he is a italian house painter, and hes important because he stole the mona lisa and hid inside a closet until the mesuem closed for the night

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "he is a italian house painter, and hes important because he stole the mona lisa and hid inside a closet until the mesuem closed for the night"

Annice Booker
5 years ago
Views:

Quiz name: People v. Shem (Case Prep - 9-16-2014) Question with Most Correct Answers: # 0 Question with Fewest Correct Answers: # 0 Date: 9/16/2014 Total Questions: 20 1.

1 Quiz name: People v. Shem (Case Prep ) Question with Most Correct Answers: # 0 Question with Fewest Correct Answers: # 0 Date: 9/16/2014 Total Questions: Look on page 5 of your packet, Who is Vincenzo Peruggia? What did he do and why is he important? he is an Italian house painter and former louver and he stole the Mona lisa an italian artist who stole the mona lisa and got away with it for two years. Because he stole Mona Lisa to give it back to his country. he is a italian house painter, and hes important because he stole the mona lisa and hid inside a closet until the mesuem closed for the night Vincenzo was an italian house painter and louvre employee. He stole the Mona Lisa, and he is important because it is relatable's case of people v. Shem ken n.,kalonw.,kev.jocci, an italian painter In 1911, Peruggia stole the Mona Lisa. T wo years later, he contacted an art dealer saying he was in possession of the portrait. But the art dealer snitched and so Peruggia was arrested. He clamied he was doing a partriotic cause.

2 2. How was Vincenzo Peruggia different from most art thieves? He stole the most expensive picture and he got away for two years he tried to resale the Mona Lisa after keeping it and getting aways with it for two years He was different because he tried to take credit for bringing it back by blaming someone else for stealing the painting when it was in his possession. he's different because the next morning he walks out of the mesuem unnoticed. any other thief wouldve left right when they got the portrait but he hid it under his clothes and left the next morning. He didn't steal it for money T he artnapping was not as publicized as it was expected. Because the art that was stolem was the Mona Lisa. Furthermore, the art was tolen extreamely damages society since history is lost 3. What is the difference between larceny and embezzlement? Larceny is when you take it without permission and embezzlement has been entrusted with legally larceny is stealing something embezzlement is when someone gives you something and they dont give it back Larceny is stealing property without intention of giving it back. While embezzlement is taking property in which was entrusted by you legally. JOVEN CAME LAT E AND IS NOW WORKING WIT H ME!!!!!!!!!!!! K? K. there different because larceny is to steal prop and emblezzment means to steal someones prop that was trusted in your hands to keep safe. Larceny is taking without permission and embezzlement is entrusting someone with your property. Larceny is you work at store and stole it. Embezzlement you just stole it.

3 4. Of the crimes listed on pages 6-7 of your packet which one do you think is the most serious and why? Which one do you think is the least serious and why? Robbery is the most serious because its taking a persons property by violence and larceny is least serious because its taking something without asking T he most serious case would be robbery since they use violence and threats on your life or someone you love. T he least serious would larceny since the property can be worth less forgery is the most serious because you're stealing someone's identity most serious is forgery, because you can steal money w someone elses signature or copy paintings etc. easy to steal from banks w forgery and take someones money. least serious is recieving stolen property because its easy to buy and not know that it was stolen Most serious crime is robbery because they use violence. Least serious crime is larceny because it not serious. Robbery is the most important because it involves violence and embezzlement is the least because you are entrusting someone with your things. 5. Review the crimes on pages 6-7 (from Forgery to Receiving Stolen Property) and read Case A on Page 8 of your packet. Discuss and decide which crimes should be charged in the case and why. Burglary, Larceny because i feel like those are the crimes that he should've committed Larceny because they did steal something over $900 forgery, larceny, selling stolen property T he charge should be burglary since he went to the house willing to steal something. Larceny and forgery because he stolen the painting without permission and the Butler also replaced it with a counterfeit painting. Forgery Beacause he replace real painting with fake one. Embezzlement for trusting butler.

4 6. Review the crimes on pages 6-7 (from Forgery to Receiving Stolen Property) and read Case B on Page 8 of your packet. Discuss and decide which crimes should be charged in the case and why. forgery Forgery because he took paintings and lied about who did them and lied that it made in Germany. T his case should be charged forgery because he used cheap material to make it seem like if it was real basically he Conn them forgery, and larceny because he used fake material to repair it. T he case to be charge is forgery since they altered the painting with the intent to deceive another person and cause a loss of money, goods and etc. Furthermore the fact that the materials used was different from what they said to the buyers indicates their intent to trick someone. Forgery because con artist use fake painting to make money 7. Review the crimes on pages 6-7 (from Forgery to Receiving Stolen Property) and read Case C on Page 9 of your packet. Discuss and decide which crimes should be charged in the case and why. Extortion and robbery because held the theives threatened to destroy the money was not paid, did two men armed with guns walked into the museum and threatened the good. embezzlement because they held the painting hostile,an robbery because they stole it extorcion because he threatned to destroy painting. larceny he took someones painting without permission. robbery because he stole with violence Extortion because they threaten them with destruction of property T hey should be charged eith extortion since they used threats against people to get the property and the second crime should be burglary since they went to the buildi g dressed as workers to steal property from the building. Extortion because thieves made ransom and threaten to mess up painting to police. Robbery for coming in with guns and taking painting.

