Tohu-wa-bohu as first substance(s)?
|
|
- Christal Norton
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Tohu-wa-bohu as first substance(s)? Timo Schmitz, Philosopher When looking at the beginning of Bereshit, it is outstanding that God at first created the heavens and the earth. It continues stating that the earth (ha-aretz) was (hayetah) tohu wa-bohu. As pointed out in the Schmitz-Translation it can be translated as without form (=formless) and without content (=empty). However, it is worth to take a more literal look on the passage to fully understand it. The word ת הוּ is actually a spelling variety of תוהו which according to Strong's H8414 tohuw is a masculine noun rooting from to lie waste and means figuratively, a worthless thing. According to the Brown- Driver-Briggs Hebrew and English Lexicon it means formlessness, of primaeval earth Genesis 1:2 (P), of land reduced to primaeval chaos Jeremiah 4:23 (both + הוּ andו ב voidness) [ ]. Rabbeinu Bahya comments on it that it is a reference to the raw material which could not be further properly definable and therefore could not yet be named. Especially, when looking on ב הוּ we get a further problem, since it was not simply chaotic, but it was also empty. And by looking on bot words, we see that they have something in common. They are made up of to-hu and bo-hu, both inheriting the hu which is Aramaic for the 3 rd person singular pronoun. The letter combination to (תו) looks close to tav ו) (ת which means character or sign. In the first chapter of the Sefer Ha-Bahir, verse two is dedicated to the question why the tohu-wa-bohu is described in the past form. The conclusion is that it is referring to a previous event and that it already happened, so it was. However, even more interesting is the description of the meaning of the two words. Tohu is something that confuses people, and bohu is something that has a substance as it is made out of bo and hu meaning that it is in it. To put it in a nutshell, the Sefer Ha-Bahir proposes to translate it as matter and form. This however, goes close to the Aristotelian view. As of Aristotle, everything which comes into being must be made out of matter and form. Matter itself has no form. It is an abstract thing that can exist as such, but cannot be grasped. Form however is the formal character which gives the matter an appearance. Let s take a pencil for example. A pencil includes lead, but that does not mean that lead cannot exist outside of a pencil. One can give another person a mass of lead, but it is useless for the other person. Just by taking its form, it will be convenient to write. Anyways, this is just a simplification, as the matter itself is much more complex. As even the lead has a form and the matter of lead also exists even if the form of lead does not exist, but then we cannot see it. Aristotle calls the substance οὐσία and the primary substance πρῶται οὐσίαι. In Categories, Aristotle emphasizes in chapter 5 that the primary substance is the basis substratum in which all other categories are realized. As such, the first substance is the individual while the second substance is the general term. Therefore, a certain individual person is the primary substance and the term human-being the second substance as the first substance has more being in it then the second
2 one. In Metaphysics, it is the exact opposite where the first substance is the general term and the second substance is the individual. Silke Piwko explains: Unter Berücksichtigung sprachlogischer Aspekte bei der Bestimmung des Begriffes der ousia ist festzustellen, dass es sich um ein griechisches Wort der Umgangssprache handelt, das bedeutet, das ousia nicht von vornherein [ ] ein philosophischer Begriff war. Ousia als Wortbildung geht auf das Partizip zu einai - sein zurück; hierbei ist es jedoch schwierig, eine passende entsprechende Übersetzung zu finden. [ ] Eine frühere Substanztheorie entwickelt Aristoteles in den Kategorien, deren Inhalt der traditionellen Deutung gemäß genau gegenteilig zu denen der Substanzbücher ausfällt. [ ] Die Frage nach der Substanz in den Kategorien erfordert die Differenzierung in Bezug auf die logische und die ontologische Bestimmung des Begriffes. Im logischen Kontext spricht man von der primären Substanz als das, was nicht vom Zugrundeliegenden (hypokeimenon) ausgesagt werden kann. Die ontologische Bestimmung der ousia ist die des unabhängigen Existierens im Unterschied zu den Eigenschaften, welche auf die Substanzen als Träger angewiesen sind. Die zweiten ousiai bringt man mit den Art- und Gattungsbegriffen in Zusammenhang, nennt man die Substanz nun zweite Substanz als die Art (eidos), in welcher sich die primären Substanzen befinden. Diese zweiten Substanzen sind nicht in einem anderen befindlich. Das bedeutet, alle nichtsubstantialen Bestimmungen bedürfen einer Substanz, von der sie abhängig sind. Sie können von der primären ousia prädiziert werden, was deren Wasbestimmtheit zum Ausdruck bringt [ ]. Die primäre Substanz liegt allem Seienden zugrunde (vgl. Kat. 5, 2b38) und nimmt hierbei eine Vorrangstellung ein, insofern sie weder von einem anderen ausgesagt wird noch sich in einem anderen befindet. Aus ontologischer Perspektive definiert Aristoteles in den Kategorien also das Einzelne als erste Substanz (prote ousia) [ ] das Allgemeine hingegen als zweite Substanz (deutere ousia) [ ]Die zweite Substanz macht durch ihr eidetischbeständiges Allgemeines das eigentliche Wassein des Einzelnen aus, macht die primäre Substanz erst zu dem, was sie ist. [ ] Im Sinne der Kategorien ist jedes Seiende durch das einzelne Ding - die ousia - seiend und somit das vorrangig vorliegende Seiende. Diese Bestimmung der ousia wird auch in der Metaphysik beibehalten (vgl. Met. Z1). [ ]Der deutlichste Unterschied zwischen beiden 2
