Timor- Leste s Troubled Waters Asia Rising
|
|
- Valerie Bryant
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Timor- Leste s Troubled Waters Asia Rising Professor Welcome to Asia Rising, the podcast of La Trobe Asia where we discuss the news, events and general happenings of Asian States and Societies. I'm your host, Executive Director of La Trobe Asia. Australia and East Timor have a curious relationship, in 1999 Australia led the International Peace Keeping Operation which played a crucial role in stabilising what was then a part of Indonesia that had been thrown into turmoil as the newly democratic country tried to work out just what to do with this former Portuguese Colony that it had annexed in Yet Australia was one of the few countries that had recognised Indonesia's claims to Timor and historically taken a decidedly realpolitik approach to its populist Northern neighbour. In recent years tensions in the relationship have resurfaced once again. In 2012, Timorese representatives accused Australia of bugging government buildings to gain an unfair advantage in their negotiations about their maritime boundary. What began as odd became almost farcical as the Australian Government refused to acknowledge these claims and then in 2013, there followed an ASIO raid on the Canberra offices of a member of Timor's legal team as well of the residents of an ASIS agent. Joining me to help shed light on the problems of one of the world's newest, smallest and poorest countries and its large rich neighbour is Dr Beck Strating. Beck is a lecturer in the Department of Politics and Philosophy at La Trobe University and a leading authority on East Timor's foreign relations. Welcome to the program Bec. Dr Beck Strating Thank you for having me. Well, let's start with this curious exchange, in which Australia has been more coy than the heroine of a Victorian novel, while the Timorese are fulminating quite publicly. What's the issue here and what's at stake in this really peculiar exchange? Talking specifically about the spying claims, this is quite a convenient set of events for Timor. So Timor- Leste seems to present an attitude of being genuinely saddened or genuinely upset by the fact that Australia spied on them during the negotiations for the CMATS Treaty. Now the CMATS Treaty was negotiated largely across 2004 and 2005, between Australia and Timor- Leste and it was a protracted set of negotiation. It wasn't until 2012 when Xanana Gusmao, the then Prime Minister of Timor- Leste found out that this bugging had happened, but there was almost suspicion among the negotiators, among Timor representatives in 2004, that Australia was keeping tabs on their negotiations. Just to go back to before 2012, in the public sphere there were already comments by Timorese leaders that they were not happy with the CMATS Treaty, the Treaty wasn't fair, that Australia was stealing Timor's resources, this is a narrative that has continued for a long period of time and it was gaining kind of traction. So you could kind of interpret that these spying allegations were quite convenient for the Timorese leadership, who were probably already looking for a way of getting out of that CMATS Treaty anyway.
2 So one of the central issues for Timor with the maritime boundaries, is that Australia withdrew from the relevant international legal instruments that arbitrate maritime boundary disputes. They did that quite deliberately, clearly in reference to this issue with Timor- Leste, so Timor cannot take Australia to the ICJ on the issue of permanent maritime boundaries because Australia has withdrawn. So the spying allegations actually allow Timor to take this issue to court, not to do with the actual limitation of the boundaries, but to do with the issues around good faith and that this compromised Timor's position when it was negotiating the CMATS. So this is their kind of Get Out Of Jail card. Yeah. So let's take a step back just for people who are not familiar with it, because it's a bit of a murky or complex issue, so in essence you've got a disagreement between Australia and Timor as to exactly where to draw the line and sea, if that metaphor holds, and the consequences that the follow from that in terms of exploiting the natural resources. That's right. Indonesia annexed Timor in the late 1975, but even before that Indonesia and Australia were trying to draw up maritime boundaries. So Portugal said, "We don't want to be a part of that," and this created a gap. Portugal was administrating East Timor and so Indonesia and Australia were only able to create boundaries up to the boundaries of East Timor effectively. Yes, because Timor was a colony of the Portuguese and very few countries apart from Australia, the US and a handful of others recognised Indonesia, so the rest of the international community were dealing with Portugal but Portugal says we're not dealing with UNCLOS. And this is a binding treaty and it sits between Indonesia and Australia but there's a gap in that line because that reflects Timor's territory. And this line is a lot closer to Indonesia than what it is to Australia. If we then fast forward, the legal ground shifts, when Timor's sovereign, how does Australia then approach this question of where this line should be drawn? The history really matters because it informs the way that Timor- Leste and Australia have to deal with this issue. It's no good to say, "Alright well now Timor's independent, let's just clear the slate and start from scratch." Australia doesn't accept that. Indonesia and Australia created the Timor Gap Treaty which basically created a joint area for exploiting the resources. Following the 1999 Independence Referendum, Timor- Leste went through a period of state building and it was well acknowledged that Timor's viability relied pretty much solely on oil and gas. Like its economic viability, it's capacity to be an independent
3 sovereign state relies significantly on getting access to those resources and exploiting them quickly. This resulted in the Timor Sea Treaty which was actually signed on the day that Timor- Leste became independent. The Timor Sea Treaty was based on the terms of the Timor Gap Treaty between Indonesia and Australia and that's become a real bone of contention. Some of the advocates of Timor- Leste's position want that clean slate. They want to go "These lines don't exist." So is that what's lying behind this gambit around the espionage. So we'll start from scratch and here's a way we can go to the courts and say that whole thing is a breach of the fundamental principle so we're not negotiating in good faith, let's chuck it out and let's start from scratch? Is that where we enter the public diplomacy, if you like, of publicly outraged East Timor and Australia who is putting it's hand in its pocket, looking at the floor and saying, "Nothing to see here governor?" The real issue I think in terms of the outrage comes from the fact that there was the Timor Sea Treaty in 2002, which Australia refused to ratify unless Timor- Leste agreed to what's called 'a unitisation' of a particular area, a particular oil field called The Greater Sunrise Field. Estimated to be worth about $40 Billion and this is the real issue at the moment. That's the total sort of if you sucked it all out? Yeah, I think so. So Australia refused to ratify the Timor Sea Treaty until Timor- Leste agreed to a unitisation of the Greater Sunrise Field that put approximately 80% of the Greater Sunrise Field in Australia's Territory and around 20% in the shared area. Like this is a realist approach, this is a hard- core realist approach to this issue in my opinion. Plain piece of paper the Timorese want, you've got the situation set up in which the deal has been struck that very clearly, economically at any rate is in Australia's advantage. The Timorese are trying to say, 'Let's reset the clock'. If you could get inside each sides' negotiators, what do they want, what's the ideal outcome in the real world? What is it that you reckon they'd be happy to settle on? I'm really glad that you asked this question because just going back to the terms of the CMATS Treaty that was eventually signed. Australia, while they claimed 80% and this unitisation was signed, they ultimately agreed that they would share the revenue of the Greater Sunrise Field 50/50, but they left open the question of how the downstream revenues would be exploited. Timor- Leste wanted a pipeline to go to the South Coast in order to develop its petro- chemical industry. To the South Coast of Timor? Yes. And at the moment Timor- Leste's government has been pushing a project called the Tasi
