Australian reenvisioning of theological education: In step with the Spirit? 1

Australian ejournal of Theology 18.3 (December 2011) Australian reenvisioning of theological education: In step with the Spirit? 1 Darren Cronshaw Abstract: There is a growing interest in local churches reshaping themselves around mission and developing an everyday theology for the marketplace, but what does this mean for theological education and leadership formation? How do we keep in step with the Spirit and help our students practice consecration through the Spirit? This article grapples with these questions by drawing on four Australian writers: marketplace theologian Robert Banks; missional church leaders Alan Hirsch and Michael Frost; and Australian poet and artist Michael Leunig. It presents innovative approaches to training at Australian colleges and training providers including Tabor College Victoria, Forge Mission Training Network and Whitley College, and discusses implications for the future of theological education in step with the Spirit. To be in step with the missionary Spirit will include reenvisioning our approach to vocation and the ministry of the whole people of God, recalibrating our churches around mission, recentring with contemplation, and engaging our cultural contexts. Keywords: theological education, missional church, vocation, contemplative spirituality, local theology ODE TO FORMATIVE TEACHERS Three stories have captured my imagination and helped form my vision for transformative theological education and leadership formation. On December 1, 1955, Rosa Parks sat in the front white section of a bus. She stood up for equal rights by sitting down, initiating the Montgomery bus boycott and catalysing the civil rights movement that transformed the United States. The sanitised version of her protest is that she was just tired. But this fails to recognise she had been active in the movement for justice and was most tired of her people being treated unequally. And earlier that year she attended a workshop at the Highlander Centre, a training centre for community workers and advocacy. At Highlander she acquired skills, but perhaps most importantly said it was where she first experienced an atmosphere of equality with 1 A previous version of this article was presented on 8 July 2011 at the Commission on Theological Education and Leadership Formation, Baptist World Alliance annual gathering, Kuala Lumpur (4 8 July 2011), and circulated for comment on http://www.buv.com.au. It also builds on my previous article: Reenvisioning theological education, mission and the local church, Mission Studies 28, (2011): 91 115. 223

members of the other race. 2 I applaud Rosa Parks initiative on the Montgomery bus. But as a teacher I am equally inspired by the training that equipped her and gave her a vision to transform her world. Rosa Parks experience prompts me to ask how can we help our students be equipped and courageous to transform the world to be more in line with God s dream for it? The second story is of Dr Gilbert Bilezikian. If you do not know Bilezikian, you probably know of one of his students, Bill Hybels, founding pastor of Willow Creek. Hybels pioneered the concept of seeker sensitive services and is widely respected for helping church leaders around the world do church in new ways. What captures my imagination is not just Hybels leadership but the formative input of Dr Bilezikian as his lecturer at Trinity College in Illinois. Hybels recalls Dr Bilezikian s inspirational teaching about the New Testament church: I don t see many churches like this in America in the 70s. I mean, I see buildings and I see programs, I see budgets and I see a lot of activities... I just don t see the life of what the Scriptures is talking about. I don t see that kind of life being breathed out in a vital way... Someday the mold will be broken. Somebody will get serious about doing church God s way and they re gonna take all the risks and endure all the attacks. Someday, somebody will start a church, and it will be a lot like this: it will rock the world. 3 Thus impressionable young Hybels was inspired. I applaud what Hybels has done for his context and generation. But I am equally inspired by the mentor in Bilezikian that sparked Hybels vision. It prompts me to ask, how can we help our people to dream and work with God to transform the church in our different contexts? The third story is of George Buttrick, a respected preacher at Madison Avenue Presbyterian who also took a mentoring interest in young developing ministers. 4 Early in Eugene Peterson s training he took a staff role at Buttrick s church, actually while Peterson was planning an academic career but needing to fulfil fieldwork requirements and pay his way through seminary. But the appointment was dangerous to his plans because Buttrick taught Peterson the craft of pastoring. He would take Peterson and other seminarians to his home after each evening service, and talk about preaching, visiting, attitudes to people and commitment to the neighbourhood. He poured his heart and life not just into his own ministry but into multiplying himself through others. Eugene Peterson is my literary mentor as a pastor/scholar/writer/teacher. But I am also inspired by George Buttrick who helped form Peterson s pastoral vocation. It challenges me to ask, how can we work with God to reenvision and transform people s understanding of their self and their vocation? 2 Highlander Research and Education Centre, A tribute to Rosa Parks, http://www.highlandercenter.org/nrosa parks.asp; also told in my Baptist Union of Victoria leadership training inspiring stories, (2008), accessible at http://www.buv.com.au/ministries/leadership training/. 3 Gregory A Pritchard, Willow Creek Seeker Services: Evaluating a New Way of Doing Church (Grand Rapids: Baker, 1996), 44 45; also told for BUV, accessible at http://www.buv.com.au/ministries/leadership training/. 4 Eugene H Peterson, The Pastor: A Memoir (New York: HarperOne, 2011), 85 87. 224

