Opening Heavens. the. Accounts of Divine Manifestations, Second Edition Edited by John W. Welch

Transcription

1 Opening Heavens the Accounts of Divine Manifestations, Second Edition Edited by John W. Welch Brigham Young University Press Provo, Utah and Deseret Book Salt Lake City, Utah

2 Copyright 2017 Brigham Young University. All rights reserved. Cover design by Bjorn W. Pendleton. Opinions expressed in this publication are the opinions of the authors and their views should not necessarily be attributed to The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Brigham Young University, BYU Studies, or Deseret Book Company. All revenues from this book are dedicated to funding future BYU Studies publications. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, digital, mechanical or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording or in an information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. To contact BYU Studies, write to 1063 JFSB, Provo, Utah 84602, or visit To contact Deseret Book Company, write to P.O. Box 30178, Salt Lake City, Utah, This volume was prepared for publication by BYU Studies, with particular assistance from Jennifer Hurlbut, Marny K. Parkin, and Sandra A. Thorne. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Welch, John W. (John Woodland), editor. Title: Opening the heavens : accounts of divine manifestations, / edited by John W. Welch. Description: Provo, Utah : Brigham Young University Press ; Salt Lake City, Utah : Deseret Book, [2017] Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN ISBN (pbk.) ISBN (ebook) Subjects: LCSH: Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints History 19th century Sources. Mormon Church History 19th century Sources. Revelation Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints History 19th century. Revelation Mormon Church History 19th century. Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints Doctrines History 19th century. Mormon Church Doctrines History 19th century. Classification: LCC BX8611.O DDC /034 dc23 LC record available at Printed in the United States of America

3 Introduction John W. Welch This volume strives to bring together all the known contemporaneous documents relevant to the key events of the Restoration of the gospel of Jesus Christ that were accompanied by divine manifestations: Joseph Smith s First Vision; the coming forth of the Book of Mormon; the restoration of priesthood authority; the heavenly visions received by Joseph Smith and his companions; and the bestowal of keys and the outpouring of holy gifts in the Kirtland Temple. We also present all known testimonies of those who were present on August 8, 1844, and saw the mantle of the Prophet Joseph Smith passing to Brigham Young, whether contemporaneous or later. These events are the backbone of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.1 If 1. We declare without equivocation that God the Father and His Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, appeared in person to the boy Joseph Smith.... Our whole strength rests on the validity of that vision. It either occurred or it did not occur. If it did not, then this work is a fraud. If it did, then it is the most important and wonderful work under the heavens.... But this glorious vision was but the beginning of a series of manifestations that constitute the early history of this work.... [T]here followed the coming forth of the Book of Mormon.... There followed the restoration of the priesthood first, of the Aaronic under the hands of John the Baptist, who had baptized Jesus in Jordan. Then came Peter, James, and John, Apostles of the Lord, who conferred in this age that which they had received under the hands of the Master with whom they walked, even the keys of the kingdom of heaven, with authority to bind in the heavens that which they bound on earth (see Matt. 16:19). Subsequently came the bestowal of further vii

4 viii Opening the Heavens these visions, revelations, miracles, and powers were, in fact, received as claimed, nothing surpasses the importance of knowing so. The plan of this book is to allow the documents, as much as possible, to stand for themselves. Contemporaneous documents are critical in getting close to these key events. Firsthand accounts uniquely convey the spirit of these important occasions. Eyewitness reports provide precious details that help modern readers construct a vivid image of what transpired. Although only a verbal shadow of greater realities, and although inevitably some reporters were more observant, better informed, or more articulate than others, the words of close participants offer us the feeling of almost being there. The impact of these documents is cumulative. As one reads account after account, the truth becomes clearer. Together these accounts reliably reveal the inside story of the rise, progress, and faith of the Latterday Saints in the 1820s, 1830s, and 1840s. As an author and editor, I have enjoyed reading these documents over and over, word by word. As these accounts become more and more familiar to me, I notice especially their honesty, integrity, consistency, and forthrightness. In transcribing, proofreading, and typesetting these powerful declarations, all who have worked on this volume have come closer to hearing the individual voices of these original writers. I recommend reading these crucial accounts slowly, thoughtfully, and at times even out loud. Listen as these numerous witnesses offer their own testimonies. Many new historical resources have become available since the first edition of Opening the Heavens. Newly discovered testimonies have been added to this second edition. Many hours have been spent in updating the footnotes, especially to the Joseph Smith Papers Project. This valuable collection offers remarkable access to the earliest historical sources. The ebook version of the second edition includes live links to online resources that contain images of original documents and information about their creation. Readers will be able to access many of the documents from which individual testimonies were taken to learn more about their context and history. Single chapters, which also contain live links to sources, are available on the BYU Studies website (byustudies.byu.edu) for a modest download fee. priesthood keys under the hands of Moses, Elias, and Elijah. Gordon B. Hinckley, The Marvelous Foundation of Our Faith, Ensign 31 (November 2002): 78.