4 Mane Project which is about developing an oil refinery on the South Coast and there's a lot of criticism from civil society organisations as well as Australia on whether or not they're efficient, whether or not they're economical, whether they represent good value and those sorts of issues. And so while they negotiated this CMATS and it was split 50/50 despite the fact that both sides had signed a unitisation that said that Australia has effectively 80% of the territory there's still been this on- going issue around this pipeline. Now when I went to Timor recently, I was trying to figure out in the minds of Timor- Leste's leaders, were they really trying to prosecute the case that they should be able to develop that pipeline to the South Coast, in order to industrialise and develop. You know they talk about sustainable development as being a crucial aspect of Timor- Leste avoiding the resource curse. Or is the priority settling permanent maritime boundaries? If Timor- Leste got the pipeline, would they been prepared, as they have in the past, to put a moratorium on setting boundaries? A classic negotiating tactic when you say, "We want all of this," where really you want less of that and you want your refinery and that's where you're prepared to give grounds to get what you want. I hypothesize that the permanent maritime boundaries and the issues around sovereignty and how Timor- Leste was presenting sovereignty, I thought that was a way of perhaps pressuring Australia on the issue of the pipeline. I thought that would be the key issue and that's what they were really focusing on and I was wrong. From my interviews it is all about sovereignty. I had an interview with the foreign minister who said quite directly, "The pipeline issue was a real issue around 2010 and and now it's all about permanent maritime boundaries." And the public discourse, the narrative sees maritime boundaries as being as important as territory as land. The way that Timor- Leste concedes or constitutes of its sovereignty is very much linked to the sea and it's linked to the oil reserve, but it's also linked to things like the exclusive economic zone and fishing and just the fact that they want these boundaries to be settled. But the other issue is that they don't want the boundaries just settled. There's a sub- claim to that, and that is, "We have the right to settle permanent maritime boundaries according to how we see permanent maritime boundaries, as including all of the Greater Sunrise Fields. Given that shift, I mean is this purely like an economic story, we want a permanent boundary there that maximises our return, is there a political symbolic component to this which is actually more important? Yeah. What's your sense of? My sense is that this is not about oil anymore. This is much more about identity and recognition. This has always been a theme but it's intensified over time, it intensified particularly after Xanana
5 Gusmao came into power I think, because I've been tracing the public discourses over time. This is an ongoing struggle for recognition. This is positioned by Timorese leaders and its advocates as being a continuation of the Independence Movement. This time the occupier is Australia and in fact, I had it put to me by one advocate that Australia is a "Longer term occupier of Timorese Territory than Indonesia". And you can imagine that Australia probably gets a little bit upset with this kinds of characterisations. It's interesting to say that the dispute is now being framed very much in political symbolic identity terms, because if you think, how's this going to end, that's going to make it much harder? As in any negotiation if it's just about resources, if it's just about bucks, you can divide that up and you may not get exactly what you want. But when it's about this is who we are, this is about what we are: that becomes really hard. So gazing into your crystal ball which is polished in front of you, how do you think this is going to end? You are right about the issues of sovereignty and rights. It's really hard once a state starts talking about rights and entitlements in the way Timor- Leste are, it's really hard to them compromise on those. At the moment Timor has one strategy and that is to win. It's informed by the Independence Movement and the people of Timor- Leste have struggled against an occupier before. Walk into the Resistance Museum in Dili and on the wall is, "To resist is to win." You know the name of Xanana Gusmao's biography is la lutte continue and it means The Struggle Continues and these phrases continue on to kind of inform decision making and to inform National Identity, issues to do with struggle and resistance and heroism. And so these themes linger and Timor has been trying to mitigate its particular vulnerability when it comes to the negotiations which is around time. Australia has a stronger negotiating position because, it can wait a long time. Timor cannot wait a long time. The oil reserves that are currently being exploited, they're expected to run out in 2020, one of the civil society organisations that's well respected La'o Hamutuk, has estimated that the petroleum fund that Timor- Leste has set up might only last five to eight years after that and Timor- Leste doesn't have a diversified economy. It really does rely significantly on oil. So while Timor says, "We've been through this struggle before", my question is well, "Can you afford to do that? And it seems like the CMATS negotiation, which I should point out was negotiated by Jose Ramos- Horta who tends to take a more pragmatic approach to things. He thinks negotiation is possible, but it shifted from this pragmatic realist approach where you can compromise, to an idealistic approach which suggests that we are right, therefore we will win. From the research I've conducted I don't think there's a Plan B, so there's a public campaign that continues, there's the International Court Cases that continue, there's attempts to involve the broader international community to pressure Australia. But I did a presentation on this at one of the universities and I tried to put this issue in the context of Australia's broader foreign policy and it's not looking really good at the moment when it comes to being a good international citizen. So in terms of gazing into my crystal ball, I don't want to make any kind of outlandish predictions, but I suspect that Timor will be attempting to get what it wants through public diplomacy, through activism, through the courts, it's trying to invalidate the CMATS Treaty. We'll really have to see whether or not it's successful in that court case, but my feeling is, Australia is not going to budge on this issue. It hasn't since 1972 and this is bi- partisan support.