3 Konzeptionen macht sich an der Tatsache fest, dass Aristoteles in der Metaphysik nicht mehr zwischen erster und zweiter Substanz unterscheidet, sondern das konkrete Einzelding wird in die beiden Aspekte Form und Materie aufgespalten. Ausgeschlossen von den Substanzen wird in der Metaphysik der Bereich der Gattungen, weil Allgemeines nicht Substanz sein kann. (Silke Piwko: Bedeutungen und Funktionen des Terminus 'ousia' bei Aristoteles, 2008) If there was chaos, then there was already a primary essence, therefore it is (bo-hu). But since it is without form, it cannot be described or grasped as such. It was neither flat nor round, but notdescribable. It was even empty, though there was something (cp. the concept of shunyata in Buddhism). But as this something had no form yet, it could not inherit anything then that-which-it-was and thus consisted of those-what-it-inherited which was not yet separated and had no accidents as such, as the accidents are things further defining the substance. However, form and matter come.רוּח together through the breath of God, the ruah Hannu Töyrilä however argues that It may seem improbable that the image of utter emptiness of the Gen 1:2 could have anything to do with the sober philosophy of Aristotle. However, such a connection was made, when in medieval Jewish thought the interpretation of tohu and bohu as matter and form important concepts in medieval philosophy and science surfaced and even attained a level of popularity. (Hannu Töyrylä: Slimy Stones and Philosophy: Interpretations of tohu wa-vohu as Matter and Form, 2004, p.2; retrieved on 21 May 2018). Furthermore, the Sefer Yetzirah describes how God creates the world with 32 mysterious ways, which are then identified with the 10 cardinal numbers and the 22 letters of the Hebrew alphabet. Each cardinal number also presents a stage in the creation, which starts from the spirit (ruah) of God, then proceeds to wind or air (ruah), then to water, fire and even further. Out of water come tohu, bohu, mud and clay, which are then used by God as material for building the world. [ ] In another verse of Sefer Yetzirah, God is said to have formed something real (mamash) out of tohu. It can be deduced from this that tohu itself is not anything real. In the Biblical usage there was hardly any difference in meaning between tohu and bohu. (Töyrylä, 2004, p.7) Indeed, the Torah has a lot of mystical information that goes either back to early belief or was later seen in it in the Middle Ages. At first, the different elements play an important role. Air or breath, as 3
4 well as water are things mentioned from the early beginning. They stand in several interrelations and strongly remember of the five elements of Daoism. This might be no surprise as everywhere in the world, people asked the question, which was the first element?. Natural philosophers such as Thales and Heraklitos worked with water as the original source saying everything was born out of water and then through thickening and thinning came into different states and manifestations and forms (cp. Aristotle: Physics, Book 1). Parmenides claimed that nothing comes from nothing, and thus the void. It goes back to an even earlier theogenic thought already found in Hesiod. It became later known as creatio ex nihilo. Melissos stated that everything which exists is one and motionless. Even further, that what is then is eternal and infinite (DK 30 B7). Despite water, the other basic elements have been proposed as first substance as well, though Aristotle rejects them as being valid (cp. Schmitz commentary on the first four chapters of Aristotle s Physics Book 1). The only natural philosopher who is in a good light in Aristotle s view is Anaxogaras who proposes the nous (=reason) as first substance. Aristotle also rejects motionlessness as nothing could change through thickening and thinning if nothing was able to move and he also rejected that there is only one first substance, because it would imply that everything must be always found in everything (which means that water also always contains meat, even in the littlest drop). Critics however could say that motion is just an illusion and that in fact everything is static and we just imagine that everything changes (skepticism). Much more interesting concerning our question however is the Platonic view as given in Timaeus. According to Plato, the universe originally was a chaotic, unformed matter, which was then brought into order by a divine being, the Demiurge. It seems, then, that the purpose of the creation myth is to give an account of the nature of man and of the universe to serve as the background for another mythical account, the purpose of which will be to show that the ideal state is superior and ultimately more powerful than an adversary which has greater material resources and skill but is morally inferior. (12) That the purpose of the creation myth is to give a systematic account of the nature of man and the world rather than a chronological report of how the world came into being, is, I think, undeniable; this systematic character of Timaeus' exposition can be seen even in the three main divisions of his discourse. There is first a prelude (27 C-29 D) (13) in which the nature and the limits of the exposition are set down. (14) Timaeus deals then with the work of the Demiurge and of the created gods (29 D-47 E) which constitutes the work of Reason in the universe. At 47 E ff., however, he declares the need to begin all over again and introduces the third factor, the receptacle; this is done in order to describe what comes about of Necessity (47 E- 69 A). We hear now of things that 4
5 the Demiurge had done before some of those described in 29 D-47 E. (15) In the third and last part of the myth (69 A-92 C), after recapitulating the two previous sections, Timaeus explains the creation of those things which are a result of the cooperation of Reason and Necessity. (Leonardo Taran: The Creation Myth in Plato's Timaeus, in: The Society for Ancient Greek Philosophy Newsletter, 252, 1966) And even in Augustine s Confessions (Book 12), the tohu-wa-bohu is a kind of formless matter which is used by God to create the world. However, he does not differentiate between tohu and bohu explicitly, but sees the whole tohu and bohu as one term: unformed matter. As such, he does not distribute one term to the other, but only looks at the whole. The most important source, in my view, however, is the look on the Sefer Ha-Bahir as described above, as it shows not only a historical formation of understanding, but rather a historical transformation through editing over centuries from the 1 st century CE to the 12 th century CE. According to Joseph Dan s