Sure, He Created the Universe, But Would He Get Tenure? by Bill Gasarch c 1996 by Bill Gasarch
LIST OF CHARACTERS All of the characters are professors at a university. : He will be arguing in favor of granting God tenure. : He will be arguing against granting God tenure. : She will also be arguing against granting God tenure, but not as much as Carl. : She is chairing the meeting. PLACE: A department meeting of a faculty at a university. TIME: The present. 1
[As the scene begins, Chris, Chairperson, Linda, and Carl are sitting in chairs, in that order, with one long table in front of them. The chairs are angled so that Chris and Carl can see each other. Throughout the play the characters can move around, get up to get coffee, etc. ] I am calling this meeting to discuss whether or not to give God tenure in our department. As you know, tenure means that He cannot be fired except for immoral behavior, which in this case seems unlikely. Here are copies of God s resume and letters of recommendation. (The Chairperson passes out folders.) Before we get started, I want to remind everyone that God is not allowed to know any of the details of this discussion. Not a single word uttered here should leave the room. Uh, excuse me, the candidate is all-knowing... In that case, why not just ask the Almighty how this meeting will turn out, and then we don t have to have it. We ll do our best to make sure that what s said in this room stays in this room. If the candidate is all-knowing, that s not our fault. Now, as usual, the items to consider are research, education, and service. Let s start with research. He started one of the most important fields of study! All He did was create the world. But He did it with speed and elegance. 2
But that was a long time ago. Whats He done lately? He wrote the entire Bible! That s still many years ago. Hey, the Bible may be old, but it s certainly original. In fact, everyone else s work is based on it. Look at God s citation index; He has more citations than Shakespeare! Yeah, but many of the citations are negative. A citation saying God doesn t exists is not good for his tenure case. But those citations are false! Whether or not they are true or false is irrelevant. They work against his case. While I admit the Bible is one helluva book, it is just one book. And it had no references. But there was nothing for God to reference! It wasn t published in a refereed journal or even submitted for peer review. 3
But God has no peers! Who would you get to referee God s work? Jesus? Nepotism! Abraham? Mohammed? Joseph Smith? Guru Nanak? L. Ron Hubbard? No, those are His graduate students. And if you recall, L. Ron Hubbard flunked out. Oh, yes, quite a scandal. Enough of this! Let s talk about the letters of recommendation. I m not that impressed with the letters. Why not? This one says that He walks on water! Yeah, yeah, but all letters say stuff like that. Besides, it said He helped someone else walk on water. Its not clear who deserves the credit. 4
And speaking of credit, there are rumors that His grad students, Moses and Paul, wrote the Bible, and He took all the credit. God generated the text; they just did the word processing. created the world by Himself. He certainly We don t know that. There was nobody around to check if He plagiarized. By the same token, there was nobody He could have plagiarized. Hmm, good point. Think of what prestige it would add to our department to have someone as well known as God as a Tenured faculty. Being well known is not necessarily a virtue. Satan is well known, and we re not considering him for tenure. Actually, that s next week s meeting. I will fight any attempt to give Satan tenure with every ounce of strength I have. If we give Satan tenure, I will (cut off) 5
Stop! We can wait until next week to have next week s meeting. Let s move on to the next topic of this week s meeting: How is God s grant support? He hasn t brought in the really big grants. Actually, all our grants are God s grants! God s name printed on them. All those dollars already have Let s discuss how well rounded He is. He s done fine interdisciplinary work. Gee, people who can t concentrate on any one thing often use the excuse, Well, I m interdisciplinary. Are you accusing the One who designed the universe of not being able to concentrate? I m just saying that it s easier to do three things badly than one thing well. But God does all things well! Not quite. Do you remember the trouble awhile back when He tried to get an assistant professorship in the Life Sciences Department? 6
Oh, yes. Those evolutionists certainly made a monkey out of Him. No, that s backwards. He made a monkey out of them? No, He made them out of a monkey. Anyway, is this the kind of controversy that we really want our department associated with? Are there any serious objections to God s work in the sciences? I have some concerns about the scientific quality and ethics of His work. But He defined science and ethics! How can you have a problem with it? Besides, His work paid off! The scientific community has had a very rough time trying to replicate His results. (sarcastic) Gee, I wonder why... 7
And He never applied to the Ethics Board for permission to use human subjects! But He is the Ethics Board! When one experiment screwed up, He tried to cover it up by drowning the subjects. When subjects didn t behave as predicted, He often punished them, or just deleted them from the sample. It s not His fault that the subjects didn t read the instructions! Ok, ok, that s enough. Let s discuss God s teaching. Many students swear by Him. He expelled His first two students for experimenting and learning something. That s a rather rough grading policy. Ah! Recall that academic dishonesty was involved. The students cheated from the tree of knowledge, which was strictly forbidden. But God didn t give the students a fair hearing. God wouldn t even let them back in the classroom to appeal the grade. 8
Other students complain that God s hard to find. One of them said that God s office hours were infrequent and usually held on a mountain top. Some say that God s just too busy. Students are always complaining. I bet they didn t even try looking for Him. God s got plenty of time to meet students after all, He s eternal! Enough on education. Let s look at His service. He keeps the world up and running. But what s He done for us? Just last week God sent out a memo to the effect that we should use paper cups instead of styrofoam to help the environment. The memo might have been more effective if it hadn t been written in ancient Hebrew. He also provided copies in Latin and ancient Greek. Chris, have you looked into the possibility of getting additional funding from the affirmative action people if we give God tenure? 9
That s a laugh! God is the ultimate dead white male. Wrong on all three counts! He s not dead, He s not white, and He s not male. He s universal, beyond gender or race. Then why do you keep calling God He? Because English has no genderless pronoun. Chris, you still haven t answered my question. Oh. We get no extra funds for hiring God. Ah, so I was right. Not quite. The higher-ups agreed with me that God was beyond gender or race; however, that also means He s not Black, Hispanic, or female. I tried telling them He had a Spanish first name, Jesus (pronounce in spanish, phonetically Hazus), but that didn t fly. Let s end this discussion and take a vote. I ve got email to read. But we re not done discussing the case! 10
In that case, someone has to make a motion to end the discussion. Then it has to be seconded and voted on. I make a motion to end the discussion and then take a vote on whether to grant tenure to God. Second. All in favor of ending the discussion and then taking a vote, raise your hands. (Linda and Carl raise their hands.) All who want to continue the discussion, raise your hands. (Chris raises his hand.) Okay, the discussion is ended, and we ll take a vote. This is, of course, a secret ballot. (They all write down on a small piece of paper a Y or an N and put it into a box. After the ballots are handed in, some special effect happens to indicate God s presence (e.g., lights flash). Something happens to the box containing the ballots to indicate that it is being changed.) The vote is three Yes s and zero No s. Looks like God gets tenure. It helps having friends in high places (looks up). 11