6 Backed by the big end of town in Melbourne and Sydney. Yeah I remember talking to an Attorney General's negotiator and he said, without question, the hardest people they ever have to deal with in terms of negotiation are the Timorese. Toughest of nuts, he said. Well that's all the time we have, East Timor is not only Asia's newest state, but it's among its most interesting. It's been a subject of a few episodes of Asia Rising and we look forward to having you back on the program to have another look of how this fares and East Timor and the International Stage more generally. Thank you for having me. You've been listening to Asia Rising, a podcast of La Trobe Asia. If you like this podcast you can subscribe to Asia Rising on itunes or Soundcloud. And while you're there read the rating and review and spread the word. Thanks for listening.
Teaching in Timor Leste
Teaching in Timor Leste https://maps.google.com.au/maps?output=classic&dg=brw Google map for a closer look at Timor Leste https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zq1d5ifzin0 Sunrise program back in 2012 about
More informationMatt Smith That was a very truncated version of your extensive resume. How well did I do there?
Asia Rising Australian Foreign Policy and Asia Welcome to Asia Rising, the podcast from La Trobe Asia where we discuss the news, views and general happenings of Asian states and societies. I'm your host.
More informationBrexit Brits Abroad Podcast Episode 20: WHAT DOES THE DRAFT WITHDRAWAL AGREEMENT MEAN FOR UK CITIZENS LIVING IN THE EU27?
Brexit Brits Abroad Podcast Episode 20: WHAT DOES THE DRAFT WITHDRAWAL AGREEMENT MEAN FOR UK CITIZENS LIVING IN THE EU27? First broadcast 23 rd March 2018 About the episode Wondering what the draft withdrawal
More informationTwice Around Podcast Episode #2 Is the American Dream Dead? Transcript
Twice Around Podcast Episode #2 Is the American Dream Dead? Transcript Female: [00:00:30] Female: I'd say definitely freedom. To me, that's the American Dream. I don't know. I mean, I never really wanted
More informationProject ZION Podcast: Extra Shot Episode 24 Tom Morain
Project ZION Podcast: Extra Shot Episode 24 Tom Morain Hello, my name is Tom Morain, and for the purposes of this little recording, I think I would like to describe myself as a recovering seeker. I was
More informationASIA RISING. Excavations in Nepal uncovering the birthplace of Buddha. La Trobe Asia. Strengthening engagement and partnerships in Asia
Issue No.4 2017 ASIA RISING Strengthening engagement and partnerships in Asia Excavations in Nepal uncovering the birthplace of Buddha latrobe.edu.au/asia La Trobe Asia CONTENTS Message from the Executive
More informationAsia Rising Podcast India's Sedition Controversy
Asia Rising Podcast India's Sedition Controversy Professor Welcome to Asia Rising, a podcast of La Trobe Asia where we discuss the news, events and general happenings of Asian states and societies. I'm
More informationActuaries Institute Podcast Transcript Ethics Beyond Human Behaviour
Date: 17 August 2018 Interviewer: Anthony Tockar Guest: Tiberio Caetano Duration: 23:00min Anthony: Hello and welcome to your Actuaries Institute podcast. I'm Anthony Tockar, Director at Verge Labs and
More informationMINISTER FOR FOREIGN AFFAIRS STEPHEN SMITH, MP. Transcript: Interview with Linda Mottram, Radio Australia, ABC. 11 March 2010
MINISTER FOR FOREIGN AFFAIRS STEPHEN SMITH, MP Transcript: Interview with Linda Mottram, Radio Australia, ABC TOPIC: Australia-Indonesia relationship 11 March 2010 LINDA MOTTRAM: It seems the conclusion
More informationBARRY JONES. HOWARD: I think there's a lot in the criticism, the sort of thing that you get from Germaine Greer and from - not from Barry Humphries
BARRY JONES HOWARD: I think there's a lot in the criticism, the sort of thing that you get from Germaine Greer and from - not from Barry Humphries but from Clive James, say that in the 1950s there was
More informationChampions for Social Good Podcast
Champions for Social Good Podcast Accelerating Performance for Social Good with Root Cause Founder Andrew Wolk Jamie Serino: Hello, and welcome to the Champions for Social Good Podcast, the podcast for
More informationI got a right! By Tim Sprod
I got a right! By Tim Sprod I got a right! Sam and Pete stopped. The voice from over the fence bellowed so loudly that they just stood there and looked at each other, intrigued. What's that all about?