Gerschom Scholem and the Mystical Dimension of Jewish History (New York, 1988), Scholem asserts that the Sefer Ha-Bahir subscribes to Bar Hiyya's tohu/hyle and bohu/form analogy (Töyrylä, 2004, p. 8). However, Töyrylä couldn't find direct support for this, neither in Scholem s Origins of the Kabbalah (Princeton University Press, 1987) nor in the Sefer Ha-Bahir, but indirect support is provided by the fact that in the Sefer Ha-Bahir, tohu is primarily interpreted as evil, which in Neoplatonism is associated with matter (cp. Töyrylä, 2004, p. 8). The hyle-form analogy goes back to Aristotle again, but Bar Hiyya also puts a Neoplatonic falvor inside (which then goes back to the Timaeus). Schmitz puts it in the whole context of Chapter 1 of the Sefer Ha-Bahir, which teaches that the beginning was a blessing (bet) which according to (alef-bet) started out of a chaos that brought forth a something which had substance. Everything that turned out from the blessing was a blessing again. As the whole nature is a blessing, Man is a blessing too, as he is an exact copy of nature that inherits God, and God is inherited in the whole nature. (Timo Schmitz: A vague interpretation of Section One of the Sefer Ha-Bahir, self-published online article, 28 April 2018). He puts it further in the context that Gen 1:2 are written alef-bet in the Hebrew Bible, not only representing the alphabet, but the beginning must be picked up there because one (alef) is the beginning, and two (bet) is a blessing and thus the blessed beginning (ibid.). And According to Bar Hiyya, Form penetrates all things from angels to the material world: the ladder of beings culminates in human beings who possess reason. The Torah elucidates such a hierarchy. (Lavinia Cohn-Sherbok & Dan Cohn-Sherbok Medieval Jewish Philosophy An Introduction, 2014, p. 73). As such Bar Hiyya distinguishes four categories in which form exists. The first is a self-subsistent form that never combines with matter; the second is form that is attached inseparably to matter; the third is form which is temporarily attached to matter; and the fourth is form which is attached to a body (ibid.). According to Jonathan Dauber Bar Hiyya's interpretation of the words tohu and bohu in Gen. 1:2 as 5
6 matter and form, respectively, is reflected in secs. 2, 9, 93, and 109 of the Bahir (Jonathan Dauber: Knowledge of God and the Development of Early Kabbalah, 2012, p. 191). Scholem points out that Abraham bar Hiyya literally speaks of form and reality (surah we-hashashah). As light has form and reality, the term formation is employed; whereas darkness has neither form nor reality, the term creation is employed (Scholem, 1987, p.63). This again shows a two-partite system, as we know it from Aristotle s form and matter and Daoism s yin and yang. Through a certain amount of yin and a certain amount of yang, a certain manifestation becomes established. The same seems to appear through tohu and bohu. They are a dualism making a oneness, but through working on them, they establish a manifestation. It is the manifestation of God s creation. Same than light and darkness are contradictions, but God can be found in both at the same time, yin and yang are contradictions in which the Dao appears at the same time. Thus, everything which the yin and yang brings forth shares a part of the Dao. The same goes to the tohu and bohu. God created the earth which was made out of the dualism, but both are divine and everything which was brought forth by it was a product of the divine, too. Therefore, the whole nature inherits God and everything must be part of God, too. Indeed, for this reason, we shall not harm our environment for no reason, as everything has God s spirit inside. At the same time, we have to be aware of Aristotle s thought on individuality. The thing itself is most individual (individual term), but as more general the term becomes as less individuality it has. The term tohu wa bohu includes everything, and thus has least individuality as everything is chaotic inside. As it encompasses everything, it also encompasses all forms, colors, etc. and therefore becomes so abstract, that it cannot be further described. As chaos has a rather negatively connotation, tohu can be indirectly seen as evil, while bohu as an affirmative state is rather good. If we see it in this way, then everything is made out of good and bad. For this reason, there is nothing perfect on earth and even human-beings who can act reasonable have flaws, as they consist of good and bad at the same time, and sometimes the good is dominating and sometimes the bad. As such, the chaos is without form as it has not much what-it-is-in itself (Seiendheit) anymore and thus is just an abstract form without form, while the material is not a specially related materia anymore and we can just say that there is any material. From here, Genesis is creating the world inductively. If we go deductively from Gen 1:27 to Gen 1:2, we can say, the first human is Adam, he is something-whichis-being (ein Seiendes). If we use the next general term, we say the term human-being (ha-adam) which means that he loses that-which-is-being (Seiendheit) by receiving the article the. The word adam comes from adamah meaning mud and thus explains everything which is muddy. It has less Seiendheit than human-being. If we go further in generality, everything loses more and more Seiendheit until we are at a point, where the thing itself is so abstract that we can only say that there 6
