History 213 Spring 2016 Gender in Jewish History Tuesdays and Thursdays, 9:00 10:20 Allbritton 103 Prof. Rachel Greenblatt rgreenbatt@wesleyan.edu Albritton 203 Office Hours: Tuesdays and Thursdays, 10:30 11:30 And by appointment (including evening hours by Skype or telephone) Investigation of the traditionally "effeminized" image of the Jewish male, and reactions against that image, have played a critical role in interpretations of modern Jewish culture as diverse as the often misogynist outlook of the eighteenth century German Jewish Enlightenment, the muscular Zionist pioneer, and the chic nerd of Dustin Hoffman's graduate. The Jewish female has been viewed as both powerless and oppressed on the one hand, overbearing and unbearably controlling on the other. This introductory survey of ideal and real gender roles throughout Jewish history, with particular focus on medieval to modern Europe and North America, provides historical background and research tools to assess and contextualize claims such as these and to think about ways in which gender categories have structured society in general and Jewish societies in particular. Major threads of discussion through the course will include the following. For each, we will examine, at different times both primary source and scholars differing viewpoints: *Ideal images: How did Jews and non Jews in different times and places envision the ideal Jewish male and Jewish female? Ideal here could mean an image one strives to attain, or it could be an ideal type, as in a non differentiated view of a Jewish Other. *Lived lives: How did Jewish women and men actually live their lives? How do these lived lives compare with ideal images, and how do the two affect one another? *The challenge of silence: how can we uncover women s own viewpoints when, throughout most of history, their voices were so rarely recorded. *Why it matters: How does gender analysis alter our view of a variety of questions in Jewish history, including those that may not appear, at first glance, to have anything to do with history?
2 Student Responsibilities. Students are expected to attend class regularly and to complete the following requirements. Percentages for each give a general idea of how grades will be calculated, but improvement over the course of the semester may also be figured in. Late papers will be graded down, usually 1 point (1% of total course grade) per unexcused day late. In general, papers are assignments are graded on a point scale. For example, an assignment with 15% of the course grade is given a mark from 1 to 15. This eases calculation of the final grade. *Participation in class and in web site discussions. Online forum will be posted for each class, providing a space to respond to class readings, raise questions about them, discuss contents with your classmates. Participation in 10 forums during the semester is required. Attendance at lectures will also be figured into the participation grade. 25% *Two written assignments. Topics will be distributed. First 10%, due Feb. 11. Second 20%, due April 28 (likely preliminary stages include source analysis due April 12, full draft for those who wish due April 19, student presentations TBD). *Midterm exam: Tues., Feb. 23 20% *Final take home exam, to be submitted online: Due May 13, 12:00 25% Grading scale: A+: 98-100 A: 93 97 A-: 90 93 B+: 88 90 B: 83 88 B-: 80 83 C+: 78 80 And so on. Collaboration Policy: Discussion and the exchange of ideas are essential to academic work. For assignments in this course, you are encouraged to consult with your classmates on the choice of paper topics and to share sources. You may find it useful to discuss your chosen topic with your peers, particularly if you are working on the same topic as a classmate. However, you should ensure that any written work you submit for evaluation is the result of your own research and writing and that it reflects your own approach to the topic. You must also adhere to standard citation practices in this discipline and properly cite any books, articles, websites, lectures, etc. that have helped you with your work. If you would like to collaborate with a classmate, in groups of no more than 3, on any written assignment that is NOT an exam (mid-term or final), please contact the Professor or TF. One paper will be submitted by all the participants together, and one grade will be assigned. Collaboration of this type requires prior authorization of the instructor. Special Needs and Accommodations. The class as a whole benefits from the inclusion of a diverse group of students, including all types of learners. If you anticipate requesting accommodations of any kind for assignments or exams, please be in touch with the instructor during the first two weeks of class.