More informationBRETT: Yes. HOWARD: And women often felt excluded and of course at that time there were a much smaller number of women in the paid work force.
JUDITH BRETT HOWARD: Bob Menzies' most famous speech, I guess, is not a speech, it's the Forgotten People broadcasts. To what extent was the Forgotten People broadcast as much a plea by him not to be forgotten
More informationTwiceAround Podcast Episode 7: What Are Our Biases Costing Us? Transcript
TwiceAround Podcast Episode 7: What Are Our Biases Costing Us? Transcript Speaker 1: Speaker 2: Speaker 3: Speaker 4: [00:00:30] Speaker 5: Speaker 6: Speaker 7: Speaker 8: When I hear the word "bias,"
More informationSenator Fielding on ABC TV "Is Global Warming a Myth?"
Senator Fielding on ABC TV "Is Global Warming a Myth?" Australian Broadcasting Corporation Broadcast: 14/06/2009 Reporter: Barrie Cassidy Family First Senator, Stephen Fielding, joins Insiders to discuss
More informationLife as a Woman in the Context of Islam
Part 2 of 2: How to Build Relationships with Muslims with Darrell L. Bock and Miriam Release Date: June 2013 There's another dimension of what you raised and I want to come back to in a second as well
More informationChampions for Social Good Podcast
Champions for Social Good Podcast Empowering Women & Girls with Storytelling: A Conversation with Sharon D Agostino, Founder of Say It Forward Jamie: Hello, and welcome to the Champions for Social Good
More informationCHARLES ARES (part 2)
An Oral History Interview with CHARLES ARES (part 2) Tucson, Arizona conducted by Julie Ferdon June 9, 1998 The Morris K. Udall Oral History Project Univeristy of Arizona Library, Special Collections 8
More informationNational Directorate for Environment Democratic Republic of Timor-Leste. La o Hamutuk
La o Hamutuk Timor-Leste Institute for Development Monitoring and Analysis I/1a Rua Mozambique, Farol, Dili, Timor-Leste Tel: +670 332 5013 email: info@laohamutuk.org website: www.laohamutuk.org Translated
More informationDesigning for Humanity Episode 4: A professional catastrophizer brings creativity to crises, with Gabby Almon
Designing for Humanity Episode 4: A professional catastrophizer brings creativity to crises, with Gabby Almon Gabriele Almon: [00:00:00] Communicating stories well and understanding how to inspire people
More informationA Mind Under Government Wayne Matthews Nov. 11, 2017
A Mind Under Government Wayne Matthews Nov. 11, 2017 We can see that the Thunders are picking up around the world, and it's coming to the conclusion that the world is not ready for what is coming, really,
More informationMOONSHOT THINKING. The biggest problem in modern society: we no longer have the foolish optimism we had in the past.
MOONSHOT THINKING MOONSHOT THINKING Dear friend, I want to share some personal ideas on moonshot thinking -- why we must always shoot for the moon, and attempt the "impossible" and the crazy/foolish ideas
More informationJoint Presser with President Mahmoud Abbas. delivered 10 January 2008, Muqata, Ramallah
George W. Bush Joint Presser with President Mahmoud Abbas delivered 10 January 2008, Muqata, Ramallah President Abbas: [As translated.] Your Excellency, President George Bush, President of the United States
More informationMessianism and Messianic Jews
Part 2 of 2: What Christians Should Appreciate About Messianic Judaism with Release Date: December 2015 Okay. Now you've talked a little bit about, we ve talked about the existence of the synagoguae and
More informationAustralian Institute of International Affairs
The Following was a speech delivered during the Australian Foreign Policy session at the AIIA 2014 National Conference, 27 October 2014 at the Hyatt Hotel Canberra. AIIA National President, John McCarthy
More informationWise, Foolish, Evil Person John Ortberg & Dr. Henry Cloud
Menlo Church 950 Santa Cruz Avenue, Menlo Park, CA 94025 650-323-8600 Series: This Is Us May 7, 2017 Wise, Foolish, Evil Person John Ortberg & Dr. Henry Cloud John Ortberg: I want to say hi to everybody
More informationLearning and Discerning: A Conversation About Education and the Spirit
Learning and Discerning: A Conversation About Education and the Spirit by Rabbi Patricia Karlin-Neumann, Sarah Simone, and Virgil Zanders University Public Worship Stanford Memorial Church February 23,
More informationPage 1 of 6. Policy 360 Episode 76 Sari Kaufman - Transcript
Policy 360 Episode 76 Sari Kaufman - Transcript Hello and welcome to Policy 360. I'm your host this time, Gunther Peck. I'm a faculty member at the Sanford School of Public Policy at Duke University, and
More informationWe'll be right back to It's Supernatural.