AUSTRALIAN WRITERS AND CASE STUDIES Those are three inspiring heroes of mine, and the schools, teachers and places of practical experience which helped train them in North America. But I grapple with how to reenvision theological education and leadership formation in Australia. I have been watching the groundswell of interest in churches reshaping around mission and everyday spirituality, but I am curious as to what this means for our teaching. How can we keep in step with the Spirit and help our students practice consecration through the Spirit? This paper grapples with these questions by drawing on four Australian writers; marketplace theologian Robert Banks and his book Reenvisioning theological education, missional church leaders Alan Hirsch and Michael Frost, and Australian poet and artist Michael Leunig and his playful contemplative prayers. It presents case studies of training at Tabor College Victoria, Forge Mission Training Network and Whitley College, pairing them with the literary inspiration of Banks, Hirsch and Frost, and Leunig, and discusses implications for the future of theological education in step with the Spirit. IN STEP WITH THE MISSIONARY SPIRIT For theological education to be in step with the Spirit, we must acknowledge foundationally that the Holy Spirit is the Spirit of mission who sends the church into the world. Missio Dei, the mission of God or the missionary God, was arguably the most important theological rediscovery of the twentieth century. It reminds us the church does not own its mission program but our God of mission birthed the church to help fulfil God s mission. 5 David Bosch identifies missio Dei as central for the emerging paradigm of mission: Mission was understood as being derived from the very nature of God Father, Son, and Holy Spirit sending the church into the world a movement from God to the world; the church is viewed as an instrument for that mission There is a church because there is a mission, not vice versa. 6 As churches and as arms of the church providing theological education, if we want to be in step with the Spirit, then we want to be part of this Trinitarian movement of being sent into the world. We can be confident that the Spirit goes before us; the invitation is to be in step with the Spirit. So to what extent are experiments in Australian reenvisioning of theological education in step with the missionary Spirit? 5 Jürgen Moltmann expressed: it is not the church that has a mission of salvation to fulfill in the world; it is the mission of the Son and the Spirit through the Father that includes the church, in The Church in The Power of the Spirit: A Contribution to Messianic Ecclesiology (London: SCM, 1977), 64. 6 David J Bosch, Transforming Mission: Paradigm Shifts in Theology of Mission (Maryknoll: Orbis, 1991), 390. I explored the influence of missio Dei on emerging missional churches in The Shaping of Things Now: Emerging Church Mission and Innovation in 21st Century Melbourne (Saarbrucken: VDM Verlag, 2009), 39 40, 100 151; and also in Reenvisioning theological education, 91 92. 225

A. Tabor College Victoria and Robert Banks Reenvisioning Robert Banks, a leading Australian theologian, has appealed for theological education to be reenvisioned with a distinctly missional focus, in his Reenvisioning Theological Education. 7 To help our students be part of the missional movement of the Spirit sending the church into the world, we need to embody this in our educational processes. Over recent decades theological educators have debated whether we belong in Athens, with a focus on character development, or Berlin, with focus on vocational skills. 8 Banks alternative is to start in Jerusalem with what he calls a missional synthesis. By that he means that the best education and formation will be at least partly field based and stretch students to do what they are studying. Classes are not for students to collect abstract learning for future ministry, but in service equipping for a more faithful expression of current mission. Banks argues theological education and leadership formation happens best when theory and practice, action and reflection are combined. It is not just about bringing theory to practice or doing action then reflection, but learning in the midst of mission or reflection inaction. 9 And this is needed not just for professional clergy. Banks argues we need training that is far more field based, encompassing all of life and addressing mission opportunities for the whole people of God: an education undertaken with a view to what God is doing in the world, considered from a global perspective. 