Honorable Lynne Abraham. District Attorney

Transcription

1 Honorable Lynne Abraham District Attorney

2 Section VI Appendix Table of Contents A. Catalogue of Sexually Abusive Priests B. List of Assignments of Sexually Abusive Priests C. Archdiocese Priest Biographical Profiles D. Selected documents E. Glossary of terms F. Articles from other jurisdictions

3 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Avery Edward V. Ordained: Late 1970s Twelve year old male Assistant Pastor, St. Philip Neri, Pennsburg (2/76-9/78) - In November 1992, Rev. Avery underwent a psychological evaluation at St. John Vianney Hospital. - In August 1993, Rev. Avery resigned as Pastor at St. Therese of the Child Jesus, Philadelphia and was placed on Health Leave for four months. - He was then assigned as Chaplain at Nazareth Hospital from 12/93 to 12/03. - The Review Board found the allegations credible. - On , the Archdiocese decreed Rev. Avery to be in violation of the policy against the sexual abuse of minors and he was placed on Administrative Leave as of Rev. Avery is currently deciding between involuntary or voluntary laicization. A-1

4 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Bolesta Michael C. Ordained: male teenagers, mostly between 16 to 17 years old Parochial Vicar, SS. Philip/James, Exton (6/89-8/91) - Rev. Bolesta underwent a psychological evaluation at St. Luke Institute in August Rev. Bolesta was assigned as Resident Priest at Immaculate Conception, Philadelphia until June Rev. Bolesta was assigned as Parochial Vicar at St. Agatha/St. James in Philadelphia; his duties included Chaplain of Children s Hospital of Philadelphia and the University of Pennsylvania. (6/92-10/94) - He was then assigned as Chaplain, Pastoral Care Services, Holy Redeemer Health Systems from 10/94 to 1/04. Died January 2, A-2

5 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Brennan Robert L. Ordained: November year old male Pastor, St. Ignatius, Yardley (6/88-1/89) St. Pius X High School Students March male seventh graders from St. Mary s Elementary School Not specified Seventh grade male student at St. Mary s and former altar server Pastor, St. Mary, Schwenksville (9/89-6/90) Pastor, St. Mary, Schwenksville (9/89-6/90) Pastor, St. Mary, Schwenksville (9/89-6/90) - On , Rev. Brennan was admitted to a hospital for a psychological evaluation. - In January 1989, Rev. Brennan was assigned as Resident Priest, St. Eleanor, Collegeville. None None - In July 1992, Rev. Brennan underwent a psychological evaluation to be followed by outpatient therapy. - Rev. Brennan was on Health Leave from September 1992 until December Not specified Inappropriate behavior with eighth grade males Parochial Vicar, Resurrection of Our Lord, Philadelphia (12/93-6/04) None On , the Archdiocese accepted the Review Board s recommendation that while the allegations against Rev. Brennan were credible, they do not rise to the level of sexual abuse as defined by the Essential Norms. A-3

6 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Brennan Robert L. Ordained: On , Rev. Brennan was informed of the Review Board s findings that they had found evidence of inappropriate behavior and certain restrictions were imposed on his ministry. - On , Rev. Brennan was assigned as Chaplain, Camilla Hall, Immaculata. A-4

7 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Broughan Leonard W. (O. Carm.) Ordained: Not specified Began in Not specified An Archdiocesan official told Msgr. McGroarty to have the complainants of whom he became aware contact the Archdiocese Male Roman Catholic H.S. student - Faculty, Roman Catholic H.S., Philadelphia (6/68-6/78) - Residence at St. Philip Neri, Philadelphia (9/72-6/78) The Archdiocese required the complainant to address the abuse with the Carmelites even though Rev. Broughan was an Archdiocesan priest when it occurred. Died December 24, A-5

8 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Brugger Craig F. Ordained: No complainant priest was receiving pornographic material - Principal, St. James Catholic H.S. for Boys, Chester (6/86-6/93) - Residence at St. John Chrysostom, Wallingford (9/89-6/93) - Rev. Brugger agreed to get rid of his pornographic material. - Msgr. Jagodzinski allowed Rev. Brugger to remain in his current assignment contingent on seeking counseling. A-6

9 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Brugger Craig F. Ordained: year old male Assistant Pastor, St. Ann, Phoenixville (6/73-6/76) Administrative Leave as of On , Rev. Brugger was placed on Administrative Leave. Rev. Brugger was admitted to St. John Vianney Hospital for a psychological evaluation. - The Review Board found the allegations credible. - On , the Archdiocese removed Rev. Brugger from active ministry. The case was being referred to the Vatican for review of laicization. A-7

10 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Brzyski James J. Ordained: Summer Rev. Brzyski was noted to spend a lot of time with one particular family (as much as 2 to 3 times/day) year old boy, between 5 th & 6 th grades Assistant Pastor, St. John the Evangelist, Morrisville (6/77-8/81) On , Rev. Graf met with the complainant s parents. Not specified twelve to thirteen year old boys Assistant Pastor, St. John the Evangelist, Morrisville (6/77-8/81) - On , Rev. Graf met with Rev. Brzyski. - On , Rev. Brzyski left active ministry and his priestly faculties were withdrawn. Not specified males Not specified - It does not appear that the Archdiocese took immediate action. In June 1986, the Archdiocese tried to contact Rev. Brzyski regarding his intention to return to ministry. - Rev. Brzyski failed to reply. However, the Archdiocese was notified that he was teaching in Metuchen, NJ in September A-8