5 Introduction ix Each document in this collection is presented unvarnished, according to the established standards of documentary editing. Several documents are published here for the first time. Four of the chapters in this book appeared initially in BYU Studies. Since 1959, this quarterly journal has been a premiere voice of the Latter-day Saint academic community, placing great emphasis on the technical editing and groundbreaking publication of scores of newly discovered documents from the founding years of the Restoration. These scholarly treatments of primary sources have earned acclaim for their accuracy, reliability, and objectivity. The previously published articles and chapters have been brought up to date in this new edition, particularly with assistance by Erick B. Carlson, Jed Woodworth, Jennifer Hurlbut, and Sandra A. Thorne. The value of these documents is immeasurable. In the history of world religions, no other body of foundational documentation rivals it for its immediacy and size. Think, for example, how few documents have survived from the time of Mohammed. And what would New Testament scholars give for a single letter from Mary or Martha about the raising of Lazarus? Or a diary entry by someone who was present when Jesus was baptized by John in the Jordan River? Or a brief report from Peter to the Twelve about what he had just seen and heard on the Mount of Transfiguration? In the case of Joseph Smith and the key events of the Restoration, we enjoy, by comparison, an overwhelming abundance. The function of this book is inviting. Each of these historical documents beckons to be understood. In a literal sense, documents do not speak for themselves, for they have no tongues, lips, or vocal chords that cry from their fragile paper and faded ink. Instead, readers supply the determinative factors of seeing (or not seeing), of catching (or missing), of emphasizing (or ignoring). Readers are invited to evaluate these primary documents themselves, to know what they say (or do not say). We start with Joseph Smith s First Vision. Dean Jessee presents an up-to-date collection of all the known accounts that come from the lifetime of Joseph Smith: ten accounts in thirteen documents,2 2. See slightly different groupings of the same accounts in the discussion in First Vision Accounts, one of the Gospel Topics Essays, available on The

6 x Opening the Heavens including his journal entries, his letters to newspapermen, and the recordings of others who heard Joseph Smith relate his experience. As James Allen and I then show, these accounts are coherent, credible, and more consistent than some people have surmised. With the full record in view, one sees that Joseph Smith shared his Vision experience with intimate groups, the general public, enquiring visitors, and newspapermen, and he did so spontaneously at their request. Distributed authentically throughout these documents from 1832 to 1844, the details supplied by each of these accounts add to our understanding and enhance the credibility of the Prophet s story, as he addressed the particular needs and interests of various audiences. The second key event in the Restoration, the coming forth of the Book of Mormon, stands as a monumental miracle. One biblical scholar under whom I studied once compared the dictation of the Book of Mormon by Joseph Smith to Moses parting of the Red Sea. And rightly so. Dictating to his scribes, Joseph Smith translated the Book of Mormon in less than three months, from April 7 to the end of June The historical documents corroborate this feat. The data they contain are organized here into an annotated chronology. Over two hundred accounts from participants and observers reveal that many people immediately sensed the importance of the work that was taking place. More than any other Restoration event, the story of the golden plates piqued the public s interest. Years later, all Joseph Smith s closest associates especially his wife Emma and the three Book of Mormon witnesses Oliver Cowdery, Martin Harris, and David Whitmer continued to tell remarkably consistent stories and never wavered in their testimonies of the Book of Mormon. A surprisingly large number of early Church documents record crucial details about the restoration of both the Aaronic and Melchizedek Priesthoods. Brian Cannon and the BYU Studies staff introduce the seventy extant documents that deal directly with priesthood restoration. Half of these documents come from Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery, the key participants. Nearly thirty other people voiced Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, -accounts?lang=eng#1; and Steven C. Harper, Joseph Smith s First Vision: A Guide to the Historical Accounts (Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 2012),