On It's Supernatural: Julie True is releasing the sounds of heaven through the music that God gives her. When people hear Julie's music, they experience peace and rest. The supernatural becomes normal,
More informationMITOCW ocw f99-lec19_300k
MITOCW ocw-18.06-f99-lec19_300k OK, this is the second lecture on determinants. There are only three. With determinants it's a fascinating, small topic inside linear algebra. Used to be determinants were
More informationANDREW MARR SHOW 30 TH SEPTEMBER 2018 TOM WATSON
1 ANDREW MARR SHOW 30 TH SEPTEMBER 2018 TOM WATSON AM: Welcome, Tom Watson. TW: And welcome to the west midlands, Andrew. AM: Thank you very much indeed. Can I ask you about the crucial question, I suppose,
More informationHOWARD: And do you remember what your father had to say about Bob Menzies, what sort of man he was?
DOUG ANTHONY ANTHONY: It goes back in 1937, really. That's when I first went to Canberra with my parents who - father who got elected and we lived at the Kurrajong Hotel and my main playground was the
More informationCHINA IN THE WORLD PODCAST. Host: Paul Haenle Guest: C. Raja Mohan
CHINA IN THE WORLD PODCAST Host: Paul Haenle Guest: C. Raja Mohan Episode 85: India Finds Its Place in a Trump World Order April 28, 2017 Haenle: My colleagues and I at the Carnegie Tsinghua Center had
More informationAl-Arabiya Television Interview With Hisham Melhem. delivered 26 January 2009
Barack Obama Al-Arabiya Television Interview With Hisham Melhem delivered 26 January 2009 AUTHENTICITY CERTIFIED: Text version below transcribed directly from audio Mr. Melhem: Mr. President, thank you
More information[music] SID: Well that begs the question, does God want all of us rich?
1 Is there a supernatural dimension, a world beyond the one we know? Is there life after death? Do angels exist? Can our dreams contain messages from Heaven? Can we tap into ancient secrets of the supernatural?
More informationSummer of Peace 2013 Global Attunement for Peace 2 (Sep. 21)
Summer of Peace 2013 Global Attunement for Peace 2 (Sep. 21) [0:00:00] Welcome friends to this Global Attunement for Peace. My name is David Nicol. I'm the Director of the Gaiafield Project. I'm delighted
More informationNewt Gingrich Calls the Show May 19, 2011
Newt Gingrich Calls the Show May 19, 2011 BEGIN TRANSCRIPT RUSH: We welcome back to the EIB Network Newt Gingrich, who joins us on the phone from Iowa. Hello, Newt. How are you today? GINGRICH: I'm doing
More informationMichael Bullen. 5:31pm. Okay. So thanks Paul. Look I'm not going to go through the spiel I went through at the public enquiry meeting.
Council: Delegate: Michael Bullen. Venue: Date: February 16 Time: 5:31pm 5 Okay. So thanks Paul. Look I'm not going to go through the spiel I went through at the public enquiry meeting. No, I'm sure you've
More informationThe Power of Your Words And Thoughts pg1
pg1 We have heard at one time or another this phrase be careful what you say in the Bible this phrase is be careful what you say the walls have ears To me the meaning is everything is listening. The Bible
More informationMeredith Brock: It can be applied to any season, so I'm excited to hear from your cute little 23- year-old self, Ash. I can't wait.
Hi, friends. Welcome to the Proverbs 31 Ministries Podcast, where we share biblical truth for any girl in any season. I'm your host, Meredith Brock, and I am here with my co-host, Kaley Olson. Hey, Meredith.
More informationMike Zissler Q & A. Okay, let's look at those one at a time. In terms of financials, what happened?
Mike Zissler Q & A Mike Zissler, I suppose the beginning is a good place to start. Take us back, if you would, to the 2014 API annual general meeting. What was the mood and what were the motions that were
More informationIs Japan Still a Pacifist Society? Asia Rising podcast
Is Japan Still a Pacifist Society? Asia Rising podcast Welcome to Asia Rising, the podcast of La Trobe Asia where we examine the news, views and general happenings of Asian States and Societies. I'm your
More information[Male voice] The following is a presentation of Artisan Church in Rochester, New York.
The Adolescent God December 30, 2018 Pastor Scott Austin artisanchurch.com [Music Intro] [Male voice] The following is a presentation of Artisan Church in Rochester, New York. [Voice of Pastor Scott] So
More informationWellnessCast Conversation with Professor Ron Tyler, Associate Professor and Director of the Criminal Defense Clinic at Stanford Law School
WellnessCast Conversation with Professor Ron Tyler, Associate Professor and Director of the Criminal Defense Clinic at Stanford Law School Musical Opening: So ring the bells that still can ring. Forget
More informationEpisode 90: The Cost of A Life: Peter Singer on Ending World Poverty
Published on Up Close (https://upclose.unimelb.edu.au) Episode 90: The Cost of A Life: Peter Singer on Ending World Poverty The Cost of A Life: Peter Singer on Ending World Poverty VOICEOVER Welcome to
More informationLiving the Christian Life as a Cultural Minority
Part 1 of 2: Generosity, Truth and Beauty in Spiritual Conversations with Release Date: September 2015 Well welcome and I want to thank you all for coming out on Monday night to hear a discussion about
More informationWhat was the significance of the WW2 conferences?
