INFERENCES LING106 KNOWLEDGE OF MEANING DOROTHY AHN SECTION 2 [2/12/2016]

INFERENCES LING106 KNOWLEDGE OF MEANING DOROTHY AHN SECTION 2 [2/12/2016]

WHAT DOES SEMANTICS DO FOR US? What does knowing meaning do for us? INFERENCES! ENTAILMENTS IMPLICATURES PRESUPPOSITIONS

ENTAILMENT A entails B if and only if in every situation that A is true, B is also true. For any situation s, if A is true, B must be true. To test A B: If it is possible for A to be true and B to be false, then A does NOT entail B. (1) John and Mary left. (2) John left.

ENTAILMENT (9) This is a nice table. (10) This has legs. (11) Jeff is a dog (12) Jeff barks. Lexical definitions are world-specific. In our world a table (usually) has legs and dogs bark. But what about w 2, w 3, etc.? [from handout 2/8]

ENTAILMENT (13) John killed Mary yesterday. (14) Mary was dead yesterday. John! STOP! :( [Luke] Mary s being dead at all time yesterday [Ryan] Entailment test works because (14) says there is no point in yesterday when Mary was dead. BUT! Also weird to say that (13) entails that there is no point in yesterday when Mary was alive. to be dead is a state to die is an achievement [from handout 2/8]

ASSIGNMENT 1 #1 (1a) You may have two cookies. (1b) You are not obliged to have two cookies. #2 (2a) If you flunk two courses, you have to pay a fee. (2b) If you flunk exactly two courses, you have to pay a fee. (3a) Mary or Peter will be hired. (3b) Either Mary or Peter, but not both, will be hired.

ENTAILMENT Entailment-based relations: SYNONYMY: entails each other (a) John is a year older than Mary. (b) Mary is a year younger than John. They are true and false in the same worlds [from handout 2/8]

ENTAILMENT Entailment-based relations: SYNONYMY: entails each other (a) John is a year older than Mary. (b) Mary is a year younger than John. They are true and in the same worlds TAUTOLOGY: always true Oracle bone inscription from the Shang Dynasty! [from handout 2/8]

SHANG ORACLE BONES (1200 1045 BCE) Oracle bone inscriptions: texts etched in tortoise plastrons or ox shoulder blades Represented questions asked of the gods Bone heated in a fire, then cracks interpreted

dīng mǎo bǔ ( ) Xuān zhēn yǔ (day names) crack (name) divine rain "(On) ding mao, cracks (were made), Xuan divined: (it will) rain."

bù qí yǔ not perhaps rain "Perhaps (it will) not rain."

ENTAILMENT Entailment-based relations: SYNONYMY: entails each other (a) John is a year older than Mary. (b) Mary is a year younger than John. They are true and in the same worlds TAUTOLOGY: always true Oracle bone inscription from the Shang Dynasty! (c) It will rain or it will not rain. p p is always true! [from handout 2/8]

ENTAILMENT Entailment-based relations: SYNONYMY: entails each other (a) John is a year older than Mary. (b) Mary is a year younger than John. They are true and in the same worlds TAUTOLOGY: always true Oracle bone inscription from the Shang Dynasty! (c) It will rain or it will not rain. p p is always true! CONTRADICTION: always false (d) It will rain and it will not rain. (p p) [from handout 2/8]

IMPLICATURE It will rain or it will not. Mary is Mary. WHY would Speaker say this to me? Grice 1967: We follow some normative principles of language use when talking to each other. We try to be cooperative Gricean Maxims: Quality: Say only what you believe to be true. Relevance: Be relevant. Quantity: Say as much as you can to be informative.