11 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Brzyski James J. Ordained: Early 1980s (Date of mtg. with Arch) Male altar server Assistant Pastor, St. Cecilia, Philadelphia (8/81-8/84) The complainant was interviewed by the Archdiocese and offered financial assistance with counseling costs. Early 1980s Fifth grade altar boy Began in Eleven year old altar boy Assistant Pastor, St. Cecilia, Philadelphia (8/81-8/84) Assistant Pastor, St. Cecilia, Philadelphia (8/81-8/84) The Victim Assistance Coordinator s Office interviewed the complainant and offered him financial assistance with counseling costs. On , the Archdiocese found the allegations credible, imposed restrictions on Rev. Brzyski s priestly ministry and referred the case to the Vatican for review of laicization. On , the Archdiocese notified Bishop Francis DiLorenzo that Rev. Brzyski was residing in the Diocese of Richmond, Virginia with restricted priestly faculties. A-9

12 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Cannon John A. Ordained: Early 1960s male teenagers - Faculty, Roman Catholic H.S., Philadelphia (9/58-6/63) - Residence, St. Monica, Philadelphia (9/58-6/63) Late 1950s to early 1960s Abuse began in 1958 July males - Faculty, Roman Catholic H.S., Philadelphia (9/58-6/63) - Residence, St. Monica, Philadelphia (9/58-6/63) Previously identified male victim contacts Archdiocese about his abuse - Faculty, Roman Catholic H.S., Philadelphia (9/58-6/63) - Residence, St. Monica, Philadelphia (9/58-6/63) - The Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Cannon and he was ordered to desist. - Rev. Cannon was transferred as Assistant Pastor to St. Eugene, Primos. - The Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Cannon and he was ordered to desist. - Rev. Cannon was transferred as Assistant Pastor to St. Eugene, Primos. - The Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Cannon. - Rev. Cannon underwent a psychological evaluation at the St. John Vianney Hospital in February Retired as of The Review Board found the allegations credible. - On , the Archdiocese found the allegations to be credible, imposed restrictions on Rev. Cannon s ministry and referred the case to the Vatican for review of laicization. -On , Rev. Cannon agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. A-10

13 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Catullo Pasquale R. Ordained: Not specified Junior female Archbishop Kennedy High School student - Faculty, Archbishop Kennedy High School, Conshohocken (6/64-6/69) - Residence, SS. Cosmas/Damian, Conshohocken (9/68-2/69) - In June 1969, Rev. Catullo was assigned to the faculty of St. John Neumann H.S. with residence at St. Magdalen DePazzi in Philadelphia. - Pastor Emeritus, Annunciation B.V.M., Philadelphia as of On , Rev. Catullo agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. - On , the Review Board found the allegations against Rev. Catullo to be credible. A-11

14 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Chambers Gerard W. Ordained: or Altar boy Assistant Pastor, Seven Dolors, Wyndmoor (9/59-10/60) - The Archdiocese interviewed the complainant. - The Archdiocese tried to retrieve records on Rev. Chambers. - Msgr. Lynn found the allegations highly possible based on a review of Rev. Chambers assignments, which included seven separate Health Leaves. - The complainant was offered a check in the amount of $6,890 for past therapy costs in return for a signed release form. 1950s brothers, all altar boys between years old Assistant Pastor, St. Gregory s, Philadelphia (7/57-9/59) The Archdiocese offered the complainants assistance with counseling. Late 1950s Fourteen year old male Not specified Altar boy Assistant Pastor, St. Gregory s, Philadelphia (7/57-9/59) Rev. Chambers was already deceased when the Archdiocese received the complaint. Rev. Chambers was already deceased when the Archdiocese received the complaint Died December 2, A-12

15 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Cochrane Richard J. (OSA) 1 Ordained: Fourteen year old teenage male (former Malvern Preparatory student) Resident Priest, Malvern Preparatory School, Faculty Residence (3/95-5/00) - On , Rev. Cochrane was arrested for a complaint filed by a former Malvern Preparatory School student. - On , Rev. Cochrane was sentenced to 1 ½ to 4 years for the sexual assault of a fourteen-yearold Malvern Preparatory student. 1 It was noted within the file that another student alleged that he was assaulted by Rev. Cochrane in spring of 1990, but was never identified. A-13

16 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Connor John P. 2 Archdiocese extern priest Assigned as following removal from active ministry in Camden Diocese for sexual abuse of minor boy. Prior to Philadelphia, assigned to Diocese of Pittsburgh. Assistant Pastor, St. Matthew Church, Conshohocken (10/88-9/93) In August 1993, Rev. Connor was transferred back to the Diocese of Camden. Rev. Connor was appointed as Hospital Chaplain of Bridgeton/Millville Hospitals with residence at Immaculate Conception Church in Bridgeton, NJ. Rev. Connor retired in the Diocese of Camden, New Jersey in Archbishop Bevilacqua who was Bishop of the Diocese of Pittsburgh accepted Rev. Connor into that Diocese in September 1985 and then allowed Rev. Connor to transfer to the Archdiocese of Philadelphia in October A-14

