Unity Transformation Experience and Integral Spirituality

Similar documents
CREATING THRIVING, COHERENT AND INTEGRAL NEW THOUGHT CHURCHES USING AN INTEGRAL APPROACH AND SECOND TIER PRACTICES

RUNNING HEAD: Philosophy and Theology 1. Christine Orsini RELS 111 Professor Fletcher March 21, 2012 Short Writing Assignment 2

Transformation Experience. Enlightened Leaders Program

Spirituality & Healing! How addressing spirit for ourselves and our clients can improve health outcomes.!

MINISTRY LEADERSHIP. Objectives for students. Master's Level. Ministry Leadership 1

President s Address. October 4, Let s listen again to this paragraph from the words of counsel:

God s Playing a New Game

In Search of a New Moral Compass The Guru and the Pandit Ken Wilber and Andrew Cohen in Dialogue

SPIRITUAL LIFE SURVEY REPORT. One Life Church. September 2011

Introduction 5. What Must I Do to Be Saved? 9. Saved by Grace... Isn t That Too Good to Be True? 17

Experiential & Writing Exercises from The Transformation Trilogy by Penney Peirce

National Standards and Benchmarks for Effective. Catholic Elementary and Secondary Schools. Rubrics for Benchmarks

HarperOne Reading and Discussion Guide for In Praise of Doubt. Reading and Discussion Guide for. In Praise of Doubt

The Scripture Engagement of Students at Christian Colleges

Catechist Formation FAQ s for Pastors, Clergy and Parish Leaders

THE CONGRUENT LIFE CHAPTER 1

Quantum Consciousness: Our Evolution, Our Salvation. Written by Ervin Laszlo Thursday, 01 March :00 - Last Updated Monday, 19 August :38

Gibbs, Eddie, Leadership Next, Downers Grove, Illinois: Intervarsity Press, pp. Reviewed by Parnell M. Lovelace, Jr.

What Is Integral Spirituality?

meets Integral Yoga Integral Discussion

REMNANT, RESTORATION, AND REVOLUTION

by scientists in social choices and in the dialogue leading to decision-making.

A Faith Revolution Is Redefining "Church," According to New Study

Reading. The Impersonal Life

The Leadership of Hindu Gurus: Its Meaning and Implications for Practice

Consultation Report for Atascocita UMC

GENEROSITY BEYOND THE STATUS QUO

PHILOSOPHY. Chair: Karánn Durland (Fall 2018) and Mark Hébert (Spring 2019) Emeritus: Roderick Stewart

VISIONING TOOL FOR INTERGENERATIONAL MINISTRY

REVEAL Spiritual Vitality Index for Brazos Meadows Baptist Church

SAMPLE Prior Learning Proposal for USM Core: Ethical Inquiry requirement

Experiential & Writing Exercises from Penney Peirce s Books on Transformation. 1 THE INTUITIVE WAY: The Definitive Guide to Increasing Your Awareness

Whole Person Caring: A New Paradigm for Healing and Wellness

Dierkes, Christopher. Indistinct Union: An Integral Introduction to Nonduality in Christianity. In Journal of Integral Theory and Practice 5/3

Instructor's Manual for Gregg Barak s Integrating Criminologies. Prepared by Paul Leighton (Boston: Allyn & Bacon, 1997) * CHAPTER 4

The Wisdom Of The Overself: The Path To Self-Realization And Philosophic Insight, Volume 2 PDF

Reasons for Belief Session 1 I Struggle With Doubt. Is That OK?

REMNANT, RESTORATION, AND REVOLUTION

Sounds of Love. Intuition and Reason

ENLIGHTENMENT UNVEILED BY JEN WARD

Appendix. One of the most important tests of the value of a survey is the sniff

Messianism and Messianic Jews

Wilber s AQAL Map and Beyond. Introduction. Wilber s AQAL Map

Russo-Netzer, P. (in press). Spiritual Development. In: In: M. H. Bornstein,

The Life Visioning Process is a spiritual technology

To change lives through the unchanging truth of God s love.

POLI 343 Introduction to Political Research

This pamphlet was produced by Young People s Ministries.

