Tlte Bmencan Bcclceiaetical IReview A MONTHLY PUBUCATION FOR THE CLERGY Cum Approbation* Superiorum VOL. CXLVIII JANUARY-JUNE, 1963 WPoBXowTts rp TIVTH TOV ebayycklov PhU. 1.27 Published by THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF AMERICA PRESS
CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVIII JANUARY The Holy Spirit and the Magisterium Ecclesiae..John J. King, O.M.I. 1 Anti-Catholicism and Know-Nothingism in Rhode Island John Michael Ray 27 The Papal Election of 1159 Lawrence F. Barmann, SJ. 37 Cardinal Ottaviani and the Council Joseph Clifford Fenton 44 Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, SS. Obligations of the Missa pro Populo 54 Interference in a Proposed Marriage 55 Obligations of Military Service 56 The Ecumenical Council (continued) 57 COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 60 The New Man, by Thomas Merton 65 Problems in Addiction: Alcoholism and Narcotics, edited by William C. Bier, SJ. 66 Saint Anne, The Mother of Mary, by Patrick Gearon, O.Carm 68 BOOKS RECEIVED 71 111
iv CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVIII FEBRUARY The Rock of the New Testament. P. Milward, SJ. 73 Theology and the Mission Apostolate...Ronan Hoffman, O.FM.Conv. 98 Members of the Qiurch: Mystici Corporis and St. Thomas. Part I Coltnan E. O'Neill, O.P. 113 John P. McCormick, S.S., and Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R. Ministerial Work Excusing from Divine Office 129 Bination on a Weekday 129 Old Age and the Eucharistic Fast 130 Restitution by a Prospective Religious 131 Pro Populo Masses 131 Confessionals for Priests 132 Bows in the New Rite 133 Color for Votive Masses 133 Genuflection at Last Gospel 133 COMMENT.Dom Patrick Granfield 135 Studies in Philosophy and the History of Philosophy. Vol. I. Edited by John K. Ryan 140 BOOKS RECEIVED 144
CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVIII v MARCH Cold War Among the Orthodox George A. Moloney, SJ. 145 An Abbot for Westminster Paul R. Rust, O.M.I. 156 Members of the Church: Mystici Corporis and St. Thomas. Part II Colman E. O'Neill, OJ>. 167 The Roman Curia and the Ecumenical Council. Joseph Clifford Fenton 185 John P. McCormick, S.S., and Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R. Mass Server's Problems 199 The Voice at the Last Gospel 200 Privileges of a Doctor 200 "Religious Junk" 201 The Act of Contrition Aloud 203 COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 205 The Catholic Viewpoint on Overpopulation, by Anthony Zimmerman, S.VJ). 210 The Apostles, by Otto Hophan, OI'M.Cap 213 BOOK NOTES 215 BOOKS RECEIVED 216
vi CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVIII APRIL A Rationalist Defense of Christianity. Part I John L. Murphy 217 The NCWC Press Department Burke Walsh 236 The Mysticism of St. Ignatius of Antioch Arthur J. Arrieri, SJ. 250 The Teaching of the Theological Manuals... Joseph Clifford Fenton 254 John P. McCormick, S.S., and Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R. A Problem of Rhythm 271 Mass or Office? 271 One Mass or Many Masses? 272 Problem of a Priest Social Worker 273 Obligation of a Priest to Serve Mass 273 Posture at Holy Communion 274 Anticipation of Lauds 275 Server's Communion 276 COMMENT Dom Patrick Grmfield 277 The Church's Magna Charta for Migrants, by G. Tessarolo 281 The Priest's Way to God, by M. Eugene Boylan, 0.C.S.0 282 A Chronicle of Catholic History of the Pacific Northwest, by Wilfred P. Schoenberg, SJ. 283 High Gothic. The Classic Cathedrals of Chartres, Reims, and Amiens, by Hans Jant sen 284 BOOKS RECEIVED 285
CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVIII vii MAY A Frontier Jerome: Gruenthaner. Part I Robert North, SJ. 289 Are All Revealed Truths in Sacred Scripture? Francis J. Connell, CSSJi. 303 A Rationalist Defense of Christianity. Part II John L. Murphy 315 The New Denzinger Joseph Clifford Fenton 337 Francis J. Connell, CSS.R., and John P. McCormick, SS. A Problem on Mental Retardation 345 Obligation of an Ex-Religious 346 Holy Communion Without Confession 347 Forty Hours and Sunday 348 COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 350 Spiritual and Pastoral Conferences to Priests, by Francis J. Connell, CSSJi. 355 Dictionary of Moral Theology, edited by Cardinal Roberti and Msgr. Pietro Palassini 356 BOOK NOTES 358 BOOKS RECEIVED 359
viii CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVIII JUNE Orally Induced Sterility Armand J. Rotondi, MJD. 361 St. Peter-Julian Eymard Ernest Lussier, SS.S. 376 The Duty of the Magisterium to Condemn Error. John J. King, O.M.I. 380 The Priest as Catechist in the Parish School Nicholas Schneider 389 A Frontier Jerome: Gruenthaner. Part II Robert North, SJ. 398 Francis J. Connell, CSS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S. Mixed Marriage Legislation 412 Baptism of a Fetus The Validity of a Marriage. 416 Covering the Ciborium 417 The Clapper in Holy Week 417 Dominus Vobiscum in the Office 418 Missa Pro Populo 418 Anticipated consecration of Hosts for Holy Thursday 418 COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 420 Catholics in England, 1559-1829, by Mary D. Leys 425 The Recipient of Extreme Unction, by Charles G. Renati 427 The Search for a Common Learning: General Education, 1800-1960, by Russell Thomas 429 The Psalms Are Christian Prayer, by Thomas Worden 430 A Catechism for Non-Catholics, by Martin Farrell 431 King and Church: The Rise and Fall of the Patronato Real, 41S by W. Eugene Shiels, SJ. 432 BOOKS RECEIVED 434 INDEX TO VOLUME CXLVIII 436 BOOKS REVIEWED AND NOTICED 440
Tlte Hmertcan Ecclesiastical IRevicw A MONTHLY PUBLICATION FOR THE CLERGY Cum Approbation Superiorum VOL. CXLIX JULY DECEMBER, 1963 'Ev ivl Tvebnan, fuq. faxv ovvadxovvres r% jrlarei rod ebayyexlov PhU. 1:27 Published by THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF AMERICA PRESS
CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLIX JULY John XXIII, 1881-1963 1 John XXIII: Pope of Saint Joseph Blaine Burkey, O.FM.Cap. 2 Baptism and Penance and the Revision of the Code... John A. Abbo 14 Must the Materialist Deny That "All Men Are Created Equal"? Francis J. McGarrigle, SJ. 29 A Frontier Jerome: Gruenthaner. Part III Robert North, SJ. 41 Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S. The Morality of Chiropractic 51 An Unusual Statement About Contraception 51 A New Idea in Catechetics 52 The Divine Office in the Vernacular 54 Commemoration on Trinity Sunday 55 St. John Nepomucene 56 Votive Office 56 Recitation of the Gradual in Solemn Mass 57 Circular Incensing of the Altar 57 COMMENT Dotn Patrick Granfield 59 The Idea of the Church, 631 B. C. Butler 63 Pastoral Liturgy, by J. A. Jungmann, SJ. 65 Young Man Luther, by Erik Erikson 66 Living Today for God, by Roger Schutz 68 BOOK NOTES 70 BOOKS RECEIVED 71 111
hr CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLIX AUGUST Pope Paul VI 73 Divine Vocation: A New Theory Kevin D. O'Rourke, O.P. 74 Liturgical Languages Angelus A. De Marco, O.FM. 90 Origins and Meaning of the Christian Altar Peter Riga 100 The Servant of God Bishop John Baptist Scalabrini Apostle of the Immigrants Paul J. Asciolla, P.S.S.C. 123 Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S. A Choir of Three Denominations 130 Coerced Confession and Holy Communion 131 St. Joseph in the Canon 132 Chalice Spoon 133 Pectoral Cross 133 Formal Clerical Attire 134 COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 135 De Figura Iuridica Postulatoris in Causis Beatificationis et Canonizationis, by Angelo Mitri, O.M.1 140 Mary and the Priest, by Mark J. Lyons 141 BOOKS RECEIVED 143
CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLIX v SEPTEMBER Scritpure and Tradition in the Commonitorium Joseph A. Fichtner, O.S.C. 145 The Lay Apostolate Donald Diets, O.M.I. 162 Catholic Reflections on O. Hobart Mowrer Jerome F. Wilkerson 171 The Priests' Total Abstinence League Miles M. McAndrew, S.S. 189 Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S. Freedom of Worship 201 Rights of a Sterilized Man 202 Who Should Get the Offering? 203 Chalice Materials 204 Some Sede Vacante Problems 205 Lavabo Water 206 The Ambry 206 COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 208 The School Question: a Bibliography on Church-State Relationships in American Education 1940-1960, compiled by Brother Edmond G. Drouin. F.I.C. '. 212 The Eastern Orthodox Church, Its Thought and Life, by Ernst Bens 213 BOOKS RECEIVED 215
vi CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLIX OCTOBER Collaboration of Priest and Psychotherapist Michael Stock, Q.P. 217 Marginal Notes to a Discussion on Scripture and Tradition John J. O'Rourke 229 Catholicity in California Francis J. Weber 233 The Popes and the Eastern Rites Allen Maloof 252 Israelitic Sacrifice William J. O'Rourke, S.J. 259 Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick. S.S. Some Requiem Problems 275 Special Anointing 275 Oratio Imperata 276 Surplice for Confession 276 Bishop's Anniversary 277 The Destruction of Pornography 277 Chemical Means of Diminishing Passion 278 Use of a Lie Detector 279 The Candidate's Right to His Reputation 280 COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 281 The Time Has Come: A Catholic Doctor's Proposals to End the Battle Over Birth Control, by John Rock, M.D 284 Sin and Penance, by Peter Riga 286 The Sacrament of Penance, by Paul Anciaux 286 BOOKS RECEIVED 287
CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLIX vii NOVEMBER St. Francis De Sales' The Love of God and the Modern World John K. Ryan 289 Thomas Augustine Judge A Pioneer of the Lay Apostolate Theodore A. Opdenaker 293 Augustine and Isocrates Eugene Kevane 301 Religious Brothers: A History Franciscus Willett, C.S.C. 322 Family Structure and Religious Orientation Raymond H. Potvin 330 Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S. The Theology of Concelebration 337 Deception in Life Insurance 338 Absolution from a Reserved Sin 339 St. John Nepomucene Again 340 Posture at Sung Masses 341 Assistance of Priests at Mass 341 COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 344 Today's Vocation Crisis, edited by Godfrey Poage, C.P., and Germain Lievin, C.SS.R 348 The Work of Pere Lagrange, by F.-M. Braun, O.P 350 The Religious Issue in the State Schools of England and Wales 1902-1914, by Benjamin Sacks 351 The Two Commandments of Christ, 631 Francis J. McGarrigle, SJ 352 The Priest Is Not His Own, by Fulton J. Sheen 354 Handbook of the Militant Christian, by Desiderius Erasmus. Translated by John P. Nolan 355 Lives of Saint Thomas More, 631 William Roper and Nicholas Harpsfield. Edited by E. E. Reynolds 355 BOOK NOTES 357 BOOKS RECEIVED 359
viii CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLIX DECEMBER The Teaching of St. Thomas in the Summa Concerning the Baptismal Character William F. Ryan, SJ. 361 The Discourse on the Good Shepherd and the Rite of Ordination /. Edgar Brims 386 A Letter from Rome Joseph Clifford Fenton 392 Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S. Comment on the Council 431 Novus Ordo 431 Membership 431 Presidency and Direction 431 Periti 432 Auditors 432 Council Dress 433 The Patriarchs 433 Forty Hours' Devotion Without Worshipers 434 The Right to Bequeath One's Property 434 May the Stipend Be Retained? 435 A Secret Convert 435 COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 437 In Defense of the Public Order: The Emerging Field of Sanction Law, by Richard Arens and Harold D. Lasswell 441 Perspectives in American Catholicism, by John Tracy Ellis 441 The Population Dilemma, edited by Philip Hauser 442 INDEX TO VOLUME CXLIX 444 INDEX OF BOOKS REVIEWED AND NOTICED 447