17 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Coonan James J. Ordained: Summer of 1966 or Fourteen year old male Assistant Pastor, Queen of the Universe, Levittown (6/65-6/70) - In January 2002, Rev. Coonan s priestly faculties were restricted to private Mass. - In March 2002, Rev. Coonan underwent a psychological evaluation at the St. John Vianney Hospital. - Retired, Villa St. Joseph as of Coonan James J. Ordained: Summer of 1966 or Fifteen year old male Assistant Pastor, Queen of the Universe, Levittown (6/65-6/70) - In January 2002, Rev. Coonan s priestly faculties were restricted to private Mass. - In March 2002, Rev. Coonan underwent a psychological evaluation at the St. John Vianney Hospital. - Retired, Villa St. Joseph as of On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Coonan s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. - On , Rev. Coonan agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. A-15

18 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Cudemo Nicholas V. Ordained: Parishioner of St. Stanislaus (Female junior from Lansdale Catholic H.S.) Assistant Pastor, St. Stanislaus, Lansdale (6/63-6/68) Female teenager - Faculty, Archbishop Kennedy H.S., Conshohocken (2/69-6/73) - Residence at Sts. Cosmas and Damian, Conshohocken (2/69-9/69) June 1975 to Fifteen year old female Cardinal Dougherty H.S. student - Faculty, Cardinal Dougherty H.S., Philadelphia (6/ ) - Residence at St. Titus, Norristown (11/71-9/77) None Rev. Cudemo s residence was moved to St. Helena s. - Rev. Cudemo was changed from high school to parish work. - Rev. Cudemo was assigned as Assistant Pastor, St. Mary Magdalen DePazzi, Philadelphia in September Teenaged female student (Cardinal Dougherty High School) female students ranging from grade to high school - Faculty, Cardinal Dougherty H.S., Philadelphia (6/ ) - Residence at St. Titus, Norristown (11/71-9/77) - Assistant Pastor, St. Stanislaus, Lansdale (6/63-6/68) - Faculty, St. John Neumann High School, Philadelphia (6/68-2/69) - Faculty, Archbishop - Rev. Cudemo was recommended for a psychological evaluation, but never received it. - Rev. Cudemo was assigned as Pastor at St. Callistus, Philadelphia in June Rev. Cudemo was directed to undergo a psychological evaluation. The Archdiocese told Rev. Cudemo that his current assignment would not be changed. A-16

19 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Cudemo Nicholas V. Ordained: Early 1970s Not notified Female Junior at Archbishop Prendergast H.S. Female Sophomore at Archbishop Kennedy H.S Fifth grade female student from St. Irenaeus Kennedy H.S., Conshohocken (2/69-6/73) - Residence, SS. Cosmas, Damien, Conshohocken (2/69-9/69) - Residence, St. Helena, Center Square (9/69-11/71) - Residence at St. Titus, Norristown (11/71-9/77) - Faculty, Cardinal Dougherty H.S., Philadelphia (6/73-9/77) - Faculty, Archbishop Kennedy H.S., Conshohocken (2/69-6/73) - Residence, SS. Cosmas, Damien, Conshohocken (2/69-9/69) - Residence, St. Helena, Center Square (9/69-11/71) - Residence at St. Titus, Norristown (11/71-9/77) Assistant Pastor, St. Irenaeus, Philadelphia (1/82-6/87) - Rev. Cudemo was not removed from his current assignment and his priestly faculties were not suspended. Rather, he underwent two psychological evaluations. Rev. Cudemo refused the directives of the Cardinal to undergo inpatient hospitalization and residence at Immaculate Conception. - On , Rev. Cudemo retired in Abington, PA. None: Rev. Cudemo was allowed to continue to assist in Archdiocesan parishes. A-17

20 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Cudemo Nicholas V. Ordained: July Female Cardinal Dougherty H.S. students - Faculty, Cardinal Dougherty H.S., Philadelphia (6/ ) - Residence at St. Titus, Norristown (11/71-9/77) Unknown - In March 2002, Rev. Cudemo was told to restrict his priestly faculties to private Mass. - On , the Archdiocese found the allegations to be credible, imposed restrictions on Rev. Cudemo s ministry and referred the case to the Vatican for review of laicization. - Rev. Cudemo is contesting efforts to laicize him. A-18

21 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Delli Carpini John J. Ordained: Thirteen year old male rectory worker Not specified, abuse occurred for four years before the priest entered the seminary Nine year old male - Assistant Pastor, St. Luke the Evangelist, Glenside (6/76-8/79) - Assistant Pastor, St. John the Evangelist, Philadelphia (8/79-6/82) - Faculty, Roman Catholic H.S., Philadelphia (6/ ) - Residence, St. Monica, Philadelphia (9/82-6/86) The sexual abuse allegedly occurred before Rev. Delli Carpini entered the seminary. - Rev. Delli Carpini was placed on a six month Leave of Absence in March He underwent a psychological evaluation at St. John Vianney Hospital. - In September 1998, Rev. Delli Carpini was assigned as Chaplain at St. Cabrini and was also assigned part-time to Archdiocese headquarters. - Rev. Delli Carpini was removed from his position as Chaplain at St. Francis Cabrini Home, Senior Sisters Residence. - Rev. Delli Carpini was placed on Administrative Leave on On , Rev. Delli Carpini was informed that the Vatican decided to remove him from ministry. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Delli Carpini s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. A-19

