Dear Friends of the Canyon, Why aren't Alta residents, land and business owners trusted to members of the Alta Planning Commission? Enclosed are copies of active voter fraud complaints. Can't we protect watershed without drowning democracy? How could Salt Lake City need Little Cottonwood Creek's water when the City sells $20.4 million of surplus water in two counties? Despite SLC drinking sewer effluent upon completion of the Wasatch Sewer plant discharging effluent into the Provo River, the drinking water will be safe. What are cabins compared to a sewage treatment plant? Both Canyon owners and Salt Lake City want to protect watershed and water quality. There is common ground. A better balance can be struck. How can Salt Lake City say it protects watershed while MWD Salt Lake & Sandy maintain water applications to build a big 410' dam in Little Cottonwood Canyon and 20 hydro-electric dams in Salt Lake County? If SLC's water district is not going to build these big dams, then withdraw the applications. SLC owns approximately 500,000 acre-feet of water. 1 SLC lapsed, terminated, or withdrew 403,576 acre-feet of water. 2 Does not treat on average 57% (31,255 acre-feet) of Big Cottonwood Creek. 3 Does not treat any Mill Creek water. SLC owns/controls Mill Creek 4 Does not use most of the City's 26 deep wells which can produce 61,607 acre-feet of water free from sewer effluent. 5 Does not use most of the City's 15,514.723 water shares. 6 Does not use the City's Ontario Mine Tunnel water leased to JSSD. 7 Does not fully use the City's Utah Lake water is under extension application. 8 SLC indirectly sold 34,237.95 acre-feet of free state water rights to CUP and Sandy. 9 Let's talk water, Dr. Kevin Tolton 1445 Skyline Drive Bountiful, Utah 84010 Toltonkevin@comcast.net 1 Utahwater.net Page 1 thumbnail 12 2 Utahwater.net Page 1 thumbnail 10 3 Utahwwater.net Page 1 thumbnail 100 4 Utahwater.net Page 1 thumbnail 70 5 Utahwater.net Page 1 thumbnail 118 6 Utahwater.net Page 1 thumbnail 6 7 Utahwater.net Page 1 thumbnail 64 8 Utahwater.net Page 6 thumbnail 4 9 Utahwater.net Page 1 thrumbnail 63
Why does Salt Lake City's Watershed Management Muscle 1 Control Alta,Utah, too? 1 Utahwater.net Page 30 thumbnail 97 2 Utahwater.net Page 33 thumbnail 15 3 Utahwater.net Page 33 thumbnail 12 4 Utahwater.net Page 33 thumbnail 5 5 Utahwater.net Page 30 thumbnail 71 6 Utahwater.net Page 33 thumbnail 16 7 Utahwater.net Page 33 thumbnail 17 8 Utahwater.net Page 33 thumbnail 8 9 Utahwater.net Page 33 thumbanil 11 10 Utahwater.net Page 33 thumbnail 18 How could a property owner get a fair shake in Alta, Utah? Give me a break. Is the answer under Secret Lake, in Devil's Castle, behind Hell's Gate, in Mineral Basin? J. Maack reviewed Alta's Voter Poll Books and alleges voter fraud and Alta's Mayor Tom Pollard lives in Sandy. 2 Where does Alta's Mayor sleep and go to church? In Alta or in Sandy? If you need money to put down irate non-resident property owners who are not allowed to speak at a Alta Council meeting 3 and try to get water Alta, then call for defense funds from Friends of Alta. At a July 12, 2007 meeting of the Alta Town Council, Ms. Black said words to the effect she submits a request to Friends of Alta and it pays the Town of Alta. 4 SLC Public Utility Director Jeff Niermeyer is an Advisory Committee member of Friends of Alta. Laura McIndoe (former Alta admin. assist.) now works for SLC Public Utilities, and is on the SLC Public Utility Advisory Committee. Friends of Alta buys land in the canyon and sells to SLC Public Utility. 5 Mimi Leavitt is president of FOA. Bill Leavitt was Alta's Mayor (1971-2005). State of Utah, Town of Alta Ordinance No. 95-0-2(B): Planning commission members shall be appointed by the Mayor subject to the approval of the Town Council. Members of the planning commission shall not be residents of the Town, own real property within the Town, or have any other financial interest whatsoever in any property or business in the Town. 6 Would SLC allow Alta to control SLC's Planning Commission? Current Alta Utah Planning Commission members: Alan (Skip) Branch (Board Member of Rocky's High Road for Human Rights/Education Project, Director Friends of Alta ) 1477 East 7200 South Salt Lake City, Utah John Nepstad 848 Terrace Hills Drive Salt Lake City, Utah Joan Degiorgio 618 West Capitol Street Salt Lake City, Utah Lee Kapalowski Board Member Water District Salt Lake & Sandy, water lawyer Prescott Muir 171 Pierpont Ave Salt Lake City, Utah Jan Striefel (Member SLC Public Utility Advisory Committee, Sec/treasure Lower Millcreek Irrigation Co.)1449 East 1700 South Salt Lake City, Utah Rob Voye 8290 Etienne Way Sandy, Utah Current Alta Utah Board of Adjustments members: Marcus Dippo (son-in-law Bill and Mimi Leavitt) 2810 E 4135 S SLC Paul Huber (Deep Powder House Alta Lodge) Lee Kapalowski Board Member Water District Salt Lake & Sandy, water lawyer Diane Stahly 9021 South Blackjack Road Sandy, Utah 84092 Thousands of picnickers and hikers pay SLC water dept for permits to trample watershed. 7 Thousands of skiers indirectly pay SLC water dept for snow making water to overload watershed for leisure and recreation, but property owners are muscled and booted out by SLC's water muscle. 8 If Alta were to join Metropolitan Water District of Salt Lake & Sandy, Alta would have continue to deny water to owners of recorded lots in Alta. 9 There is no water for the undesirable cold bed canyon land owners, but water a plenty for non-resident picnickers, hikers, bikers, skiers, moose, and hot bed 10 lodgers. Q: Why can't a Utahan have equal access to use Utah's water? A: When a public employee decrees your land Public Property, then uses water muscle to unjustly devalue and take that private property for 10 cents on the dollar for the so-called public good.