Mystic s Musings. An interview with Sadhguru Jaggi Vasudev, realized master an. page 26

Spirituality in Higher Education: A National Study of College Students Search for Meaning and Purpose

Stewardship Roadmap. Elmhurst CRC

Video Reaction. Opening Activity. Journal #16

2004 College Students' Beliefs and Values (CSBV) Factor Scales Table Using 2004/2007 Sample

Introducing Hybrid-7

Northfield Methodist Church

Reiki Inspired Art. THOUSANDS OF YEARS before art for art s sake became

studyıng phılosophy: a brıght ıdea

Meditation and Insight II The Role of Insight in Buddhadharma

Spiritual Gifts Assessment Traders Point Christian Church

Qualitative Research Methods Assistant Prof. Aradhna Malik Vinod Gupta School of Management Indian Institute of Technology - Kharagpur

A Study of National Market Potential for CHEC Institutions

Report on UCC Conference Ministers Delegation to China April 4, 2011

Evolutionary Enlightenment: A New Path To Spiritual Awakening By Andrew Cohen, Deepak Chopra

In writing this paper, I will be looking at the curriculum SPICE RACK - and

BOOK REVIEW: Gideon Yaffee, Manifest Activity: Thomas Reid s Theory of Action

Master of Arts in Health Care Mission

Illustration by Gaia Orion

The Intellectual Life of the Bahá í Community by Farzam Arbab

The Soul Journey Education for Higher Consciousness

In Concerning the Difference between the Spirit and the Letter in Philosophy, Johann

Leadership Network - ADVANCE

4 Elements of Transformational Leadership

A Brief History of Thinking about Thinking Thomas Lombardo

Copyright 2017 All Rights Reserved Worldwide Angel Lady Aurora, LLC

Neo-Confucianism: Metaphysics, Mind, and Morality

Poetry as Data Analysis: Honoring the words of research participants

The Use of Self in Therapy

THE OFFERING MOMENT 90 SECONDS TO ENGAGE YOUR GIVERS

Healing the Spirit After Cancer

Philosophy 125 Day 1: Overview

Romans: The Practice of Righteousness (part 1 of 13)

DANIEL AKIN, President, Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary

WHY APOLOGETICS HAS A BAD NAME

Stewardship, Finances, and Allocation of Resources

Trinda Latherow, Author of Pieces of the Puzzle book Series Interview with Enoch Tan on Wed, 18 Apr 2007

Interview. with Ravi Ravindra. Can science help us know the nature of God through his creation?

BY-LAWS THE MISSIONARY CHURCH, INC., WESTERN REGION

CONGREGATIONAL VITALITY VOL

VEDANTIC MEDITATION. North Asian International Research Journal of Social Science & Humanities. ISSN: Vol. 3, Issue-7 July-2017 TAPAS GHOSH

THE VITAL ROLE OF CULTURAL ANTHROPOLOGY IN DEVELOPMENT OF THEOLOGY by Robert H. Munson

RECONNECT The Spirit of Truth John 15:18 16:15. Introduction

A Smaller Church in a Bigger World?

Cultural factors in Discipling: Critiquing Cultures Together. Katie Rawson ACMI InterVarsity Christian Fellowship

Suffering = Stuck. The Wheel of the Cart. by GP 2010 GP Walsh - All Rights Reserved. Page 1

National Incubator for Community-Based Jewish Teen Education Initiatives Qualitative Research on Jewish Teens Fall 2014-Winter 2015

Fruitful Congregation Journey Consultation Report Smith Valley United Methodist Church March 17, 2013

20 September A Time to Act!

World without Design: The Ontological Consequences of Natural- ism , by Michael C. Rea.

St. Anselm Church 2017 Community Life Survey Results

Congregational Vitality Survey

Transcription:

Unity Transformation Experience and Integral Spirituality April 2013 To my dear Unity family I am again sending an open letter to you about what I believe to be the greatest threat to Unity's ministry today. I am aware that what is revealed below may shock some readers. Please know that my intention is not to shock or be inflammatory in any way. I send it anonymously so that it may reach your discerning heart, without personality, and that you may ponder and chose to accept or reject my thinking in the quiet of your stilled mind. I do not wish to debate, only to highlight and inform. I trust that Spirit flows through you, as you, as me, and that, together, we shall move forward in harmony and love. Four years of Unity's Transformation Experience Unity Worldwide Ministries has placed tremendous effort and focus on the Transformation Experience 1 during the past four years. Twenty-two articles about the pilot program of thirteen churches in TE have appeared in Contact Magazine, making it the most covered topic in Contact Magazine since 2009. 2 Ministers of pilot ministries have contributed nearly half of the articles, beginning with Aliza Bloom's June 2010 piece entitled The Path of Transformation Is Not Always Easy. Her piece sets the pattern for most of these stories, describing a leap of faith, frustration and murmurings emerging a little later, the sage guidance of Consultant Guides and the eventual shift from a minister-centric model of ministry to a community model. It seems to me that there is something unusual here. Doesn't it seem strange that a pilot program of thirteen churches has dominated Unity's attention for over four years? Was all this attention really about a dozen or so churches? If so, the pilot officially ended in September 2012, so where are the details about exit interviews and metrics? Why were there no results in the March 2013 issue of Contact Magazine? If not, what was the Transformation Experience about anyway? What was the Transformation Experience about? Take a look at the June 2011 article in Contact Magazine by Gary Simmons about his 1 Unity Transformation Experience http://www.unityworldwideministries.org/transformation-experience 2 Transformation Experience Contact Magazine Articles Overview http://www.unityworldwideministries.org/transformation-experience-contact-magazine-articles-overview Unity Transformation Experience and Integral Spirituality p.1