7 Introduction xi their understanding of what they had heard, often from Joseph or Oliver themselves. While May 15, 1829, the date of the Aaronic Priesthood restoration, is well known, the timing of the restoration of the Melchizedek Priesthood is less clear. Though Cannon acknowledges that the documentary record has a few gaps, the available sources support the traditional dating of the Melchizedek Priesthood restoration in May June The sources further reveal that early Church members realized the necessity of priesthood authority and understood that it had been restored from heaven. During his prophetic ministry, Joseph Smith enjoyed the gift of seeing visions and receiving visitations. From the time he was fourteen, he garnered strength and knowledge from his communions with the heavens, which allowed him to establish the Church. He enjoyed numerous visions, and each was unique. Students of LDS Church history will readily recognize Joseph Smith s most famous visions. But Alexander Baugh goes well beyond those well-known few and places them against the expansive backdrop of many additional heavenly manifestations, some of which were simultaneously shared by multiple recipients. The impressive total truly evinces the opening of the heavens. Several Church members experienced some of these heavenly manifestations with Joseph Smith at the time of the dedication of the Kirtland Temple in early If only one isolated account existed of the great pentecostal outpouring that accompanied this spiritual season, one might wonder about that account s accuracy or credibility. As Steven Harper shows, however, several people went home and independently recorded what they had just seen, heard, felt, and experienced. The keys that were restored on April 3, 1836, by Moses, Elias, and Elijah, constitute the basis of divinely authorized temple building, temple sealings, and temple work for the dead among the Latter-day Saints. This set of six contemporaneous documents brings attentive readers into the sacred spheres of the temple. Fortunately, one more divinely manifested key event in the Restoration assures that these priesthood powers were not lost when Joseph Smith died. Many Church members reported that they received a strong spiritual witness that convinced them that Joseph Smith s mantle of authority had fallen on Brigham Young. Long an integral

8 xii Opening the Heavens part of Mormon history, the story of Brigham Young appearing and speaking as Joseph Smith at a public meeting on August 8, 1844, had not been fully documented until the late 1990s. Lynne Jorgensen has exhaustively chronicled all known written testimonies of this singular event. These statements, now numbering more than 120, come from a great variety of individuals and document the mantle experience as an extraordinary collective spiritual experience. Men and women, old and young, attest to it in greater numbers than ever was previously suspected. Some wrote as early as fall 1844; others wrote of this indelible experience much later. Several witnesses bore their testimony orally to their descendants, who then recorded their words. Here are the documentary exhibits of the Restoration. They are open for the world to read. They may be judged without hesitation. The outlook for this book of documents is enduring. It may be one of the most important LDS Church history books you will ever read, for these original, eyewitness accounts will outlive us all. They will last. A generation from now, few people will care how various historians in our day have interpreted the past. Academic reputations are short-lived, and popular memories are even shorter. Voguish theories come and go; they offer their flash of light on certain corners and fade out of fashion. But the original documents convey testimonies that will always be of utmost interest. In submitting his Wentworth letter to the publisher of the Chicago Democrat, Joseph Smith made only one request: All that I shall ask at his hands, is, that he publish the account entire, ungarnished, and without misrepresentation. 3 In this book, we hope to have complied with this request. Here are six major collections of key Restoration documents, in their full authenticity and veracity. 3. Joseph Smith, Church History, Times and Seasons 3 (March 1, 1842): 706 7, available on Church History Library, The Joseph Smith Papers,

9 The Earliest Accounts of Joseph Smith s First Vision Dean C. Jessee The direct, primary historical sources pertaining to Joseph Smith s First Vision that are now known amount to ten accounts in thirteen documents eight documents produced or reported in the first person by or from the Prophet himself,1 and five contemporary reports by others who heard him relate his experience and recorded what he said in the third person. The purpose of this essay is to identify and present these accounts and to consider the context in which each was created. First Vision Accounts in Context From the beginning of his public ministry, Joseph Smith struggled to record the events of his life. The conditions in which he was raised did not facilitate a literary course; indigent circumstances, which required the labor of the entire Smith family to meet their daily needs, limited Joseph s schooling. He later wrote that he had been deprived of the bennifit of an education suffice it to say I was mearly instructtid 1. The discussion in First Vision Accounts, one of the Gospel Topics Essays, available on The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, topics/first-vision-accounts?lang=eng#1, groups these eight first-person documents as four accounts because the content is so similar. Steven C. Harper, Joseph Smith s First Vision: A Guide to the Historical Accounts (Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 2012), 31 66, groups the first-person documents into five accounts. 1