5 8. Review the crimes on pages 6-7 (from Forgery to Receiving Stolen Property) and read Case D on Page 9 of your packet. Discuss and decide which crimes should be charged in the case and why. burglary because he entered and intended to comit a crime. larceny because he stole property without permission. Burglary and larceny and receiving stolen property because they took the sculptures without permission from the studio and receiving stolen property because the metal recycling dealer bought the sculpture. larceny because they took it without anyones knowing, robbery btw i forgot to put extortion on case c! because they wanted a ransom for the painting Burglary because as soon as the sculpture was returned it was stolen from his storage yard T he theives can be charged eith burglary since they went into the house of the artist to steak the painting or he can be charged with larceny grand theft since he stole it with intent. While the scrapper should be charged with receiving stolen property since he should have known that what he got worth more than what he gave the theives. T his indicates that the property he received was obviously stolen. Burglary because stole it inside store. Larceny took sculpture without asking. 9. Review the crimes on pages 6-7 (from Forgery to Receiving Stolen Property) and read Case E on Page 9 of your packet. Discuss and decide which crimes should be charged in the case and why. Burglary and larceny because it involves stealing over $ 400,000 worth of artwork and larceny because he took it intentionally. theft because it was stolen robbery because he stole it Burglary because someone went into the store to steal something T he charge should be burglary since he broke into the producers home to steal the $400,000 art work. Larceny and robbery Beacause he broke into house and stole it.

6 10. Review the crimes on pages 6-7 (from Forgery to Receiving Stolen Property) and read Case F on Page 9 of your packet. Discuss and decide which crimes should be charged in the case and why. receiving stolen property because he was well know in the art industry?? Larceny and forgery because that he was trusted with and forgery because he forage the catalogs T he manager can be charged eith embezzlement and larceny since he stole property worth thousands of dollars and embezzlemnt since he was intrusted eith the care of painting(it was his job) yet it was stolen. Embezzlement Beacause he stole art painting for himself and forgery Beacause of forged catalogs. 11. Who is Marty McCulloch? (Pages 11-12) Why did he give Detective Barron permission to take a painting to police headquarters? Marty owned the painting he is saying that shem stoled the painting.so the police can compare the painting to the stolen one Marty McCulloh an heir to a railroad fortune, has a prestigious collection of artwork and he's a professor of art history at Hamiltonia University. Marty is the owner and host of the painting gallery/mansion. Also he gave the painting to the detectibe so they can further investigate the paintings retrieved from Shems apartment and figure out whether the painting found in the apartment was an imitation of the painting stolen in the mansion He was owner of painting that was stolen. 12. Who is Evan Shem? (Pages 11-12) and why was a warrant for his arrest issued and executed? Evan shem is the person being charged with the crime. All the evidence was appointed to him Even Shem is a student at Hamiltonia Unviersity person being charged with the crime. Shem is the defendant and hesupposedly stole the painting from th mansion where he interned and docent. A warrant was executed because he was a top suspect of the crime due to his interest to the painting. Not only that but a similar painiting was found in his apartment Suspect of stealing painting

7 13. Now that you are familiar with the case (pages 11-12) what does your group think? Is Evan Shem guilty or not guilty and why? i feel he is guilty. there are a lot of missing spots in the story he told, not to mention they found the painting in his possesion after expressin intrest in the painting. Shem is guilty because all the evidence is pointed towards him We think he is guilty since all evidence is pointed towards him. Not guilty because shem has hobby of recreated painting. 14. Now that you are familiar with the case (pages 11-12) If you were the Prosecutor which Federal Cases (pages 17-19) would you use to show the search by police was lawful and why? Illinois v Rodriguez because the police feel like they have enough evidence i dont understand the question so i shall skip it :) Illinois and florida can help the case since the police belived that Charlie had joint access or ownership of the apartment Case b because it show that many work was recreated 15. Now that you are familiar with the case (pages 11-12) If you were the Defense Attorney which Federal Cases (pages 17-19) would you use to show the search by police was unlawful and why? Stoner and US v Davis since Charlie did not have legal joint access to the property of where the evidence is being looked for Stoner vs California because they didn't consent with owner. 16. Now that you are familiar with the case (pages 11-12) If you were the Prosecutor which State Cases (pages 19-20) would you use to show the search by police was lawful and why? Jenkins case since the police believe that both people have right to consent to the search and seizure Illinois v Rodriguez Beacause police didn't have consent to go inside owner apartment.

8 17. Now that you are familiar with the case (pages 11-12) If you were the Defense Attorney which State Cases (pages 19-20) would you use to show the search by police was unlawful and why? People v cruz since charlie and ann did not have the right to give consent since they just lived there and not all properyy witgin the building belonged to theirs so they had no right to give consent to searcha nd seize someone elses property People v Cruz because guest couldnt have marijuana in owner apartment. 18. Look over Detective Reese Barron's witness statement on page Why do you think he was selected as a witness for the prosecution? I give up. T oo many questions Because officer has already formed strong opinion that it was inside job 19. Look over Sidney Ogden's witness statement on page Why do you think he was selected as a witness for the defense? Because she knows Evan well 20. Look over Charlie Gibbons witness statement on pg Why do you think he was selected as a witness for the Prosecution? Him and Evan seemed obsessed over painting

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF JACKSON COUNTY, MISSOURI AT INDEPENDENCE

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF JACKSON COUNTY, MISSOURI AT INDEPENDENCE POLICE NO. : 18-000206 PROSECUTOR NO. : 095443345 STATE OF MISSOURI, PLAINTIFF, vs. BRANDON J. ADAMS 10907 E. 19th St. S., Apt 1, Independence,