10 This missional agenda in training forming students who can keep in step with what the Spirit is doing in the world is central to reenvisioning theological education. How can colleges empower the whole people of God to discover and live out their callings, in the church, but also in society and the marketplace? God calls people not just for religious vocations but for vocations in science, business and education. We want to help God s people to be in step with the Spirit in the church, but also in politics and health, parenting and recreation, media and finance. In Australia only about 20% of 14,000 students in 69 theological colleges are preparing for professional ministry. The missional and vocational challenge is for colleges to equip not just those preparing to serve in the church, but those called to serve as the church in the world. 11 It is about forming a new generation of church leaders, like Bill Hybels and Eugene Peterson, who transform the church, but also civic leaders and activists like Rosa Parks who transform the world. 7 Robert Banks, Reenvisioning Theological Education: Exploring a Missional Alternative to Current Models (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1999); reviewed in Darren Cronshaw, Pioneering leadership and innovation reading guide, Zadok Papers (2011): 9 16, at 10,; and discussed in Cronshaw, Reenvisioning theological education, 92 99, 104 110. 8 David H Kelsey, Between Athens and Berlin: The Theological Education Debate (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1993). 9 Donald A Schön, The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action (New York: Basic, 1983), 68; in Banks, Reenvisioning, 139. 10 Banks, Reenvisioning, 142. 11 Charles Sherlock, Uncovering Theology: The Depth, Reach and Utility Of Australian Theological Education (Adelaide: ATF Press, 2009), 111 112. 226

Tabor One Australian college that is grappling with training the whole people of God for their vocations in the world is Tabor College Victoria. Tabor started in Adelaide in 1979 and Melbourne in 1988 as a Pentecostal ministry college, but now draws from a wide range of churches and offers a broad offering of courses to 500+ students. 12 As well as theological, ministry and mission streams and counselling courses, they have recently developed programs in education and the arts for teacher training and a unique Master of Arts in Vocational Practice (MAVP) for church leaders, development workers and soon to include health, media and business leaders. 13 Principal Wynand De Kock says Tabor wants to be a comprehensive Christian college that equips men and women to respond to the call of God wherever the voice of God calls them to. 14 Tabor s mission is to empower God s people to transform the world. Foundational to Tabor s vision is the importance of vocation. Vocation is derived from vox and vocare, Latin for voice and to call, because vocation relates to hearing the voice of God about how God has made and called us to contribute to the world. De Kock suggests a basic characteristic of followers of Jesus, as sheep who know the shepherd s voice (John 10:27), is that they follow his voice into any sphere of life in the world. He suggests the beauty of identifying and understanding vocation is that it reminds the people of God that they are called and drawn to work with God where God is already working, not just in church but in the broader world. 15 De Kock is influenced by Parker Palmer, who invites people to develop their vocation not from what they or others think they ought to do, but from discerning how God has made them and what passions God has given them. Palmer quotes Frederick Buechner who defines vocation as the place where your deep gladness meets the world s deep need. 16 This is a good framework for forming leaders helping them to discern vocational directions that are life giving both for them (in terms of their passions) and for the world (in terms of meeting real needs). For example and relevant for us as teachers, Palmer s own sense of vocation is clearly as a master teacher: I had never stopped being a teacher... In fact, I could have done no other: teaching, I was coming to understand, is my native way of being in the world. Make me a cleric or a CEO, a poet or a politico, and teaching is what I will do. 17 For those of us who are teachers and if that is where our deep gladness meets the world s deep need, then let us pursue that with passion. For those in 12 Wynand de Kock, Interview with author (18 Jan 2011); Tabor brief history, accessible at http://www.tabor.vic.edu.au/about/history.i studied a Certificate IV in Workplace Assessment and Training at Tabor in 2003 and have been an occasional visiting lecturer at Tabor since 2005. 13 http://www.tabor.vic.edu.au/study/ma/church practice. 14 De Kock, Interview. 15 De Kock, Interview. 16 Frederick Buechner, Wishful Thinking: A Theological ABC (New York: Harper & Row, 1973), 95; Parker J Palmer, Let Your Life Speak: Listening for the Voice of Vocation (San Francisco: Jossey Bass, 2000), 16; discussed in Darren Cronshaw, Confessions of an angry missionary, Mission Horizons: Newsletter of the School of World Mission 22 (2006): 3. 17 Palmer, Let Your Life Speak, 21. 227