10 2 Opening the Heavens in reading and writing and the ground <rules> of Arithmatic which const[it]uted my whole literary acquirements. 2 In light of Joseph s background, it is not surprising that the boy Joseph did not record his experience that spring morning in 1820 after returning from the grove. Years later, still harboring misgivings about his ability to communicate with the pen, he yearned for deliverance from what he called the little narrow prison... of paper pen and ink and a crooked broken scattered and imperfect language. 3 His writings contain occasional apologies for his lack of writing skill. Even had his literary preparations been ideal, the at-times-violent forces that dogged him continually were persistently present to disrupt his record-keeping ventures. Large gaps in his record coincide with periods of unrest and disorder in his life, and many important portions of his life s story were either lost or never recorded. Another factor that shaped the historiography of the First Vision grew out of the process of developing a plan for record keeping in the early years of the Church. Problems of defining the nature, scope, and format of a historical record limited the resultant archive, as did difficulties in finding and retaining capable clerical help to assist in the creation and care of the records. Following the 1830 revelation that initiated Joseph Smith s record keeping,4 procedures for creating 2. Letterbook 1, 1, Joseph Smith Collection, Church History Library, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Salt Lake City, available on Church Historian s Press, The Joseph Smith Papers, paper -summary/letterbook-1/7; Karen Lynn Davidson and others, eds., Histories: Volume 1, Joseph Smith Histories, , vol. 1 of the Histories series of The Joseph Smith Papers, ed. Dean C. Jessee, Ronald K. Esplin, and Richard Lyman Bushman (Salt Lake City: Church Historian s Press, 2012), Joseph Smith to William W. Phelps, November 27, 1832, copy in Letterbook 1, 4; Matthew C. Godfrey and others, eds., Documents, Volume 2: July 1831 January 1833, vol. 2 of the Documents series of The Joseph Smith Papers, ed. Dean C. Jessee, Ronald K. Esplin, Richard Lyman Bushman, and Matthew J. Grow (Salt Lake City: Church Historian s Press, 2013), The opening words of the revelation presented by Joseph Smith at the organization of the Church on April 6, 1830, were, Behold there Shall <be> a Record be kept among you (D&C 21:1). Revelation Book 1, Church History Library, available on Church Historian s Press, The Joseph Smith Papers, smith papers.org/paper-summary/revelation-book-1/12; Robin Scott Jensen, Robert J. Woodford, and Steven C. Harper, eds., Revelations and

11 Joseph Smith s First Vision Accounts 3 pertinent records were slow to develop. It took several years marked by false starts before a format was settled on and the enduring work began on Joseph Smith s history of the Church.5 As evidence of the challenges he faced, by October 29, 1839, when Joseph left Nauvoo for Washington, D.C., to present the Missouri grievances of his people before the federal government, only fifty-nine pages of his history had been written; and six days after his departure, his scribe, James Mulholland, died.6 After returning to Nauvoo in March 1840, Joseph lamented the passing of his faithful scribe and expressed disappointment that an adequate record of his Washington trip had not been kept: I depended on Dr. Foster to keep my daily journal during this journey, but he has failed me. 7 Robert B. Thompson, who was appointed General Church Clerk on October 3, 1840, continued writing the history where Mulholland left off. Nevertheless, only sixteen pages were added to the history before he too met an untimely death on August 27, By the time Willard Richards was appointed General Church Clerk and private secretary to the Prophet in December 1841, a mere 157 pages had been written of a history that would eventually number more than two thousand pages. This history, begun in 1838, would not be finished until 1856, twelve years after Joseph Smith s death.9 Shortly Translations, Volume 1: Manuscript Revelation Books, vol. 1 of the Revelations and Translations series of The Joseph Smith Papers, ed. Dean C. Jessee, Ronald K. Esplin, and Richard Lyman Bushman (Salt Lake City: Church Historian s Press, 2011), Now known as History, , with volumes A-1 through F History, , Volume C-1 [2 November July 1842], 1023, Church History Library, available on Church Historian s Press, The Joseph Smith Papers, papers.org/paper-summary/history volume-c-1-2-november july -1842/195; Joseph Smith Jr., History of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, ed. B. H. Roberts, 2d ed., rev., 7 vols. (Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 1971), 4:46 (hereafter cited as History of the Church). 7. History, , Volume C-1, 1023; History of the Church, 4: History, , Volume C-1, 1223; History of the Church, 4: The manuscript of the History, , shows that the first fifty-nine pages were written by James Mulholland, that Robert B. Thompson wrote at least part of the next sixteen, and that William W. Phelps had written eighty-two pages before Willard Richards began writing. It was not until after Richards s