22 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER DePaoli Edward M. Ordained: Child pornography material was confiscated from Rev. DePaoli s room at Holy Martyrs parish in Oreland, PA - Faculty, Bishop McDevitt H.S., Wyncote (6/79-6/85) - Residence, Holy Martyrs, Oreland (6/80-6/85) On , Rev. DePaoli was admitted to a treatment facility. His priestly faculties were removed and suspended Arrested and indicted on one count of child pornography Found guilty on a child pornography charge and given one year s probation Seen buying and found possessing child pornography Residence at St. John Vianney Hospital, Downingtown (Treatment Center) (6/85-5/87) Residence at St. John Vianney Hospital, Downingtown (Treatment Center) (6/85-5/87) Residence at House of Affirmation in Hopedale, MA (5/87-1/88) Rev. DePaoli was treated at a facility and his priestly faculties were still suspended. Rev. DePaoli was treated at a facility and his priestly faculties were still suspended. Rev. DePaoli was released from the House of Affirmation on He was assigned to St. John Vianney Church in Colonia, NJ for approximately three years and four months. He was allowed to return to active ministry in the Archdiocese of Philadelphia on as Parochial Vicar of St. John the Baptist, Philadelphia. A-20

23 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER DePaoli Edward M. Ordained: May Receiving pornographic material in the mail addressed to St. John the Baptist Rectory May Rev. DePaoli was receiving inappropriate magazines at St. Gabriel s Fourteen year old female Parochial Vicar, St. John the Baptist, Philadelphia (7/91-12/92) Residence, St. Gabriel Rectory, Stowe Assistant Pastor, Our Lady of Mt. Carmel, Doylestown (6/70-6/75) - Msgr. Lynn directed Rev. DePaoli to stop receiving questionable items in the mail. In December 1992, his current assignment was suspended and he was reassigned to Residence at Immaculate Conception in Philadelphia. Rev. DePaoli was placed on Administrative Leave on and his faculties were restricted to private Mass unless permission granted by Secretary for Clergy. - Administrative Leave as of The Archdiocese interviewed Rev. DePaoli. His priestly faculties were still restricted. - The Stradley Ronon Law Firm reported the sexual abuse complaint to the District Attorney of Bucks County in July In December 2002, Rev. DePaoli was removed from residence at St. Gabriel s. - On , the Archdiocese found the allegations credible, imposed restrictions on Rev. DePaoli s priestly ministry and referred the case to the Vatican for review of laicization. A-21

24 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER DePaoli Edward M. Ordained: On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. DePaoli s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. - On , Rev. DePaoli was informed that the Vatican s action to remove him from the clerical state could not be appealed. He was offered financial support from the Archdiocese until March A-22

25 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Donofrio Michael J. Ordained: Male teenaged parish worker Assistant Pastor, St. Thomas Aquinas, Philadelphia (6/81-6/86) - On , Rev. Donofrio was relieved of his duties in Peru. - Rev. Donofrio s last assignment ended in the Diocese of Abancay, Peru on On , Msgr. Lynn wrote to Rev. Donofrio who was working in Apurimac, Peru. Rev. Donofrio was requested to return to Philadelphia for a psychological evaluation. - On , Msgr. Lynn requested from Bishop Ribera that Rev. Donofrio be relieved of his priestly duties in Peru. - The current location of Rev. Donofrio is unknown. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Donofrio s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. A-23

26 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Dougherty William J. Ordained: Not specified Female high school student Not specified - Administrative Leave as of The Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Dougherty. - On , the Archdiocese approved the Review Board s recommendation that allegation of sexual abuse of minors was credible. - On , Rev. Dougherty was informed that the Archdiocese found the allegations credible, imposed restrictions on his priestly ministry and referred the case to the Vatican for review of laicization. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on his priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. - On , Rev. Dougherty wrote to the Vatican to request voluntary laicization. A-24

27 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Dowling Philip J. Ordained: s and 11 year old sisters - Assistant Pastor, Corpus Christi Philadelphia ( ) - Faculty, St. Charles Borromeo Seminary ( ) - The Archdiocese was informed of the allegations by the Philadelphia Inquirer on Msgr. Dowling had retired in July Msgr. Dowling admitted to the Philadelphia Inquirer reporter that he had molested one of the sisters. - He was suspended from ministry. On Administrative Leave pending Review Board Action. A-25

28 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Dunne Peter J. Ordained: Abuse began in 1958 Not specified Fourteen year old male students from St. Francis Vocational School - 1 male, age unknown - Faculty, Cardinal Dougherty H.S., Philadelphia (9/58-6/71) - Residence, St. Bartholomew, Philadelphia (9/58-6/67) - Residence, Camp Neumann, Jamison (9/67-9/74) Not specified - The Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Dunne. - On , Rev. Dunne resigned as Pastor of Sacred Heart, Oxford. - On , Rev. Dunne was placed on Sick Leave and resided at St. John Vianney Hospital. - The Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Dunne. - On , Rev. Dunne resigned as Pastor of Sacred Heart, Oxford. - On , Rev. Dunne was placed on Sick Leave and resided at St. John Vianney Hospital for 10 months then reassigned as Assistant Pastor to Nativity in Warminster. - Rev. Dunne retired on in Kintnersville, PA. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Dunne s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. Dunne Peter J. Ordained: On , Rev. Dunne agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. A-26

