Brushing the History against the Grain- Mahasweta Devi s after KuruKshetra

Similar documents
Delving Deep into Karna: Search of Self of a Divine Solitude

Empowering the Subaltern: A reading of Mahasweta Devi s After Kurukshetra

Revisiting Some Women Characters of the Mahābhārata: Issues and Perspectives. Ashvini Agrawal Panjab University, Chandigarh

Representing the life of a Dalit: A Study of KAnchA ilaiah S untouchable god

alive. Besides being a first-rate writer, musician, theatre thespian, educationist, philosopher, humanist and

AND TRANSLATION STUDIES (IJELR) PORTRAYAL OF THE OTHER IN MAHASWETA DEVI S THE FIVE WOMEN : A SUBALTERN STUDY

Vyasa is a central and revered figure in most Hindu traditions.

MAHABHARATA Part 4 1

Origins. Indus River Valley. When? About 4000 years ago Where?

THE HISTORY OF TANTRA

Running head: PAULO FREIRE'S PEDAGOGY OF THE OPPRESSED: BOOK REVIEW. Assignment 1: Paulo Freire's Pedagogy of the Oppressed: Book Review

Contesting Categories, Remapping Boundaries: Literary Interventions by Tamil Dalits

Bhagavad Gita AUTHORSHIP AND ORIGIN

THE SEMIOTIC ANALYSIS OF PURDAH (VEILING) IN DIFFERENT CULTURES: In relation to Imitiaz DharkEr s poem Purdah

Online Readings for TRA #1a. Essential Elements of Culture (in the course content site):

WOMEN IN EPICS 13. KUNTHI

STAND TALL September 9 th, 2018

The Setting and Purpose of the Gita

MENTORING INSIGHTS FROM MAHABHARATA

Don t You Realize I Have Power Over You? Don t you realize I have power over you? asked Pilate of Jesus.

2016, IX, 275 S., X, 265 S.,

TB_02_01_Socrates: A Model for Humanity, Remember, LO_2.1

UNHEARD AND IGNORED VOICES IN OMPRAKASH VALMIKI S JOOTHAN

Today s Lecture. This Lecture: A comment about speed Concluding our study of Hinduism:Women and Hinduism

QUESTION: Why Do Hindus Worship Many Gods?

From the ELCA s Draft Social Statement on Women and Justice

We never read the Bible by ourselves. Even if you go on a long hike

SECULARIZATION AS A PROCESS OF LESS RELIGIOSITY

23 2 Timothy. Good News for Those Condemned to Death

JESUS AND THE GOSPELS. Warren G Kunkle III Master Catechist 1

THE FEMININE GENIUS AND ITS ROLE IN BUILDING THE CULTURE OF LIFE

Proverbs 25:12 Like a gold ring or an ornament of gold is a wise reprover to a listening ear.

WHO IS AFRAID OF PROTEST? DR. MAHENDRA SHINDE Associate Professor & Head Department of English, Nutan College Sailu, Dist. Parbhani (MS).

Written by Kamala Subramanium Tuesday, 30 August :59 - Last Updated Tuesday, 24 November :53

Lapis Lazuli An International Literary Journal

Caring Cultures: How Congregations Respond to the Sick. Susan J Dunlap. Waco, TX: Baylor University Press, pages, paper, $24.95.

I Am Your Sister COLLECTED AND UNPUBLISHED WRITINGS OF AUDRE LORDE. Edited by RUDOLPH P. BYRD JOHNNETTA BETSCH COLE BEVERLY GUY-SHEFTALL

BIBLE RADIO PRODUCTIONS

MAHABHARATA Part 5 (Hidimbasura and Bakasura Vadha)

Blind Spots. Vienna Presbyterian Church The Rev. Dr. Peter G. James Genesis 37:17b-36

10 Commandments 7 Douglas Donigian OVERVIEW

SPIRITUAL ARMOUR PRAYER. Pray every morning and night.

Mahabharata Immersion

JDH WOMEN OF MAHABHARATA IN PLAY OF POWER AND POLITICS: SUBLIMATION FROM DEPRIVATION TO EMPOWERMENT

ETERNAL PUNISHMENT AND REWARD

Journal of Religion & Film

THE MAHABHARATA: PARADIGM SHIFT IN VALUES

Phil 114, Wednesday, April 11, 2012 Hegel, The Philosophy of Right 1 7, 10 12, 14 16, 22 23, 27 33, 135, 141

Rituals and Realities: Valliyurkkavu a Historical Enquiry

The Meaning of Judgment. Excerpts from the Workshop held at the Foundation for A Course in Miracles Temecula CA. Kenneth Wapnick, Ph.D.

