DIRECTIONS IN DEVELOPMENT Finance Economic Development and Islamic Finance Zamir Iqbal and Abbas Mirakhor, Editors ß THE WORLD BANK Washington, D.C.
Contents Foreword Acknowledgments Contributors Abbreviations %% xüi xv xix Overview 1 Views on Economic Development 3 The Islamic Concept of Economic Development 5 Summary of Chapters 10 References 22 PART 1 Theoretical Foundation 23 Chapter 1 Chapter 2 Epistemological Foundation of Finance: Islamic and Conventional 25 Abbas Mirakhor and Wang Yong Bao An Ideal Conventional Financial System 26 An Ideal Islamic Finance System 31 Achieving the Ideal: Uncertainty, Risk, and Equity Markets 41 Summary and Conclusion 53 References 57 Background Reading 60 Islamic Finance Revisited: Conceptual and Analytical Issues firom the Perspective of Conventional Economics 67 Andrew Sheng and Ajit Singh Introduction 67 The Central Tenet of Islamic Finance: Absolute Prohibition against Interest Rates 69 Ethical Foundations of Islamic Finance 76 Modigliani and Miller Theorems 78 Risk Sharing, Risk Shifting, and the Risks of Bankruptcy 81 The Stock Market and Islamic Finance 82
vi Contents Interim Summary of the Main Rindings and Two Further Questions 83 Islamic Finance and Economic Development 85 The Real Challenge of Islamic Finance 86 Conclusion 87 Notes 88 References 88 Chapter 3 The Foundational Market Principles of Islam, Knightian Uncertainty, and Economic Justice 93 S. Nuri Erba and Abbas Mirakhor Introduction 93 The Foundational Islamic Market Principles 97 Knightian Uncertainty and the Islamic View of Uncertainty 99 Institutional Development, Trust, and Uncertainty 101 Islamic Contracts and Risk Sharing 106 Research Agenda for Islamic Economics: A Proposal 118 Concluding Remarks 119 Notes 120 References 125 PART 2 Developmental Aspects 131 Chapter 4 Finance and Development in Islam: A Historical Perspective and a Brief Look Forward 133 Murat Qzakga Introduction 133 Basic Characteristics of an Islamic Economy and Finance 134 Implementation. 135 Historical Evidence 136 Stagnation and Decline 141 Relevance for Today: What Needs to Be Done? 143 Conclusion 145 Notes 146 References 147 Chapter 5 Economic Development in Islam 151 Hossein Askari The Evolution of Western Thinking on Development 152 Economic Development in Islam 158 Concluding Comments 175 Notes 175 References 176 Economic Development and Islamic Finance http://dx.cloi.org/10.1596/978-0-8213-9953-8
Contents vi! Chapter 6 Islam's Perspective on Financial Inclusion 179 Zamir Iqbal and Abbas Mirakhor What Is Financial Inclusion and Why Is It Important? 181 Issues with the Conventional Approach to Financial Inclusion 183 The Concept of Financial Inclusion in Islam 185 Redistributive Instruments of Islam 188 Public Policy Implications 191 Government as the Risk Manager Promoting Risk Sharing 192 Need for Developing a Supportive Institutional Framework 193 Institutionalization of Islamic Redistributive Instruments 195 Conclusion 198 Notes 199 References 200 Chapter 7 Financial Inclusion and Islamic Finance: Organizational Formats, Products, Outreach, and Sustainability 203 Habib Ahmed Introduction 203 Inclusive Finance: Scope and Constraints 205 Islamic Finance and Inclusive Finance 209 Islamic Inclusive Finance: An Overview and Comparison 213 Organizational Formats, Services, Outreach, and Sustainability 220 Conclusion 224 Notes 225 References 226 Chapter 8 Theory and Instruments of Social Safety Nets and Social Insurance in Islamic Finance: Takaful and Ta'min 231 Kamaruddin Sharif and Wang Yong Bao Islamic Social Safety Nets 232 The Institutional Framework of Social Safety Nets in Islam 234 The Concept of Social Security in Islam 239 Social Insurance: Takaful and Ta'min 241 Takaful in Practice 245 Conclusion 248 Notes 248 References 249 Chapter 9 Islamic Capital Markets and Development 253 ObtyathuUa Ismath Bacha and Abbas Mirakhor Introduction 253