29 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Durkin Thomas J. Ordained: or or 1965 Eleven and twelve year old brothers Assistant Pastor, St. Charles Borromeo, Bensalem (6/64-6/65) None April 1965 April 1965 Male minor Assistant Pastor, St. Charles Borromeo, Bensalem (6/64-6/65) Between June 1965 and June 1966 Summer Fourteen year old altar boy brothers between the ages of 11 to 13 years old Not specified Eleven year old boy Male Unknown Assistant Pastor, Holy Savior, Linwood (6/65-6/66) Assistant Pastor, Holy Savior, Linwood (6/65-6/66) Assistant Pastor, Holy Spirit, Sharon Hill (6/66-12/66) Rev. Durkin was transferred to Holy Savior in Linwood as Assistant Pastor in June The Archdiocese questioned Rev. Durkin. He was sent to see a psychiatrist. The Victim Assistance Coordinator s Office offered assistance to the complainant. - Rev. Durkin left active ministry on On , the Archdiocese contacted Rev. Durkin in Hawaii, asking Rev. Durkin to respond in order to discuss his status with the Archdiocese to be determined by the Vatican. A-27

30 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Dux James M. Ordained: Not specified male minors one a seventh grade boy Found to possess inappropriate sexual material, including child pornography, confiscated and destroyed 1960s (just one) 2 Altar boys at St. Philip Neri Church Not specified Unknown eighth-grade boys and girls (altar servers) 1960s Male fifth grade altar server Assistant Pastor, St. Anthony of Padua, Ambler (6/74-2/75) Parochial Vicar, St. John the Baptist, Philadelphia (2/75-2/94) Assistant Pastor, St. Philip Neri Church, Lafayette Hill (5/60-6/65) Parochial Vicar, St. John the Baptist, Philadelphia (2/75-2/94) Assistant Pastor, St. Eugene, Primos (6/66-6/74) - The Archdiocese questioned Rev. Dux. - Rev. Dux was transferred to St. John the Baptist as Parochial Vicar in Philadelphia in February He was directed to seek a Catholic psychiatrist. The inappropriate sexual material was destroyed. None - In March 1994, Rev. Dux was encouraged by the Archdiocese to retire from active ministry. - Cardinal Bevilacqua approved Rev. Dux for retirement on at Villa St. Joseph. - The Archdiocese questioned Rev. Dux regarding the sexual abuse allegation. - On , Msgr. Lynn notified Rev. Dux that he was restricted to celebrating private Mass only and was not to have contact with children. A-28

31 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Dux James M. Ordained: Not specified Not specified Ten year old male Eight or nine year old male altar server Not specified Assistant Pastor, St. Eugene, Primos (6/66-6/74) Male altar server Parochial Vicar, St. John the Baptist, Philadelphia (2/75-2/94) Not specified Male altar server (sixth grade) Nine year old male Not specified The sexual abuse allegedly occurred while Rev. Dux was a summer houseguest at the complainant s family s home in Livonia, Michigan. Msgr. Lynn offered counseling services. Msgr. Lynn also offered to meet with the complainant in person. On , Msgr. Lynn reminded Rev. Dux that he was restricted to saying private Mass. Msgr. Lynn informed the complainant that Rev. Dux was not in active ministry. The complainant was also offered counseling services. Msgr. Lynn informed the complainant that Rev. Dux was retired and not in active ministry. On , Rev. Dux was notified that the Archdiocese found the allegations credible, imposed restrictions on his priestly ministry and referred the case to the Vatican for review of laicization. 3 Complainant indicated that he first spoke with the Archdiocese around April of 2002 regarding the complaint, although there is no documentation found in his file. A-29

32 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Dux James M. Ordained: On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on his priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. - On , Rev. Dux agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a life of prayer and penance. A-30

33 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Furmanski Leonard A. Ordained: May-June year old male altar server and helper at parish Pastor, St. Elizabeth Ann Seton, Bensalem (6/98-7/98) - On , the Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Furmanski. - In July 1999, Rev. Furmanski underwent a psychological evaluation. - On , Rev. Furmanski resigned from his current assignment. - On , Rev. Furmanski was reassigned as Chaplain, Nazareth Hospital Male freshman at Cardinal O Hara H.S. - Faculty, Cardinal O Hara H.S., Springfield (6/64-6/75) - Residence, St. Joseph, Aston (6/64-9/70) - Residence, Sacred Heart, Clifton Heights (9/70-6/75) - On , the Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Furmanski. - Rev. Furmanski underwent a psychological evaluation from to Left in assignment as Chaplain, Nazareth Hospital. A-31

34 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Furmanski Leonard A. Ordained: Male altar server Pastor, Sacred Heart, Swedesburg (6/77-6/89) Rev. Furmanski was placed on Administrative Leave on Late 1970 s (lasted two years) December year old girl Pastor, Sacred Heart, Swedesburg (6/77-6/89) - Rev. Furmanski had already been placed on Administrative Leave. - On , the Archdiocese accepted the Review Board s recommendation that the allegations were credible. - On , Rev. Furmanski was notified that the Archdiocese had found the allegations credible, imposed restrictions on his priestly ministry and referred the case to the Vatican for review of laicization. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Furmanski s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. 4 Victim testified before the Grand Jury. She later notified the Archdiocese. A-32