our classes whose vocation lies elsewhere, let us help them explore the big questions and worthy dreams of their vocation. 18 Consecration through the Spirit to vocation Banks, Palmer and Tabor College emphasise that consecration through the Spirit includes commitment to identifying and developing our vocation and the vocations of our students. We need fresh approaches to training and curriculum reform that take seriously people s diverse vocations. Traditional theological education, shaped around preparing church leaders, is not sufficient. We need fresh approaches to training, developed by and with Christian leaders in all spheres, to help leaders grapple theologically with issues of economics and politics, ethics and workaholism, multiculturalism and globalisation. 19 It is appropriate to channel our best thinking into how faith engages with the marketplace. We need foundational frameworks for understanding the Bible and church history, but also skills and practice in making the connections between theology and everyday life and work. God is a worker, as Banks describes in another of his classic books, and our vocation as the people of God is to apprentice with God in what God is working in the world. 20 The Spirit and transformation De Kock argues that consecration through the Spirit is largely to help believers love and be involved in social change including multicultural inclusion. This is part of the charismatic tradition of Tabor wants to claim charismatic empowering for personal and social transformation. Rather than being preoccupied with gifts of the Holy Spirit, De Kock looks for fruit and missional implications. The Spirit empowers God s people for mission is the central charismatic truth they want students to grasp. This has implications for multicultural ministry. De Kock is interested that the Azusa Street revival, where modern Pentecostalism started at the beginning of the twentieth century, had a black evangelist and one account is that it was a little black girl who spoke in tongues. De Kock says that is a true sign of Spirit baptism that injustice and racial divides disappeared as in Acts 2. 21 This section leads me to ask what consecration through the Spirit means in terms of our vocations. At our best in theological education, how do we engage the whole people of God in their vocations? What does it mean to reenvision theological education around the vocation of the whole people of God? 18 Parker J Palmer, Arthur Zajonc, and with Megan Scribner, The Heart Of Higher Education: A Call to Renewal, Transforming the Academy Through Collegial Conversations (San Francisco: Jossey Bass, 2010). 19 Banks, Reenvisioning, 185 186; see also Robert Banks and R. Paul Stevens, eds., The Complete Book of Everyday Christianity: An A to Z Guide to Following Christ in Every Aspect of Life (Downers Grove: IVP,1997). 20 Robert Banks, God The Worker: Journeys into the Mind, Heart and Imagination of God (Sydney: Albatross, 1992); Michael Frost, Exiles: Living Missionally in a Post Christian Culture (Peabody: Hendrickson, 2006), 177 200; discussed in Cronshaw, Shaping of Things Now, 235. 21 De Kock, Interview; see also the volume edited by Tabor s Cheryl Catford, Following Fire: How the Spirit Leads Us to Fight Injustice (Springvale: Urban Neighbours of Hope, 2008). 228

B. Frost & Hirsch s Shaping and Forge Michael Frost and Alan Hirsch Alan Hirsch and Michael Frost, leading Australian missional thinkers and activists, have appealed for an overhaul of church and training around mission. In Shaping of things to come they appeal to the church in the West to be more incarnational in infiltrating our communities for the gospel (rather than waiting for people to come to church); messianic in recognising the relevance of Jesus as Lord for all of life (rather than the dualistic tendency of separating sacred and secular concerns); and apostolic in affirming the pioneering/ generative roles of leaders who are gifted apostolically, prophetically and evangelistically (not just the operative roles of pastors and teachers). 22 In their later books like The forgotten ways and Exiles they urge recalibrating around a fresh understanding of Jesus, reprioritising discipleship, decentralising organic systems that release people s innovative capacities, letting communitas 23 evolve as groups engage in adventurous mission together, and focusing on apostolic movement and mobilising everyone for mission. 24 Their main contribution to our theological education conversation is to catalyse our conversation around missional training. 25 Forge Mission Training Network Hirsch and Frost co founded Forge in 1996 as a mission training network to form two things: missionary identity and pioneering leadership skills. Other colleges offered sufficient training for pastors and teachers, they felt, but they wanted Forge to multiply apostolic, prophetic and evangelistic leaders who can take risks, question the status quo, communicate relevantly and pioneer new initiatives. 26 So they designed an actionreflection program that placed interns in an incarnational mission context that stretched 22 Michael Frost and Alan Hirsch, The Shaping of Things to Come: Innovation and Mission for the 21st Century Church (Peabody: Hendrickson, 2003); discussed in Cronshaw, Shaping of Things Now, 36 69. 