SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS Grants & Denials List Monday, January 28, 2008 GRANTS STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTY TRIAL JUDGE TRIAL COURT NO. APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT NATURE OF APPEAL ACTION Nashville Terrance Carter v. Ricky Bell M2006-01363-SC-R11-HC Judge Monte Watkins No. 3766 Williams, J. Granted - Application of Terrance Carter State of v. Bradley Ferrell M2005-02552-SC-R11-CD Van Buren County Circuit Judge Larry B. Stanley No. 1688-M Glenn, J. Granted - Application of Bradley Ferrell State of v. Adrian Scott M2007-02024-SC-S09-CO Judge Monte Watkins No. 2006-B-1108 Smith, J. Wedemeyer, J. Rule 9 Denied Granted - Application of Adrian Scott Page 1 of 8
Knoxville State of v. David Harold Hanson E2006-00883-SC-R11-CD Anderson County Circuit Judge James B. Scott No. A4CR0208 Reversed and Dismissed Granted - Application of the State of State of v. Ariel Ben Sherman, et al. E2006-01226-SC-R11-CD Loudon County Circuit Judge E. Eugene Eblen No. 10,611 A&B Witt, J. Reversed and Granted - Application of Ariel Ben Sherman Steven Waters et al. v. Loren L. Chumley E2006-02225-SC-R11-CV Loudon County Chancery Chancellor Frank V. Williams, III No. 10710 Lee, J. Granted - Application of Loren L. Chumley Jackson Cheryl Brown Giggers, et al. v. Memphis Housing Authority, et al. W2006-00304-SC-R11-CV Shelby County Circuit Court Judge Kay S. Robilio No. CT-000896-03 Highers, J. Granted - Application of Cheryl Brown Giggers, Charles C. Brown, Jr., Angela G. Brown and Joann Fisher Page 2 of 8
SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS Monday, January 28, 2008 DENIALS STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTY TRIAL JUDGE TRIAL COURT NO. APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT NATURE OF APPEAL ACTION Nashville Leslie Quimby Allen v. William E. Sulcer, et al. M2006-01236-SC-R11-CV Giles County Circuit Court Judge Jim T. Hamilton No. CC-10629 Farmer, J. Reversed and Denied - Application of William E. Sulcer, et al. Erodito D. Lopez-Corranza v. State of M2007-01024-SC-R11-PC Judge J. Randall Wyatt No. 2004-B-1217 Denied - Application of Erodito D. Lopez-Corranza Lennie George v. Alexander Automotive, LLC d/b/a Alexander Toyota M2006-02655-SC-R11-CV Williamson County Circuit Judge Robbie T. Beal No. 04468 Farmer, J. and Denied - Application of Lennie George Jonathan Patrick Hayes v. Deborah Ingrid Hayes M2006-02356-SC-R11-CV Rutherford County Chancery Judge Royce Taylor No. 037565DR Franks, J. Vacated as to Property Division; Case Denied - Application of Deborah Ingrid Hayes Page 3 of 8
James Edward Holt v. State of M2006-02159-SC-R11-PC Williamson County Circuit Judge Jeffrey S. Bivins No. CR 051848 Denied - Application of James Edward Holt Michael Douglas Hughes v. State of M2007-02140-SC-R11-PC Judge Cheryl Blackburn No. 91-A-184 Woodall, J. Smith, J. Wedemeyer, J. Denied Denied - Application of Michael Douglas Hughes James Earl Kenner v. State of M2005-00622-SC-R11-HC Davidson County Circuit Judge Walter Kurtz No. 05C-189 Woodall, J. Denied - Application of James Earl Kenner Matthew Jackson v. State of M2007-01907-SC-R11-PC Robertson County Circuit Judge Michael Jones Nos. 01-0022 and 01-0086 Wedemeyer, J. Rule 28 Denied Denied - Application of Matthew Jackson Danny Ray Meeks v. Claudia Bonnyman M2006-02657-SC-R11-CV Davidson County Circuit Judge Barbara Haynes No. 06C-2106 Franks, P.J. Denied - Application of Danny Ray Meeks Teresa Angela Ross v. Gregory Bruce Ross, Sr. M2007-02705-SC-S10-CV Williamson County Chancery Judge R. E. Lee Davies No. 32575 Per Curiam Rule 10 Denied Rule 10 Denied - Application of Gregory Bruce Ross, Sr. State of v. James N. Cook M2006-01247-SC-R11-HC Judge Steve Dozier No. 99-B-1100 Woodall, J. Reversed Denied - Application of James N. Cook State of v. Joshua J. McKissick M2006-01996-SC-R11-CD Robertson County Circuit Judge Michael R. Jones No. 04-0303 Witt, Jr., J. Denied - Application of Joshua J. McKissick State of v. Eric James Osborne M2006-00888-SC-R11-CD Judge Cheryl Blackburn No. 2003-B-940 Woodall, J. Denied - Application of Eric James Osborne Page 4 of 8