35 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Furmanski Leonard A. Ordained: On , Rev. Furmanski agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. - On , the Archdiocese notified Bishop Joseph Galante of the Diocese of Camden, NJ that Rev. Furmanski had been removed from ministry and was residing in his diocese. A-33

36 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Gallagher Francis J. Ordained: Arrested in Sea Isle City, New Jersey for soliciting an eighteen year old male and companion. Not specified teenage brothers Faculty, Cardinal Dougherty H.S., Philadelphia (9/89-6/91) Unknown - On , Rev. Gallagher was admitted to St. John Vianney Hospital. - On , Rev. Gallagher was transferred to another treatment facility, St. Luke Institute. - None - On , Rev. Gallagher was appointed as Associate Pastor at Immaculate Conception, Jenkintown. - Rev. Gallagher was in residential treatment at St. John Vianney Hospital from until Rev. Gallagher was placed on Administrative Leave on On , Rev. Gallagher petitioned for laicization. A-34

37 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Gallagher Francis J. Ordained: On , Rev. Gallagher withdrew his intention to petition for laicization and appointed a canonical advocate. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Gallagher s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. A-35

38 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Gallagher Joseph P. Ordained: Not specified Twelve year old boy Assistant Pastor, St. Monica s, Philadelphia (6/73-2/74) - Rev. Gallagher underwent inpatient therapy. - Rev. Gallagher was reassigned as Assistant Pastor, St. Joseph s in Aston in June Rev. Gallagher was on Administrative Leave on On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Gallagher s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. - On , Rev. Gallagher agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. A-36

39 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Gana Stanley M. Ordained: Thirteen year old male (Abuse lasted until the male was a St. Charles Borromeo seminarian) Abuse began when Rev. Gana was assigned as Assistant Pastor, Our Lady of Calvary, Philadelphia (6/80-12/84) year old male - Assistant Pastor, Ascension, Philadelphia (10/74-6/80) - Assistant Pastor, Our Lady of Calvary, Philadelphia (6/80-12/84) None - Rev. Gana underwent a psychological evaluation at St. John Vianney Hospital in November On , Rev. Gana resigned from his current assignment as Assistant Pastor at Our Mother of Sorrows parish. Rev. Gana was placed on Administrative Leave on 4/2/ year old male Assistant Pastor, Ascension, Philadelphia (10/74-6/80) - Rev. Gana was placed on Health Leave in December Rev. Gana was admitted to Southdown in February 1996 for inpatient treatment. - On , Cardinal Bevilacqua forwarded Rev. Gana s case to the Vatican. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Gana s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. A-37

40 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Gana Stanley M. Ordained: On , the Archdiocese notified Bishop Joseph Martino that Rev. Gana was residing in the Diocese of Scranton. - On , Rev. Gana agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. A-38

41 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Gausch Joseph P. Ordained: June Fourteen year old seventh grade male - St. Joseph s male student - Eighth grade boys Assistant Pastor, St. Joseph, Jim Thorpe (12/45-6/48) Early 1960s August 1964 Male minor Assistant Pastor, Our Lady of Peace, Milmont Park (5/61-8/64) Not specified Grade School boys Twelve year old altar boy - Altar boy Early 1980s Boy who worked at rectory Eighteen year old male Assistant Pastor, Queen of the Universe, Levittown (6/73-2/77) Pastor, Good Shepherd, Philadelphia (4/80-6/92) Pastor, Good Shepherd, Philadelphia (6/92-5/99) Assistant Pastor, St. Stanislaus, Lansdale (5/56-5/61) - Rev. Gausch was placed on Health Leave and was admitted to the Alexian Brothers Hospital in Oshkosh, Wisconsin in July Rev. Gausch was transferred to St. Bridget as Assistant Pastor in Philadelphia in August Rev. Gausch was transferred to St. Aloysius as Assistant Pastor in Pottstown in February The Archdiocese suggested, but did not enforce, psychiatric treatment. - Rev. Gausch was told that if no future scandal occurred, then he could be considered for pastoral appointment. - Rev. Gausch was questioned by the Secretary for Clergy, but allowed to remain at his current assignment as Pastor Emeritus, Good Shepherd. Rev. Gausch was already deceased when the complaint was received by the Archdiocese. Rev. Gausch was already deceased when the complaint was received by the Archdiocese. A-39

42 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Gausch Joseph P. Ordained: Altar boy Assistant Pastor, Our Lady of Peace, Milmont Park (5/61-8/64) Thirteen year old altar boy Assistant Pastor, St. Bridget, Philadelphia (5/56-5/61) Sixth grade boy Assistant Pastor, St. Stanislaus, Lansdale (5/56-5/61) Not specified Altar boy Assistant Pastor, St. Bridget, Philadelphia (5/56-5/61) Rev. Gausch was already deceased when the complaint was received by the Archdiocese. Rev. Gausch was already deceased when the complaint was received by the Archdiocese. Rev. Gausch was already deceased when the complaint was received by the Archdiocese. Rev. Gausch was already deceased when the complaint was received by the Archdiocese. Died May 30, A-40