RESURRECTED HOPE. Text: John 20:19-31

instrumentalize this idea for the suppression of women or to compel them to wear a veil in order to frighten them, so they will not use makeup or

In you I feel safe. Naomi and Ruth

CONTEMPORARY MORAL PROBLEMS LECTURE 14 CAPITAL PUNISHMENT PART 2

Story to illustrate Lobha, Moha, Mada, Matsarya: The coffee cups (See previous class)

[MJTM 15 ( )] BOOK REVIEW

There are scripts in the world about what the Bible is and isn t. One of these scripts

The Immolation of Sampati Kuer: Hindutva and the Defining of Volition and Agency in Sati

The Hero's Journey - Life's Great Adventure by Reg Harris

CONCLUSION. India is sometimes designated as a country of spirituality by many

Chapter 2 Reading Test

DALIT WAY OF THEOLOGICAL EXPRESSION

THEMES: PROMPT: RESPONSE:

WHY DOESN T GOD DO SOMETHING... NOW?

Climbing the Stairs Discussion Questions

Persistent Women: Miriam Exodus 2:1-10 Rev. Thomas G. James Washington Street UMC September 9, 2018

Free Online Index for The Primacy of Stewardship (by Chapter and Pages)

Our Heavenly Father. A sermon by Rev. Michael Gladish Mitchellville, MD, February 21 st, 2016

World religions. Comparing and contrasting Hinduism and Christianity. Introduction

- WORLD HISTORY II UNIT ONE: ENGLIGHTENMENT & THE ATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE & REVOLUTIONS LESSON 3 CW & HW

ARCHETYPES IN LITERATURE AUGUST 2018 JESTICE What are archetypes?

(NEW) In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful INTRODUCTION

Worthy is the Lamb Revelation 5

WOMEN OF SUBSTANCE AND HEROISM: A STUDY FROM THE MAHABHARATA

International Journal of Multidisciplinary Approach and Studies

Unfruitful Works Of Darkness

Rosary of the Seven Sorrows of Mary

But you are a chosen generation, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, His own special people, (1 Peter 2:9a)

MAHABHARATA Part 1 (Bhishma s Vow)

Grief into Gratitude Sermon, Rev. Lissa Anne Gundlach Unitarian Church of All Souls

50: , 2012 L.G.

In His Image: A Question of Creation and Humanity's right to Human Dignity.

RECENT TRENDS OF EXPLOITATION IN NARENDRA JADHAV S AUTOBIOGRAPHY OUTCASTE: A MEMOIR

Napoleon was and still is a controversial figure. He rose to power following a period of Terror in

Zen River Sangha Ethical Guidelines

Family Life. CURRICULUM by TOPIC FAMILY

Crime and Punishment A Christian View of Dostoevsky s Classic Novel

Journal of Religion & Film

MDiv Expectations/Competencies ATS Standard

The Myths We Live By. January 7, Rev. Dr. Len De Roche

Social Laws Deuteronomy 21:1-26:19 Study Guide. Day 1

Thank you for downloading CQ Rewind Summary Only Version!

An Evil Spirit From God? February 12, Samuel 16:13-23

Interfaith Marriage: A Moral Problem for Jews, Christians and Muslims. Muslim Response by Professor Jerusha Tanner Lamptey, Ph.D.

Nation, Science and Religion in Nehru s Discovery of India

Mary s Sorrow Luke 2:21-35

Ruth as literature & some themes

Chapter 5. Kāma animal soul sexual desire desire passion sensory pleasure animal desire fourth Principle

Then Moses, the servant of the LORD, died there, in the land of Moab, at the LORD s command. As those who live in the Christian

Condition of Our Heart

Transcription:

