Congregation Ahavath Torah Rabbinic Transition Survey Question This packet includes: Total Survey Results Question Results Executive Summary Question Demographic Cross-Tabulations to Question All Questions Cross-Tabulated for Question
Congregation Ahavath Torah Rabbinic Transition Survey Total Survey Results As % of Surveys Distributed Surveys Distributed 09 Opened 9 8.7% Unopened 8.% Clicked Through 7 9.9% Not Clicked Though 9 0.0% Filled Out 78 7.0% Not Filled Out 7.0% Unopened 7% Not Filled Out % Opened 8% Filled Out 7% Not Clicked Though 0% Clicked Through 70%
Question Sixteen: Congregation Ahavath Torah Rabbinic Transition Survey in regard to the transition from Rabbi Goldin as Senior Rabbi to our next Senior Rabbi.Select the option you prefer: As % of People Who Took Survey* Launch a formal search process for Senior Rabbi that would include Rabbi Poupko as a candidate but would also establish a sear.9%.7% Negotiate a short term agreement with Rabbi Poupko to promote him to become C.A.T. s next Senior Rabbi and immediately com.0%.7% 89 9.% 9.% in regard to the transition from Rabbi Goldin as Senior Rabbi to our next Senior Rabbi. Select the option you prefer: in regard to the transition from Rabbi Goldin as Senior Rabbi to our next Senior Rabbi. Select the option you prefer: As % of Survey Takers % % % % %
Executive Summary Question There is clear support for Rabbi Poupko. Of the 78 people (including the paper surveys) who took the survey, (% of those who answered this question or.7% of Total Respondents) choose, Negotiate a short term agreement with Rabbi Poupko to promote him to become C.A.T. s next Senior Rabbi and immediately commence a search for the position of an Associate or Assistant Rabbi. In contrast, (.9% of people who answered this question or.7% of Total Respondents) choose, Launch a formal search process for Senior Rabbi that would include Rabbi Poupko as a candidate but would also establish a search committee to interview and invite additional candidates for Senior Rabbi as well as a search for the position of an Associate or Assistant Rabbi or. It could be understood that those who answered in favor of a search are not necessarily opposed to Rabbi Poupko, only that they believe a search is in the best interests of the congregation. Something that may be of interest is that of the people who indicate a desire for a search (), of them or 0% are over 0. This is logical as.% ( people) who completed the survey are over 0 as well. Interestingly, of the people from the 8: Straus Sanctuary (Main) who choose, 7 or.% were over age 0. In general, 9.7% of those who choose were from the 8: Straus Sanctuary (Main) Overall the numbers indicated strong support for. is in the minority among almost every demographic within the congregation with an approximate / split. Please see the graphs on the following pages. However, two demographics are of interest as they were exceptions to this trend. The respondents who gave their age as below were evenly split (0 to ) between Option s A and B. This was striking as in the other (much more numerous) age groups, garnered on average 7% of respondents. Another close split that can be observed is in Question 0 regarding frequency of Minyan attendance. Those who selected, Once or Twice a week, as their frequency of attendance were also closely split 0 vs. (% for vs. 8% for ). This stood out as in the other (also much more numerous) attendance options, garnered on average 70% of respondents. While these are small numbers, they may indicate areas where Rabbi Poupko s presence may not be as strongly felt.
