HOW RICH ARE PAKISTANI MNAS?

Transcription

1 HOW RICH ARE PAKISTANI MS? Key Points from the Analysis of th Declaration of submitted by Ms for the Years - to 5-6 A research paper by

2

3 is an independent, non-partisan and not-for-profit indigenous research and training institution with the mission to strengthen democracy and democratic institutions in Pakistan. is a registered non-profit entity under the Societies Registration Act XXI of 86, Pakistan. Copyright Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development And Transpar All rights reserved Printed in Pakistan First Published: August 7 ISBN: No part of this publication may be produced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, via photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior permission of. This publication is provided gratis or sold, subject to the condition that it shall not, by way of trade or otherwise, be lent, re-sold, hired out or otherwise circulated without the publisher's prior consent in any form of binding or cover other than in which it is published and without a similar condition, including this condition being imposed on the subsequent publisher. Disclaimer and its researchers have done their best to ensure accuracy of the data and the conclusions drawn from it. Since it was a gigantic amount of data which needed to be digitised before its analysis, the chances of inaccuracy can not be ruled out. is not responsible for any errors, omissions or inaccuracies as it is not deliberate. Printed by: Son Printers, Lahore Published by Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development and Transpar No. 7, 9th Avenue, F-8/, Islamabad, Pakistan Tel: (+9-5) --45; Fax: (+9-5) info@pildat.org; URL:

4

5

6 Abbreviations and Acronyms ICT M MQM PKMAP -F -N -Q PTI Islamabad Capital Territory Muttahidda Majlis-e-Amal Member National Assembly Muttahida Qaumi Movement National Assembly Pakhtoon-Khwa Milli Awami Party Pakistan Muslim League-Functional Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz Pakistan Muslim League-Quaide-e-Azam Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf 5

7 Foreword ccording to the provisions of Section 4 A of the Representation of the People Act, 976 and Section 5 A of the Senate A(Election) Act, 975, all elected representative in the national and provincial legislatures in Pakistan have to submit a detailed account of their assets and liabilities to the Election Commission of Pakistan on a prescribed performa by the end of each financial year. Failure to submit the declarations may lead to disqualification of the elected member. The declared assets are compiled and published by the Election Commission in the form of a Gazette of the Federal Government for the information and use of general public. This is a very welcome step to ensure transpar about the financial dealings of the elected representatives, which may lead to accountability if the public, media and the civil society are alert, organised and vigilant. This can prove an effective step in cleansing the public life of corruption and wrongdoing. It is equally important that these declarations of assets are made more and more accessible to public so that they may examine these and raise a voice if they notice a discrepancy or misreporting. It is also very important that these declarations are scientifically analysed to understand the underlying trends among parties, provinces and individual legislators. This analysis will bring the declarations out of abstract and make their understanding easier for the public. In addition, the analysis will put the cold numbers of declared assets of public representatives in perspective. team of researchers and analysts has painstakingly entered the data of the declarations in electronic mode to make its computer-based analysis possible. The entire exercise is based on the data provided in the declarations. We have not tried to verify or confirm the information provided by the legislators; rather we have placed entire reliance on the information contained in the declarations. The net worth of an M was computed by adding up the assets of each M, his/her spouse and children and then deducting his/her and his/her immediate family's liabilities. Our analysis of the declared assets of Ms reveals that one M, Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, - Q), owned assets worth Rs.59 in year - which was around 86 % of the combined value of the assets of all Ms. The value of his assets remained almost unchanged between - and -4. He remained the richest M for the first two years of the National Assembly. However, his reported assets have reduced considerably after -4. His declaration indicates no balance in his bank accounts during the years 4-5 and 5-6. His total assets are Rs. 87 both in 4-5 and 5-6. The extraordinary value of his assets in the first two years created considerable distortions in the analysis. Since this high value has drastically reduced during the year and 4, it was decided to disregard the value of his assets for the first two years of the assembly for the purpose of analysis of assets. Various tables and analyses reflect this approach unless indicated otherwise. We hope that this presentation of the key findings of the analysis will enhance public understanding of their representatives in a comparative perspective and will help promote political discourse based on facts and specifics. 6

8 Executive Summary his report attempts to present some key findings of the analysis of declaration of assets by the Members of the th National TAssembly of Pakistan filed during the past 4 years starting in -. The source of information for this report is The Gazette of Pakistan published by the Election Commission of Pakistan on October, ; October 6, 4; November 8, 5 and October, 6. According to the findings of the report, the average value of the assets of an M has been Rs in -; Rs..8 in -4, Rs..8 in 4-5 and Rs. 8.5 for 5-6. The high figures for the years - and -4 drop down to Rs.6.6 and Rs.7. respectively, if the assets of one M, namely Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt, a -Q M from Vehari, are disregarded - whose net assets are worth Rs.59. for the year -4 which is more than 86 % of the total assets of all the Ms. The value of the net assets of all Ms increased by 45 % over the four years. The average value of assets owned by non-muslim Ms (Rs.8 ) is 5 % lower than the overall average (Rs. 8 ), based on 5-6 figures. The disparity was greater in the previous years. Ms from Islamabad Capital Territory (ICT) have the highest average value of assets per M or, in other words, on the average, an M from ICT is the richest followed by an M from Punjab, FATA, Balochistan, Sindh and NWFP. In terms of the percentage share of the combined value of assets, Punjab Ms top the list with 7 % of the combined assets which is far greater than warranted by their number (54 %) in the National Assembly. This means that in terms of the collective wealth of Ms, Punjab is the richest province / territory followed by Sindh ( %), ICT (5 %) Balochistan (4 %), NWFP (4 %), and FATA ( %). Analysing Ms' assets on the basis of their party affiliation, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf tops the list in terms of average wealth of its Ms as its lone M, Mr. Imran (-7, Mianwali-I, Punjab, PTI) holds the highest assets (Rs.8 in 5-6) followed by -N (average assets per M: Rs. 6 ), -Q (average assets per M: Rs. 56 ) and (average assets per M: Rs. 4 ). stands at 6th position in terms of average assets per M at Rs. 6 ), MQM at 9th (average assets per M: Rs. 4 ) and PKMAP at th (average assets per M: Rs.. ) position. According to the latest declaration of assets for 5-6, the richest M is Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (-4, Kasur-III, Punjab, -Q) current Foreign Minister of Pakistan, with total assets of Rs. 976, followed by his boss, Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, -Q), the Prime Minister of Pakistan, with total assets of Rs Mian Mohammad Aslam (-48 Islamabad I, ) with assets amounting to Rs. 47 is at the third position followed by Mr. Jahangir Tareen (-95 Rahimyar IV, Punjab, -Q), the Minister for Industries with total assets of Rs.45 at the fourth position. Another -Q M, Mr. Aijaz Ahmed Chaudhry (-8 Mandi Bahauddin I, Punjab, -Q) with assets worth Rs. 88 is the fifth richest M in 5-6. One M, Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, -Q) owned assets worth Rs.59 in - which 7