7 is form, but we cannot talk of a specific form anymore as it is chaos, and we can only say that there is matter, because we know there is a substance but it has such less Seiendheit that it cannot be further precised. To put it in a nutshell, tohu-wa-bohu refers to the first ousiai from which everything further developed. Therefore, everything stands in a connection with it, which means that from an individual term to a general term, all general terms might be further generalized until one gets to the tohu-wa-bohu. This also means that everything is connected to one another and that nothing exists independently for it alone (cp. parinispanna (absolute nature) as part of the three natures of Yogacara-Buddhism). Therefore, instead of seeing everything independently for itself, we need to understand how everything relies to each other to finally become one with God. Although tohu and bohu exist for themselves, they cannot be split off leaving only tohu or bohu, but where there is tohu there must be bohu as well, making them inseparable. As such, using one term to explain both (such as unformed matter) is legit, since neither the unformed nor the matter appear alone. Based on this, we can build further dualisms such as light and darkness, as well as formation and creation. In chapter one of Genesis, the word creation can be found through bara and its form wayibra (and He created) which refers to things that are separated out of another thing through setting aside, and the form wa-ya as (and He made) from asah (to do, to make) refers to things that were made through God s will out of the thought of God and thus what God thinks also necessarily becomes. As a result, things that are created, always can be generalized until the most abstract thing. In Genesis chapter 2 it gets evident, when it is pointed out that the plants which were brought forth by God were still not on the surface as the necessity of rain was lacking. This shows, that the plants cannot exist without the earth and they cannot come into visual being without the rain. But even the things that God made are not independently but already rely on a substance that was there. The firmament which was made, but at the same time was not a separated entity from the waters around (see Gen 1:7). Therefore, we can also assume that neither tohu nor bohu are static, but in constant motion and thus are responsible for the change of manifestations of God s creation. Timo Schmitz, 22 May
Real predicates and existential judgements
Real predicates and existential judgements Ralf M. Bader Merton College, University of Oxford 1 Real predicates One of the central commitments of Kant s (pre-critical as well as Critical) modal theory
More informationIbn Sina on Substances and Accidents
Ibn Sina on Substances and Accidents ERWIN TEGTMEIER, MANNHEIM There was a vivid and influential dialogue of Western philosophy with Ibn Sina in the Middle Ages; but there can be also a fruitful dialogue
More informationMichael Thompson: Life and Action Elementary Structures of Practice and Practical Thought, Cambridge/MA
Michael Thompson: Life and Action Elementary Structures of Practice and Practical Thought, Cambridge/MA. 2008. Wiederholung der letzten Sitzung Hans Jonas, Organismus und Freiheit Wie die Substanz für
More informationThe is the best idea/suggestion/film/book/holiday for my. For me, the is because / I like the because / I don t like the because
Giving reason for statements In towns/the country you I like better, because can/can t (don t) find Comparison of adjectives more interesting/boring than exciting expensive modern cheap > cheaper than
More informationThe Simultaneity of the Three Principles in the Grundlage der gesamten Wissenschaftslehre Michael Kolkman University of Warwick
The Simultaneity of the Three Principles in the Grundlage der gesamten Wissenschaftslehre Michael Kolkman University of Warwick 1. Introduction The Tathandlung with which the Grundlage der gesamten Wissenschaftslehre
More informationTodays programme. Background of the TLP. Some problems in TLP. Frege Russell. Saying and showing. Sense and nonsense Logic The limits of language
Todays programme Background of the TLP Frege Russell Some problems in TLP Saying and showing Sense and nonsense Logic The limits of language 1 TLP, preface How far my efforts agree with those of other
More informationQUESTIONING GÖDEL S ONTOLOGICAL PROOF: IS TRUTH POSITIVE?
QUESTIONING GÖDEL S ONTOLOGICAL PROOF: IS TRUTH POSITIVE? GREGOR DAMSCHEN Martin Luther University of Halle-Wittenberg Abstract. In his Ontological proof, Kurt Gödel introduces the notion of a second-order
More informationAbout the history of the project Naatsaku
About the history of the project Naatsaku In the end of World War II the mother of my wife fled with her husband from Estonia to the west and left her mother there. After the war the old woman, who had
More informationThe human nature in the face of God
The human nature in the face of God By Timo Schmitz, Philosopher In my article The dilemma of natural law in an organised society, I showed that the primary ethics which I introduced two years ago in my
More informationA vague interpretation of Section One of the Sefer Ha-Bahir
A vague interpretation of Section One of the Sefer Ha-Bahir By Timo Schmitz, Philosopher The Book of Illumination (Sefer Ha-Bahir) is a mystical Jewish book which is attibuted to Rabbi Nehunia ben Hakana,
More informationThe Boundaries of Hegel s Criticism of Kant s Concept of the Noumenal
Arthur Kok, Tilburg The Boundaries of Hegel s Criticism of Kant s Concept of the Noumenal Kant conceives of experience as the synthesis of understanding and intuition. Hegel argues that because Kant is
More informationConsciousness might be defined as the perceiver of mental phenomena. We might say that there are no differences between one perceiver and another, as
2. DO THE VALUES THAT ARE CALLED HUMAN RIGHTS HAVE INDEPENDENT AND UNIVERSAL VALIDITY, OR ARE THEY HISTORICALLY AND CULTURALLY RELATIVE HUMAN INVENTIONS? Human rights significantly influence the fundamental
More informationArgumentative Analogy versus Figurative Analogy
Argumentative Analogy versus Figurative Analogy By Timo Schmitz, Philosopher As argumentative analogy or simply analogism (ἀναλογισµός), one calls the comparison through inductive reasoning of at least
More informationHISTORY AND TRUTH: A STUDY OF THE AXIOM OF LESSING
HISTORY AND TRUTH: A STUDY OF THE AXIOM OF LESSING I "CONTINGENT truths of history can never be proof of the necessary truths of reason." 1 Of the assertions of Lessing there is none which has come down
More informationFrom Aristotle s Ousia to Ibn Sina s Jawhar
In the Name of God, the Merciful, the Beneficent From Aristotle s Ousia to Ibn Sina s Jawhar SHAHRAM PAZOUKI, TEHERAN There is a shift in the meaning of substance from ousia in Aristotle to jawhar in Ibn
More informationHealing with Sound And the
Healing with Sound And the Vibratory Attunement Part I By Kevin Townley The phenomenon of sound is perhaps the most singularly celebrated cause of creation. Sacred texts abound with either direct statements