12 4 Opening the Heavens before his death, Joseph Smith summarized the problems that had beset his record keeping: Since I have been engaged in laying the foundation of the Church of Jesus Christ <of Latter Day Saints> I have been prevented in various ways from continuing my Journal. and the History, in a manner satisfactory to myself, or in justice to the cause. Long imprisonments, vexatious and long continued Law Suits The treachery of some of my Clerks; the death of others; and the poverty of myself and brethren from a continued plunder and driving, have prevented my handing down to posterity a connected memorandum of events, desirable to all lovers of truth. He added, I have continued to keep up a Journal in the best manner my circumstances would allow, and dictate for my history from time to time, as I have had oppertunity, so that the labors and suffering of the first Elders and Saints of this last kingdom might not wholly be lost to the world. 10 The historical records of Joseph Smith s life, including those pertaining to the First Vision, are best seen in this context. appointment in December 1841 that any significant progress was made on writing the History. Part of volume A-1 of these histories is reproduced in Davidson and others, Histories, Volume 1, ; all six parts of History, , are available on Church Historian s Press, The Joseph Smith Papers, smith papers.org/the-papers/histories/jspph3. See also Dean C. Jessee, The Writing of Joseph Smith s History, BYU Studies 11, no. 4 (1971): History, , Volume C-1, 1260; History of the Church, 4:470. Speaking to the newly appointed Twelve in February 1835, Joseph remarked, If I now had in my possession, every decision which has been had, upon important items of doctrine and duties, which have been given since the commencement of this work, I would not part with it for any sum of money, but we have neglected to take minutes of such things, thinking, perhaps, that they would never benefit us afterward.... [A]nd now we cannot bear record to the church, and to the world, of the great and glorious manifestations which have been made to us, with that degree of power and authority, we otherwise could, if we now had these things to publish abroad. A Record of the Transactions of the Twelve Apostles..., 1 2, Church History Library, available on Church Historian s Press, The Joseph Smith Papers, -book-1?p=90; compare History of the Church, 2:

13 Joseph Smith s First Vision Accounts 5 First Vision Accounts Produced by the Prophet The Church records created during these turbulent years include eight documents in which Joseph Smith recorded details of his initial vision experience. Three of these, with minor differences, are duplications of a previous one. 1. Joseph Smith History Account (1832) The first of these was a six-page autobiographical narrative intended to be a history of his life and an account of the rise of the church of Christ, but it was abruptly discontinued, evidently when a new plan for the history was conceived. It was written most probably between February and November 1832 on three leaves that were later cut from the ledger book that contained them.11 This 1832 narrative contains the 11. Letterbook 1, 1; Davidson and others, Histories, Volume 1, 10. Evidence for the 1832 date comes from handwriting identification and inspection of the ledger book that contained the severed pages. Davidson and others, Histories, Volume 1, 3. The handwriting reveals that the document was alternately penned by Joseph Smith and Frederick G. Williams, Joseph s scribe and counselor in the First Presidency. Williams converted to the Church in fall 1830 and immediately left for Missouri. His handwriting in the beginning pages of the Kirtland Revelation Book shows that by February 1832 Williams was writing for Joseph Smith, after returning to Ohio. And according to his own statement, he was officially appointed on July 20 as the Prophet s scribe. F. G. Williams, Statement, n.d., MS 782, Frederick G. Williams Papers, Church History Library, available on Church History Library, DeliveryManagerServlet?dps_pid=IE , image 18. From this it is evident that the writing of the History could have occurred as early as February Nor is it likely that this history was written after November 27, 1832, since on that date the ledger book in which it was written was converted to a letterbook for recording important historical Church documents. The evidence for this is two-fold. First, although they were later cut from the volume, the three leaves containing this history match the cut edges still protruding from the binding of the ledger book. The terminal letters of words severed when the pages were removed also match. The cut page stubs immediately precede the November 27, 1832, letter entry, the first item in the letterbook. Second, the page numbering indicates this arrangement. The pages of the history were numbered one through six, and the November 27 letter begins on page 1a. Both the last page of the history and the pages of the letter were written by Frederick Williams. He would not have started numbering the pages containing the letter with 1a had there not been a preceding page 1.