23 Communitas is a term drawn from Victor Turner s anthropological study of African rites of passage and the resulting deep comradeship and belonging. Victor Turner, The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti Structure (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1969), 94 165; Victor Turner, Passages, Margins, and Poverty: Religious Symbols of Communitas, Worship 46 (1972): 390 412; drawing on Arnold van Gennep, The Rites of Passage (Chicago: University of Chicago, 1960); as cited in Frost, Exiles, 105 129; Alan Hirsch, The Forgotten Ways: Reactivating the Missional Church (Grand Rapids: Brazos, 2006), 220 224; and as discussed in Cronshaw, Shaping of Things Now, 42 43 24 Frost, Exiles; Hirsch, Forgotten ways, 24 25; Michael Frost and Alan Hirsch, ReJesus: A Wild Messiah for a Missional Church (Peabody: Hendrickson, 2009); Alan Hirsch and Darryn Altclass, The Forgotten Ways Handbook to a Revolution: A Guide to Mission Incarnational Practice (Grand Rapids: Brazos, 2009); Alan Hirsch and Debra Hirsch, Untamed: Reactivating a Missional Form of Discipleship (Grand Rapids: Baker Books/ Shapevine, 2010); Alan Hirsch and Dave Ferguson, On the Verge: A Journey into the Apostolic Future of the Church (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2011); Alan Hirsch and Lance Ford, Right Here, Right Now: Everyday Mission for Everyday People (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2011); Michael Frost and Alan Hirsch, The Faith of Leap: Embracing a Theology of Risk, Adventure & Courage (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2011); http://www.theforgottenways.org/. 25 Hirsch says A catalyst inspires people to connect and talk about things that matter. In a ministry sense, catalysts facilitate discussion and dreaming around participating in Gods missionary endeavour. Hirsch and Altclass, TFW handbook, 134. 26 Ephesians 4:11; Frost and Hirsch, Shaping of Things to Come, 165 81, 218 23; discussed in Cronshaw, Shaping of Things Now, 66 68, 198 203. My doctoral research evaluated Forge inspired churches, and I worked with Forge as part time Director of Theological Studies 2005 2009 and have an ongoing sessional role supervising students doing Forge courses through ACOM, Whitley and Stirling Colleges. 229

them out of their comfort zone. They were supported with monthly coaching and peer clusters to reflect on what they were experiencing in mission, and three teaching intensives with inspirational mission practitioners. It is a reflection in action experience 27, and focused on acting into new ways of thinking rather than expecting students to think into new ways of acting. 28 A third of interns did Forge for accredited study with a partnering college (including Tabor and Whitley), but most were attracted just for the value of the inspiration and networks. Forge has given hundreds of interns and students exposure to ministry among the poor, new paradigms for mission, disciplines for sustainability in mission, and skills in cultural analysis and understanding consumerism. Often what interns most appreciated was hearing stories of imaginative new expressions of mission and seeing it in action, and having the space to dream and implement their own passions. Forge has had to scale down Australian operations in recent years, even as it has been spreading in others parts of the world. And there is a need to evaluate the results of Forge s training and the sustainability of its church plants. But the mission of Forge remains: to help birth and nurture the missional church in Australia and beyond. 29 Consecration through the Spirit to mission Frost, Hirsch and Forge s legacy underline how revolutionary it is to understand that God is missio Dei a missionary God and the Spirit is a missionary Spirit, who sends and invites God s people to join God in mission. To be in step with the Spirit in theological education includes helping our students realise their identity as missionaries. It will fuel an entrepreneurial, pioneering spirit to join with what God is doing in the world. Lesslie Newbigin appealed for distinctly missional leadership formation: Ministerial training as currently conceived is still far too much training for the pastoral care of the existing congregation, and far too little oriented toward the missionary calling to claim the whole of public life for Christ and his kingdom. 30 Frost and Hirsch are among those inspired by Newbigin who are calling for a recalibration of the church in the West around mission. Instead of starting with an assumed and inherited picture of church, they ask what would be the shaping of church if we centred on mission, and formed our understanding of mission around Christ? So the ordering is Jesus Mission Church. 31 The training challenge is to help our students have their imagination captured by a fresh encounter and understanding of Jesus, in order to shape their understanding of mission, and to let their understanding of mission shape how they lead the church. Furthermore, what would be the shape of our mission if we shaped it around a renewed Trinitarian understanding of God? There are two streams of how Trinitarian theology can help us understand what it means to be in step with the Spirit in mission and 27 Banks, Reenvisioning, 147. 28 Hirsch, Forgotten Ways, 120 124; drawing on Richard T Pascale, Mark Millemann, and Linda Gioja, Surfing the Edge of Chaos: The Laws of Nature and the New Laws of Business (New York: Crown, 2000), 14. 29 Frost and Hirsch, Shaping of Things to Come, 219. 30 Lesslie Newbigin, The Gospel in a Pluralist Society (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1989), 231. 31 Frost and Hirsch, Shaping of Things to Come, 16, 209. 230

