksj opu dgrs gsa rks esa vki ij Øks/k ugha dj ldrk D;ksafd rc eq>s uksdjh tkus dk [+krjk eglwl gksrk gsa blfy, esa bls,d= dj j[krk gaw] vkids }kjk fd;k tkus okyk lkjk vieku esa pqipki lg ysrk gwa vksj tsls gh eq>s eksdk feyrk gs esa vkidks pksv igqapkdj cnyk ys ysrk gwaa ç u % esa Hkxoku dks dsls ik ldrh gaw\ Talks with Students/f k{kk D;k gs Page 5

Krishnamurti: A little girl asks how she can find God. Probably she wants to ask something else, and she has forgotten it already. In answer to the question, we are talking to the little girl and also to the old people. The teachers will kindly listen and tell the girl in Hindi, as the question is important to her. Have you ever watched a leaf dancing in the sun, a solitary leaf? Have you watched the moonlight on the water and did you see the other night the new moon? Did you notice the birds flying? Have you deep love for your parents? I am not talking of fear, of anxiety, or of obedience, but of the feeling, the great sympathy you have when you see a beggar, or when you see a bird die, or when you see a body burned. If you can see all these things and have great sympathy and understanding understanding for the rich who go in big cars blowing dust everywhere, and understanding for the poor beggar and the poor ekka horse which is almost a walking skeleton, knowing all that, having the feeling of it not merely in words but inwardly, the feeling that this world is ours, yours and mine, not the rich man s nor the communist s, to be made beautiful if you feel all this, then behind it there is something much deeper. But to understand that which is much deeper and beyond the mind, the mind has to be free, quiet, and the mind cannot be quiet without understanding all this. So, you have to begin near, instead of trying to find what God is. Ñ.kewfrZ %,d NksVh lh cpph iwn jgh gs fd og Hkxoku dks dsls ik ldrh gsa kk;n og dksbz nwljk ç u iwnuk pkgrh gs ij mls bl le; og Hkwy xbz gsa bl ç u dk mÿkj nsrs le; ge ml NksVh lh cpph ls,oa cm+s yksxksa ls ckrsa dj jgs gsaa f k{kd Ñi;k eu yxkdj /;kuiwozd lqusa vksj bl ckfydk dks bldk mÿkj fgaaaaaaaaaaaaaanh esa crk,a D;ksafd mlds fy, ;g ç u egÿoiw.kz gsa D;k vkius lwjt dh /kwi esa fdlh iÿks dks] fdlh vdsys iÿksssssssssss dks u`r; djrs ns[kk gs\ D;k vkius ty dh lrg ij paaaaaaaaaaanzek dh pkanuh dks ns[kk gs vksj D;k fdlh jkf= esa vkius iwf.kzek ds uoksfnr paaaaaaaaaaaaaanz dks ns[kk gs\ D;k vkius fpfm+;ksa dks mm+rs gq, ns[kk gs\ D;k vkidks vius ekrk&firk ls xgu çse gs\ esa Hk;] cspsuh ;k vkkkdkfjrk dh ckr ugha dj jgk gwa] esa rks ml Hkkouk ds ckjs esa dg jgk gwa] ml lgkuqhkwfr ds ckjs esa dg jgk gwa tks fdlh fhk[kkjh dks ns[kdj] fdlh i{kh dks ejrk gqvk ns[k dj ;k fdlh ko dks tyk;k tkrk ns[k dj vkids eu esa mbrh gsa ;fn vki bu lc ckrksa dk voyksdu djrs gsa vksj vkiesa xgjh lgkuqhkwfr vksj le> gs&&cm+h&cm+h dkjksa esa csbdj /kwy mm+krs pys tkus okys laiuu yksxksa vksj ml nhu fhk[kkjh ds çfr] ml efj;y vflfk&fiatj ls?kksm+s ds çfr ftls bdds esa tksrk x;k gs] bl lcdks tkurs&eglwl djrs gq, vkiesa,slh dksbz Hkkouk mbrh gs tks dsoy kkfcnd u gksdj vkids ân; esa gksrh gs] ;g Hkkouk fd ;g fo o gekjk gs] vkidk vksj esjk gs] u fd dsoy fdlh le`) O;fDr dk ;k de;wfulv dk] bl fo o dks gesa lqqqqqqqanj cukuk gs&&;fn vkidks ;g lc eglwl gksrk gs rks mlds ewy esa dksbz vf/kd xgjh ckr fnih gsa ij ml xgjkbz dks tks eu ls Hkh ijs gs&&mls le>us ds fy, eu dks eqdr] eksu gksuk gksxk vksj eu bu reke ckrksa dkss le>s fcuk eksu ugha gks ldrka blfy, vkidks bz oj D;k gs bldh [kkst djus ds ctk; vius vklikl ls gh bl ckjs esa kq#vkr djuh gksxha Talks with Students/f k{kk D;k gs Page 6