Congregation Ahavath Torah Rabbinic Transition Survey What is your gender? Two basic options As % of as People of Total Who Survey Took Respondents Survey Male 0 9.%.0% 9.% Female 0 0.9% 7.0%.90% 89 9.% 9.% Breakdown of Options A & B Among Women Breakdown of Options A & B Among Men % % 8% %
Congregation Ahavath Torah Rabbinic Transition Survey What is your age? Two basic options As of Total Respondents % of Respondents in this Age Group who Choose % of Respondents in this Age Group who Choose - 0 8.9% 8.7% 9.8% 0.8% -9 9 0.8% 8.7% 9.7% 70.8% 0-8.% 8.%.87%.% + 8 0.8% 78.%.8% 7.% 89 9.% 9.% Breakdown by Age Breakdown by Age + % % + % 7% 9 7% 9 % 0 % 0 % What is your age? 0 00 Launch a formal sear 0 00 0 Negotiate a short term agreement with Rabbi Poupko to promote him to become C.A.T. s next Senior Rabbi and immediately commence a search for the position of an Associate or Assistant Rabbi 0 9 0 +
Congregation Ahavath Torah Rabbinic Transition Survey How often do you attend Minyan at the congregation? Two basic options* As of Total Respondents % of Respondents of this Minyan frequency who Choose Option A % of Respondents of this Minyan frequency who Choose Shabbat and Holidays only 7.0% 79.%.%.8% Once or Twice a week 0 0.% 7 9.7%.7% 8.% Multiple Times a week 7 8.9%.% 8.8% 7.% Seasonal 0.%.7% 8.7% 7.% Rarely 0 8.% 8.%.% 7.8% 89 9.% 9.% Breakdown by Minyan Frequency Breakdown by Minyan Frequency Seasonal % Rarely % Seasonal % Rarely % Multiple Times a week 0% Once or Twice a week % Shabbat and Holidays only 9% Multiple Times a week % Shabbat and Holidays only % Once or Twice a week 9% How often do you attend Minyan at the congregation? 00 0 00 0 - Launch a formal sear 00 0 00 0 0 Shabbat and Holidays only Once or Twice a week Multiple Times a week Seasonal Rarely - Negotiate a short term agreement with Rabbi Poupko to promote him to become C.A.T. s next Senior Rabbi and immediately commence a search for the position of an Associate or Assistant Rabbi
Congregation Ahavath Torah Rabbinic Transition Survey Which Shabbat morning Minyan do you generally attend? Two basic options As % of People Who Took Survey % of % of Respon Respon dents dents who who attend attend this this Minyan Minyan who who Choose Choose 8:00 Beth Midrash (Hashkama) 7.% 90.0%.7%.% 8: Straus Sanctuary (Main) 8.0%.8%.0%.9% 9:00 Katz Sanctuary (Auxiliary) 9 8.% 9.9%.%.9% Sephardic 0 0.7% 7 0.0% 7.0% 7.97% 9.% 89 9.% Sephardic 8% 8:00 Beth Midrash (Hashkama) % Sephardic % 8:00 Beth Midrash (Hashkama) % 9:00 Katz Sanctuary (Auxiliary) 8% 9:00 Katz Sanctuary (Auxiliary) 8% 8: Straus Sanctuary (Main) 0% 8: Straus Sanctuary (Main) 7% Which Shabbat morning Minyan do you generally attend? 0 00 0 - Launch a formal sear 00 0 00 0 0 8:00 Beth Midrash (Hashkama) 8: Straus Sanctuary (Main) 9:00 Katz Sanctuary (Auxiliary) Sephardic - Negotiate a short term agreement with Rabbi Poupko to promote him to become C.A.T. s next Senior Rabbi and immediately commence a search for the position of an Associate or Assistant Rabbi
Congregation Ahavath Torah Rabbinic Transition Survey INSTRUCTIONS: Please rank each of the following items in order of importance where = Most item and = Least item)what are the main reasons you attend C.A.T.? Two basic options Rating Average* As % of People Who Took Survey Davening 9 0 8 7 9 0 8 9 8.7..9 8.% Hearing the Rabbi's drasha 8 0 9.9.9.0 90 79.9% Educational programming (e.g. guest scholars, weeknight shiurim, mishmar) 7 9 8 0 8 8..9.8 8 78.8% Catching up with friends/ going to kiddush 8 0 8 79 9 8 0.08.. 