More informationSEVEN 4COLORS LYRICS
SEVEN 4COLORS LYRICS Don t Help Me Don't help me Just give me company Don't try to help me And just be there for me I shut myself down The key is drowning in your mind Dare to believe that all I need is
More informationMaterie und Geist. Eine philosophische Untersuchung. Arno Ros. Paderborn, Germany: Mentis 2005, 686 pages, 84, paperback
1 Materie und Geist. Eine philosophische Untersuchung. Arno Ros. Paderborn, Germany: Mentis 2005, 686 pages, 84, paperback Reviewed by Jörg R.J. Schirra, private researcher, www.jrjs.de Among the many
More informationMan and the Presence of Evil in Christian and Platonic Doctrine by Philip Sherrard
Man and the Presence of Evil in Christian and Platonic Doctrine by Philip Sherrard Source: Studies in Comparative Religion, Vol. 2, No.1. World Wisdom, Inc. www.studiesincomparativereligion.com OF the
More informationPlato's Epistemology PHIL October Introduction
1 Plato's Epistemology PHIL 305 28 October 2014 1. Introduction This paper argues that Plato's theory of forms, specifically as it is presented in the middle dialogues, ought to be considered a viable
More informationGeneral terms and existence By Timo Schmitz, Philosopher
General terms and existence By Timo Schmitz, Philosopher In my previous article on logic 1, the identity of a singular term was in the spotlight. A singular term might be Berne, as well as the capital
More informationTHE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SCIENCE, RELIGION AND ARISTOTELIAN THEOLOGY TODAY
Science and the Future of Mankind Pontifical Academy of Sciences, Scripta Varia 99, Vatican City 2001 www.pas.va/content/dam/accademia/pdf/sv99/sv99-berti.pdf THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SCIENCE, RELIGION
More informationGod is a Community Part 2: The Meaning of Life
God is a Community Part 2: The Meaning of Life This week we will attempt to answer just two simple questions: How did God create? and Why did God create? Although faith is much more concerned with the
More informationThe Greatest Mistake: A Case for the Failure of Hegel s Idealism
The Greatest Mistake: A Case for the Failure of Hegel s Idealism What is a great mistake? Nietzsche once said that a great error is worth more than a multitude of trivial truths. A truly great mistake
More information3. The World Citizen from the Perspective of Alien Reason: Notes on Kant s Category of the Weltbürger according to Josef Simon
3. The World Citizen from the Perspective of Alien Reason: Notes on Kant s Category of the Weltbürger according to Josef Simon Carola Häntsch How do we understand the idea of kosmopolis and the concept
More informationThe Juche philosophy of North Korea Philosophical Content and Practical Failure
The Juche philosophy of North Korea Philosophical Content and Practical Failure Timo Schmitz The Juche philosophy has been the leading philosophy of the DPRK, probably one of the most isolate countries
More information(2) Then take careful note of Gen.1:2b,3: And darkness was upon the face of the deep. (Note further) And the Spirit of God (the Holy Spirit) moved
REFUTING THE GAP THEORY Ed Dye 1. The first and best evidence to refute the Gap theory, in my opinion, is the following: a. Gen.1:1: In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. b. Gen.1:31-2:2:
More informationChapter 16 George Berkeley s Immaterialism and Subjective Idealism
Chapter 16 George Berkeley s Immaterialism and Subjective Idealism Key Words Immaterialism, esse est percipi, material substance, sense data, skepticism, primary quality, secondary quality, substratum
More informationHeidegger Introduction
Heidegger Introduction G. J. Mattey Spring, 2011 / Philosophy 151 Being and Time Being Published in 1927, under pressure Dedicated to Edmund Husserl Initially rejected as inadequate Now considered a seminal
More informationCreation in Genesis According to the Hebrew Text
Creation in Genesis According to the Hebrew Text Victor Christensen The six-day creation in Genesis is under attack for varying reasons from many quarters. Desmond Ford complains that the literal Genesis
More informationThe Names of God. from Summa Theologiae (Part I, Questions 12-13) by Thomas Aquinas (~1265 AD) translated by Brian Shanley (2006)
The Names of God from Summa Theologiae (Part I, Questions 12-13) by Thomas Aquinas (~1265 AD) translated by Brian Shanley (2006) For with respect to God, it is more apparent to us what God is not, rather
More informationLogic: Deductive and Inductive by Carveth Read M.A. CHAPTER VI CONDITIONS OF IMMEDIATE INFERENCE
CHAPTER VI CONDITIONS OF IMMEDIATE INFERENCE Section 1. The word Inference is used in two different senses, which are often confused but should be carefully distinguished. In the first sense, it means
More informationIdentity in Frege's Begriffsschrift
Identity in Frege's Begriffsschrift Where Both Thau-Caplan and Heck Are Wrong Frege's views on identity continue to provoke scholars, and rightly so. In particular his view in Begriffsschrift (Bs) of 1879,
More informationStill alive The True Story of The Dinosaurs
Vor und Nachbereitungsmaterial sandkorn-theater-berlin - 1 - Die Verwendung der Texte ist nur für den Schulgebrauch gestattet! Still alive The True Story of The Dinosaurs 1.Teil Dino - Valley Scene 1 People:
More informationMorphomata Lectures Cologne. Herausgegeben von Günter Blamberger und Dietrich Boschung
Morphomata Lectures Cologne 8 Herausgegeben von Günter Blamberger und Dietrich Boschung Eckart Schütrumpf The Earliest Translations of Aristotle s Politics and the Creation of Political Terminology Wilhelm
More informationTheDao 1. 1 Kessler, Voices of Wisdom, pp
TheDao 1 The name "Daoism" was first coined by Han scholars to refer to the philosophy developed by Laozi and Zhuangzi. We have already encountered some of the thoughts of Zhuangzi in the Prelude to this
More informationVol 2 Bk 7 Outline p 486 BOOK VII. Substance, Essence and Definition CONTENTS. Book VII
Vol 2 Bk 7 Outline p 486 BOOK VII Substance, Essence and Definition CONTENTS Book VII Lesson 1. The Primacy of Substance. Its Priority to Accidents Lesson 2. Substance as Form, as Matter, and as Body.