What was the significance of the WW2 conferences? Look at the this photograph carefully and analyse the following: Body Language Facial expressions Mood of the conference A New World Order: Following WW2,
More informationConference: Transforming service A conference for educators and leaders in Service Learning
Conference: Transforming service A conference for educators and leaders in Service Learning Title The Year of Mercy and Transformative Community Engagement Abstract Pope Francis challenges us in the Year
More informationLehrer: No breakthrough yet on the Turkish bases situation; is that right?
2/20/2003 Donald Rumsfeld Interview The NewsHour - PBS http://www.defenselink.mil/transcripts/transcript.aspx?transcriptid=1938 Lehrer: And now to the Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld. Mr. Secretary,
More informationHello and welcome to the CPA Australia podcast, your weekly source for business, leadership and Public Practice accounting information.
Voice over: Hello and welcome to the CPA Australia podcast, your weekly source for business, leadership and Public Practice accounting information. Welcome. My name is Kimberly White. I am conference producer
More informationTwenty Years of the OECD s Anti-Corruption Campaign Nicola Bonucci
TRACE International Podcast Twenty Years of the OECD s Nicola Bonucci [00:00:07] Welcome back to the podcast, Bribe, Swindle or Steal. I'm Alexandra Wrage, and we're recording today's interview in person
More informationRamsey media interview - May 1, 1997
Ramsey media interview - May 1, 1997 JOHN RAMSEY: We are pleased to be here this morning. You've been anxious to meet us for some time, and I can tell you why it's taken us so long. We felt there was really
More informationEpisode 109: I m Attracted to the Same Sex, What Do I Do? (with Sam Allberry) February 12, 2018
Episode 109: I m Attracted to the Same Sex, What Do I Do? (with Sam Allberry) February 12, 2018 With me today is Sam Allberry. Sam is an editor for The Gospel Coalition, a global speaker for Ravi Zacharias
More informationPodcast 06: Joe Gauld: Unique Potential, Destiny, and Parents
Podcast 06: Unique Potential, Destiny, and Parents Hello, today's interview is with Joe Gauld, founder of the Hyde School. I've known Joe for 29 years and I'm very excited to be talking with him today.
More informationNeutrality and Narrative Mediation. Sara Cobb
Neutrality and Narrative Mediation Sara Cobb You're probably aware by now that I've got a bit of thing about neutrality and impartiality. Well, if you want to find out what a narrative mediator thinks
More informationIra Flatow: I don't think they know very much about what scientists actually do, how they conduct experiments, or the whole scientific process.
After the Fact Scientists at Work: Ira Flatow Talks Science Originally aired Aug. 24, 2018 Total runtime: 00:12:58 TRANSCRIPT Dan LeDuc, host: This is After the Fact from The Pew Charitable Trusts. I m
More informationPastor's Notes. Hello
Pastor's Notes Hello We're going to look at an aspect of mercy that promises to bring freedom to every corner of your life. It's the truth that mercy forgives. God's mercy brings forgiveness into your
More informationLeaders and Entrepreneurs - Elizabeth Plunkett Buttimer, President of Bowden Manufacturing
Leaders and Entrepreneurs - Elizabeth Plunkett Buttimer, President of Bowden Manufacturing An Interview by Marie J. Kane Bowden Manufacturing is a family run business over 50 years old who manufacture
More informationYeah. OK, OK, resistance may be that you're exactly what God is calling you to do. Yeah.
I'm curious how many of you are looking for some divine direction in your life, maybe some guidance about what's coming up. Maybe some of you, maybe I'm the only one, but maybe some of you are feeling
More informationEpisode 31: Boys Need a Culture of Excellence
THE SCOTS COLLEGE Episode 31: Boys Need a Culture of Excellence Brave Hearts Bold Minds Episode Transcript Hello and welcome to the Brave Hearts Bold Minds podcast: Growing Fine Young Men. I m Leigh Hatcher.
More informationThe Man in the Mirror. Integrity: What s the Price?
The Man in the Mirror Solving the 24 Problems Men Face Integrity: What s the Price? Unedited Transcript Luke 16:10-12, Job 2:3, 42:12 Good morning, men! Welcome to Man in the Mirror Men's Bible Study,
More information3M Transcript for the following interview: Ep-18-The STEM Struggle
3M Transcript for the following interview: Ep-18-The STEM Struggle Mark Reggers (R) Jayshree Seth (S) Introduction: The 3M Science of Safety podcast is a free publication. The information presented in
More informationINTERVIEW WITH JOSH FLEMISTER AND CHRISTINA JANUARY 17, 2001
INTERVIEW WITH JOSH FLEMISTER AND CHRISTINA JANUARY 17, 2001 BILL: Josh, I appreciate you coming in. I know we talked the other night and I was gonna try and get with you the other night.... JOSH: Yeah,
More informationANDREW MARR SHOW 25 TH FEBRUARY 2018 KEIR STARMER
1 ANDREW MARR SHOW 25 TH FEBRUARY 2018 AM: Can I ask first of all what the Labour position is on a customs union? KS: Well, we ve long championed being in a customs union with the EU and the benefits of
More informationTrade Defence and China: Taking a Careful Decision
European Commission Speech [Check against delivery] Trade Defence and China: Taking a Careful Decision 17 March 2016 Cecilia Malmström, Commissioner for Trade European Commission Trade defence Conference,
More informationPage 1 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA Page 1 STATE OF ALASKA, Plaintiff, vs. ELI LILLY AND COMPANY, Defendant. Case No. 3AN-06-05630 CI VOLUME 18 TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS March 26, 2008 - Pages
More informationA lack of worth Presenter: Susanne Gibson
A lack of self-worth: first person A lack of worth Presenter: Susanne Gibson I'm not worth anything, you know, I'm damaged goods. Every negative that you can think of, I will have felt it about myself
More informationPastor's Notes. Hello
Pastor's Notes Hello We're going to talk a little bit about an application of God's love this week. Since I have been pastor here people have come to me and said, "We don't want to be a mega church we
More informationIt s Supernatural. SID: ZONA: SID: ZONA: SID: ZONA:
1 Is there a supernatural dimension, a world beyond the one we know? Is there life after death? Do angels exist? Can our dreams contain messages from Heaven? Can we tap into ancient secrets of the supernatural?