3 Required Books (available at Broad Street Books and on Reserve at Olin): Beth Zion Abrahams, trans. and ed. Life of Gluckel of Hameln Judith Baskin, ed. Jewish Women in Historical Perspective Daniel Boyarin, Unheroic Conduct: The Rise of Heterosexuality and the Invention of the Jewish Man Paula Hyman, Gender & Assimilation in Modern Jewish History Recommended Books: Elisheva Baumgarten, Practicing Piety in Medieval Ashkenaz Sander Gilman, The Jew's Body Riv Ellen Prell, Fighting to Become Americans: Jews, Gender and the Anxiety of Assimilation Chava Weissler, Voices of the Matriarchs Michael Brenner, A Short History of the Jews Raymond Scheindlin, A Short History of the Jewish People: From Legendary Times to Modern Statehood Please note: Thursday evenings, Jan 28 March 3, at 8 pm are screenings of the Ring Family Wesleyan Israeli Film Festival. A complete line up is here. Submit a 2 3 page gender analysis of any film for extra credit in this course. Course outline Specific dates and assignments are subject to change due to unforeseen circumstances. If you miss a class, please be in touch with a classmate or with the instructor to double check assignments for the following class meeting. If readings on Moodle are different than those listed on the syllabus, please follow what appears on Moodle. 1. Thurs. Jan. 21. Introductions 2. Tues. Jan. 26. Gender as a Category of Analysis Joan Scott Gender: a Useful Category of Historical Analysis Weissler, Voices of the Matriarchs, chapter 2 (pp. 36 50); recommended: chapter 3 (pp. 51 65) Boyarin, Unheroic Conduct, pp. ix xxiv, 1 23
4 3. Thurs. Jan. 28. The Heterosexual Ideal *We begin our historical analysis at a moment spanning the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, a moment when idealized versions of male and female Jews with which we still live today were crystallized. Boyarin, Unheroic Conduct, ch. 1 Goyim Naches, (pp. 31 80) Hyman, Gender and Assimilation, ch. 4, The Sexual Politics of Jewish Identity, (pp. 134 169) Distributed: Instructions and prompts for Assignment 1 to be distributed today. 4. Tues. Feb. 2. Biblical Beginnings *In class, we analyze together Genesis Chapters 1, 2; Proverbs 31 Susan Niditch, Portrayals of Women in the Hebrew Bible in Baskin, ed., Jewish Women (pp. 25 45). ***Please use the time afforded by the light reading load this week to work on Assignment 1. There is more reading next week. 5. Thurs. Feb. 4. Rabbinic understandings *In class, we read together from the Mishna, tractate Nashim ( Women ) DUE: If you would like to submit a draft of Assignment 1 for comment, please do so by today. 6. Tues. Feb. 9. Modern Interpretations of Rabbinic Understandings Natan Margalit, Priestly Men and Invisible Women: Male Appropriation of the Feminine and the Exemption of Women from Positive Time Bound Commandments, AJS Review Boyarin, Unheroic Conduct, ch.3, Rabbis and their Pals (pp 127 150) Recommended: Elizabeth Shanks Alexander, Gender and Timebound Commandments in Judaism 7. Thurs. Feb. 11. Women and Men in Medieval Jewish Ritual: Positive, Time Bound Commandments and Torah study Elisheva Baumgarten, Practicing Piety in Medieval Ashkenaz, ch. 4, Positive Time Bound Commandments: Class, Gender and Transformation (pp. 138 171)
5 Boyarin, Unheroic Conduct, first half of ch. 4, Feminization and its Discontents (pp. 151 172) Judith R. Baskin, Jewish Women in the Middle Ages in Baskin, ed., Jewish Women (pp. 101 127) DUE: Assignment 1, due electronically by 5 pm. 8. Tues. Feb 16. Medieval Views of Jewish Gender * In class, we will read together Elazar HaRokeach s elegy to his wife and daughters, and selections from Crusade literature Susan Einbinder, Jewish Women Martyrs: Changing Models of Representation Recommended: Irven M. Resnick, Medieval Roots of the Myth of Jewish Male Menses, The Harvard Theological Review, 93, No. 3 (Jul., 2000): 241 263. Judith Baskin, Male Piety, Female Bodies: Men, Women, and Ritual Immersion in Medieval Ashkenaz, Jewish Law Association Studies 17 (2007): 11 30. 9. Thurs. Feb. 18. The Islamic and Sephardi Words Renée Levine Melammed, Sephardi Women in the Medieval and Early Modern Periods, in Baskin, ed., Jewish Women (pp. 128 149) Karin Hofmeester, Jewish Ethics and Women's Work in the Late Medieval and Early Modern Arab Islamic World, International Review of Social History 56 (2011): 141 164. Start reading: Abrahams, ed., The Memoirs of Gluckel of Hameln 10. Tues. Feb. 23. Mid term exam