7 77.78% Social programming (e.g. comedy night, wine tasting, etc.) 9 9 8 88 8 0.9.0.99 7.% I go to shul because of my children 7 8 0 8 7.9.8.9 7.07% 89 9.% 9.% *The similarity in the averages between and B illustrated by the Rating Average suggests that support for either option is not correlated with any of Q 's motivations for attending C.A.T. In other words, supporters of both options have similar reasons for attending C.A.T. This can also be observed in the graph below. INSTRUCTIONS: Please rank each of the following items in order of importance where = Most item and = Least item)what are the main reasons you attend C.A.T.? - Launch a formal sear - Negotiate a short term agreement with Rabbi Poupko to promote him to become C.A.T. s next Senior Rabbi and immediately commence a search for the position of an Associate or Assistant Rabbi 0 Davening Educational programming (e.g. guest scholars, weeknight shiurim, mishmar) Social programming (e.g. comedy night, wine tasting, etc.) Rating Average
Congregation Ahavath Torah Rabbinic Transition Survey Cross Tabulated For Question
Congregation Ahavath Torah Rabbinic Transition Survey. What do you believe should be C.A.T.'s most important goals for the future? - - Rating Average To play a significantly greater role in the broader Jewish community 0 70 8 7 Moderately 77 Slightly 0 9 Not at All 0.9.. 7 To give women a greater role in Orthodox religious life 7 Moderately 9 0 Slightly 9 8 Not at All..9.8 79 More engagement with Tefillah and overall decorum in the building 8 9 9 Moderately 7 9 Slightly 8 Not at All 9.0.8.90 79 More focus on building bridges between members of different minyanim 0 87 7 0 Moderately 7 8 Slightly 8 7 Not at All.0.9. 77 To drive greater religious growth and passion 0 9 79 Moderately Slightly 9 Not at All 9.8.8.8 77 To increase involvement with Jewish learning 7 98 9 Moderately 7 8 Slightly 0 Not at All.98.00.99 7 To better integrate younger couples (- year-olds) 9 97 8 Moderately 89 Slightly 9 Not at All.0.09.08 7 To better engage youth, teens and those college aged 9 70 8 Moderately Slightly 8 9 Not at All...8 77 8 8
. Please rank your top three choices from the previous question by dragging and dropping the choices in order of preference, with your top choice in the first position. - - Rating Average To play a significantly greater role in the broader Jewish community 9 8 7 7 8... 8 To give women a greater role in Orthodox religious life 8 0 8 0 0 7 9 7 8 8 9 8..9.70 07 More engagement with Tefillah and overall decorum in the building 8 9 8 7 0 7 0 8..8.97 More focus on building bridges between members of different minyanim 8 9 7 7 8 7.7.79.77 9 To better integrate younger couples (- year-olds) 7 0 7 9 7 8 8...7 9 To drive greater religious growth and passion 8 0 9 8 9 7 9 0 8 7.97.89.9 97 To better engage youth, teens and those college aged 7 79 87 70 8 9 0 7 8 9.8.0. 9 To increase involvement with Jewish learning 7 7 8 8 7 8.7.. 7 8
. How important do you think it is for C.A.T. to run more programs for: Seniors Moderately Slightly Not at All Younger couples (- year-olds) Moderately Slightly Not at All Youth, teens, and those college aged Moderately Slightly Not at All Widow(ers) and older singles Moderately Slightly Not at All - - Rating Average 8 0 08 9 0 9 7 9..9.0 9 0 0 9 00 7 8 0.8..0 9 80 0 9.7.. 7 0 98 8 80 0...8 8 7
