Disciplers Bible Studies

Similar documents
The Problem of False Teachers. 2 Pt. 2:1-22

2 Peter 1 New American Standard Bible (NASB) Growth in Christian Virtue 1 Simon Peter, a bondservant and apostle of Jesus Christ,

1:12 Therefore I be not negligent to put you always in remembrance of these things, though you know them, and are about to be established in the

Caution! False Teachers Part 2

Now, he warns us of false teachers. Remember the truth and watch out for the liars.

2Peter1 in ASL 67 Verse 2. May God give you more and more grace and peace as you grow in your knowledge of God and Jesus our Lord. Verse 3. By his div

English Standard Version. 2 Peter. How to Be Kept from Falling

A Practical Study of 2 Peter: A Winner s Game Plan

II PETER The Mark of False Teachers January 19, 2014

A'. 4 Whereby are given unto us exceeding great and precious promises: i. that by these ye might be partakers of the divine nature,

faith, hope, love 2 Peter 2:1-22 Inductive Discovery Lesson 14 Standing in Hope

523 II PETER CHAPTER ONE

ORDER OF WORSHIP SERVICE

2nd Peter Series Part 4 Faith s Contentions 2

Mt. Traveler Missionary Baptist Church, Waverly, Alabama Synopsis of Sermon Preached by Rev. Chris Johns, Youth Minister

INDUCTIVE LESSON ELEVEN

Caution! False Teachers Part 1

At the beginning of this second Chapter in 2 Peter, we read the following:

The Second Epistle General Of Peter

Description Of False Teachers

Disciplers Bible Studies

Contend for the Faith

3-WEEK STUDY THROUGH THE BOOK OF JUDE

Hope in Action. 2 Peter 2: Standing in Hope. Lesson 7. 2 Peter 2:1 22

For Easy Reading and Enjoyment THE SIMPLIFIED CATHOLIC NEW TESTAMENT - PARAPHRASED 2 PETER CHAPTER 1

Beware of Gnosticism and Hedonism cesspool rabbit holes

JUDE PART 2 BIBLE STUDY BY JAMIE MCNAB 11/7/15

Looking Back toward the World Genesis 19 June 16, 2013

Helping Our Children Learn to Understand the Last Days

Explore the Bible Lesson Preview May 20, 2007 "Spiritual Error Is Rampant" Background: 2 Peter 2:1-22 Lesson: 2 Peter 2:1-3, 12-14, 17-22

God Will Not Spare the Guilty

Do Not Be Deceived. b. We have to deal with deception. i. We have to be on guard. ii. Not everyone is honest in our world. iii. A sad, but true story.

Depravity of False Teachers

In his first epistle, Peter, with great pastoral concern, sought to. False Teachers. Lesson. Sabbath Afternoon. *June 3 9

THE SECOND EPISTLE GENERAL OF PETER

A Humanistic Satan-Inspired Misunderstanding Of Matthew 7:1-5

2nd Peter Chapter 2 John Karmelich

BACKSLIDING - APOSTACY. Backsliding meshuwbah - apostasy - turning away

Our Incredible, Amazing Bible - Jude Sunday, October 1, :30 AM

Study Guide for PETER. Growing Christians Ministries Box 5757, River Forest, IL growingchristians.org

Letters of Peter: Lesson 9 Warning: False Prophets and their Demise 2 Peter 2.10b-22

PETE BUMGARNER MINISTRIES

Contend Earnestly for the Faith Part 2

English Standard Version. 2 Peter. How to Be Kept from Falling

Truth versus Deception & Lies

2 nd Peter 3:18 Grow in the grace and knowledge of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ, to Him be the glory, both now and to the day of eternity. Amen.

Scriptures that state that Christians will be taken off of the Earth while still alive.

Valley Bible Church - Sermon Transcript. Ungodliness Prophesied Jude 14-19

The Unseen Line. 2 Timothy 4:10 - Demas has forsaken me, having loved this present world. NKJV

The General Epistles Hebrews, James, 1-2 Peter, John, Jude. Ross Arnold, Winter 2013 Lakeside institute of Theology

Profiles Of False Teachers 2 Peter 2:10-18 Introduction

ADVANCED TRAINING ONCE SAVED ALWAYS SAVED I DON T THINK SO! and be forever saved. In fact in Revelation the third chapter verse five, Jesus

I & II Peter Eight Lessons (Verse-by-Verse)

PORTAITS OF FAILING. Rev. Robert T. Woodyard First Christian Reformed Church May 20, 2018, 6:00 PM. Scripture Texts: II Peter 2.

5/6/2018 The Wages of Sin 1

Calvary Chapel of El Cajon Women s Bible Studies

advancing evil than good. We may wonder, at times, why God delays ending the world. Perhaps Peter supplied the answer in 2 Peter 3:9.