9 was around 86 % of the combined value of assets of all Ms. The value of his assets remained almost unchanged between - and -4 and he remained richest M for the first two years of the National Assembly. However, his reported assets have reduced considerably after -4 and stand at Rs. 87 both in 4-5 and 5-6. The former richest M, Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, -Q), runs a construction business in Saudi Arabia. Four out of the five richest Ms belong to Punjab and the ruling -Q while one belongs to Islamabad and is a part of. Ms. Naheed (-9, Women Punjab-XX, ) has been consistently one of the five poorest Ms during the last four years. She was the poorest M during -4, 4-5 and 5-6 with net liabilities of Rs. 7.6, Rs and Rs..6 respectively. Based on the assets declarations of 5-6, Molvi Noor (-59 Quetta, Balochistan, ), Mr. Sabir Hussain Awan (-4 Peshawar IV, NWFP, ), Chaudhry Manzoor Ahmed (-9 Kasur II, Punjab, ) and Mufti Ibrar Sultan, (-4, Kohat, NWFP, ) are the second, third, fourth and the fifth poorest Ms respectively. Two each of the poorest Ms belong to Punjab and NWFP and one to Balochistan. Party-wise, two belong to the and three to the. In -, the poorest M was Mr. Amir Muqam (-, Shangla, NWFP, and later joined -Q), the current Minister of State for Water and Power who had net liabilities of Rs.6. However, during -4, his financial position has considerably improved with net assets of Rs In Balochistan, Sardar Yaqoob Nasir (-6, Loralai, Balochistan, -N), Sardar Yar Mohammad Rind (-67, Kachhi, Balochistan, -Q) and Ms. Zobaida Jalal (-7, Kech-cum-Gwadar, Balochistan, -Q) are the three richest Ms in descending order. Molvi Noor (-59 Quetta, Balochistan, ), Ms. Imrana Khawar (-, Women Balochistan-III, ) and Mr. Mahmood Achakzai (-6, Killa Abdullah, Balochistan, PKMAP) are the three poorest Ms of Balochistan. Mir Zafarullah Jamali (-66, Nasirabad, Balochistan, -Q), the former Prime Minister of Pakistan, was one of the three poorest Ms of Balochistan in -. In NWFP, Ms. Zeb Gohar Ayub (-, Women NWFP-I, -Q), Maulana Abdul Haleem (-, Kohistan, NWFP, ) and Mr. Amir Muqam (-, Shangla, NWFP, -Q) are the three richest Ms in descending order. Mr. Amir Muqam was the poorest M in the country in -. Mr. Sabir Hussain Awan (-4, Peshawar-IV, NWFP, ), Mufti Ibrar Sultan, (- 4, Kohat, NWFP, ) and Maulana Qasim (-, Mardan II, NWFP, ) are the three poorest Ms of NWFP. In Punjab Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (-4, Kasur-III, Punjab, -Q), Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, - Q) and Mr. Jahangir Tareen (-95 Rahimyar IV, Punjab, -Q) are the three richest Ms in the descending order. Ms. Naheed (-9, Women Punjab-XX, ), Chaudhry Manzoor Ahmed (-9 Kasur II, Punjab, ) and are the three poorest Ms of Punjab. In Sindh, Ms. Sherry Rehman (-9, Women Sindh-II, ), Makhdoom Amin Faheem (-8, Hyderabad-I, Sindh, ) and Sardar Khalid Ahmed Lund (-, Ghotki-I, Sindh, ) are the three richest Ms in descending order. Ms. Ruqia um Soomro (-, Women Sindh-III, ), Mr. Abdul Waseem (-4, Karachi-V, Sindh, MQM) and Ms. Khurshid Afghan (-, Women Sindh-XIV, -F) are the three poorest Ms belonging to Sindh. Ms. Sherry Rehman (-9, Women Sindh-II, ) is also the richest female M, followed by Ms. Tahira Asif (-9, Women Punjab-XIX, -Q) and Ms. Tanzeela Amir Cheema (-75, Women Punjab-III, -Q). During the previous three years, Ms. Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani (-, Women, Sindh-V, ), Ms. Ishrat Ashraf (-, Women Punjab-XXXI - N), Ms. Yasmeen Rehman (-97, Women Punjab-XXV, ), Ms. Sumera Malik (-69, Khushab-I, Punjab, -Q), Ms. Belum Hasnain (-9,Women Punjab-XXI ), Ms. Tehmina Daultana (-4, Women Punjab-XXXII, -N) had been among the three richest female Ms. Within, Ms. Sherry Rehman (-9, Women Sindh-II, ), Mr. Ghulam Murtaza Satti (-5, Rawalpindi-I, Punjab, ) and Makhdoom Amin Faheem (-8, Hyderabad-I, Sindh, ) are ranked as the three richest Ms in descending order. During the previous years, Ms. Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani (-, Women, Sindh-V, ), Ms. Yasmeen Rehman (- 97, Women Punjab-XXV, ), Ms. Belum Hasnain (-9,Women Punjab-XXI, ), Mr. Aitzaz Ahsan, and Ms. Samina 8