conversation with Ken Wilber entitled Ken Wilber Applauds the Transformation Experience. 3 Gary writes, Ken explained that moving to any enlightened perspective requires not only a movement toward greater spiritual maturity, but also an actual leap in consciousness. This leap is not possible unless the church s leadership is actively engaged in spiritual practice and shadow work... I shared how each ministry in the Pilot Program has an Art & Practice Ambassador trained in facilitating a 21-Day aware-apy activity called the Q Process TM a methodology for shadow work and how this has equipped leaders to differentiate between issues that arise from the organization s pain body and their own shadow material. It seems to me that there are two concerns here: (1) the goal of bringing about a leap in consciousness by means of shadow work and (2) the adoption of a method of doing shadow work described as 21-Day aware-apy activity called the Q Process TM. I will address them in reverse order. The Q Effect If you read the eleven stories by ministers of pilot ministries of the TE, you'll see plenty of positive references about The Art & Practice of Living with Nothing and No One Against You and the Q Process. Gary has his own article in the March 2012 issue of Contact Magazine, which describes this method and has the following byline: Rev. Dr. Gary Simmons is co-founder of the Q Effect, LLC, and serves the New Thought movement as a private consultant. For information on hosting a no-upfrontcosts Art & Practice of Living with Nothing and No One Against You workshop or how to become a certified Q Coach, visit www.theqeffect.com. In June 2010 Contact Magazine had a story entitled Q and A About the Transformation Experience which answered the question How is it financed? by saying we have been blessed by donors who dedicated funds to this process. In addition, our Association receives a Templeton grant specifically for this project. Each pilot ministry agreed to send 3 Contact Magazine http://content.unity.org/association/publications/contactmagazine.html Unity Transformation Experience and Integral Spirituality p.2

10 percent of our income to the Association. In June 2011 Deborah Frownfelter wrote that The total income for the Transformation Experience comes from the John Templeton Foundation grant monies plus the increased portion of tithes from the Thriving Ministries Pilot Program and Enlightened Leaders Program participating ministries. There are some serious issues here. If Gary was employed by UWM, why was the program he developed not part of the intellectual property of UWM? Second, since Gary was at sometime previously employed by UWM, was there a transparent process that selected Q Effect, LLC as the principle contractor for Transformation Experience? Finally, it is said in two articles that no operating funds from UWM went into the TE program. But the question remains how much of the money which went to UWM from Templeton, tithes and donations flowed out to Q Effect, LLC? If UWM decides to continue the program, should we not expect that a full accounting of finances be included in the report of results that we expect from UWM? Is there not a transparency issue here? Can we trust the process without a full accounting of all transactions? The Leap in Consciousness The second question is who is Ken Wilber and what does he have to say about leaps in consciousness? Ken Wilber is a well-known American philosopher and you can find plenty of information about him and by him on the Internet. In June 2005 Ken Wilber wrote a summary of his beliefs as they relate directly to the role of spirituality in the modern and postmodern world. The document is 118 pages and available on the Internet by doing a search on What is Integral Spirituality? 4 I encourage you to download and read the document. Here are some things that Wilber says in Integral Spirituality: Metaphysical Baggage. Wilber writes on pp.3-4, 12-13: We start with the simple observation that the 'metaphysics' of the spiritual traditions have been thoroughly trashed by both modernist and postmodernist epistemologies, and there has as yet arisen nothing compelling to take their place. So this paper begins with an overview of the methodologies available that can be used to reconstruct the spiritual systems of the great wisdom traditions but with none of their metaphysical baggage 4 Ken Wilber What is Integral Spirituality? http://files.meetup.com/91062/integral%20spirituality.pdf Unity Transformation Experience and Integral Spirituality p.3