More informationGeointeresting Podcast Transcript Episode 8: Jack O Connor, author of "NPIC: Seeing the Secrets and Growing the Leaders" Jan 15, 2016
Geointeresting Podcast Transcript Episode 8: Jack O Connor, author of "NPIC: Seeing the Secrets and Growing the Leaders" Jan 15, 2016 Welcome to Geointeresting, presented by the National Geospatial-Intelligence
More informationTrust in God, Pt. 1 Wayne Matthews February 14, Welcome to this Sabbath, brethren.
! Welcome to this Sabbath, brethren. Wayne Matthews February 14, 2015 You often hear the term, "I trust God." There are many people who believe and say they trust in God. As we live during this last (final)
More informationAn Alternative to Risk Management for Information and Software Security Transcript
An Alternative to Risk Management for Information and Software Security Transcript Part 1: Why Risk Management Is a Poor Foundation for Security Julia Allen: Welcome to CERT's Podcast Series: Security
More informationis Jack Bass. The transcriber is Susan Hathaway. Ws- Sy'i/ts
Interview number A-0165 in the Southern Oral History Program Collection (#4007) at The Southern Historical Collection, The Louis Round Wilson Special Collections Library, UNC-Chapel Hill. This is an interview
More informationWeek 3 - Empathic Listening: Loving the Stranger Brief summary of readings
Week 3 - Empathic Listening: Loving the Stranger The theme or focus for this week is empathic listening - loving the stranger. It s important to understand the feelings and needs of the other (both those
More information/10/2007, In the matter of Theodore Smith Associated Reporters Int'l., Inc. Page 1419
1 2 THE STATE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT THE UNIVERSITY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK 3 4 In the Matter of 5 NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION v. 6 THEODORE SMITH 7 Section 3020-a Education Law Proceeding (File
More informationFanny: OK, I see. Brian: That's another good question. I think that there are still quite a lot of resources. Fanny: Oh, nice.
Strong Economy Brian talks about his country s economy. 1 Fanny: Hey, Brian, you know, recently I heard that the Canadian dollar is very strong. Brian: It is. It's been amazingly strong in the last few
More information- Grace and peace to you from God our Father, and from our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ, Amen.
About My Father s Business Pastor Korey Van Kampen Mt. Calvary Lutheran Church (WELS) Flagstaff, AZ December 30, 2018 - Grace and peace to you from God our Father, and from our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ,
More informationTHE ANDREW MARR SHOW INTERVIEW: JOSE MANUEL BARROSO PRESIDENT, EU COMMISSION FEBRUARY 16 th 2014
PLEASE NOTE THE ANDREW MARR SHOW MUST BE CREDITED IF ANY PART OF THIS TRANSCRIPT IS USED THE ANDREW MARR SHOW INTERVIEW: JOSE MANUEL BARROSO PRESIDENT, EU COMMISSION FEBRUARY 16 th 2014 And so to Britain
More informationInterview of the Vice President by Kelly O'Donnell, NBC News
Page 1 of 7 For Immediate Release Office of the Vice President May 7, 2006 The Excelsior Hotel Dubrovnik, Croatia 11:15 A.M. (Local) Q This has been, I think, a particularly interesting trip, especially
More informationTranscript excerpt from : Fox News Network - September 29, 2009 Tuesday - Hannity Show (9PM EST) (Sean Hannity).
Transcript excerpt from : Fox News Network - September 29, 2009 Tuesday - Hannity Show (9PM EST) (Sean Hannity). Conversation Former between Hannity and James Traficant (former Ohio Congressman out of
More informationEp #62: The Power in Finding Your Why with Linda Lakin
Full Episode Transcript With Your Host Allison Watts, DDS Welcome to Practicing with the Masters for dentists with your host, Dr. Allison Watts. Allison believes that there are four pillars for a successful,
More information1 DAVID DAVIS. ANDREW MARR SHOW, 12 TH MARCH 2017 DAVID DAVIS, Secretary of State for Exiting the EU
ANDREW MARR SHOW, 12 TH MARCH 2017, Secretary of State for Exiting the EU 1 AM: Grossly negligent, Mr Davis. DD: Good morning. This is like Brexit central this morning, isn t it? AM: It really is a bit
More informationSPEECH. Over the past year I have travelled to 16 Member States. I have learned a lot, and seen at first-hand how much nature means to people.