10 Khalid Ghurki were among the three richest Ms of the party. Ms. Naheed (-9, Women Punjab-XX, ), as mentioned earlier, is the poorest M among Ms followed by Ms. Ruqia um Soomro (-, Women Sindh-III, ) and Mr. Zamurd (-54, Rawalpindi-V, Punjab, ). These three Ms along with Chaudhry Manzoor Ahmed (-9 Kasur II, Punjab, ) were among the poorest Ms of the party in the previous years. In -Q, Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (-4, Kasur-III, Punjab, -Q), Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, - Q) and Mr. Jahangir Tareen (-95 Rahimyar IV, Punjab, -Q) are the three richest Ms. In the past, Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, -Q) and Mr. Aijaz Ahmed Chaudhry (-8 Mandi Bahauddin I, Punjab, - Q) had also been a part of the elite club in terms of their declared and published assets. Mr. Khurram Munawar Munj (-4, Sheikhupura-IV, Punjab, -Q) is the poorest M among -Q Ms followed by Ms. Riffat Amjad (-79, Women Punjab-VII, -Q) and Dr. Rozina Tufail (-9, Women Punjab-XVIII, -Q). In previous years, Ms. Onaza Ehsan (-88, Women Punjab-XVI, -Q) and Sardar Shahjehan Yousaf (-, Mansehra-I, NWFP, -Q) were also among the three poorest Ms in the party. Within, Mian Mohammad Aslam (-48 Islamabad I, ), Maulana Abdul Haleem (-, Kohistan, NWFP, ) and Sahabzada Abulkhair Zubair (-, Hyderabad-III, Sindh, ) are ranked as the three richest Ms in descending order. During the previous years, Ms. Ambreen Naeem (-7, Women NWFP-VI, ), Qazi Hussain Ahmed (-5, Nowshera-I, NWFP, ) and Maulana Syed Naseeb Ali Shah (-6, Bannu, NWFP, ) were among the three richest Ms of the party. Molvi Noor (-59 Quetta, Balochistan, ), Mr. Sabir Hussain Awan (-4, Peshawar-IV, NWFP, ) and Mufti Ibrar Sultan, (-4, Kohat, NWFP, ) are the three poorest Ms of. In the previous years, Maulana Amanullah (-7, Lakki Marwat, NWFP, ), Maulana Shah Abdul Aziz (-5, Karak, NWFP, ), Qazi Hameedullah (-96, Gujranwala-II, Punjab, ), Maulana Mohammad Sherani (-64, Zhobcum-Killa-Sherani Sa, Balochistan, ), Maulana Qasim (-, Mardan II, NWFP, ), Maulana Shah Abdul Aziz (-5, Karak, NWFP, ) and Ms. Inayat Begum (-8, Women NWFP-VII, ) were also among the three poorest Ms in the party. Dr. Sher Afgan Niazi (-7, Mianwali-II, Punjab, PPP) the Federal Minister for Parliamentary Affairs, proved to be the most effective asset manager over the four years as his net assets (Rs. 5) in - increased by over 9 times to Rs. 456, 55. Mr. Amir Muqam (-, Shangla, NWFP, -Q), Federal Minister of State for Water and Power and Provincial President of -Q in NWFP, made the most dramatic turn around by turning his net liabilities of Rs. 6 in - into net assets of Rs. 74 in 5-6. Among the other top asset managers are Makhdoom Amin Faheem (-8, Hyderabad-I, Sindh, ), and Dr. Atiya Inayatullah, (-8, Women Punjab-VIII, -Q). Fortunes of Khawaja Asif (-, Sialkot-I, Punjab, -N) went down drastically during the past four years. His net assets reduced from Rs. to Rs. 65,, representing a decrease to the order of 46 to. of Chaudhry Manzoor Ahmed (-9 Kasur II, Punjab, ) dwindled to the order of 65 to as his net assets of Rs. 4. in - reduced to Rs. 65 in 5-6. of Ms. Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani (-, Women, Sindh-V, ) reduced to the order of 87 to as her net assets of Rs. 77 in - decreased to Rs. 6 in 5-6. The assets of Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, -Q) went down to the order of 679 to as the value of his net assets in - was reduced from Rs. 59, 7 to Rs. 87 in

11 Average Value of of an M he average value of an M's assets was 7 in - which increased to Rs. 8 in 5-6 Trepresenting a growth of around 45 % in four years. The increase in average assets has not been phenomenal and may be considered modest when adjusted against inflation. The rate of growth of the average assets has, however, increased with each passing year. Table Average Value of of an M Year Average value of of an M (M.Rs.) Percentage Increase Over Previous Year -.6 % 5. %.6 % Fig. Growth of Ms / / /

12 Provincial Picture of Average ICT and Punjab Ms have the highest value of average assets mong the Provinces and territories in Pakistan, the Islamabad Capital Territory (ICT) Ms have the highest average value Aof assets - Rs in 5-6. ICT has maintained its top position in terms of the highest value of average assets per M throughout the four years. The average value of Ms' assets in ICT increased from Rs in - to Rs in 5-6, representing an appreciation of 6 % or four and a half times! This extra-ordinary growth is attributable to the phenomenal growth in the assets of Mian Mohammad Aslam (-48 Islamabad, ) from Rs in - to Rs in 5-6, an increase of 497 % or 6 times! Sindh was in the second position in - but Punjab overtook in -4 and maintained its second position for the rest of the three years. The provincial ranking is presented in Table. Table Ranking of Provinces and Territories in Terms of Average Asset of an M Rank Province/ Territory Average per M (M RS.) Province/ Territory Average per M (M Rs.) Province/ Territory Average per M (M Rs.) Province/ Territory Average per M (M Rs.) ICT Sindh Punjab Balochistan FATA NWFP Overall for Pakistan ICT Punjab FATA Balochistan NWFP Sindh ICT Punjab FATA Balochistan NWFP Sindh ICT Punjab FATA Balochistan Sindh NWFP Fig. Average per M, 5-6 Provincial Ranking

13 Provincial Share in the Combined Value of of all Ms Punjab and Sindh Ms have the Highest Value of Combined he combined value of the assets of all Ms was Rs.68.4 in -, Rs.68.4 in -4, Rs.9.9 T in 4-5 and Rs..5 in 5-6.This is after considering NJF. Punjab ranks No. in terms of combined value of assets of its Ms.The percentage share of Punjab Ms in the total assets has increased during the past 4 years from 58 % to 7 % - and is far greater than warranted by the number of Ms from Punjab, which is about 54 % of all Ms. The combined value of the assets of the Ms from Punjab was Rs.5. in -, which constituted about 58 % of the combined value of the assets of all Ms. In -4, this value was Rs.7. or 77 % of the assets of all Ms; in 4-5, Rs.7.4 or 75 % of all assets; in 5-6, Rs.9.7 or 7 % of all assets. Sindh ranks at No. and holds per cent share in combined assets which is far less than the number of Sindh Ms who constitute % of the total Ms: Sindh, with combined assets of its Ms at about or 4 % of the total assets of all Ms was at second position in -. Combined value of Sindh Ms' assets was Rs.794 or % of the total assets in -4, Rs. or % of the total assets in 4-5 and Rs..8 or % of the total assets in 5-6. The combined assets of Sindh Ms fell by 7. % between - and -4. The extraordinary fall in the value of the combined assets of Sindh Ms in -4 over the previous year is explained by the fall in the assets of one of the female Ms from, Ms. Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani (-, Women, Sindh-V, ), whose assets have drastically decreased by over 99 % from Rs..7 in - to 6.65 in -4. Balochistan ranks at No. 5 in terms of combined value of its Ms' : Balochistan, with combined assets of its Ms at about Rs.8 or.4 % of the total assets of all Ms was at third position in -. Although combined value of Balochistan Ms' assets increased to Rs.96 constituting.4 % of combined assets in -4, its position plummeted to No. 5. In 4-5, the combined assets of its Ms was Rs..89 or % of the total assets of all Ms. Combined assets of its Ms was Rs or 4 % of the total assets of all Ms in 5-6. Balochistan remained at 5th position in the years 4-5 and 5-6. The number of Balochistan Ms constitutes about 5 % of total Ms. NWFP ranks at No. in combined value of its Ms'. NWFP, with combined assets of its Ms at about 79 or about.4 % of the total assets of all Ms was at the 4th position in -. However combined value of NWFP Ms' assets increased to Rs. 484 or.7 % of the total assets moving it to the third position in -4. In 4-5, assets of its Ms was more than Rs. 57 which increased to Rs. 65 in 5-6 or about 5 % of the total assets of all Ms in both years. The number of NWFP Ms constitutes about % of total Ms. NWFP maintained its third position for the years 4-5 and 5-6. Ms from Islamabad Capital Territory (ICT) hold the 4th highest Value of : ICT, with the combined assets of its Ms th at or.8 % of the total value of assets of all Ms was at the 5 position in -. It moved up to the 4th position in -4 when the combined value of the assets of its Ms increased to Rs. 4 (or.45 % of the total for all Ms). In 4-5 and 5-6 combined assets of its Ms was more than Rs. 47 or 4 % of the total value of assets of all Ms and Rs. 57 or 5 % of the total value of assets of all Ms respectively. In terms of number, the ICT Ms constitute about.58 % of the National Assembly. The percentage share of each province/ territory in the combined assets of all Ms is shown in table. If we do not disregard the NJ factor, the ranking remains the same with Punjab having a total value of its Ms' assets at about 94 % in -, which rose to 97 % in -4 and then decreased to 74 % in 4-5 and ultimately to 7 % in 5-6. Sindh saw an increase from 4 % to about %, while in all the other provinces there is increase in the share in the combined assets of Ms from - to 5-6.