This leads to an entirely new approach to metaphysics that is actually postmetaphysics, in that it requires none of the traditional baggage of metaphysics The important truth advanced by the postmodernist epistemologies is that all perceptions are actually perspectives, and all perspectives are embedded in bodies and in cultures. Wilber is advocating for a postmodern version of Metaphysics. Truth, rather than being revealed by God (the traditionalst approach), or by being discovered by science (the modern approach), is embedded in culture as a perspective. Egocentric, Ethnocentric and Worldcentric Worldview. On p. 18 Wilber refers to the way we respond to life as being preconventional, conventional, and postconventional. We often summarize these as egocentric, ethnocentric, and worldcentric. He describes these worldviews by posing an old question: A poor man is married to a woman who has a terminal illness that an expensive medicine can cure. Does he have the right to steal the medicine? Wilber explains that the traditionalist, characterized by the pre-conventional response, will say Fuck you, nobody tells me what to do! IQ and morality. Wilber describes a dozen or so lines of human development, which include the cognitive, moral, spiritual, emotional lines (p.27). But he emphasizes the importance of the cognitive line and implies that stupid people have no morality: you can be highly developed in the cognitive line and poorly developed in the moral line (very smart but not very moral: Nazi doctors), but we don't find the reverse (low IQ, highly moral). Spiral Dynamics, Primitive States and Jesus. Wilber enthusiastically embraces the Spiral Dynamics idea ranking of human development in history and in individuals. On pages 49-51 he asks how, in whatever way that we define enlightenment today, can somebody 2000 years ago say, Buddha or Christ Jesus or Padmasambhava still be said to be 'enlightened' or 'fully realized' by any meaningful definition? Is it possible that someone like Jesus, who lived in the lower stages of development such as magic or mythic could still have profound religious, spiritual, and meditative state experiences. Wilber's answer is affirmative, but complicated. The subtle answer is that yes, Jesus was enlightened, at the magical, preconventional and egocentric stage of development in which he lived (p.54). Worldcentric and Postconventional or Nazi. Wilber writes on p. 92: Unity Transformation Experience and Integral Spirituality p.4

Start with a few facts. Depending on which scales you use, somewhere between 50-70% of the world's population is at the ethnocentric or lower waves of development. This means amber or lower in any of the lines. To put it in the bluntest terms possible, this means around 70% of the world's population are Nazis In the great developmental unfolding from egocentric to ethnocentric to worldcentric and higher, 70% of the world's population has not yet made it to worldcentric, postconventional levels of development. So 70% is now ethnocentric or lower. This would be enough to rattle the average onlooker. But it gets a bit worse. Who owns the ideas that are subscribed to by this 70%? Basically, the world's great religions. It is apparent from the above that for Ken Wilber, the leap of consciousness which he told Gary Simmons is necessary for a Transformation Experience is from a modern to postmodern worldview. The goal of the Transformation Experience, as it appears to me, is shifting the seventy percent of Unity's congregations from traditional and modern worldviews to the postmodern worldview. I want to conclude this section by repeating the same thing I wrote in my first open letter: Worldview We see life through the lens of three worldviews traditional, modern and postmodern and the worldview we chose shapes the preference we have for one value over another. 5 Our lens of tradition indicates to us that some things are True and some practices are wrong. Most important, this lens tells us that Truth is revealed by God, by the church, though the Bible, or directly from headquarters through spiritual intuition. The lens of tradition also tells us that ethical practices are followed because they align us with the order of the created universe. Our modernist lens also leads us to Truth and ethical behavior. But they are not revealed by any source, internal or external. Rather modernism equips us to arrive at them 5 Valuescapes in Postmodernity: An International Study of Undergraduate Worldviews; Norwine, et. al. http://www.siue.edu/geography/online/norwine.htm Unity Transformation Experience and Integral Spirituality p.5

by scientific inquiry and reason. We follow such inquiry for the pursuit of happiness. Our postmodern lens enables us to see hidden ideologies and implied power relationships behind our previous understanding of Truth and ethical behavior. It indicates that Truth is relative and most any behavior is ethical, given a proper context. Finally, it shows that we must be the judge and arbiter of all things and that we must do this to assure that all people are respected and empowered. We use these lenses in varying degrees. Best estimates indicate that 25-35% of our society relies primarily on the lens of tradition, 50% of our society relies on the lens of modernity and 15-25% of our society relies on the postmodern lens. But the lens we use can also vary based on the life context. It may be that we use a postmodern lens to navigate social relationships, a modern lens to help make business and political decisions and the lens of tradition to cope with religious or life-or-death issues. Unity's Lens Unity has fallen into seeing itself from a particular worldview postmodern and this prevents us from being a movement for all people. Truth transcends worldview. Any church or religion that is based on a particular worldview instead of Truth is limiting itself and its ministry. If we were to assemble a panel of three persons with three worldviews a traditionalist, a modern and a post-modern and we asked questions for ninety minutes then we would learn how spiritual things look from different points of view. We would see how the language we use and the things we emphasize make all the difference when conveying Unity's basic positioning statement: "Unity is a practical, positive and progressive approach to Christianity, based on the teachings of Jesus and the power of prayer." We would learn that Unity's teachings are equally relevant to people from all walks of life traditionalists, moderns and postmoderns and that, when we position ourselves as Truth students, no person, regardless of their cultural, social or political perspective can fail to inspire and bless us when given the opportunity to share with us how the Spirit within expresses through and as them. Unity Transformation Experience and Integral Spirituality p.6