More informationChapter 1 Emergence of being
Chapter 1 Emergence of being Concepts of being, essence, and existence as forming one single notion in the contemporary philosophy does not figure as a distinct topic of inquiry in the early Greek philosophers
More informationAnthony P. Andres. The Place of Conversion in Aristotelian Logic. Anthony P. Andres
[ Loyola Book Comp., run.tex: 0 AQR Vol. W rev. 0, 17 Jun 2009 ] [The Aquinas Review Vol. W rev. 0: 1 The Place of Conversion in Aristotelian Logic From at least the time of John of St. Thomas, scholastic
More informationChristian Lotz, Commentary, SPEP 2009 Formal Indication and the Problem of Radical Philosophy in Heidegger
Christian Lotz, Commentary, SPEP 2009 Formal Indication and the Problem of Radical Philosophy in Heidegger Introduction I would like to begin by thanking Leslie MacAvoy for her attempt to revitalize the
More informationThe Unmoved Mover (Metaphysics )
The Unmoved Mover (Metaphysics 12.1-6) Aristotle Part 1 The subject of our inquiry is substance; for the principles and the causes we are seeking are those of substances. For if the universe is of the
More informationOn The Logical Status of Dialectic (*) -Historical Development of the Argument in Japan- Shigeo Nagai Naoki Takato
On The Logical Status of Dialectic (*) -Historical Development of the Argument in Japan- Shigeo Nagai Naoki Takato 1 The term "logic" seems to be used in two different ways. One is in its narrow sense;
More informationTHE UNCOMFORTABLE QUESTION OF EVIL
THE UNCOMFORTABLE QUESTION OF EVIL DANTE NICOTERA PROMPT In the Confessions, Augustine considers the nature and source of evil in the world. Present the argument of VII.12-13. First explain how Augustine
More informationSubstance as Essence. Substance and Definability
Substance as Essence Substance and Definability The Z 3 Alternatives Substance is spoken of if not in more senses, still at least in reference to four main objects; for both the essence and the universal
More informationImmanuel Newsletter GOD S WORK OUR HANDS
JULY 2018 IMMANUEL EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH Connecting people with God and with other people to make a difference! 14100 WORTHINGTON ROAD PHILADELPHIA, PA 19116 Phone: 215-464-1540 www.immanuelphilly.org
More informationCONSTRUCTIVE ENGAGEMENT DIALOGUE SEARLE AND BUDDHISM ON THE NON-SELF SORAJ HONGLADAROM
Comparative Philosophy Volume 8, No. 1 (2017): 94-99 Open Access / ISSN 2151-6014 www.comparativephilosophy.org CONSTRUCTIVE ENGAGEMENT DIALOGUE SEARLE AND BUDDHISM ON THE NON-SELF SORAJ ABSTRACT: In this
More information- 1 - Outline of NICOMACHEAN ETHICS, Book I Book I--Dialectical discussion leading to Aristotle's definition of happiness: activity in accordance
- 1 - Outline of NICOMACHEAN ETHICS, Book I Book I--Dialectical discussion leading to Aristotle's definition of happiness: activity in accordance with virtue or excellence (arete) in a complete life Chapter
More informationKant s Critical Thoughts on Freedom from a Contemporary Perspective -
Kant s Critical Thoughts on Freedom from a Contemporary Perspective - To what extent are these thoughts of practical philosophical significance for us? Gerhard Bos Student Number: 0354422 Master s Thesis
More informationDifficult Normativity
Difficult Normativity Normative Dimensions in Research on Religion and Theology Bearbeitet von Jan-Olav Henriksen 1. Auflage 2011. Taschenbuch. 145 S. Paperback ISBN 978 3 631 61993 3 Format (B x L): 14
More informationThe Need for Metanormativity: A Response to Christmas
The Need for Metanormativity: A Response to Christmas Douglas J. Den Uyl Liberty Fund, Inc. Douglas B. Rasmussen St. John s University We would like to begin by thanking Billy Christmas for his excellent
More informationBeyond Sklavenmoral - Kanamaru Toshiyuki and Harry Graf Kessler
Götz Bachmann, Metadata Project, Goldsmiths College, 4.8.08 Series: Nico Nico Douga Texts 1, Nr. 21 Beyond Sklavenmoral - Kanamaru Toshiyuki and Harry Graf Kessler Kanamaru-san (id:kana0355) is a pragmatic
More informationAquinas and Bonaventure: The World s Beginning in Time
Aquinas and Bonaventure: The World s Beginning in Time Mark Hellinger PHIL 211: Medieval Philosophy March 27, 2015 1 One of the questions that the Medieval Philosophers pondered was the question of whether
More informationZWISCHENBERICHT TONGJI UNIVERSITY, SHANGHAI, CHINA Master Angewandte Politikwissenschaften CH-2016-J3GK7-w
ZWISCHENBERICHT 2016-2017 TONGJI UNIVERSITY, SHANGHAI, CHINA Master Angewandte Politikwissenschaften CH-2016-J3GK7-w Sunset at the Bund, Shanghai Wie waren Ankunft und die erste Woche in Ihrem Gastland?
More informationAquinas' Principle of Individuation. Patrick W. Hughes Denison University
Aquinas' Principle of ndividuation Patrick W. Hughes Denison University Saint Thomas Aquinas, the Thirteenth Century Catholic theologian and philosopher was one of the first Medieval philosophers to attempt
More informationProof of the Necessary of Existence
Proof of the Necessary of Existence by Avicenna (Ibn Sīnā), various excerpts (~1020-1037 AD) *** The Long Version from Kitab al-najat (The Book of Salvation), second treatise (~1020 AD) translated by Jon
More informationWintersemester 2005/2006 Interdisziplinäres Seminar
Wintersemester 2005/2006 Interdisziplinäres Seminar Anglo-Saxon, Norse and Norman: Battles, Books and Buildings Exkursion: Skipton Hastings Bayeux 22. 3. 4. 4. 2006 1. Tag (22. 3.): Tübingen Rotterdam
More informationUnderstanding my philosophy as state philosophy or theoretical philosophy?