14 Table Province wise Percentage of Combined of all Ms (Disregarding NJF) Province/ Territory Percentage of Combined of Ms Rank Percentage of Combined of Ms Rank Percentage of Combined of Ms Rank Percentage of Combined of Ms Rank Punjab Sindh Balochistan NWFP ICT FATA Fig. Provincial Share of Combined of Ms, 5-6 4

15 Table 4 Province wise Percentage of Combined of all Ms (Including NJF) Province/ Territory Percentage of Combined of Ms Rank Percentage of Combined of Ms Rank Percentage of Combined of Ms Rank Percentage of Combined of Ms Rank Punjab Sindh Balochistan NWFP ICT FATA

16 How Political Parties Figure in the Ms'? Mr. Imran 's Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf is the richest party followed by -N, -Q and in terms of average assets of their Ms akistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf (PTI) of Mr. Imran (-7, Mianwali-I, Punjab, PTI) emerged as the richest in 5-6 in Pterms of average value of the assets of its Ms, which happens to be only one, i.e., Mr. Imran (-7, Mianwali-I, Punjab, PTI) himself. This value was Rs in -, which increased to Rs.8.57 in 5-6 registering a 4 % increase. The party ranked at No. in - but moved up to the first position in -4 and 4-5 which it maintained in 5-6 as well. -Q Ms with their average assets at Rs.46.5 ranks second while -N at Rs.7.4 ranks third in N was at 4th position in -, climbing to the rd position in -4 and 4-5., however, plummeted to the 6th position in -4 from its nd position in -. climbed to 4th position in 5-6. and MQM rank 7th and th respectively in 5-6. The party rankings in terms of average assets per M for all the four years are reflected in Table 5. If the NJ factor is disregarded, the ranking of political parties changes placing in No. position in - followed by TI, -N and -Q. TI secured No. position in -4 followed by -N, -Q and. In 4-5, -Q was ranked second after being ranked first in - and -4 with its average assets drastically decreasing from Rs. 45 to Rs. 46. BNP-M used to be the poorest party in that respect before its lone M, Mr. Abdur Rauf Mengal resigned in protest against the killing of Sardar Akbar Bugti. Currently another party of Balochistan, PKMAP holds that position at rank with average assets at Rs.,. 6

17 Table 5 Party Ranking in terms of Average per M (Including NJF) Political Party Average per M, (M.Rs.) Rank Average per M, (M.Rs.) Rank Average per M, (M.Rs.) Rank Average per M, (M.Rs.) Rank -Q PTI -N PPP -F PAT JWP MQM PKMAP IND BNP-M For All Parties Fig. 4 Average Per M, 5-6 Party Ranking 7

18 The Richest Ms Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (-4, Kasur-III, Punjab, -Q) is the richest M followed by Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, -Q) For the first two years, little-known Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, -Q)was the richest M with net worth of Rs.59 and owned 86 % of the combined value of assets of all Ms ccording to the latest declaration of assets for 5-6, the richest M is Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (-4, AKasur-III, Punjab, -Q) the current Foreign Minister, with total assets of Rs. 976 ; followed by his boss, Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, -Q), the Prime Minister, with total assets of Rs Mian Mohammad Aslam (-48 Islamabad I, ), with assets amounting to Rs. 47, is at the third position followed by Mr. Jahangir Tareen (-95 Rahimyar IV, Punjab, -Q), Minister for Industries, with total assets of Rs. 45 at the fourth position; and Mr. Aijaz Ahmed Chaudhry (-8 Mandi Bahauddin I, Punjab, -Q) with assets worth Rs. 88 at the fifth position. Out of the five richest Ms, two have, until recently, been or even at present are overseas Pakistanis: Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, -Q) worked for long years in Saudi Arabia, UK and USA until he returned to Pakistan in 999 to become Finance Minister in General Pervez Musharraf's first cabinet while Mr. Aijaz Ahmed Chaudhry (-8 Mandi Bahauddin I, Punjab, -Q) has lived in Kuwait. The former richest M, Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, -Q) runs a construction business in Saudi Arabia. Four out of the five richest Ms belong to Punjab and the ruling -Q while one belongs to Islamabad and is a part of.the details of the top 5 richest Ms for the last four years are given in Table 6. One M, Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, -Q) owned assets worth Rs.59 in year - which was around 86 % of the combined value of assets of all Ms. The value of his assets remained almost unchanged between - and -4. He was the richest M for the first two years of the National Assembly. However, his reported assets have reduced considerably after -4. His declaration indicates no balance in his bank accounts during the years 4-5 and 5-6. His total assets are Rs. 87 both in 4-5 and 5-6. While Mr. Jatt runs a construction business in Saudi Arabia, most of his assets were located here in Pakistani banks. He still maintains his workingresident status in Saudi Arabia and had never run for a public office before. In -4, Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, -Q) was followed by a distant second richest M, Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, -Q), the current Prime Minister. The next positions were bagged by Mr. Aijaz Ahmed Chaudhry (-8 Mandi Bahauddin I, Punjab, -Q), Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (-4, Kasur-III, Punjab, - Q) and Mr. Jahangir Tareen (-95 Rahimyar IV, Punjab, -Q). In -, when Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, -Q) was not yet elected to the National Assembly, the four richest Ms after Mr. Jatt included Ms. Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani (-, Women, Sindh-V, ) at second position, Ms. Ishrat Ashraf (-, Women Punjab-XXXI -N) at the third position, Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (-4, Kasur-III, Punjab, -Q) at the fourth position and Mr. Jahangir Tareen (-95 Rahimyar IV, Punjab, -Q) at the fifth position. In 4-5, the richest M was Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (-4, Kasur-III, Punjab, -Q); Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, -Q) at second position; Mr. Aijaz Ahmed Chaudhry (-8 Mandi Bahauddin I, Punjab, -Q) at the third position; Mian Mohammad Aslam (-48 Islamabad I, ) at the fourth position and Mr. Jahangir Tareen (-95 Rahimyar IV, Punjab, -Q) at the fifth position. 8