. Please rate C.A.T. on the following, choosing the rating that indicates the extent to which you agree with each statement. - - Rating Average I believe that C.A.T. needs to partner more with other Jewish institutions and shuls Strongly Agree Agree 9 08 Undecided 7 8 Disagree 8 Strongly Disagree 8...8 7 I believe that C.A.T. has a common vision/mission that could be articulated easily by the membership Strongly Agree 7 Agree Undecided 7 Disagree 9 9 Strongly Disagree 7.7.9. 9 I believe that C.A.T. provides opportunities for people with talent to contribute in meaningful ways that lead to greater leadership Strongly Agree 0 Agree 7 Undecided Disagree 7 9 Strongly Disagree 8 0..8.9 7 I believe that C.A.T. integrates new members effectively Strongly Agree 0 Agree Undecided 79 Disagree 9 9 Strongly Disagree 9 8..99.07 7 Comments 9 7. How satisfied are you that this team structure meets the needs of the C.A.T. community? Extremely Satisfied Very Satisfied Moderately Satisfied Somewhat Satisfied Not at all satisfied Please explain: - - 8.% 97 7 88 8.% 9 8.% 0.% 8 8.8% 9 8 7
. How important is it that our future professional team provides the following? Leadership and vision, with strong management skills Moderately Slightly Not at All Social, educational, and communal programming Moderately Slightly Not at All Religious inspiration - - Rating Average 79 0 7 8 0..8.7 7 9 8 07 09.7.7.7 7 70 9 99 Moderately Slightly Not at All... 7 Community outreach (e.g. unaffiliated and other groups of interest to the community) 0 00 77 Moderately Slightly 0 Not at All 9 9...8 70 Establishing personal relationships with youth, teens, and those college aged 7 Moderately 0 Slightly Not at All.0.. 77 Establishing personal relationships with younger couples (- year-olds) 0 7 8 9 Moderately 8 Slightly Not at All.79.8.8 7 78
7. Please select the statement that is most closely aligned with your views: I am satisfied with the current level of female educational a I think that the shul would benefit from employing a female Other, please specify - - 77 9 0.% 70 08 88.% 9 7.% 0 8 8. Recognizing that all members would like to keep dues as low as possible, would you be willing to entertain a dues increase in order to achieve what you would consider the optimal rabbinic team? Yes No Perhaps (please explain) - - 7 78.% 07 88 8.% 9 0 80 9.% 0 78
9. Please rate the following qualities for the next Senior Rabbi of C.A.T. - - Rating Average Depth of Knowledge: He is worldly (e.g. conversant with popular culture) 9 8 80 Moderately Slightly 9 Not at all... 77 He is well-educated secularly (e,g. masters or doctorate) 0 8 8 Moderately 8 Slightly Not at all.80.0.9 7 He is respected as a Jewish scholar and Posek (halachic decider) by his peers 9 9 8 Moderately 7 7 Slightly 0 Not at all.88.9.9 78 Leadership Strength:He is willing to take a stand when necessary 78 9 9 Moderately 9 Slightly Not at all.7..0 79 He has the ability to enforce and command respect for decorum 9 Moderately 7 Slightly 0 Not at all... 78 He has a vision for community growth 7 9 Moderately Slightly Not at all... 7 Hashkafah (Religious Outlook): He is accepting of all of the different and unique models of Jewishness found in the commun Moderately 9 8 Slightly 9 Not at all 9...0 7 He is engaged with present day issues of concern (women's roles within Orthodoxy, conversion, LGBT, etc.) 98 7 Moderately 0 Slightly 9 9 Not at all.7.8.8 7 He enables the C.A.T. community to be part of the broader Orthodox community from Right to Left 9 8 98 77 Moderately 7 Slightly 8 Not at all 0.8.9.9 77 He has a Modern Orthodox hashkafah (religious outlook) 7 9 Moderately 7 Slightly Not at all 9..0. 7 Religious Qualities:He is a spiritual role model with the ability to inspire growth 7 Moderately 9 Slightly Not at all... 7 He is known for his middot (character) 70 88 Moderately 8 Slightly Not at all...8 77 Relationship Builder:He reaches and develops strong relationships with all diverse parts of the congregation 9 8 Moderately 9 Slightly 0 Not at all 0.8.8.8 7 He has excellent pastoral skills for all life cycle events 8 9 Moderately 9 Slightly 0 Not at all 0...8 7 79 0