Understanding my philosophy as state philosophy or theoretical philosophy? By Timo Schmitz, Philosopher Part 27 of the series Individualism between Moral and Virtues, Government and Religion In this philosophical
More informationRoots of Psychology Aristotle and Descartes
Roots of Psychology Aristotle and Descartes Aristotle s Hylomorphism Dualism of matter and form A commitment shared with Plato that entities are identified by their form But, unlike Plato, did not accept
More informationThe Trinity and the Enhypostasia
0 The Trinity and the Enhypostasia CYRIL C. RICHARDSON NE learns from one's critics; and I should like in this article to address myself to a fundamental point which has been raised by critics (both the
More informationThe Sacred Scriptures
The Sacred Scriptures» The New Covenant & New Testament The Book of Psalms & The Book of Daniel «~ all verses and explanations in German and English with»appendix«in English ~ ~ 29th Special Edition ~
More informationTHE LEIBNIZ CLARKE DEBATES
THE LEIBNIZ CLARKE DEBATES Background: Newton claims that God has to wind up the universe. His health The Dispute with Newton Newton s veiled and Crotes open attacks on the plenists The first letter to
More informationNature and Grace in the First Question of the Summa
Scot C. Bontrager (HX8336) Monday, February 1, 2010 Nature and Grace in the First Question of the Summa The question of the respective roles of nature and grace in human knowledge is one with which we
More informationQuestioning the One and the Many with Aristotle and Zhu Xi May Sim (College of the Holy Cross)
Questioning the One and the Many with Aristotle and Zhu Xi May Sim (College of the Holy Cross) Is there a single question of being which can take various forms like what is being/ousia?, and why is there
More informationReviewed by Jörg R.J. Schirra, Illingen, Germany
1 Materie und Geist. Eine philosophische Untersuchung. [Matter and Mind. A Philosophical Investigation]. Arno Ros. Paderborn, Germany: Mentis, 2005, 686 pages, 84 paperback. Reviewed by Jörg R.J. Schirra,
More informationPlotinus and Aquinas on God. A thesis presented to. the faculty of. the College of Arts and Sciences of Ohio University. In partial fulfillment
Plotinus and Aquinas on God A thesis presented to the faculty of the College of Arts and Sciences of Ohio University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Master of Arts Steven L. Kimbler
More information26 Auxiliaries = Modalverben
26 Auxiliaries = Modalverben 26.1 Grammatik Ability etwas können Ability (= Fähigkeit) can/could be able to Possibility es kann sein, dass / es könnte sein, dass Permission / Prohibition dürfen / nicht
More informationThe Absolute and the Relative
2 The Absolute and the Relative Existence has two aspects: an unchanging aspect and an ever-changing aspect. The unchanging aspect of Existence is unmanifest; it contains no forms. The ever-changing aspect
More information11 good reasons for the taz* * abbreviation for taz possibly the best loved national newspaper in Germany
Mini, but mighty: 11 good reasons for the taz* * abbreviation for taz possibly the best loved national newspaper in Germany 1 Independence A luxury we can afford Let s buy the taz before someone else beats
More informationWittgenstein on The Realm of Ineffable
Wittgenstein on The Realm of Ineffable by Manoranjan Mallick and Vikram S. Sirola Abstract The paper attempts to delve into the distinction Wittgenstein makes between factual discourse and moral thoughts.
More informationPART TWO: DEATH AS AN ONTIC EVENT: coming to terms with the phenomenon of death as a determinate possibility
PART TWO: DEATH AS AN ONTIC EVENT: coming to terms with the phenomenon of death as a determinate possibility INTRODUCTION "Death is here and death is there r Death is busy everywhere r All around r within
More informationConscience and Awareness By Timo Schmitz, Philosopher
Conscience and Awareness By Timo Schmitz, Philosopher Conscience and awareness always played a role in human history, mostly through religion, mythology, fairytales or aphorisms. A new side and especially
More informationWHAT ARISTOTLE TAUGHT
WHAT ARISTOTLE TAUGHT Aristotle was, perhaps, the greatest original thinker who ever lived. Historian H J A Sire has put the issue well: All other thinkers have begun with a theory and sought to fit reality
More informationI Come with Thanks Most Grateful : Paul Gerhardt and Psalm 111 on Studying God s Works
Word & World Volume 27, Number 3 Summer 2007 I Come with Thanks Most Grateful : Paul Gerhardt and Psalm 111 on Studying God s Works FREDERICK J. GAISER 1 Praise the LORD! I will give thanks to the LORD
More informationcomparative philosophy
2002 9 141 170 1 Dialog religiöse Begegnung comparative philosophy religiöser confrontation - - 1 Abgrund Dynamik 2 homology Nichts religiöse Homogenität, religious Idee nyat 2 H.Bergson H. Bergson, The
More informationOn What There Is. Thomas Gil. Individual things, qualities, facts and classes are for many philosophers the basic entities that
Individual things, qualities, facts and classes are for many philosophers the basic entities that Thomas Gil make up reality. Answering the ontological question on what there really is, means saying precisely
More informationTHE STUDY OF UNKNOWN AND UNKNOWABILITY IN KANT S PHILOSOPHY
THE STUDY OF UNKNOWN AND UNKNOWABILITY IN KANT S PHILOSOPHY Subhankari Pati Research Scholar Pondicherry University, Pondicherry The present aim of this paper is to highlights the shortcomings in Kant
More informationBuilding Systematic Theology
1 Building Systematic Theology Study Guide LESSON FOUR DOCTRINES IN SYSTEMATICS 2013 by Third Millennium Ministries www.thirdmill.org For videos, manuscripts, and other resources, visit Third Millennium
More informationFrontismatter, preface, table of contents.