IMPLICATURE (3) You know, politics is politics. [Paul] Sometimes you use tautologies when you don t know what to say. Yes! Ignorance implicature (3) implies [S doesn t know what to say] (4) It will rain or it will not rain. (4) implies [S doesn t know whether it will rain]

IMPLICATURE To test A implicates B: You can cancel B. You can reinforce B without being redundant. (5) Some students passed the test. (6) It is not the case that all students passed. Some students passed the test. In fact, all students passed the test. YES Some students passed the test, and it is not the case that all students passed. YES

ASSIGNMENT 1 #1 (1a) You may have two cookies. (1b) You are not obliged to have two cookies. #2 (2a) If you flunk two courses, you have to pay a fee. (2b) If you flunk exactly two courses, you have to pay a fee. (3a) Mary or Peter will be hired. (3b) Either Mary or Peter, but not both, will be hired.

PRESUPPOSITION

PRESUPPOSITION A presupposes B iff B must be true for A to be asserted or denied felicitously. B must be true for A to have a truth value (to be true OR false). B is taken for granted when asserting A.

PRESUPPOSITION (5) The King of the USA is in New York. Presupposes: There is a King of the USA. In our world (w 0 ), there is no King of the USA: Presupposition failure (5) is not true; (5) is not false. You cannot say (5) is false because what is false is the presupposition that there is a King of the USA.

PRESUPPOSITION (5) The King of the USA is in New York. Presupposes: There is a King of the USA. [Luke] Depends on how flexible you are in interpreting the definite article the.

PRESUPPOSITION (5) The King of the USA is in New York. Presupposes: There is a King of the USA. [Luke] Depends on how flexible you are in interpreting the definite article the. (6) A King of the USA is in New York [[5]] = (there is a K.USA). HE is in NY. [[6]] = There is a K.USA if you go to NY.

PRESUPPOSITION Testing for presupposition: Projection If B is presupposed, B is background information. B has to hold for us to have any kind of felicitous conversation about A, which depends on B. P-Family: Asserting A: John stopped smoking. Negating A: John didn t stopped smoking. Asking A: Did John stop smoking? Conditionalizing A: If John stopped smoking, à In all cases, B (John used to smoke) is preserved!

PRESUPPOSITION [Sam & Athena] Is presupposed material also entailed? Entailment test: Contradiction to have A and ~B. Presupposition: Non-sense to have A and ~B. [Jenny] What is the difference?

PRESUPPOSITION [Sam & Athena] Is presupposed material also entailed? Entailment test: Contradiction to have A and ~B. Presupposition: Non-sense to have A and ~B. [Jenny] What is the difference? A B A p à B A & B A & ~B??? ~A & ~B???

(7) Only John is bringing beer. Presupposes: (7p) John is bringing beer. Entails: (7e) Others aren t. Let s test for contradiction/non-sense! [[7p]] [[7]] [[7p]] [[7]] [[7]] [[7e]] [[7]] [[7e]]

(7) Only John is bringing beer. Presupposes: (7p) John is bringing beer. Entails: (7e) Others aren t. Let s test for contradiction/non-sense! [[7p]] [[7]]??? [[7p]] [[7]]??? [[7]] [[7e]] F [[7]] [[7e]] T

PRESUPPOSITION Presupposition Triggers Factives John discovered that A. It is crazy/amazing that A. Operators John met the/his King. John jumped too/again. Aspectuals John stopped/continues smoking. Lexical meanings John scared Mary.

[Schwarz 2014]

NOT SO SIMPLE! (5) Is Mary about to give birth? [Kayla] (5) can be used to ask if Mary is pregnant. Kayla asks (5), and the hearer makes some inferences: Asking (5) seems to suggest that Kayla assumes it is background knowledge that Mary is pregnant. But it is not, because I m not good friends with Mary. Kayla knows that, so she probably doesn t assume that I know the answer. Then, it must be that she is implying that Mary has a big belly. I agree, and I will answer accordingly:

NOT SO SIMPLE! (5) Is Mary about to give birth? [Kayla] (5) can be used to ask if Mary is pregnant. Kayla asks (5), and the hearer makes some inferences: Asking (5) seems to suggest that Kayla assumes it is background knowledge that Mary is pregnant. But it is not, because I m not good friends with Mary. Kayla knows that, so she probably doesn t assume that I know the answer. Then, it must be that she is implying that Mary has a big belly. I agree, and I will answer accordingly: H: Yea, right?