State of v. Lamanuel Stockard M2007-00456-SC-R11-CD Judge Cheryl Blackburn No. 2004-A-308 Denied - Application of Lamanuel Stockard State of v. Joe Carpenter Tyree M2006-02173-SC-R11-CD Marshall County Circuit Judge Robert Crigler No. 16907 Denied - Application of Joe Carpenter Tyree State of v. Michael Vaughn M2006-01341-SC-R11-CD Humphreys County Circuit Judge George Sexton No. 10773-A Smith, J. Denied - Application of Michael Vaughn Randall L. Woodruff as Bankruptcy Trustee for Legacy Healthcare, Inc. et al. v. South Central Conference of Seventh-Day Adventists M2007-02191-SC-S09-CV Davidson County Circuit Judge Hamilton V. Gayden, Jr. No. 07C1889 Per Curiam Rule 9 Denied Denied - Application of South Central Conference of Seventh-Day Adventists Knoxville O. Hogan Harrison, et al. v. Avalon Properties, LLC, et al. E2006-00537-SC-R11-CV Loudon County Chancery Chancellor Frank V. Williams, III No. 10471 Swiney, J. Reversed in Part; in Part; Denied - Application of O. Hogan Harrison, et al. Jermaine Hunter v. State of E2007-00438-SC-R11-HC Johnson County Circuit Judge Robert E. Cupp No. 4934 Denied - Application of Jermaine Hunter Jim Hunter v. State of E2007-00451-SC-R11-HC Hamilton County Criminal Judge Rebecca Stern No. 262286 Witt, J. Ogle, J. Thomas, J. Dismissed Denied - Application of Jim Hunter Page 5 of 8
Brandon Roland v. State of E2006-02785-SC-R11-PC Rhea County Circuit Judge J. Curtis Smith No. 15923 Witt, J. Denied - Application of Brandon Roland Omawale A. Shabazz v. Jim Worthington, Warden E2007-00634-SC-R11-HC Morgan County Circuit Judge E. Eugene Eblen No. 9263 Wedemeyer, J. Denied - Application of Omawale A. Shabazz State of v. Royal Freeman E2006-00792-SC-R11-CD Blount County Circuit Judge D. Kelly Thomas, Jr. No. C-15145 Witt, J. Denied - Application of Royal Freeman State of v. Terna Hatten E2006-01923-SC-R11-CD Hamilton County Criminal Judge Rebecca J. Stern No. 252784 Williams, J. Denied - Application of Terna Hatten Towe Iron Works, Inc. et al. v. Donald Towe, Sr. et al. E2006-01971-SC-R11-CV Knox County Chancery Chancellor John F. Weaver No. 161807-1 Franks, J. Reversed and Denied - Application of Towe Iron Works, Inc. and David L. Towe, Sr. Jackson Travis Baggett, et al. v. Takata Corp. et al. W2006-01115-SC-S09-CV Haywood County Circuit Judge Clayburn Peeples No. 3594 Highers, J. Farmer, J. Rule 9 Denied Denied - Application of TK Holdings, Inc., Takata Seat Belts, Inc., and TK- Taito, LLC Denied - Application of United States Testing Company, Inc. James Beasley v. State of W2006-01844-SC-R11-PC Madison County Circuit Judge Roy Morgan No. C-05-467 Tipton, J. Denied - Application of James Beasley Page 6 of 8
Macario Chism v. Tony Parker W2007-00592-SC-R11-HC Lauderdale County Circuit Judge Joseph H. Walker, III No. 6126 Witt, Jr., J. Denied - Application of Macario Chism Bobby Marable v. State of W2007-00119-SC-R11-PC Crockett County Circuit Judge Clayburn Peeples No. 3584 Williams, J. Denied - Application of Bobby Marable State of v. Michael Ray Bates W2006-02492-SC-R11-CD Madison County Circuit Judge Donald H. Allen No. 05-206 Ogle, J. Denied - Application of Michael Ray Bates State of v. Aaron Leon Burnette, Jr. W2006-02092-SC-R11-CD Hardeman County Circuit Judge J. Weber McCraw No. 06-01-0163 Ogle, J. Denied - Application of Aaron Lee Burnette, Jr. State of v. Marty Michelle Clark W2006-01343-SC-R11-CD Madison County Circuit Judge Roy B. Morgan, Jr. No. 04-738 Denied - Application of Marty Michelle Clark State of v. Michael Davis W2006-01151-SC-R11-CD Shelby County Criminal Judge W. Otis Higgs No. 03-04293 Hayes, J. Denied - Application of Michael Davis State or v. Maurice Emery W2006-02300-SC-R11-CD Gibson County Circuit Judge Clayburn Peeples No. H-69980 Tipton, J. Denied - Application of Maurice Emery State of v. Jarvis Harris W2006-02234-SC-R11-CD Shelby County Criminal Judge Arthur T. Bennett Nos. 03-00441 & 03-00442 Glenn, J. Denied - Application of Jarvis Harris State of v. Curtis Daniel Hart W2006-01332-SC-R11-CD Tipton County Circuit Judge Joseph H. Walker No. 5207 Hayes, J. Denied - Application of Curtis Daniel Hart Page 7 of 8
State of v. Anthony McKinnis W2006-00996-SC-R11-CD Lauderdale County Circuit Judge Joseph H. Walker, III No. 7888 Williams, J. Denied - Application of Anthony McKinnis State of v. Fred E. Smith W2006-02504-SC-R11-HC Lake County Circuit Judge R. Lee Moore, Jr. No. 06-CR-8842 Denied - Application of Fred E. Smith Roy Williams v. State of W2006-02128-SC-R11-PC Shelby County Criminal Judge Joseph B. Dailey No. P-27513 Denied - Application of Roy Williams Page 8 of 8