theological education. 32 Firstly, there is a Trinitarian sending work of God: the Father sending the Son, Father and the Son sending the Spirit, the Trinitarian godhead sending the church. 33 Part of the good news of the Trinitarian God sending us into the world is that the Spirit goes before us. Newbigin explains: the Spirit who thus bears witness in the life of the Church to the purpose of the Father is not confined within the limits of the Church. It is the clear teaching of the Acts of the Apostles, as it is the experience of missionaries, that the Spirit goes, so to speak, ahead of the Church. 34 Frost and Hirsch encourage Christians to adopt a spirituality of engagement, based on the understanding that God goes ahead of us into even so called secular areas and sends us there to discern and join what God is doing. 35 The other Trinitarian stream that shapes mission and potentially reenvisions theological education is social trinitarianism: the interrelatedness and interdependence of three persons in the Godhead and how this reality is reflected in the church. 36 God in three persons models social life and invites people into the life and community of God, or more poetically the perichoresis; the movement or dance of God. 37 Not only does God send the people of God into the world, but God who is already active in the world invites us to join how God is moving, creating and dancing in the world. The church as a community inmission mirrors the overflowing self giving community of Trinitarian life. 38 Forge has focused more on understanding missio Dei and the centrality of Jesus in the gospels as inspiration for mission. 39 But social trinitarianism richly inspires our mission and theological education to be in step with God Father, Son and Spirit. The Holy Spirit is a spirit of creativity and of mission; to experience consecration through the Spirit is intrinsically missional. The early church realised their need to be in step and filled with the Spirit in order to fulfil the mission of God (Acts 1 2). Jesus himself modelled consecration through the Spirit and living its missional implications (Luke 4:18 19). Forge writers acknowledge that the missional church movement and its training has not learned as much as they could from the charismatic and Pentecostal traditions. Hirsch comments, What is still largely 32 Stephen B Bevans and Roger P Schroeder, Constants in Context: A Theology of Mission for Today (Maryknoll: Orbis, 2004), 286 304; Craig Van Gelder, How missiology can help inform the conversation about the missional church in context in The Missional Church in Context: Helping Congregations Develop Contextual Ministry, ed. Craig van Gelder (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2007), 28 30. 33 David Bosch, Mission to the world: The Christian Mission in Theological Perspective (London: Marshall, Morgan & Scott, 1980), 390. 34 Lesslie Newbigin, Trinitarian Faith for Today s Mission (Richmond: John Knox, 1964), 49. 35 Frost and Hirsch, Shaping of Things to Come, 95 133; Frost, Exiles, 142. 36 John D Zizioulas, Being as Communion (Crestwood: St Vladimir's Seminary, 1985); Trinitarian perspectives previously discussed in Shaping of Things Now, 61 62. 37 Catherine Mowry LaCugna, God for Us: the Trinity and Christian Life (San Francisco: Harper, 1991), 272; Miroslav Volf, After our likeness: The Church as the Image of the Trinity (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1998); popularised at Tabor by C Baxter Kruger, The Great Dance: The Christian Vision Revisited (Blackwood: Perichoresis, 2002). 38 Bevans and Schroeder, Constants, 287. 39 Hirsch, Forgotten Ways, 180 81; Frost, Exiles, 146 47; Michael Frost, In a league of their own? An examination and assessment of the claims and practice of the emerging church in Australia (DMin thesis, Australian College of Theology, 2008), 45 50, 93; cf. Gary M Simpson, A Reformation is a terrible thing to waste: A promising theology for an emerging missional church, in The Missional Church in Context: Helping Congregations Develop Contextual Ministry, ed. Craig van Gelder (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2007), 75 83. 231

missing from this emergent phenomenon is any sustained and explicit Pentecostal presence, with all its fire and passion. 40 On the other hand, charismatic and Pentecostal interest in the Spirit has not always been missional at its heart. This section leads me to ask what does consecration through the Spirit mean in terms of our mission? At our best, what does it mean to reenvision theological education around missional church, and for missional church to experience consecration through the Spirit? C. Whitley College and Michael Leunig s playful contemplative prayers Michael Leunig Michael Leunig is arguably Australia s most popular contemporary poet and artist. His work, though not explicitly Christian, combines prophetic challenge, spiritual dimension and humorous asides. Outside the Bible, his work would be the most quoted by the worship leaders in my local church. People love the way he weaves words and comic art to invite us to contemplate the importance of relationships and nature, prayer and solitude, recreation and justice. Leunig s cartoons appear regularly in daily newspapers in Melbourne, often commentating on political and social issues, but also showing astute understanding of the pressures of suburbia and modern lifestyles. Like the best of Christian mystics, Leunig values space for contemplation but also courage for prophetic social engagement. In his booklet, When I Talk to You: A Cartoonist Talks to God, he includes a prayer that treasures places of simplicity and peace and how cultivating our inner lives can help us transform the world: Dear God, We give thanks for places of simplicity and peace. Let us find such a place within ourselves. We give thanks for places of refuge and beauty. Let us find such a place within ourselves. We give thanks for places of nature s truth and freedom, of joy, inspiration and renewal, places where all creatures may find acceptance and belonging. Let us search for these places: in the world, in ourselves and in others. Let us restore them. Let us strengthen and protect them and let us create them. May we mend this outer world according to the truth of our inner life and may our souls be shaped and nourished by nature s eternal wisdom. 