2 ABBOT SUGER, 1081-1151 Ambula(ory and chapels, Abbe C v ou h. rc,sr.-de' POO(O Cre<!ir: Foto" b nls, France, 1140-44 "la, U'g/A. rr Resource, NY 42 Abbot uger
In 1122, Suger was appoinred the head of the Abbey Church of St.-Denis, an institution that for many centuries had been associated with the sovereigns of France. As the original ninth-century church was in need of enlargement and repair, Suger set out to create a magnificenr and lavish religious building to surpass all others. Indeed, the new St.-Denis, as conceived by Suger but completed after his death, contained a number of srrucrural, spatial, and aesthetic innovations. For example, exterior buttressing allowed the mass of the walls to dematerialize and be largely replaced by colorful stained glass. This was especially apparent in the newly devised double ambulatory (located at the far end of the church behind rhe alrar and choir), an area replete with dazzling colored lighr rhat filtered in through stained glass windows. The increased transparency, brightly colored light, and novel planning configurations, as well as other specialized developments, caused many architectural historians to acknowledge the renovated St.-Denis, begun largely at Suger's behest, as the first truly Gothic structure. Suger's documentation ofst.-denis's reconstruction, excerpted below, provides a rare glimpse into a significant work of medieval architecture. 43
The Book of Sugar, Abbot of St.-Denis, On What Was Done Under His Administration (1144-49) XXV. Of the First Addition to the Church... I found myself, under the inspiration of the Divine will and because of that inadequacy which we often saw and felt on feast days... (for the narrowness of the place forced the women to run toward the altar upon the heads of the men as upon a pavement with much anguish and noisy confusion), encouraged by the counsel of wise men and by the prayers of many monks... to enlarge and amplify the noble church consecrated by the Hand Divine; and I set our at once to begin this very thing... Thus we began work at the former entrance with the doors. We tore down a certain addition asserted to have been made by Charlemagne on a very honorable occasion... and we set our hand to this part. As is evident we exerted ourselves incessantly with the enlargement of the body of the church as well as with the trebling of the entrance and the doors, and with the erection of high and noble towers... The Other Little Book on the Consecration of the Church of St.-Denis (1144-46/47) II... Since in the front part, toward the north, at the main entrance with the main doors, the narrow hall was squeezed in on either side by twin towers neither very sturdy bur threatening ruin, we began, with the help of God, strenuously high nor to work Abbot Suger of St.-Denis "On What W D. ' as one Under HIS Administration" and "The Other little Book on the Consecration of the Church ofsr.-deni 44 ".... s,11-1149, 10 The Book O/Suger, Abbot of Sr-Denis, trans. and ed. ErwlO Panofsky (PflnCeton' P. U".. flnceton niversitypress, 1946) 43-51, 89-91. 20d ed. Gerda Panofsky- Soergel (Pnnceton: Princeton Universir Press 1..... y, 979). Ong1Oally rltled Liber de rebtts in administratione sua gesti, 0144--1149) and LibelLus alter de.. Repflnted. WIth. permission of the publisher. eonseeratlone ecclesia«saneti Dionysii 0144-1146/47) ' respectively- 44 Abbot Suget
on this part, having laid very strong material foundations for a straight nave and twin towers, and most strong spiritual ones of which it is said: For otherfoundation can no man lay than that is laid, which is]esus Christ. Leaning upon God's inestimable counsel and irrefragable aid, we proceeded with this so great and so sumptuous work to such an extent that, while at first, expending little, we lacked much, afterwards, expending much, we lacked nothing at all and even confessed in our abundance: Our sufficiencyis of God. Through a gift of God a new quarry, yielding very strong stone, was discovered such as in quality and quantity had never been found in these regions. There arrived a skillful crowd of masons, stonecutters, sculptors and other workmen, so that-thus and otherwise-divinity relieved us of our fears and favored us with Its goodwill by comforting us and by providing us with unexpected [resources}.... In carrying out such plans my first thought was for the concordance and harmony of the ancient and the new work.... [from On What Was Done Under His Administration} XXVII. Of rhe Cast and Gilded Doors Bronze casters having been summoned and sculptors chosen, we set up the Main doors on which are represented the Passion of the Savior and His Resurrection, or rather Ascension, with great cost and much expenditure for their gilding as was fitting for the noble porch. Also [we set up} others, new ones on the right side and the old ones on the left beneath the mosaic which, though contrary to modern custom, we ordered to be executed there and to be affixed to the tympanum of the portal. We also committed ourselves richly to elaborate the tower[s} and the upper crenelations of the front, both for the beauty of the church and, should circumstances require it, for practical purposes. Further we ordered the year of the consecration, lest it be forgotten, to be inscribed in copper-gilt letters in the following manner: For the splendor of the church that has fostered and exalted him. Suger has labored for the splendor of the church. 45
Giving thee a share of what is thine, 0 Martyr Denis, He prays to thee to pray that he may obtain a share of Paradise. The year was the One Thousand, One Hundred, and Fortieth Year of the Word when [this structure} was consecrated. The verses on the door, further, are these: Whoever thou art, if thou seekest to extol the glory of these doors, Marvel not at the gold and the expense but at the craftsmanship of the work. Bright is the noble work; but, being nobly bright, the work Should brighten the minds, so that they may travel, through lights, the true To the True Light where Christ is the true door. In what manner it be inherent in this world the golden door defines: The dull mind rises in truth through that which is material And, in seeing this light, is resurrected from its former submersion. XXVIII. Of the Enlargement of the Upper Choir In the same year, cheered by so holy and so auspicious a work, we hurried to begin the chamber of the divine atonement in the upper choir... How much the Hand Divine Which operates in such matters has protected this glorious work is also surely proven by the fact that it allowed that whole magnificent building in three years and three months, from the crypt below to the summits above, elaborated with the variety of so many arches and columns, including [to be completed} of the vaults even the consummation of the roof Therefore the inscription of the earlier consecration also defines, with only one word eliminated, the year of completion of this one, thus: The year was One Thousand, One Hundred, Forry and Fourth of the Word when [this structure} Wasconsecrated. 46 Abbot Suget
To these verses of the inscription we choose the following ones to be added: Once the new rear parr is jointed to the part in front, The church shines with its middle part brightened. For bright is that which is brightly coupled with the bright, And bright is the noble edifice which is pervaded by the new light; Which stands enlarged in our time, I, who was Suger, being the leader while it was being accomplished. Eager to press on my success, since I wished nothing more under heaven than to seek the honor of my mother church which with maternal affection had suckled me as a child... we devoted ourselves to the completion of the work and strove to raise and to enlarge the transept wings of the church [so as to correspond} to the form of the earlier and latter work that had to be joined by them. 47