SPEECH Ladies and Gentlemen, It is a great pleasure to welcome you here to the Square. The eyes of Europe are upon us, as we consider its most vital resource its nature. I am sure we will all be doing
More informationCivil Society and Community Engagement in Angola: The Role of the Anglican Church
Africa Programme Meeting Summary Civil Society and Community Engagement in Angola: The Role of the Anglican Church Anglican Bishop of Angola Associate Fellow, Africa Programme, Chatham House Chair: J.
More informationWippl Transcript. OY: Olya Yordanyan TR: Toria Rainey JW: Joseph Wippl
Wippl Transcript OY: Olya Yordanyan TR: Toria Rainey JW: Joseph Wippl OY: Welcome to the EU Futures Podcast, exploring the emerging future in Europe. I am Olya Yordanyan, an Outreach Coordinator at the
More information/organisations/prime-ministers-office-10-downing-street) and The Rt Hon David Cameron
GOV.UK Speech European Council meeting 28 June 2016: PM press conference From: Delivered on: Location: First published: Part of: 's Office, 10 Downing Street (https://www.gov.uk/government /organisations/prime-ministers-office-10-downing-street)
More informationInterview With Parents of Slain Child Beauty Queen
Interview With Parents of Slain Child Beauty Queen Aired January 1, 1997-4:34 p.m. ET NATALIE ALLEN, CNN ANCHOR: And Brian is here, he conducted an exclusive interview today with the child's parents, John
More informationThe Colour of Money - Charles Birch Interview
The Colour of Money - Charles Birch Interview By Richard Slaughter Charles Birch is Emeritus Professor of Biology at the University of Sydney. He was born in Melbourne in 1918. He is a highly respected
More informationInterview with Richard Foster Recorded at Yale Publishing Course For podcast release Monday, August 6, 2012
Interview with Richard Foster Recorded at Yale Publishing Course 2012 For podcast release Monday, August 6, 2012 KENNEALLY: Summer school is in session. On the leafy campus of Yale University, the view
More informationOur Statement of Purpose
Strategic Framework 2008-2010 Our Statement of Purpose UnitingCare Victoria and Tasmania is integral to the ministry of the church, sharing in the vision and mission of God - seeking to address injustice,
More informationEpisode 220 Dr. Clyde Angel, John Sullivan, and Dr. Vincent Starnino: At My Core, I m Not the Same: Spiritual Injury and Military Trauma (part 1 of 2)
Episode 220 Dr. Clyde Angel, John Sullivan, and Dr. Vincent Starnino: At My Core, I m Not the Same: Spiritual Injury and Military Trauma (part 1 of 2) [00:00:08] Welcome to insocialwork. The podcast series
More informationJohn 15:18-25 Counting the Cost Tim Anderson 14/10/18
John 15:18-25 Counting the Cost Tim Anderson 14/10/18 When I was a kid, 'hate' was a word my mother told me not to use. It's OK to dislike someone, or to dislike something they have done to you. But you
More informationCODE OF ETHICS AND MINISTRY PRACTICE
Uniting Church in Australia CODE OF ETHICS AND MINISTRY PRACTICE for Ministers in the Uniting Church in Australia (whether in approved placements or not) Approved by the Twelfth Assembly July 2009 In this
More informationExecutive Power and the School Chaplains Case, Williams v Commonwealth Karena Viglianti
TRANSCRIPT Executive Power and the School Chaplains Case, Williams v Commonwealth Karena Viglianti Karena Viglianti is a Quentin Bryce Law Doctoral scholar and a teaching fellow here in the Faculty of
More informationCODE OF ETHICS AND MINISTRY PRACTICE
Uniting Church in Australia CODE OF ETHICS AND MINISTRY PRACTICE for Ministers in the Uniting Church in Australia (whether in approved placements or not) Approved by the Twelfth Assembly July 2009 In this
More informationRemarks as delivered ADM Mike Mullen Current Strategy Forum, Newport, RI June 13, 2007
Remarks as delivered ADM Mike Mullen Current Strategy Forum, Newport, RI June 13, 2007 The single reason that I m here is because of the people that I ve been fortunate enough to serve with, literally
More informationEpisode #138: Seeing the Gift in the Neglected Member of the Trinity
Grit 'n' Grace: Good Girls Breaking Bad Rules Okay, Susie described an early encounter with the holy spirit and said, "The helper had arrived." I just love that. So, Cheri, how have you experienced the
More informationSherene: Jesus Saved Me from Suicide December 8, 2018
Sherene: Jesus Saved Me from Suicide December 8, 2018 Dear Family, I'm sorry you haven't heard from me for days, because I've been intensely involved with a young woman who ran away from home in Trinidad.
More informationCHINA IN THE WORLD PODCAST. Host: Paul Haenle Guest: Elizabeth Economy
CHINA IN THE WORLD PODCAST Host: Paul Haenle Guest: Elizabeth Economy Episode 66: Interpreting the South China Sea Tribunal Ruling July 19, 2016 Haenle: You are listening to the Carnegie Tsinghua China
More informationSID: Kevin, you have told me many times that there is an angel that comes with you to accomplish what you speak. Is that angel here now?
Hello, Sid Roth here. Welcome to my world where it's naturally supernatural. My guest died, went to heaven, but was sent back for many reasons. One of the major reasons was to reveal the secrets of angels.
More information