43 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Giliberti Francis A. Ordained: Fifteen year old male (Cardinal O Hara H.S. Student) Seventeen year old male (Senior Cardinal O Hara H.S. Student) - Faculty, Cardinal O Hara High School, Springfield (6/73-6/78) - Residence, Nativity B.V.M., Media (9/73-2/87) - Faculty, Cardinal O Hara High School, Springfield (6/73-6/78) - Residence, Nativity B.V.M., Media (9/73-2/87) The Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Giliberti and directed him to undergo a psychological evaluation. - In October 2002, Rev. Giliberti underwent a psychological evaluation by Kelly Counseling and Consulting. - On , Rev. Giliberti requested to resign as Pastor of Nativity B.V.M. A-41

44 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Giliberti Francis A. Ordained: Late 1960 s teenage boys Not specified Rev. Giliberti already had restricted priestly faculties and was retired. - The Stradley Ronon Law Firm notified the Delaware County District Attorney s Office of the allegations. - On , the Archdiocese accepted Rev. Giliberti s resignation from Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary, Media. - On , Rev. Giliberti retired at Villa St. Joseph. - On , the Archdiocese found the allegations credible, imposed restrictions on Rev. Giliberti s priestly ministry and referred the case to the Vatican for review of laicization. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Giliberti s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. - On , Rev. Giliberti agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. A-42

45 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Gillespie John E. Ordained Two male altar servers who were brothers Twelve year old male Freshman male high school student and weekend sacristan Assistant Pastor, Immaculate Conception, Levittown (10/54-6/62) Pastor, Our Lady of Calvary, Philadelphia (6/85-6/00) Pastor, Our Lady of Calvary, Philadelphia (6/85-6/00) None None The Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Gillespie. He underwent a psychological evaluation at the St. John Vianney Hospital in February In June 2000, Rev. Gillespie was appointed Pastor Emeritus at Our Lady of Calvary. - In June 2000, he was also assigned Chaplain, Motherhouse Grey Nuns. Approximately around Fifteen year old male The complainant alleged that the incident occurred at Mother of Divine Providence parish (Rev. Gillespie assisting there). Rev. Gillespie was encouraged to retire. On , his assignment was terminated and his priestly faculties were restricted to private Mass. - Rev. Gillespie was placed on Administrative Leave at Villa St. Joseph on On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on his priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. - On , Rev. Gillespie agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. A-43

46 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Grumm Thomas J. Ordained: On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Grumm s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. - On , Rev. Grumm agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. A-45

47 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Grumm Thomas J. Ordained: Male Cardinal Dougherty H.S. student - Faculty, Cardinal Dougherty H.S., Philadelphia (6/77-6/87) - Residence, Nativity BVM, Philadelphia (8/85-6/87) - Faculty, Archbishop Kennedy H.S., Conshohocken (6/87-1/89) - Residence, St. Justin Martyr, Narberth (6/87-6/88) - In April 2002, the Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Grumm and placed him on Administrative Leave. - Rev. Grumm was admitted to St. John Vianney Hospital from April to November 2002 for treatment. - On , Cardinal Bevilacqua notified Bishop Harry Flynn of St. Paul, Minnesota that Rev. Grumm was residing in his diocese with restricted faculties. - On , Rev. Grumm was notified that the Archdiocese found the allegations credible, imposed restrictions on his priestly ministry and referred the case to the Vatican for review of laicization. A-44

48 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Henry James T. Ordained: Not specified 12/87 Fifteen year old female sophomore Cardinal O Hara H.S. student, Worker at Holy Cross rectory Assistant Pastor, Holy Cross, Springfield (6/85-12/87) In December 1987, Rev. Henry was transferred to Our Lady of Lourdes as Assistant Pastor, Philadelphia. He underwent a psychological evaluation in December He continued to receive psychological treatment. - On , Rev. Henry was informed that the Archdiocese found the allegations credible, imposed restrictions on his priestly ministry and referred the case to the Vatican for review of laicization. - On , Rev. Henry agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. A-46

49 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Hermley Robert J. (OSFS) Ordained: (Wilmington, Delaware) Fourteen year old boy - Thirteen year old boy Early 1980s Ten or eleven year old male Padua Academy, Wilmington, Delaware ( ) Our Lady of Perpetual Help, Seaside Heights, New Jersey ( ) - Arrested watching pornographic film with thirteen-year-old boy and fourteen-year old boy in parked car. 19 pornographic magazines confiscated from car. - Rev. Hermley was released into the custody of Rev. J. Stuart Dooling, OSFS, Provincial of the Oblates. Johns Hopkins University medical doctors determined that Rev. Hermley did not need help. He received three years probation for the 1982 incident. On , Rev. Dooling assigned him to a parish in Vienna, Virginia. This sexual abuse was reported to Rev. Bill Davis, OSFS by the complainant s mother. The Oblates handled this sexual abuse allegation. A-47

50 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Hermley Robert J. (OSFS) Ordained: (Wilmington, Delaware) Thirteen year old boy Father Judge High School for Boys, Philadelphia ( ) The Archdiocese was going to contact the unidentified complainant through his e- mail address. The Provincial of the Oblates, Rev. Joseph Morrisey, OSFS was to be contacted by the Archdiocese. Archdiocesan employee, Karen Becker felt that the DA s Office and law enforcement should be contacted also. Currently residing at the DeSales Center in Childs, Maryland. A-48