19 Table 6 The Richest Ms Rank 4 5 Ch.Nazir Ahmed Jatt Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani Ishrat Ashraf Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri Jahangir Tareen Ch.Nazir Ahmed Jatt Shaukat Aziz Ch. Aijaz Ahmed Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri Jahangir Tareen Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri Shaukat Aziz Ch. Aijaz Ahmed Mian Mohammad Aslam Jahangir Tareen Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri Shaukat Aziz Mian Aslam Jahangir Tareen Ch.Aijaz Ahmed

20 The Poorest Ms Ms. Naheed (-9, Women Punjab-XX, ) is the poorest M with about Rs. 8 net liabilities s. Naheed (-9, Women Punjab-XX, ) has been consistently one of the five poorest Ms during the last four years. She was the second poorest M in -. She was the poorest M during -4 with net Mliabilities of Rs. 7.6 and during 4-5 with net liabilities of Rs Her net liabilities have increased to Rs..6 in 5-6. Molvi Noor (-59 Quetta, Balochistan, ) is the second poorest M with zero assets and liabilities. Mr. Sabir Hussain Awan (-4, Peshawar-IV, NWFP, ), Chaudhry Manzoor Ahmed (-9 Kasur II, Punjab, )and Mufti Ibrar Sultan (-4, Kohat, NWFP, ) are the third, fourth and the fifth poorest Ms with assets of Rs. 5, 65 and 9 respectively. Two of the five poorest Ms belong to Punjab; two to NWFP and one to Balochistan. Party-wise, two belong to and three to. A noted landlord of South Punjab, Rais Munir Ahmed (-97 Rahimyar VI, Punjab, -Patriot) had been one of the five poorest Ms in - with net liabilities of Rs..6. In -, the poorest M was Mr. Amir Muqam (- Shangla, NWFP, and later joined -Q), the current Minister of State for Water and Power, who had net liabilities of Rs.6. However, during -4, his financial position considerably improved with net assets of Rs The details of the five poorest Ms during the past four years are given in Table 7. Table 7 The Poorest Ms Rank 4 5 Maulvi Sadiq Nawab Mirza Advocate Rais Munir Ahmed Naheed Amir Muqam Maulana Qasim Qazi Hameed Ullah Khurram Munawar Manj Abdul Waseem Naheed Khurram Munawar Manj Shah Abdul Aziz Maulana Qasim Maulana Abdul Malik Wazir Naheed , -9, Mufti Ibrar Sultan Ch. Manzoor Ahmed Sabir Hussain Awan Molvi Noor Naheed , 65, 5, -.6

21 The Richest and Poorest Ms in Each Province Balochistan Ms. Zobaida Jalal (-7, Kech-cum-Gwadar, Balochistan, -Q) was the richest M from Balochistan followed by Sardar Yaqoob Nasir (-6, Loralai, Balochistan, -N) and Sardar Yar Mohammad Rind (-67, Kachhi, Balochistan, -Q) for the year -. In -4 however, Sardar Mohammad Yaqoob became the richest M followed by Sardar Yar Mohammad Rind (-67, Kachhi, Balochistan, -Q) and Ms. Zobaida Jalal (-7, Kech-cum- Gwadar, Balochistan, -Q). In 4-5, Sardar Yaqoob Nasir (-6, Loralai, Balochistan, -N) and Sardar Yar Mohammad Rind (-67, Kachhi, Balochistan, -Q) remained the top two richest Ms, whereas Ms. Zobaida Jalal (-7, Kech-cum-Gwadar, Balochistan, -Q) was replaced by Pir Abdul Qadir Algillani. However, in 5- rd 6 Ms. Zobaida Jalal (-7, Kech-cum-Gwadar, Balochistan, -Q) regained her position as being the richest M, while Sardar Sardar Yaqoob Nasir (-6, Loralai, Balochistan, -N) and Sardar Yar Mohammad Rind (-67, Kachhi, Balochistan, -Q) remained at the top two positions. Interestingly, Mir Zafarullah Jamali (-66, Nasirabad, Balochistan, -Q), the former Prime Minister of Pakistan was the third poorest M from Balochistan in - following Mr. Mohammad Shirani (-64 Zhob cum Qila Sher, Balochistan, ), the poorest and Mr. Abdul Rauf Mengal (-69 Khuzdar, Balochistan, BNP-M), the second poorest M. In 4, however, Mir Zafarullah Jamali (-66, Nasirabad, Balochistan, -Q) was replaced by Mr. Abdul Rauf Mengal with net assets of Rs..47. Molvi Noor (-59 Quetta, Balochistan, ) with net assets of Rs..48 was the second poorest M. The assets of Mr. Mohammad Shirani remained unchanged at Rs... In 4-5, Ms. Imrana Khawar (-, Women Balochistan-III, ), Maulana Abdul Ghafoor Haidri (-68 Kalat-cum- Mastung, Balochistan, ) and Mr. Abdul Rauf Mengal were the poorest Ms, with Mr. Abdul Rauf Mengal being the poorest with net assets of Rs..75 and Ms. Imrana Khawar (-, Women Balochistan-III, ) being the third poorest with Rs..94 net assets. Mr. Mahmood Achakzai (-6, Killa Abdullah, Balochistan, PKMAP) with net assets of Rs.. was identified as the third poorest in 5-6 whereas Ms. Imrana Khawar (-, Women Balochistan-III, ) (Rs..4 ) and Molvi Noor (-59 Quetta, Balochistan, ) (Rs. ) as the second poorest and the poorest respectively. Table 8 The Richest Ms from Balochistan Rank Zobaida Jalal Sardar Yaqoob Sardar Yar Mohammad Rind Sardar Yaqoob Sardar Yar Mohammad Rind Zobaida Jalal Million 68.6 Million 59.6 Sardar Yaqoob Sardar Yar Mohammad Rind Pir Abdul Qadir Algillani Sardar Yaqoob Sardar Yar Mohammad Rind Zobaida Jalal Million 5.5