viii Contents Are Capital Markets Necessary? 253 Issues Concerning Capital Markets 255 Concept of Islamic Capital Markets 257 Equity and Sukuk Markets in an Islamic Capital Market 260 The Reality of Capital Markets in the Muslim World 268 Concluding Remarks: Implementing the Risk-Sharing Framework 270 Notes 272 References 272 Chapter 10 Islamic Stock Markets in a Global Context 275 Andrew Sheng and Ajit Singh Introduction 275 Do Stock Markets Help Economic Development? 278 Lessons for Islamic Stock Markets 280 Stock Markets and Economic Efficiency: Further Lessons for Islamic Stock Markets 284 Issues of Globalization and of Long-Term Growth for Islamic Stock Markets 289 Conclusion 291 Notes 292 References 293 PART 3 Policy Formulation 297 Chapter 11 A Survey of the Economic Development of OIC Countries 299 Hossein Askari and Scheherazade Rehman Introduction 299 Fundamental Islamic Economic Doctrines 300 The Performance of OIC Countries 306 Concluding Remarks on Islam and Economic Performance and Prosperity 317 Notes 322 References 323 Chapter 12 Islam and Development: Policy Challenges 325 Azura Othman and Abbas Mirakhor Introduction 325 The Islamic Economy and the Role of the State 326 Policy Tools in Macroeconomic Management 328 Policy Instruments in an Islamic Economy 332 Challenges in Policy Implementation 338 Summary 342 Notes 343 References 344
Contents ix Glossary of Arabic Terms 345 Boxes 0.1 Basic Principles of an Islamic Economic and Financial System 4 12.1 The Malaysian Financial Services Master Plan (2001-10) and the Malaysian Financial Sector Blueprint (2011-20) 341 Figures 0.1 Growth of Islamic Banking and Conventional Banking Assets in Selected Countries, 2006-10 2 0.2 Total Sukuk Issuance, 2002-12 3 7.1 The Basic Structure oftakaful Models 212 8.1 Dynamics of Poverty Reduction 247 11.1 U.N. Human Development Index (HDI) Trends 307 11.2 U.N. Education Index 308 11.3 Gender Inequality 309 11.4 U.N. Health Index 310 11.5 U.N. Income (Wealth) Index 311 11.6 Gini Coefficient 312 11.7 Poverty 313 11.8 Environment Index, 2010 314 12.1 A Transmission Mechanism in a Conventional Economy 330 12.2 A Transmission Mechanism in an Islamic Economy 338 Tables 0.1 Total Islamic Banking Assets 2 3.1 Banking Crises in Predominantly Muslim and Non-Muslim Countries, 1800-2008 110 7.1 Organizational Types and Services Provided 222 7.2 Criteria Used to Rank Outreach and Sustainability 223 7.3 Outreach of Different Organization 223 7.4 Sustainability of Different Organizations 223 7.5 Inclusive Finance, Outreach, and Sustainability 223 8.1 Increase in Regional Growth Rates in Takaful, 2010-11 245 10.1 Financing of Corporate Growth in 19 Developing Economies and 22 Advanced Economies, 1995-2000 282 11.1 Overall Islamicity Index Rank by Economy 315 11.2 Summary Results of the Islamicity Index (I 2 ) by Country Subgroup 318 11.3 Economic Islamicity Index (EI 2 ) Rankings by Economy 318 11.4 Economic Islamicity (El 2 ) Index Ranking Averages of All Countries and Various Subgroups 321