0. How would you order the qualities from the previous question as they relate to the next senior rabbi of CA.T. (where = Most quality and = Least quality)? Depth of Knowledge Leadership Strength Hashkafah (Religious Outlook) Religious Qualities Relationship Builder - - Rating Average 0 9 0 8 9 7 0 7.9.08.0 9 9 0 87 8 9.0.. 9 9 9 89 7 89.0.90.9 80 7 0 7 90 9..8. 9 0 8 9 7 9... 88 0 9. Do you believe the next Senior Rabbi of C.A.T. should encourage the congregation to: Elevate the level of religious observance Moderately Slightly Not important at all Deepen spirituality and passion for Judaism Moderately Slightly Not important at all Expand Jewish knowledge Moderately Slightly Not important at all - - Rating Average 7 90 8 9.0..7 78 7 7 70 8.7.0.9 77 0 7 0 7..77.7 7 79 0. Should the Senior Rabbi's efforts in the previous question be done: From the pulpit Privately Only by being a living example Not at all Other (please specify) - - 8.% 9 0 7.% 0 8.8%.% 7 9 78
. While a rabbi's outside commitments (such as teaching in a school) may add to the prestige of the congregation, it may also make greater demands upon the other members of the rabbinic staff. Assuming that this is the case, do you think that Yes No - - 78.% 00 0.9%. Should having a rebbetzin who will be actively engaged with the community be a requirement for the senior rabbi role? Yes No Comments - - 9.% 97 8.% 8 7 8.% 7 7. If you answered yes to the previous question, please rank each of the following functions in order of importance (where = Most Function and = Least Function): Willing to open her home to singles, new members, guests, etc. - Serve as a spiritual and religious counselor to women in the community Participate in shul events - Rating Average 7 7 7 8.9.0.00 89 0 0 70 0.7..7 8 8 8.9.. 70 9. - Launch a formal search process for Senior Rab - Negotiate a short term agreement with Rabbi Po Comments - - 0.0% 0.0% 7 89 0
7. What is your gender? Male Female - - R Poupko 0.0% 0 0 7.0% 89 0 8. What is your age? - -9 0- + - - R Poupko 0 8.9% 9 0.8% 8.% 8 8 0.8% 78 89 0 9. Do you have children under 8 at home? Yes No - - R Poupko 0 8.9% 7 0.% 89 0 0. How often do you attend Minyan at the congregation? Shabbat and Holidays only Once or Twice a week Multiple Times a week Seasonal Rarely - - R Poupko 7.0% 79 0 0.% 7 7 8.9% 0.% 0 8.% 8 89 0. Which Shabbat morning Minyan do you generally attend? 8:00 Beth Midrash (Hashkama) 8: Straus Sanctuary (Main) 9:00 Katz Sanctuary (Auxiliary) Sephardic - - R Poupko 7.% 90 8.0% 9 8.% 9 0 0.7% 7 89 0
. What is your membership level? Single Family - - R Poupko.% 8 9 9.% 89 0. INSTRUCTIONS: Please rank each of the following items in order of importance where = Most item and = Least item)what are the main reasons you attend C.A.T.? Davening Hearing the Rabbi's drasha - - R Poupko Rating Average 9 0 8 7 9 0 8 9 8.7..9 8 0 9.9.9.0 90 Educational programming (e.g. guest scholars, weeknight shiurim, mishmar) 7 9 8 0 8 8..9.8 8 Catching up with friends/ going to kiddush 8 0 8 79 9 8 0.08.. 7 Social programming (e.g. comedy night, wine tasting, etc.) 9 9 8 88 8 0.9.0.99 I go to shul because of my children 7 8 0 8 7.9.8.9
. Do you have any additional comments? - - 0