22 Table 9 The Poorest Ms from Balochistan Rank Mir Zafar Ullah Jamali Abdul Rauf Mengal Mohammad Sherani Abdul Rauf Mengal Molvi Noor Mohammad Sherani Imrana Khawar Maulana Abdul Ghafoor Haidri Abdul Rauf Mengal Million.6.7 Mahmood Achakzai Imrana Khawar Molvi Noor Million.4 FATA For the year -, Mr. Javaid Hussain Mian (-7 Independent), with net assets of 9.774, was the richest M from FATA, followed by Syed Ghazi Gulab Jamal (-9 Independent) and Mr. Naseem Afridi (-47 Independent). Year - 4 saw a slight change in the ranking with Mr. Noor ul Haq Qadri (-45 Independent) bagging the top slot with Rs assets, followed by Mr. Javaid Hussain Mian and Syed Ghazi Gulab Jamal. Mr. Noor ul Haq Qadri continued being ranked as the richest M consecutively for years: -4, 4-5 and 5-6 without any change in his net assets. Syed Ghazi Ghulab Jamal is ranked as the second richest M for the years 4-5 and 5-6 with his net assets being Rs..4 in 4-5 and increasing to Rs.49.5 in 5-6. However, Syed Javed Hussain Mian ranked as the second richest M in -4 was ranked as the third richest M in 4-5 and for the year 5-6 the third richest M was identified to be Mr. Munir Orakzai (-8 Independent). Maulvi Mohammad Sadiq (-4 Independent) was the poorest M from FATA in - with net liabilities worth Rs..4, followed by Maulana Nek Zaman (-4 Independent) with virtually no assets and no liabilities at all and Mr. Abdul Malek Wazir (-47 Independent) with assets worth Rs..65. For the year -4, Maulana Nek Zaman has the lowest assets at about Rs.. followed by Miraj ud Din (-4 Independent) and Mr. Abdul Malek Wazir. In the year 4-5 and 5-6 Maulana Abdul Malik Wazir remains to be the poorest M; with his net liabilities being Rs..9 in 4-5 and his net assets being Rs..9 in 5-6. Maulana Nek Zaman was identified as the second poorest M when he climbed a step ahead in 5-6 to be the third poorest M in 5-6 with net assets being Rs..5 and Rs..6 respectively. Maulana Miraj ud Din was identified as the third poorest in 4-5 with net assets of Rs..96. Maulvi Sadiq was the second poorest M in 5-6.

23 Table The Richest Ms from FATA Rank Syed Javed Hussain Mian Syed Ghazi Gulab Jamal Naseem Afridi Noor ul Haq Qadri Syed Javed Hussain Mian Syed Ghazi Gulab Jamal Noor ul Haq Qadri Syed Ghazi Gulab Jamal Syed Javed Hussain Mian Noor ul Haq Qadri Syed Ghazi Gulab Jamal Munir Orakzai Table The Poorest Ms from FATA Rank Abdul Malek Wazir Maulana Nek Zaman Maulvi Sadiq Abdul Malek Wazir Miraj ud Din Maulana Nek Zaman Miraj ud Din. Maulana Nek Zaman. Maulana Abdul Malik Wazir Maulana Nek Zaman Maulvi Sadiq Maulana Abdul Malik Wazir

24 NWFP Maulana Abdul Haleem (-, Kohistan, NWFP, ) was the richest M from NWFP for - as well as -4. In -, he was followed by Mr. Omar Ayub (-9, -Q) the current Minister of State for Finance at No. and his mother Ms. Zeb Gohar Ayub (-, Women NWFP-I, -Q) at No.. In 4 Ms. Zeb Gohar Ayub (-, Women NWFP-I, -Q) took the second slot followed by her son Mr. Omar Ayub as the third richest M from NWFP. Maulana Abdul Haleem (-, Kohistan, NWFP, ) was identified as the richest M in 4-5 with net assets of Rs , whereas he switched ranking with Ms. Zeb Gohar Ayub (-, Women NWFP-I, -Q) in 5-6 being the second richest M with net assets of Rs Ms. Zeb Gohar Ayub (-, Women NWFP-I, -Q) was ranked second in 4-5 with assets being Rs whereas she was ranked the richest M from NWFP in 5-6 with net assets increasing to Rs.... Amir Muqam (-, Shangla, NWFP, -Q) was identified as the third richest M in 4-5 with net assets of Rs. 7.4 and maintained his third position in 5-6 with net assets of Rs This is quite an improvement as he was the poorest M in the country in -. For the year - the M with lowest assets in NWFP was. Amir Muqam (-, Shangla, NWFP, -Q) with Rs.6. worth of liabilities, followed by Maulana Shah Abdul Aziz (-5, Karak, NWFP, ) with no assets and no liabilities and Maulana Amanullah (-7, Lakki Marwat, NWFP, ) with net assets worth.. In -4, the M with the lowest net assets was Maulana Qasim (-, Mardan II, NWFP, ) with Rs..6 assets followed by Mr. Pervaiz Masih (-9, ) and Maulana Shah Abdul Aziz (-5, Karak, NWFP, ). Maulana Qasim (-, Mardan II, NWFP, ) was identified as the poorest M in 4-5, whereas in 5-6 he was ranked as the third poorest M with his assets being Rs.7, in 4-5 and increasing to.44 in 5-6. Ms. Inayat Begum (-8, Women NWFP-VII, ) was ranked as the third poorest M in 4-5 and Maulana Shah Abdul Aziz (-5, Karak, NWFP, ) as the second poorest. In 5-6 Mufti Ibrar Sultan, (-4, Kohat, NWFP, ) was ranked as the second poorest and the poorest was Mr. Sabir Hussain Awan (-4, Peshawar-IV, NWFP, ) with net assets being Rs.5,. Table The Richest Ms from NWFP Rank Maulvi Abdul Haleem Omer Ayub Zeb Gohar Ayub Maulana Abdul Haleem Zeb Gohar Ayub Omer Ayub Maulana Abdul Haleem Zeb Gohar Ayub Amir Muqam Zeb Gohar Ayub 78.9 Maulana Abdul Haleem 7.4Amir Muqam

25 Table The Poorest Ms from NWFP Rank Maulana Amanullah Maulana Shah Abdul Aziz Amir Muqam Maulana Shah Abdul Aziz Pervaiz Masih Maulana Qasim Inayat Begum Maulana Shah Abdul Aziz Maulana Qasim , Maulana Qasim Mufti Ibrar Sultan Sabir Hussain Awan , Punjab Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, -Q) was the richest M from Punjab for both the years - and --4. For -, Ms. Ishrat Ashraf (-, Women Punjab-XXXI -N) was the second richest M followed by Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (-4, Kasur-III, Punjab, -Q), the current Foreign Minister of Pakistan. Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, -Q), the current Prime Minister, was the second richest M for the year - 4 followed by Mr. Aijaz Ahmed Chaudhry (-8 Mandi Bahauddin I, Punjab, -Q). Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (- 4, Kasur-III, Punjab, -Q) and Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, -Q) were ranked the richest and the second richest respectively in years 4-5 and 5-6 with minor changes in their net assets. Mr. Aijaz Ahmed Chaudhry (- 8 Mandi Bahauddin I, Punjab, -Q) was ranked as the third richest M with net assets of Rs..6 and was replaced in the year 5-6 by Mr. Jahangir Tareen (-95 Rahimyar IV, Punjab, -Q) with net assets being Rs Ms. Naheed (-9, Women Punjab-XX, ) is the poorest M from Punjab for both years while for the - Mr. Rais Munir Ahmed (-97 PPP) is the second poorest followed by Mr. Khurram Munawar Munj (-4, Sheikhupura-IV, Punjab, -Q) in - and for -4 it is Mr. Khurram Munawar Munj (-4, Sheikhupura-IV, Punjab, -Q) and Qazi Hameed Ullah (-96, ). For the year 4-5, Ms. Naheed (-9, Women Punjab-XX, ) was ranked as the poorest M with net liabilities of Rs Mr. Khurram Munawar Munj (-4, Sheikhupura-IV, Punjab, -Q) was ranked as the second poorest M with liabilities of Rs.5 and Dr. Rozina Tufail (-9 -Q) was ranked as the third poorest with net assets of Rs..45. Ms. Naheed (-9, Women Punjab-XX, ) was ranked the poorest in 5-6, when Chaudhry Manzoor Ahmed (-9 Kasur II, Punjab, ) (net liabilities Rs.. ) and Mr. Khurram Munawar Munj (-4, Sheikhupura-IV, Punjab, -Q) ranked the second poorest and third poorest respectively. 5