14 Joseph Smith s First Vision Accounts 7 earliest known account of Joseph s First Vision and the only account in his own handwriting. In the transcription that follows, the boldfaced type indicates the portions of the document written in the Prophet s handwriting. The remainder is in the handwriting of his secretary, Frederick G. Williams. Underlining is reproduced from the original document. Editorial marks include angle brackets < > to indicate above-the-line insertions. Strikeouts are shown as written. Brackets [ ] indicate editorial comments. A History of the life of Joseph Smith Jr. an account of his marvilous experience and of all the mighty acts which he doeth in the name of Jesus Ch[r]ist the son of the living God of whom he beareth record and also an account of the rise of the church of Christ in the eve of time according as the Lord brought forth and established by his hand <firstly> he receiving the testamony from on high seccondly the ministering of Angels thirdly the reception of the holy Priesthood by the ministring of Aangels to adminster the letter of the Law <Gospel > < the Law and Commandments as they were given unto him > and in <the> ordinencs, forthly a confirmation and reception of the high Priesthood after the holy order of the son of the living God power and ordinence from on high to preach the Gospel in the administration and demonstration of the spirit the Kees of the Kingdom of God confered upon him and the continuation of the blessings of God to him &c I was born in the town of Charon [Sharon] in the <State> of Vermont North America on the twenty third day of December AD 1805 of goodly Parents who spared no pains to instruct<ing> me in <the> christian religion[.] at the age of about ten years my Father Joseph Smith Seignior moved to Palmyra Ontario [now Wayne] County in the State of New York and being in indigent circumstances were obliged to labour hard for the support of a large Family having nine chilldren and as it required their exertions of all that were able to render any assistance for the support of the Family therefore we were deprived of the bennifit of an education suffice it to say I was mearly instructtid in reading and writing and the ground <rules> of Arithmatic which constuted my whole literary acquirements. At about the age of twelve years my mind become seriously imprest [p. 1] with regard to the all importent concerns of for the wellfare of my immortal Soul which led me to searching the scriptures believeing as I was taught, that they contained the word of God thus applying myself to them and my intimate acquaintance with

15 Table 1: Background Conditions Mentioned in the First Vision Accounts 1832 Smith 1835 Documents 1838 Smith 1840 Pratt 1842 and 1843 Smith 1842 Hyde 1843 Richards 1843 White 1844 Neibaur Joseph s age 14 or about 14 Joseph s age 15 or about 15 Religious excitement of the period Wanted to get religion Joseph s concern for his soul (or future state) His quest for forgiveness of sin Joseph s concern for mankind in general Confusion or strife among denominations Insincerity and bad feelings among religionists No church built or set up as in New Testament His quest to know which church (if any) was right Convinced of God s goodness and greatness Reason told him there was only one truth All could not be right, God not author of confusion Not to rely on chance but positive evidence His searching the scriptures, James 1:5 * *Includes the phrase no respecter to persons.

16 Table 2: Joseph Smith s Quest and Struggle 1832 Smith 1835 Documents 1838 Smith 1840 Pratt 1842 and 1843 Smith 1842 Hyde 1843 Richards 1843 White 1844 Neibaur He prayed He prayed mightily or fervently Cried for mercy Called on God for the first time Realized no church was built on scriptural gospel Wanted to know which church was right Heard footsteps Inability to speak, tongue swollen or bound Beset by doubts and strange images Tempted or beset by dark powers Thick darkness or cloud Exerted all powers Prayed again Felt easier

17 Table 3: What Joseph Smith Saw and Asked 1832 Smith 1835 Documents 1838 Smith 1840 Pratt 1842 and 1843 Smith 1842 Hyde 1843 Richards 1843 White 1844 Neibaur Appearance of light or pillar of light Appearance of fire or pillar of fire Light brighter than the sun Above my head Light desended from above Gradually Flame rested on trees Light rested on Joseph Light all around First one personage in pillar, then another * Two personages Exactly like each other Glory, defies description Appearance of many angels Joseph asks which church to join or which is right *Possibly implied; see discussion on pp