International Journal of Research in Social Sciences Vol. 8 Issue 5, May 2018, ISSN: 2249-2496 Impact Factor: 7.081 Journal Homepage: Double-Blind Peer Reviewed Refereed Open Access International Journal - Included in the International Serial Directories Indexed & Listed at: Ulrich's Periodicals Directory, U.S.A., Open J-Gage as well as in Cabell s Directories of Publishing Opportunities, U.S.A Brushing the History against the Grain- Mahasweta Devi s after KuruKshetra Dr. Indrani Singh Rai * Abstract: Mahasweta Devi s collection of short stories After Kurukshetra is a historic reflection of The Mahabharata where the rajavritta and janavritta confront; where the epic turns the veils of the hidden truth which spotlights the subaltern women who are from the fringes of society but no less than the vanquishers of the epic. The three subaltern women in the volume are the true heroes as they forfeit their lives for the sake of elite and conquer the lifelong pain. The paper focuses on the agony and anguishes of the marginal women of the era of the Mahabharata; the unsophisticated women, standing within janavritta confront and conquer imposing rajavritta intrepidly. Being insignificant, they remain isolated and abandoned the whole lives even anonymous in the great epic but their prolonged silence is an incongruous critic to the royal dynasty as well as the established social customs. In the interplay of janavritta and rajavritta, does humanity lose its identity? The paper is a sincere attempt to seek the answer. Keywords: Subaltern, acknowledgement, liberty, bliss * Associate Professor, Amity School of Languages,Amity University Chhattisgarh, Raipur 690 International Journal of Research in Social Sciences

Introduction: Mahasweta Devi is accepted for her ground-breaking and inexhaustible renowned work focusing on the quandary of the cast out tribes and other marginalized people. She has evaluated the gender correlation in the perspective of subaltern as she was enforced by a sense of history. Her immeasurable legendary works describe the inheritance of viciousness of the elite group and the wretched plight of the tormented. Tharu and K. Lalitha say: Women s subjugation is portrayed as linked to the oppressions of class and class. But in the best of her writing she quite brilliantly, and with resonance, explores the articulation of class, caste and gender in the specific situations she depicts. (Tharu and K. Lalitha 235) The Mahabharata is a momentous Sanskrit epic that forms a vital component of Hindu mythology. The war of Kurukshetra is the central point of this epic but Mahasweta contemplates and examines largely the aftermath of this battle. Since unrestrained time, even in the time of The Mahabharata or in present time, the androcentric patriarchal society has taken advantages, exploited and battered the female body for the sake of them. After Kurukshetra traces three stories from The Mahabharata to portray the innate infringe between the rajavritta/ elite and the janavritta/'other' and captures the marginalized psyche of three subaltern women. A common bond has intimately knitted all the three women; their position in the society; they all live in the marginal ring of janavritta, and proscribed to cross the threshold of rajavritta as human being, they can be the slaves of the elites but can never be the identical. In fact, they are doubly marginalized as two forces make them suppressed; the androcentric, patriarchal society and the gynocentric exclusively elite women of the societal hierarchy. The dharma-yudhha of Kurukshetra failed to remember the dharma of humankind. The first story, The Five Women unfolds a cruel truth faced by the five marginal women who cross the threshold of royal palace to empathize Uttara, the wretched widow of Abhimanyu, the great warrior of the epic battle. They are not of the rajavrittas, women of royalty, nor are they servants or attendants. These women are from the families of the hundreds of foot soldiers who were issued no armour. So they died in large numbers. (Devi 1) Widowhood is a traumatic and harrowing state of womanhood both societal and psychological and no measuring means can discriminate the pain of the elite and the dreg. The common women too have the sensitivity, pain of parting but irony is that the five common widowed women are called forth in the palace to 691 International Journal of Research in Social Sciences

console an elite widow, Uttara; it seems, basic sensitivity of humankind is divided by an unseen law; pain belongs to the elite group solely. So there stands a boundary between the five common widows and Uttara, the widow from the grand Pandava dynasty. As Uttara is going to beget the future king of Hastinapur, the inheritor to the throne, so it is crucial to keep her in good spirits. Actually, from time immemorial, the royal women have learnt what has been taught to them. They remain closed, secluded and absolutely unacquainted of the ruthless realities of the exterior. Therefore, reality has made them traumatized. Nevertheless, Uttara understands a precious truth of life by the five women from strong ground of reality that all those who had perished in the holy war of Kurukshetra are not destined to go to divyalok, or heaven. No chariots came down from divyalok. They did not go to heaven. The foot soldiers died fighting in the very same dharma-yuddha. But no funeral rites were held for their souls. (16) If analyzed profoundly, it is prominent that it is not only the common females who are marginal; the queens of the palaces are in the same queue in another way. They are privileged but unconscious of the veracity of life. Howe ver, Mahasweta uplifts the human bond above all narrow societal segregations and Uttara and the five common widows are shown inseparable breaking the wall or merging the two unlike worlds. The five women are the core energy which compels elite women to rethink and reconsider their roles in royal dynasty as well as society. The story Souvali is about a dasi (maid servant) named Souvali who is stressed to be a sexual partner to King Dhritarashtra at the time when his wife Gandhari is with child. The subaltern woman bears Dhritarashtra s son who gets the royal name as Yuyutsu but remains unacknowledged by his father. Even more, Souvali and her son are heartlessly thrown out of rajavritta. Mahasweta has particularly pointed out the inherent distinction between the rajavritta and the other. Souvali does never feel mortified for his subaltern status rather she feels liberated when she leaves behind the royal ring. In reality, it is the marginalized woman who acts as an archetypal driving force for the royal women and teaches them the truth of existence. I was nothing but a dasi in the royal household but here, amongst the common people, I m a free woman (49) Yuyutsu, though a son of a subaltern mother did the tarpan for his deceased father 692 International Journal of Research in Social Sciences