26 Table 4 The Richest Ms from Punjab Rank Ch. Nazir Ahmed Jatt Ishrat Ashraf Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri Ch. Nazir Ahmed Jatt Shaukat Aziz Ch. Aijaz Ahmed Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri Shaukat Aziz Ch. Aijaz Ahmed Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri Shaukat Aziz Jahangir Tareen Table 5 The Poorest Ms from Punjab Rank Khurram Munawar Manj Rais Munir Ahmed Naheed Qazi Hameed Ullah Khurram Munawar Manj Naheed Dr. Rozina Tufail Khurram Munawar Manj Naheed Khurram Munawar Manj Ch. Manzoor Ahmed Naheed , 65, -.6 6

27 Sindh Ms. Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani (-, Women, Sindh-V, ) was the richest M from Sindh in - with assets worth Rs..7 followed by Ms. Sherry Rehman (-9, Women Sindh-II, ) and Dr. Fehmida Mirza (-5, ). For the year -4 Dr. Fehmida Mirza was the richest M from Sindh followed by Ms. Sherry Rehman (-9, Women Sindh-II, ) and Syed Ghulam Mustafa Shah. In the year 4-5 the richest M was Sardar Khalid Ahmed Lund (-, Ghotki-I, Sindh, ) with net assets of Rs.., followed by Syed Zafar Ali Shah (- ) with net assets of Rs The third richest M was Ms. Sherry Rehman (-9, Women Sindh-II, ) (Rs ) in the year 4-5. Ms. Sherry Rehman (-9, Women Sindh-II, ), however, was ranked as the richest M in 5-6 with net assets of Rs.., followed by Makhdoom Amin Faheem (-8, Hyderabad-I, Sindh, ) with net assets Rs.. and the third richest M with net assets of Rs.68. being Sardar Khalid Ahmed Lund (-, Ghotki-I, Sindh, ). Mr. Nawab Mirza Advocate (-54, MQM) was the poorest M for the year -, with net liabilities of Rs..6 followed by Ms. Ruqia um Soomro (-, Women Sindh-III, ) and Ms. Khurshid Afghan (-, Women Sindh- XIV, -F). Mr. Abdul Waseem (-4, Karachi-V, Sindh, MQM) is the poorest M from Sindh followed by Mr. Mohammad Abid Ali Umang (-4, MQM) and Ms. Khurshid Afghan (-, Women Sindh-XIV, -F) for year -4. As for 4-5, the poorest M was Ms. Khurshid Afghan (-, Women Sindh-XIV, -F) with net assets of Rs..55 whereas she was ranked the third poorest in 5-6 with net assets being Rs..6. Ms. Shabina Talat (- 9, MQM) (net assets Rs..45 ) and Mr. Abdul Waseem (-4, Karachi-V, Sindh, MQM) were ranked the second and third poorest respectively in 4-5. Whereas, in 5-6, Mr. Abdul Waseem (-4, Karachi-V, Sindh, MQM) was ranked as the second poorest while the poorest was Ms. Ruqia um Soomro (-, Women Sindh-III, ) with net assets being Rs..9. Table 6 The Richest Ms from Sindh Rank Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani Sherry Rehman Dr. Fehmida Mirza 9 5, Dr. Fehmida Mirza Sherry Rehman Syed Ghulam Mustafa Shah Khalid Ahmed Lund Syed Zafar Ali Shah Sherry Rehman 9. Million Sherry Rehman Makhdoom Amin Fahim Khalid Ahmed Lund

28 Table 7 The Poorest Ms from Sindh Rank Khurshid Afghan Ruqia um Soomro Nawab Mirza Advocate Khurshid Afghan Abid Ali Abdul Waseem Shabina Talat. Khurshid Afghan Ruqia um Soomro Khurshid Afghan Abdul Waseem Ruqia um Soomro ICT There are only two Ms from ICT: Mian Mohammad Aslam (-48 Islamabad I, ) is the richer M followed by Syed Nayyer Hussain Bokhari ( 49, Islamabad II, ). Table 8 Ms from ICT Rank Mian Mohammad Aslam Syed Nayyer Hussain Bukhari Mian Mohammad Aslam Syed Nayyer Hussain Bukhari Mian Mohammad Aslam Syed Nayyer Hussain Bukhari Million Mian Mohammad Aslam Syed Nayyer Hussain Bukhari

29 The Richest Female Ms or -, Ms. Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani (-, Women, Sindh-V, ) was the richest female M, followed by FMs. Ishrat Ashraf (-, Women Punjab-XXXI -N) and Ms. Yasmeen Rehman (-97, Women Punjab-XXV, ). In -4, Ms. Ishrat Ashraf (-, Women Punjab-XXXI -N) was the richest female M followed by Ms Ms. Tehmina Daultana (-4, Women Punjab-XXXII, -N) and Ms. Sumera Malik (-69, Khushab-I, Punjab, -Q). In 4-5 Ms. Sumera Malik (-69, Khushab-I, Punjab, -Q) was identified as the richest female M, followed by Ms. Tanzeela Amir Cheema (-75, Women Punjab-III, -Q) and Ms. Belum Hasnain (-9,Women Punjab-XXI ). For 5-6, Ms. Sherry Rehman (-9, Women Sindh-II, ) was the richest female M, followed by Ms. Tahira Asif (-9, Women Punjab-XIX, -Q) and Ms. Tanzeela Amir Cheema (-75, Women Punjab-III, -Q). Table 9 The Richest Female Ms Rank Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani Ishrat Ashraf Yasmeen Rehman Ishrat Ashraf Tehmina Daultana Sumera Malik Sumera Malik Tanzeela Aamir Cheema Belum Husnain Sherry Rehman Tahira Asif Tanzeela Aamir Cheema