6 11. Thurs. Feb. 25. Early Modern Ashkenaz: Masculine & Feminine Ideals Moshe Rosman, Poland: Early Modern (1500 1795), Jewish Women s Archive Encyclopedia Rachel L. Greenblatt, To Tell Their Children: Jewish Communal Memory in Early Modern Prague, chapters 2, 5, 6. Recommended: Andreas Gotzmann, Respectability Tested: Male Ideals, Sexuality, and Honor in Early Modern Ashkenazi Jewry, Jewish Masculinities (2012) 23 49 12. Tues. March 1. Early Modern Ashkenaz: the role of family networks Abrahams, ed., The Memoirs of Gluckel of Hameln 13. Thurs. March 3. Early Modern Ashkenaz: Womend and God; Women and Business Abrahams, ed., The Memoirs of Gluckel of Hameln Natalie Zemon Davis, Women on the Margins, pp. 1 62. Recommended: Robert Liberles, " She Sees That Her Merchandise Is Good, and Her Lamp Is Not Extinguished at Nighttime: Glikl's Memoir as Historical Source Debra Kaplan, Because our Wives Trade and do Business with our Goods : Gender, Work, and Jewish Christian Relations, in New Perspectives on Jewish Christian Relations (2012): 241 261 March 7 18: Mid semester recess 14. Tues. March 22. Spiritual Lives; Hasidic Movement Guidelines Distributed: Assignment 2 Weissler, Voices of the Matriarchs, chpts. 1, 6, 8. Marcin Wodziński, Women and Hasidism: a Non sectarian Perspective, Jewish History 27 (2013): 399 434.
7 15. Thurs. March 24 Purim day. Screen Yentl, part 1. 16. Tues. March 29. Exceptional Women/Learned Women Screen Yentl, part 2. Readings TBA RECOMMENDED lecture: Wed, March 30, 8 pm, Daniel Family Commons. Deborah Dash Moore Walkers in the City: Jewish American Photographers 17. Thurs. March 31. The Yeshiva World of Eastern Europe & the Challenge of Anachronism *No office hours today I. B. Singer, Yentl the Yeshiva Boy I. B. Singer interview in NYT DUE: Preliminary Bibliography for Paper 2 18. Tues. April 5. Enlightenment, Emancipation and Assimilation in Central Europe Paula Hyman, Gender and Assimilation, ch. 1, Paradoxes of Assimilation (pp. 10 49) Deborah Herz, Emancipation through Intermarriage? Wealthy Jewish Salon Women in Old Berlin, in Baskin, ed., Jewish Women (pp. 193 207). Marion Kaplan, Tradition and Transition: Jewish Women in Imperial Germany, in Baskin, ed., Jewish Women (pp. 227 248) 19. Thurs. April 7. Enlightenment, Emancipation and Assimilation in Eastern Europe Paula Hyman, Gender and Assimilation, ch. 2, Seductive Secularization (pp. 50 92) Additional readings TBA
8 RECOMMENDED lecture: Monday, April 11, 8 pm, Russell House. Prof. Jodi Eicher Levine, The Monstrous in Jewish Children's Literature 20. Tues. April 12. America: the Immigrant Generation Paula Hyman, Gender and Assimilation, ch. 3, America, Freedom and Assimilation (pp. 93 133). Additional Readings TBA DUE: Source analaysis for Paper 2 *All readings for class meetings from April 14 through the end of the semester will be announced by March 24. I hope this approach will allow me to tailor the final portion of the course more closely to student interests than would be possible otherwise.* 21. Thurs. April 14. American Popular Culture: WWII through the Sexual Revolution 22. Tues. April 19. Zionism and Israel DUE: Draft of Assignment 2 for students wishing feedback before final submission 23. Thurs April 21. Student Presentations 24. Tues. April 26 (4 th day of Passover). Student Presentations 26. Thurs. April 28 (6 th day of Passover). In the Jewish world today. DUE: Assignment 2 27. Tues. May 3. Review & Conclusions Online Essay Exam: Due May 13 12:00 pm