but he has a crucial question at the same, Never went near him, never called him father, and today I did the tarpan for him. (43) Can salvation be achieved by a royal king with the tarpan of his illegitimate subaltern son? The stories of Souvalya and Karna are quite alike. Both are of royal lineage, but are never acknowledged, both are punished without any sin. The encounter between the Kshatriya queen and the untouchable Nishadin in Kunti and the Nishadin, is an ethical confrontation. The story is another mirror which reflects the barbarous torture of the elite sect. The Nishadins are considered to be the most marginalized sect of the society but when Kunti, the great queen royal dynasty and proud mother of brave Pandavas confronts the old Nishadin woman, she is wrecked as she is reminded her greatest crime. (130) The Nishadin is a long-grieving mother, who lost her five children in the fire at Varnavrat, where they died in order that Kunti and the Pandavas could live, considers Kunti as sinner because to sacrifice or harm innocents in one s own self-interest is the most unpardonable sin (131) and Kunti is guilty. As Madhu Singh says, Devi s obvious intention is to underscore the contrast between the Rajavritta, in which one becomes cunning and treacherous, and the Lokavritta, in which one honours and celebrates life. (Madhu 7) But a divine retribution for the sins of the past is planned and a natural forest fire is waiting to take place and it will scorch the earth and burn alive the three royals. There is a heart touching description of the mass death in the story at Yudhisthira s orders, burned on mass pyres organized by Vidura. The air was thick with the stench of burning flesh. To cover the stink of putrefaction; ghee and camphor were poured onto the flames. But the fumes of death may not be so easily hid. (32) The untouchable Nishadin brings Kunti to a littered recognition of her crimes, that of abandoning Karna and murdering six innocent tribals. The Nishadin s final judgment splinters Kunti since customary atonement cannot berate her sins, You couldn t even remember this sin. Causing six innocent forest tribals to be burnt to death to serve your own interests. In our eyes, by the laws of Mother Nature, you, your sons, your allies, are all held guilty. (38) Conclusion: In all these stories of the volume The Kuruksheta the royal house becomes the oppressor but the polyphony and heterogeneity of female voices of Mahasweta dislodges the omniscient narrative voice of Vyasa. It is obvious that until the collective consciousness of society is heaved and impelled into invalidating the venerable paradigm of caste, class and 693 International Journal of Research in Social Sciences

gender hegemony towards a more egalitarian society, the lokavritta or janavritta will continue to suffer. After Kurukshetra is an essential companion to The Mahabharata because it tells the untold stories, brings in the unknown heroes and compels to listen to the unheard music of the forbidden and forlorn heroes. With a subtlety, the stories ignite the intellectual minds to travel through the myriad by-lanes and hidden corners of mythology. The Mahabharat, altogether is not just one effortless naive story; it is meant to dole out as a discourse on Dharma, the lesson of right and wrong. But the inquisitive minds surely ask, whose Dharma is it about? References: Devi, Mahasweta. After Kurukshetra. (trans by Anjum Katyal). Calcutta: Seagull, 2005. Singh, Madhu. Mahasweta Devi s Kunti and the Nishadin: A Re-Visionist Text in Journal of the School of Language, Literature and Culture Studies, Spring 2007 (ed. GJV Prasad) New Delhi: JNU, 2007. Tharu, Susie and K. Lalitha. Women Writing in India. Vol. II. New York: The Feminist Press, 1993. 694 International Journal of Research in Social Sciences