18 Table 4: What Joseph Smith Heard 1832 Smith 1835 Documents 1838 Smith 1840 Pratt 1842 and 1843 Smith 1842 Hyde 1843 Richards 1843 White 1844 Neibaur Father introduced or testified of the Son Joseph called by name Your prayers are answered, special blessing to be given Thy sins are forgiven Go thy way, keep the commandments Jesus described himself Join no church Do not join Methodists All wrong, none right None do good All in sin, gone astray, broken everlasting covenant All professors of religion corrupt Creeds are an abomination All churches teach false doctrine Draw near with lips only Form of godliness but deny the power thereof Forbidden again to join any church None acknowledged as his church, kingdom, people Lord angry, comes quickly Gospel fullness promised

19 Table 5: Aftermaths of the Vision 1832 Smith 1835 Documents 1838 Smith 1840 Pratt 1842 and 1843 Smith 1842 Hyde 1843 Richards 1843 White 1844 Neibaur Lying on his back Uncommonly feeble Joseph filled with love Joseph filled with joy Joseph filled with calmness, comfort, peace Ponder in heart Lord was with Joseph Tried to get others to believe the story Many tried to oppose Joseph unsuccessfully

20 84 Opening the Heavens Events Surrounding the Translation of the Book of Mormon 1827 Sep Joseph obtains the plates from the angel Moroni. Dec Joseph and Emma move to Harmony, Pennsylvania Feb Martin Harris visits Professor Charles Anthon in New York City. Apr 12 June 14 June 15 July Sep 22 Dec The 116 pages are translated. Joseph and Emma s first child is born and dies. Martin Harris loses the 116 pages. Joseph travels to Manchester, New York. Joseph again obtains interpreters and plates. David Whitmer makes a business trip to Palmyra, New York, where he meets Oliver Cowdery Feb Joseph s parents come from Manchester to Harmony. Mar Apr 5 Apr 7 Late June July Aug Nov Joseph receives Doctrine and Covenants 4. The Lord first appears to Oliver Cowdery. A few pages may have been translated. Martin Harris visits Joseph from Palmyra. Oliver Cowdery arrives in Harmony. The Book of Mormon is translated (see text on pp and chart on pp ). E. B. Grandin and T. Weed decline to print. E. B. Grandin agrees to print. Martin Harris mortgages his farm for the printing. Typesetting commences. Oliver Cowdery s preparation of the Printer s Manuscript reaches Alma Mar 26 Publication of the Book of Mormon completed.

21 Estimated Day-by-Day Translation in 1829 Date (1829) Possible Chapters Translated Event March Mosiah 1 A few pages translated. The work of translation resumed where it left off after loss of the 116 pages in April 5 Sun. Oliver Cowdery arrived in Harmony, Pennsylvania.* 6 Joseph purchased property from Emma s father.* About this time, D&C 6 was received, directed to Oliver Cowdery as he began serving as Joseph Smith s scribe. 7 Mosiah 2 4 Oliver began working as Joseph s scribe.* 8 Mosiah Mosiah 8 11 About this time, D&C 8 was received, directed to Oliver about the power to translate. Compare Mosiah 8:11 16, speaking of King Mosiah s power to translate. 10 Mosiah Mosiah Sun. Mosiah About this time, Oliver wrote a letter to David Whitmer. 13 Mosiah Mosiah 29 and Alma Alma Alma Alma Alma Sun. Alma About this time, Oliver wrote a second letter to David Whitmer. 20 Alma Alma Alma Alma Alma Alma 37 38

22 April 26 Alma Sun. About this time, D&C 9 was received (compare D&C 9:14, a hair of your head shall not be lost, and you shall be lifted up at the last day, with Alma 11:44 or 40:23). 27 Alma Alma Alma Alma May 1 Alma Alma Sun. Alma Alma and Helaman 1 5 Helaman Helaman Helaman Helaman Helaman Sun. 3 Nephi Nephi Nephi Nephi Nephi Nephi Restoration of the Aaronic Priesthood.* At this time, Joseph and Oliver went into the nearby woods to pray about baptism for the remission of sins, which they had found mentioned in the translation, presumably in 3 Nephi 11:21 12: Nephi Sun. 3 Nephi About this time, Oliver wrote a third letter to David Whitmer. 18 About this time, Joseph and Oliver traveled 30 miles to Colesville, New York. 19 Joseph and Oliver returned 30 miles from Colesville. Perhaps at this time, Peter, James, and John appeared to restore the higher priesthood and the power to give the gift of the Holy Ghost, mentioned in 3 Nephi 18: Nephi 24 27