41 Leunig is committed to addressing issues of the world but also cultivating the soul; to be contemplative in the interest of personal and social change: God help us to change. To change ourselves and to change our world. To know the need for it. 40 Hirsch, Forgotten ways, 271; cf. Michael Frost, Towards a Missional Perspective on the Holy Spirit, in Cheryl Catford (ed), Following Fire: How the Spirit Leads Us to Fight Injustice (Melbourne: UNOH, 2008), 33 41. 41 Michael Leunig, When I Talk to You: A Cartoonist Talks to God (Pymble, NSW: HarperCollins, 2004). My italics. 232

To deal with the pain of it. To feel the joy of it. To undertake the journey without understanding the destination. The art of gentle revolution. Amen. 42 Although he does not capture the fullness of the gospel, Leunig is a source of inspiration for me to be in step with the Spirit; to be open to change and repentance and join with God s art of gentle revolution that we understand as the kingdom of God. He models an acute attentiveness to my cultural context, a willingness to engage courageously with its big social and political and lifestyle issues, and a commitment to slowing down and finding contemplative space in the midst of life s challenges. Whitley College The place that has most taught me and embodied for me a commitment to both context and contemplation is Whitley College, the Baptist Theological College of Victoria. 43 In 2010 they had 353 students (98 EFTS), including 90 TransFormation students, an innovative program for culturally and linguistically diverse students. 44 With a vision for equipping leaders for a different world, they have recently overhauled their whole curriculum and college life. 45 But attention to our Australian cultural contexts remains an important aspect of teaching across the curriculum. Whitley s Principal Frank Rees encourages exploration of what it means to be Christian and church in the unique context of Australia, and to reflect theologically on this in conversation with Australian cultural forms: We need not only a quest for an Australian spirituality but an Australian theology images, metaphors and stories to name God in new ways, Australian ways. We need to sift through our literature, films and music, our ways of living and working and playing, to find new ways of understanding and being church. 46 Rees conversational method of contextual theology invites culture and experience as theological sources in conversation with Scripture and tradition. 47 Whitley offers a number of units on mission in Australian contexts but also grapples with contemporary cultural challenges across the curriculum Charles Sherlock suggests Whitley offers the 42 Michael Leunig, Common Prayer Collection (North Blackburn: HarperCollins, 1993). I discuss these prayers and other aspects of Leunig in Darren Cronshaw, Credible Witness: Companions, Prophets, Hosts and Other Australian Mission Models (Melbourne: Urban Neighbours of Hope, 2006), 32 37; inspired in part by Mark Brett, The gospel according to Michael Leunig, Collins Street Baptist Church Bulletin (Sunday 14 April 2001), a reflection on A Conversation with Michael Leunig, Whitley College, Melbourne (10 April 2002). 43 My involvement with Whitley includes training for ordination and study programs in 1996 1999 and 2005 2009, teaching as adjunct faculty in leadership and mission since 2001, and being an Honorary Research Associate with MCD since 2011. 44 Cf. Sherlock, Uncovering Theology, 133. 45 Ross Langmead, Report on Whitley's directions (Unpublished paper, 19 June 2010); Whitley College Undergraduate information (2010), accessible at, http://whitley.unimelb.edu.au/theologicalschool/handbooks 2010. This section draws on previous discussion of Whitley in my Reenvisioning theological education, 94 108. 46 Frank Rees, Oz Church goes to kinder, St Mark's Review (1999): 21 26, at 21. 47 Frank Rees, Beating around in the bush: methodological directions for Australian theology, Pacifica 10 (2002): 266 293, at 285 286. 233