IM WATER RIGHTS PURCHASES: Q AS A MEANS OF PROTECTING THE WATERSHEDS ij 1- Salt Lake City has had a long standing policy of acquiring water rights in the canyon streams along eastern Salt Cake County. i 2. The City's water rights in Parleys, Millcreek, Big ana Little Cottonwood Canyons are based on "exchange" agreements with the original appropriators, whereby Salt Lake City provid.es Utah Lake water in exchange for the high quality canyon water J These exchanges were made between 1888 and 1935. ( 3. Through these exchange agreements, Salt Lake city has gained control of the canyons. ' a. 1914 and 1934 Congressional legislation to protect Salt Lake City Water supplies. ] b. Utah State Legislation granted first class cities (Salt Lake City) extraterritorial Jurisdiction!to protect its water supply and watersheds. ; c. Through ownership of the water rights the city has controlled growth in the canyons by controlling water sales permits. Salt Lake has had in place a water sales moratorium since 1981.. 4. The City has purchased water rights as they have come available. In this manner Salt Lake City becomes the "outright owner" of the rights rather than en owner through contract. As the owner through contract, the City.*must fully comply with the terms and conditions of the exchange agreements. We are dealing with, individual owners and companies that have their interests to protect. The City has had several law suits over the years with various companies. 5. As long as the water rights are held by the individual or the companies there is a potential for water being transferred into the canyons. A case in point is the Boyer Development in Emigration Canyon. By acquiring water rights from Mount Olivet Cemetery and transferring them up the canyon they were able to acquire the necessnry water rights to develop. Salt Lake City had refused to provide water to this development. 6. If an individual or company was successful in transferring their water, either by stock or water right up into the other canyons, Salt Lake City will loose control of the ability to control growth by denying water sales contracts.
Water Rights Purchases Page 2 August 16, 19G9 7. Controlling the water rights is just as important as owning the land, where there is so much private land available. It is to the City'a best interest to acquire water rights from the various owners with whom it has exchange contracts. If we do not do so, they will seek out others to meet their best interest. Up until now the city has controlled the canyons and the water rights. It would be a mistake to invite others to deal with those who own the water rights in these canyons. LWH:mf
State of Utah' OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SEP 2 6 12S7 WATER I-Kil-n Carol Clawson Soficrar GefMf*l Jan Graham ATTORNEY GENERAL Reed Richards CtlM Dipuly Anorn*/ G«fllr*l PAIMEA OEPAULIS CM slot Sutl MEMORANDUM TO: BOB MORGAN, State Engineer KENT JONES, Assistant State Engineer JIM RILEY, Regional Engineer, Utah Lake/Jordan River FROM: H. MABEY, JR. Assistant Attorney General DATE: September 26,1997 RE: Salt Lake Citv Corp. v. State Engineer and Wavne G. Crawford. Salt Lake County Civil No. 950906811AA; Approved Change Application Number 57-9301 (a!8075) Attached is a copy of the Order of Dismissal dated September 18,1997 which dismisses the above case. The Order and Stipulation have the effect of affirming the Memorandum Decision dated July 21, 1995 which approved Change Application Number 57-9301 (a 18075), with the following modifications: 1. Mr. Crawford has conveyed all water rights evidenced by the Change and assigned the Change to Salt Lake City Corporation, reserving a right to the use of water as set forth in the Quit Claim Deed and Assignment, each dated September 9, 1997. 2. Salt Lake City will likely amend the Change Application to delete the underground well point of diversion. 1594 West North TCMPtE #300. Box 14065S S«lt Lake Cnr. UTAH 641I4-06SS TEL : 801-538-7227 - FAX : 536-7440
Crawford Memo - September 26, 1997 Page 2 3. Mr. Crawford and his heirs, successors and assigns reserved the right to divert and use water, free of charge, in amounts sufficient under the approved Change for four single family residences for 75 years beginning September 9, 1997. The nature and place of use is as described in the Change Application. The four residences may be located anywhere within or adjacent to the Pine Tree Subdivision area of Big Cottonwood Canyon, as described in the Change. The point of diversion shall be the surface point of diversion described in the Change Application, unless Crawford identifies in writing an alternative spring source in the general area of the Pine Tree Subdivision within three years of September 9, 1997. If Crawford so identifies an alternative spring source. Salt Lake City will undertake to gain the State Engineer's approval for the use and diversion from the alternative spring source. file. Please endorse your records accordingly and remove the red litigation tag from the water right Please contact me should you have any questions regarding this matter. Attachment: Order of Dismissal