23 May 21 3 Nephi and 4 Nephi About this time, D&C 7 may have been received, speaking about John not tasting death. Compare material in the account about the Three Nephites in 3 Nephi 28:1 ( what desirest thou? D&C 7:1); 28:9 ( bring souls, 7:2); 28:2 ( speedily, 7:4); 28:7 ( never taste death, power over death in 7:2). 22 Mormon Mormon Sun. Mormon Ether 1 3 Samuel Smith was baptized.* 26 Ether Ether Ether Near this date, Hyrum Smith and David Whitmer arrived in Harmony, Pennsylvania. 29 Ether and Moroni Moroni 5 8 About at this point, D&C 12 was received, directed to Joseph Knight Sr. (compare 12:8, full of love, faith, hope and charity, with Mosiah 3:19; Ether 12:28; Moro. 7:1; 8:14). 31 Sun. Moroni 9 10 and title page* June 1 About this time, D&C 11 was revealed to Hyrum. Compare D&C 11:16 ( my gospel ), and 11:25 ( deny not ) with 3 Ne. 27:21 and Moro. 10:8. Joseph and Oliver packed and moved from Harmony, Pennsylvania, to Fayette, New York.* 2 Travel to Fayette. 3 Travel to Fayette. 4 Travel to Fayette and unpack. About this time, D&C 10 was finalized, telling Joseph to translate the plates of Nephi (D&C 10:41). 5 Translation resumes with 1 Nephi 1 2 About this time, the voice was heard in Father Whitmer s chamber authorizing Joseph and Oliver to be ordained elders. 6 1 Nephi Sun. 1 Nephi 7 9 About this time, John and Peter Whitmer Sr. were baptized, and D&C 15 and 16 were received.

24 June 8 1 Nephi About this time, D&C 14 was given for David Whitmer. 9 1 Nephi About this time, D&C 18 was received (compare 18:20, church of the devil, with 1 Ne. 14:10) Nephi Copyright form was filed in United States District Court for the Northern District of New York, using the full title page as the title of the book on the copyright form.* 12 1 Nephi Nephi Sun. Oliver wrote to Hyrum.* His letter used some words similar to those in 2 Ne. 9:21 23; Mosiah 5:9 10; and Moro. 8. About this time, David and Peter Whitmer Jr. were baptized Nephi Nephi Nephi Nephi Nephi Nephi Sun. About this time, Oliver Cowdery composed the Articles of the Church of Christ. This document quotes extensively, verbatim, from the Original Manuscript of 3 Ne. 9:15 16, 18; 11:23 27, 32, 39 40; 18:22, 28 33; 27:8 10, 20; Moro. 3:1 4; 4:1 2; 5:1 2; 6:6; and also from D&C 18:4, 22 25, 31, Nephi About this time, D&C 17 was received, authorizing Oliver, David, and Martin to obtain a view of the plates (17:2; compare 2 Ne. 27:12) Nephi About this time, the manifestation of Moroni was given to the Three Witnesses, as prompted by the translation of 2 Ne. 27: Jacob Jacob Jacob Enos and Jarom

25 June 28 Omni and Sun. Words of Mormon 29 In Manchester, New York.* About this time, the Eight Witnesses were shown the plates. 30 By this date, the translation was finished.* About this time, the testimonies of the Three and the Eight Witnesses were written. July About this time, the preface to the 1830 edition of the Book of Mormon was written. It uses at least nine phrases found in the title page or in D&C 10. *Bolded texts give historically documentable details. For historical documentation, see pp All other dates are estimates, assuming a relatively consistent rate of translation. Royal Skousen, The Book of Mormon: The Earliest Text, has 269,510 words in the original Book of Mormon text. The number of days allotted for the translation of each book in the Book of Mormon corresponds proportionally with the percentage of total words contained in each book, except for Sundays, for which fewer words were counted. Large Plates Small Plates words percent words percent Mosiah 31, Nephi 25, Alma 85, Nephi 29, Helaman 20, Jacob 9, Nephi 28, Enos 1, Nephi 1, Jarom Mormon 9, Omni 1, Ether 16, Words of Mormon Moroni 6, Title Page Maximum number of possible days available for the translation of the Book of Mormon from April 7 to June 30: Mosiah Moroni: 53 days 1 Nephi Words of Mormon: 21 days Total: 74 days