most integrated contextual approach of any Australian college. 48 Dean of the Theological School and Missiology Professor, Ross Langmead, teaches on mission in the Australian context. 49 Hebrew Bible Professor Mark Brett teaches insights that biblical scholars can learn from Aboriginal perspectives on the land and oral traditions. 50 And a unit on specifically Australian contextual theology is titled Curly Flat Theology, referring to the imaginary land Curly Flat where Leunig places some of his characters who reflect on what is most important in life. Whitley s syllabus assumes we can be faithful to Scripture and integrally engaged with our cultural contexts; indeed, being in step with the missionary Spirit demands it. 51 A second key element of Whitley s ethos is contemplation. We need to know our world (with contextual awareness) but we also need to know our God and our selves (through contemplative prayer and formation). Our colleges and processes for leadership formation need to rigorously engage the academy but also, as Henri Nouwen suggests, need to reclaim the place of the monastery and silence to cultivate communion with God. 52 As part of formation, Langmead teaches the importance of guarding space for contemplation. As an activist for mission and justice he is engaged with difficult issues that need transformation, but warns: If mission were all action, with no reflection, we would go off the rails. We would hard sell the gospel, organise our way to being an international brand name, manage the church and cram every living moment with mission activity. But it s mission with mystery, and waiting is as important as outreach, listening as speaking, responding as pro active planning. The reflective and meditative dimension of mission is central. 53 Whitley does not teach that contemplation is separate from everyday life and ministry, but engaged with it. They also offer a range of subjects on Spirituality, Vocation and Community, Experiencing God, Patterns in the Practice of Christianity, Table Spirituality, Spirituality of Everyday Life, Contemporary Spiritual Writers and Spirituality Beyond Consumerism. A highlight of my studies at Whitley was practising new spiritual disciplines together with a small class, and my teacher Jill Manton challenging me towards deeper contemplation and reflection and not just rushing to finish an assignment. A highlight of my teaching at Whitley is seeing students discerning their vocation and exercising spiritual practices for their assignments. It is easy for students to prefer intellectually focused book reviews and essays, but a well crafted practical assignment can help students learn to contemplate deeply and practise consecration through the Spirit. This section leads me to ask what does it mean to be consecrated to the Spirit in terms of contextualisation and contemplation? At our best in theological education, how can we help students to be consecrated to the Spirit in their cultural engagement and in 48 Sherlock, Uncovering Theology, 115, cf. 208, 244 245. 49 Ross Langmead, Re Imagining God and Mission: Perspectives from Australia (Adelaide: Australian Theological Forum, 2007). 50 Mark Brett, Feeling for country: interpreting the Old Testament in the Australian context, Pacifica 23 (June 2010): 137 156, at 145. 51 Cronshaw, Credible Witness, 8, 160 75. 52 Henri J Nouwen, The way of the heart: desert spirituality and contemporary ministry (San Francisco: HarperCollins, 1991), 46 48; see also Banks, Reenvisioning, 162 63. 53 Ross Langmead, Theological reflection in ministry and mission, Ministry, society and theology 18 (2004): 25 26; drawing on Donald E Messer, Contemporary images of Christian ministry (Nashville: Abingdon, 1989). 234

their contemplative prayer? What does it mean to reenvision theological education around our contexts and our calling to be prayerful? Benediction What is the path to being in step with the Spirit and practising consecration through the Spirit in our leadership formation and theological education? This article has suggested part of the answer is in reenvisioning our approach to vocation and the ministry of the whole people of God (inspired by Banks and Tabor), recalibrating our churches around mission (inspired by Forge) and recentring with contemplation and seriously engaging our contexts (inspired by Leunig and Whitley). Grappling with this project, I resonate with another of Leunig s prayers which is an appropriate conclusion: God help us with ideas, those thoughts which inform the way we live and the things we do. Let us not seize upon ideas, neither shall we hunt them down nor steal them away. Rather let us wait faithfully for them to approach, slowly and gently like creatures from the wild. And let them enter willingly into our hearts and come and go freely within the sanctuary of our contemplation, informing our souls as they arrive and being enlivened by the inspiration of our hearts as they leave. These shall be our truest thoughts. Our willing and effective ideas. Let us treasure their humble originality. Let us follow them gently back into the world with faith that they shall lead us to lives of harmony and integrity. Amen. 54 Author: Darren Cronshaw is passionate about training, coaching and resourcing leaders and missionaries through his work as the Coordinator of Leadership Training with the Baptist Union of Victoria and Pastor of Auburn Baptist Church. He is an Honorary Research Associate with Whitley College (MCD) and Associate Professor in Missiology and Pastoral Theology with Australian Colleges of Ministries (SCD), and has also taught with Tabor College Victoria and Forge Mission Training Network. He completed a Doctor of Theology in 2008 through Whitley (MCD) with the help of an Australian Postgraduate Award, supervised by Dr Ross Langmead and published as The shaping of things now: emerging church mission and innovation in 21st century Melbourne (Saarbrücken: VDM Verlag, 2009). Email: darren.cronshaw@buv.com.au 2011 Darren Cronshaw 54 Leunig, When I talk to you. 235