30 The Richest and Poorest Ms in each Party Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarian () Ms. Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani (-, Women, Sindh-V, ) topped the list for - followed by Ms. Yasmeen Rehman (-97, Women Punjab-XXV, ) and Ms. Belum Hasnain (-9, Women Punjab-XXI ). During - 4, Ms. Belum Hasnain (-9, Women Punjab-XXI ) became the richest M among the Ms followed by Mr. Aitzaz Ahsan (-4 Punjab) and Ms. Samina Khalid Ghurki (- Punjab) for -4. In 4-5, Mr. Ghulam Murtaza Satti (-5, Rawalpindi-I, Punjab, ) was ranked as the richest M in his party, followed by Ms. Belum Hasnain (-9,Women Punjab-XXI ) and Aitzaz Ahsan. In 5-6, Ms. Sherry Rehman (-9, Women Sindh-II, ), Mr. Ghulam Murtaza Satti (-5, Rawalpindi-I, Punjab, ) and Makhdoom Amin Faheem (-8, Hyderabad-I, Sindh, ) are ranked as the richest, second richest and third richest Ms respectively. Ms. Naheed (-9, Women Punjab-XX, ) is the poorest M among Ms followed by Ms. Ruqia um Soomro (-, Women Sindh-III, ) and Mr. Zummrad for the year - and the same trend continues for -4. Ms. Naheed (-9, Women Punjab-XX, ) and Ms. Ruqia um Soomro (-, Women Sindh-III, ) are ranked as the poorest and third poorest Ms respectively for both the years 4-5 and 5-6. Whereas, in 4-5 Zummrad is ranked as the second poorest and in 5-6 Chaudhry Manzoor Ahmed (-9 Kasur II, Punjab, ) is ranked as the second poorest. Table The Richest Ms from Rank Rubina Saadat Qaimkhani Yasmeen Rehman Belum Husnain Belum Husnain Aitzaz Ahsan Samina Khalid Ghurki Ghulam Murtaza Satti Belum Husnain Aitzaz Ahsan Sherry Rehman Ghulam Murtaza Satti Makhdoom Amin Faheem

31 Table The Poorest Ms from Rank Zummrad Ruqia am Soomro Naheed Zummrad Ruqia am Soomro Naheed Zummrad Ruqia am Soomro Naheed Ruqia am Soomro Ch. Manzoor Ahmed Naheed , -.6 Pakistan Muslim League-Quaid-e-Azam (-Q) Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, -Q) was the richest M among the -Q Ms followed by Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, -Q) and Mr. Aijaz Ahmed Chaudhry (-8 Mandi Bahauddin I, Punjab, -Q) for -4. In -, it was Chaudhry Nazir Ahmed Jatt (-67 Vehari-I, Punjab, -Q) followed by Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (-4, Kasur-III, Punjab, -Q) and Mr. Jahangir Tareen (-95 Rahimyar IV, Punjab, -Q). Mr. Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri (-4, Kasur-III, Punjab, -Q) and Mr. Shaukat Aziz (-59, Attock-III, Punjab, -Q) were identified to be the richest and second richest Ms in 4-5 and 5-6 respectively. Whereas, in 4-5 Mr. Aijaz Ahmed Chaudhry (-8 Mandi Bahauddin I, Punjab, -Q) was ranked as the third richest M. In 5-6 Mr. Jahangir Tareen (-95 Rahimyar IV, Punjab, -Q) was ranked as the third richest M. For -, Mr. Khurram Munawar Munj (-4, Sheikhupura-IV, Punjab, -Q) was ranked as the poorest M among -Q Ms followed by Ms. Riffat Amjad (-79, Women Punjab-VII, -Q) and Dr. Rozina Tufail. For -4, Dr. Rozina Tufail is the second poorest M from -Q followed by Ms. Onaza Ehsan (-88, Women Punjab-XVI, -Q). In 4-5, Mr. Khurram Munawar Munj (-4, Sheikhupura-IV, Punjab, -Q) was identified as the poorest M in his party, while Dr. Rozina Tufail was ranked as the second poorest and Sardar Shahjehan Yousaf (-, Mansehra-I, NWFP, - Q) was ranked as the third poorest. Mr. Khurram Munawar Munj (-4, Sheikhupura-IV, Punjab, -Q) was ranked as the poorest in 5-6, with Dr. Rozina Tufail being the second poorest and Sardar Shahjehan Yousaf (-, Mansehra-I, NWFP, -Q) being the third poorest.

32 Table The Richest Ms from -Q Rank Ch. Nazir Ahmed Jatt Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri Jahangir Tareen Ch. Nazir Ahmed Jatt Shaukat Aziz Ch. Aijaz Ahmed Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri Shaukat Aziz Ch. Aijaz Ahmed Khurshid Mehmud Kasuri Shaukat Aziz Jahangir Tareen Table The Poorest Ms from -Q Rank Onaza Ehsan Dr. Rozina Tufail Dr. Rozina Tufail Riffat Amjad Sardar Shahjehan Yousaf Dr. Rozina Tufail Sardar Shahjehan Yousaf Dr. Rozina Tufail Khurram Munawar Manj 4 Khurram Munawar Manj 4 Khurram Munawar Manj 4.5 Khurram Munawar Manj 4.6

33 Muttahida Majlis-e-Amal () Mian Mohammad Aslam (-48 Islamabad I, ) has been ranked as the richest M of for all four years. In -, he is followed by Maulana Abdul Haleem (-, Kohistan, NWFP, ) and Ms. Ambreen Naeem (-7, Women NWFP-VI, ). In -4, he is followed by Maulana Abdul Haleem (-, Kohistan, NWFP, ) and Qazi Hussain Ahmed (Qazi Hussain Ahmed (-5, Nowshera-I, NWFP, ). In the 4-5, Maulana Abdul Haleem (-, Kohistan, NWFP, ) was ranked second, when Maulana Syed Naseeb Ali Shah (-6, Bannu, NWFP, ) was ranked as the third richest M in. In 5-6, however, Sahabzada Abulkhair Zubair (-, Hyderabad-III, Sindh, ) was ranked the third richest. In -, Qazi Hameed Ullah ( 96 Punjab) was the poorest M among Ms followed by Maulana Shah Abdul Aziz (-5, Karak, NWFP, ) and Maulana Amanullah (-7, Lakki Marwat, NWFP, ). In -4, Qazi Hameed Ullah was followed by Maulana Qasim (-, Mardan II, NWFP, ) and Maulana Mohammad Sherani (-64, Zhob-cum-Killa-Sherani Sa, Balochistan, ). In 4-5, Maulana Qasim (-, Mardan II, NWFP, ) was ranked as the poorest M with Maulana Abdul Aziz being the second poorest M and Ms. Inayat Begum (-8, Women NWFP-VII, ) being the third poorest M. However, in 5-6, Molvi Noor (- 59 Quetta, Balochistan, ), Mr. Sabir Hussain Awan (-4, Peshawar-IV, NWFP, ) and Mufti Ibrar Sultan, (-4, Kohat, NWFP, ) were the poorest, second poorest and third poorest Ms of respectively. Table 4 The Richest Ms from Rank Mian Mohammad Aslam Maulana Abdul Haleem Ambreen Naeem Mian Mohammad Aslam Maulana Abdul Haleem Qazi Hussain Ahmed Mian Mohammad Aslam Maulana Abdul Haleem Naseeb Ali Shah Mian Mohammad Aslam Maulana Abdul Haleem Shahibzada Abulkhair Zubair