51 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Iannarella James M. Ordained: May to August year old female from St. Joseph s Parochial Vicar, St. Joseph, Aston (6/96-10/99) - In September 1999, Rev. Iannarella underwent a psychological evaluation at St. John Vianney Hospital. He was to undergo outpatient treatment at St. John Vianney Hospital after his evaluation was completed. - He was relieved of his current assignment and his priestly faculties were restricted. - Rev. Iannarella was placed on Administrative Leave in October Left active ministry on September 24, A-49

52 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Jones Richard G. (GJ-1991) Ordained: s Sixteen year old male member of the Ephphatha Community Seventeen year old male member of the Ephphatha Community Faculty, Cardinal O Hara H.S., Springfield (9/70-6/87) - Rev. Jones took a Health Leave from 10/88 to 3/90 at St. John Vianney Hospital. - Rev. Jones took a Leave of Absence from 3/90 to 10/93. Some of this time was spent living in Florida. Left active ministry as of On , Cardinal Bevilacqua wrote to Bishop Robert Lynch that Rev. Jones was residing in his Diocese of St. Petersburg, Florida with restricted faculties. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Jones priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. - On , the Archdiocese wrote to Rev. Jones in St. Petersburg, Florida. He was requested to consider voluntary laicization. The Archdiocese offered a financial package for priests in this situation. A-50

53 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Joseph William T. Ordained: Late 1970 s Male fifth grader (rectory worker) Assistant Pastor, St. Martha, Philadelphia (6/76-9/80) - Rev. Joseph underwent a psychological evaluation at St. John Vianney Hospital in February On , he officially submitted his resignation as pastor of St. Elizabeth Ann Seton. The Archdiocese accepted this and appointed him as a retired priest on to Villa St. Joseph. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Joseph s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. On , Rev. Joseph agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. A-51

54 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Kohler Thomas M. Ordained: Male Assistant Pastor, Our Lady of Good Counsel, Southampton (9/72-6/77) - The Archdiocese directed Rev. Kohler that his current assignment was terminated and he was not to have any contact with the complainant. - In May 1994, he underwent a psychological evaluation at the St. John Vianney Hospital and sent to St. John Vianney Hospital for treatment. - Rev. Kohler was placed on Administrative Leave on June Fifteen yearold boy photographed by Kohler and other priest. Criminal charge brought 5 Resident Priest, St. Charles Borromeo, Bensalem (2/86-6/94) - He was not given a priestly assignment and his faculties were restricted to private Mass. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Kohler s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. 5 Rev. Kohler was charged with one count of obscenity in connection with William O Connell, a former Rhode Island cleric. O Connell was charged with sexually assaulting a boy and taking obscene pictures. A search warrant was issued and non-illegal pornographic tapes were confiscated from Rev. Kohler s home in the Villas, New Jersey. A-52

55 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Kornacki Matthew J. Ordained: Reported to Archdiocese that New York City police visited him concerning possessing and viewing child pornography. St. Charles Borromeo Seminary, Overbrook - Rev. Kornacki was placed on Administrative Leave on In July 2003, Rev. Kornacki was admitted to St. John Vianney Hospital for treatment. - On , Rev. Kornacki was indicted in federal court for possession of child pornography. - On , Rev. Kornacki was informed that the Archdiocese found the allegations credible, imposed restrictions on his priestly ministry and referred the case to the Vatican for review of laicization. A-53

56 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Kornacki Matthew J. Ordained: On , Rev. Kornacki pleaded guilty before U.S. District Judge R. Barclay Surrick on one count of violation of the federal statute for possession of child pornography. - On , the Archdiocese imposed further restrictions on Rev. Kornacki s priestly ministry and informed him that his name would not appear in the 2005 Catholic Directory. - On , Rev. Kornacki agreed to the removal of his priestly faculties, to forgo the Church penal process and to accept the imposition of a supervised life of prayer and penance. - On , Rev. Kornacki was sentenced to 30 months in federal prison plus a $6, fine. A-54

57 CATALOGUE OF SEXUALLY ABUSIVE S S NAME OF AT TIME OF AFTER Kostelnick Albert T. Ordained: Eight year old girl Pastor, St. Mark, Bristol (6/82-6/97) Young female Pastor, St. Mark, Bristol (6/82-6/97) None None Not specified unidentified sisters (8 th & 9 th graders) - Grade school female - Female rectory worker year old female rectory worker year old female rectory worker Pastor, St. Mark, Bristol (6/82-6/97) - Faculty, Cardinal Dougherty H.S., Philadelphia (9/56-6/82) - Residence, St. John of the Cross, Roslyn (9/56-6/82) - Faculty, Cardinal Dougherty H.S., Philadelphia (9/56-6/82) - Residence, St. John of the Cross, Roslyn (9/56-6/82) None - The Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Kostelnick on He underwent a four-day psychodiagnostic assessment at St. John Vianney Hospital. - He maintained his position as Senior Priest, Assumption B.V.M., Feasterville. - The Archdiocese interviewed Rev. Kostelnick on He was directed to receive counseling once a week. - On , Cardinal Bevilacqua granted him retirement status at Villa St. Joseph. A-55