Bond University epublications@bond From Word to Silence, 1. The Rise and Fall of Logos From Word to Silence, by Raoul Mortley December 1986 Frontismatter, preface, table of contents. Raoul Mortley Bond
More informationThe Existence of God. G. Brady Lenardos
Page 1 of 16 The Existence of God By G. Brady Lenardos (c) 1995, 2000 G. Brady Lenardos In August of 1993, my friend, Jeff McCain, and I participated in a debate at the Orange County Regional Gathering
More informationIntroduction to Philosophy
Introduction to Philosophy Philosophy 110W Spring 2012 Russell Marcus Class #7: The Oneness of Being and the Paradoxes of Motion Parmenides Poem Marcus, Introduction to Philosophy, Slide 1 Business P The
More informationRichard L. W. Clarke, Notes REASONING
1 REASONING Reasoning is, broadly speaking, the cognitive process of establishing reasons to justify beliefs, conclusions, actions or feelings. It also refers, more specifically, to the act or process
More informationThe church of Sweden model of catholicity
The church of Sweden model of catholicity Autor(en): Objekttyp: Lindow, Anders Article Zeitschrift: Internationale kirchliche Zeitschrift : neue Folge der Revue internationale de théologie Band (Jahr):
More informationQUESTION 3. God s Simplicity
QUESTION 3 God s Simplicity Once we have ascertained that a given thing exists, we then have to inquire into its mode of being in order to come to know its real definition (quid est). However, in the case
More informationThe Trinity, The Dogma, The Contradictions Part 2
The Trinity, The Dogma, The Contradictions Part 2 In the second part of our teaching on The Trinity, The Dogma, The Contradictions we will be taking a deeper look at what is considered the most probable
More informationLesson 2 Student Handout 2.2 Confucius (Kong Fuzi), BCE
Lesson 2 Student Handout 2.2 Confucius (Kong Fuzi), 551-479 BCE Confucius was a sage, that is, a wise man. He was born in 551 BCE, during a period when China was divided into many small states, each with
More informationDoctrine of the Hypostatic Union (HU)
Doctrine of the Hypostatic Union (HU) Colossians 1:15 15 He is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation. We saw in our last lesson how verses 15-19 are five of the most important descriptive
More informationThomas Aquinas on the World s Duration. Summa Theologiae Ia Q46: The Beginning of the Duration of Created Things
Thomas Aquinas on the World s Duration Thomas Aquinas (1224/1226 1274) was a prolific philosopher and theologian. His exposition of Aristotle s philosophy and his views concerning matters central to the
More informationAspects of Western Philosophy Dr. Sreekumar Nellickappilly Department of Humanities and Social Sciences Indian Institute of Technology, Madras
Aspects of Western Philosophy Dr. Sreekumar Nellickappilly Department of Humanities and Social Sciences Indian Institute of Technology, Madras Module - 21 Lecture - 21 Kant Forms of sensibility Categories
More informationThe Early Church worked tirelessly to establish a clear firm structure supported by
Galdiz 1 Carolina Galdiz Professor Kirkpatrick RELG 223 Major Religious Thinkers of the West April 6, 2012 Paper 2: Aquinas and Eckhart, Heretical or Orthodox? The Early Church worked tirelessly to establish
More informationHamlet. Hamlet s first soliloquy - Act I, sc 2
Hamlet Hamlet s first soliloquy - Act I, sc 2 O, that this too too solid flesh would melt Thaw and resolve itself into a dew! Or that the Everlasting had not fix'd His canon 'gainst self-slaughter! O God!
More informationOF THE REFORMATION. October 25, :00 p.m.
A JOINT CELEBRATION OF THE 500 TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE REFORMATION October 25, 2017 5:00 p.m. The Rev. Lawrence M. Eckart, Island Lutheran Church, Hilton Head Island, SC The Rev. Dr. Emil H. Klatt, III,
More informationHeidegger s Claim Carl Schmitt denkt Liberal Introduction to the conference Political Theology and Modernity The Legacy of Carl Schmitt
Heidegger s Claim Carl Schmitt denkt Liberal Introduction to the conference Political Theology and Modernity The Legacy of Carl Schmitt Northern Theory School and The Politics, Philosophy and Religion
More informationTHREE LOGICIANS: ARISTOTLE, SACCHERI, FREGE
1 THREE LOGICIANS: ARISTOTLE, SACCHERI, FREGE Acta philosophica, (Roma) 7, 1998, 115-120 Ignacio Angelelli Philosophy Department The University of Texas at Austin Austin, TX, 78712 plac565@utxvms.cc.utexas.edu
More informationIn Search of the Ontological Argument. Richard Oxenberg
1 In Search of the Ontological Argument Richard Oxenberg Abstract We can attend to the logic of Anselm's ontological argument, and amuse ourselves for a few hours unraveling its convoluted word-play, or
More informationChapter Six. Aristotle s Theory of Causation and the Ideas of Potentiality and Actuality
Chapter Six Aristotle s Theory of Causation and the Ideas of Potentiality and Actuality Key Words: Form and matter, potentiality and actuality, teleological, change, evolution. Formal cause, material cause,
More informationPeter L.P. Simpson December, 2012
1 This translation of Book One Distinctions 1 and 2 of the Ordinatio (aka Opus Oxoniense) of Blessed John Duns Scotus is complete. These two first distinctions take up the whole of volume two of the Vatican
More informationUnderstanding Genesis, Part One: The Creation Account by John A. Jack Crabtree Version 1.0 August 16, 2017
Understanding Genesis, Part One: The Creation Account by John A. Jack Crabtree Version 1.0 August 16, 2017 The opening creation account in Genesis (Genesis 1:1 2:4a) is arguably the most important passage
More information/ 16 Nov 2013
Grafted In Fellowship King George Lesson 1 Study of Genesis Dr. Skip Moen, D.Phil. Disc 1 13-9-5774 / My Notes: Structure of Hebrew Language - Word placement denotes importance or relationship Your Notes:
More informationAristotle and the Definition of Man
Aristotle and the Definition of Man 1 To be, or not to be: that is the question. This phrase has passed from literature and the stage into everyday parlance: it has become a commonplace. Yet, while the
More information[1938. Review of The Philosophy of St. Bonaventure, by Etienne Gilson. Westminster Theological Journal Nov.]
[1938. Review of The Philosophy of St. Bonaventure, by Etienne Gilson. Westminster Theological Journal Nov.] Etienne Gilson: The Philosophy of St. Bonaventure. Translated by I. Trethowan and F. J. Sheed.
More information