Jude Sounds the Alarm

Noah and the Flood Lesson #1 - Genesis 6:5-17 (Most Scriptures used are from the New King James Version)

THE SECOND LETTER OF PETER

Ps Peter Nicholes Sunday 24 th March, 2019

Disciplers Bible Studies

11/27/2016 Conversion 1

How to Deal with False Teaching in the Church

file:///c:/acm/nick/ephesians/unholy_fellowship5_7.htm Unholy Fellowship Pastor Nick Bibile

I & II Peter, & Jude

1:24 Wherefore God also gave them up to uncleanness through the lusts of their own hearts, to dishonour their own bodies between themselves:

Contemporary Theology Sunday School Class. July 13: The Inhospitable Hosts of Sodom, Gomorrah, and Gibeah (Genesis 19 and Judges 19)

RAPTURE TIMING OF THE RAPTURE

19. WHAT ARE RIGHT AND WRONG KINDS OF RIGHTEOUSNESS?

CHRISTIANITY WITHOUT THE RELIGION BIBLE SURVEY. The Un-devotional JAMES, 2 PETER, & JUDE. Week 4

2 Peter 1 Continue to Grow

Barry G. Johnson, Sr. 3/1/2015

SECOND PETER. Bible Books Book by Book Series

PERGAMOS REVELATION 2:12-17


Review the results from the Spiritual Growth Challenge last week if applicable.

Old And New Apostates Jude verses 5-11 NKJV

Bible Study # 4 September 8, 1987 Mr. John Ogwyn

Gleanings of Grace. Jude

2nd Peter Series Part 3 Faith s Contentions 1

The Riches of God's Amazing Grace! - Ephesians 1: things that are true before and after salvation

Death traps us in our sin If we die in our sin, we have no opportunity left to receive new life.

Compromise and Tolerance

Jude. Deeper Bible Studies. Life Changing, Life Application

Acting in Ignorance. Thesis: Acts 3:17 21 (ESV)

Stuart Heights Sunday School 2 Peter, Week 11 October 28, 2018

Workbook On 1 st and 2 nd Peter

Valley Bible Church Sermon Transcript

BRENTWOOD BAPTIST CHURCH

These Dreamers Pollute Their Own Bodies, Reject Authority and Slander Celestial Beings

The Christian s Response to False Doctrine June 8, 2014

In Search of the Lord's Way. "God Has Spoken"

Positives in the Christian Life. Ephesians 4:17-32

Ephesians 4:1-16. Extra Questions and Commentaries

Christ the King Community Church Doctrinal Statement

Things the Man of God Should Do 1 Timothy 6:11-12

THE BOOK OF ISAIAH THE GOD OF OUR SALVATION

Principles for Christian Living Jude: 17-23

No Spirit, No Truth. Jude 17-19

Transcription:

Disciplers Bible Studies 2 PETER LESSON 8 DESTRUCTIVE HERESIES 2 PETER 2 Introduction Peter exhorted his readers to heed the word of God s prophets. He described the prophets as holy men who spoke forth the word of God as they were moved by the Holy Spirit. Their prophetic word had been confirmed before Peter s eyes and ears by God s voice on the Mount of Transfiguration, affirming His pleasure in His Son (2 Peter 1:17-21). Now Peter reveals that these holy prophets had faced opposition from false prophets, as will the recipients of this letter. False teachers are nothing new. They were a danger in the days of the Old Testament prophets and have been throughout the history of the church. Peter wants his readers to beware of false teachers and their destructive heresies. As a believer, you need to know how to distinguish true from false teaching in order to avoid error and stand firm in your faith. Peter s warning against the false teachers and their destructive heresies is scathing. He recognized the danger as being very real and serious. His description of the depravity, deception and definite doom of the false teachers should quicken your discernment and stimulate you to stand firm in your faith! OUTLINE OF 2 PETER 2 I. Wickedness of False Teachers - 2 Peter 2:1-9 II. Ways of False Teachers - 2 Peter 2:10-16 III. Wiles of False Teachers - 2 Peter 2:17-22 I. Wickedness of False Teachers - 2 Peter 2:1-9 Peter begins his warning against following false teachers by showing that they are wicked and that they will be judged and destroyed. A. Their ways are destructive - 2 Peter 2:1-3a destructive words and ways bring dishonor upon Him and upon His sacrifice for sin. Thus they deny Him and at the same time bring destruction upon themselves. 2. They are licentious - 2:2 The New King James uses the words "destructive ways," but the Greek is literally translated "licentiousness" or "lasciviousness," referring to shameful ways of conduct. Perhaps Peter had in mind some of the same shameful conduct he had written about in 1 Peter 4:3, licentiousness, lusts, drunkenness, revelries, drinking parties, and abominable idolatries. a. They blaspheme the way of truth - 2:2 Their behavior defiles and desecrates all that Christianity stands for. b. They attract many followers - 2:2 It really is not surprising that many would follow the destructive ways of the false teachers. Matthew Henry in The Matthew Henry Commentary, rightly notes that "men drink in iniquity like water and are pleased to live in error." 3. They exploit their victims - 2:3a False teachers operate in a realm of covetousness, with the purpose of exploiting people. The word "exploit" means literally "to make merchandise, to buy, sell or trade," denoting the greediness with which false teachers manipulate people for their own purposes. The means of the exploitation is deceptive words, the Greek "plastois," meaning "to mold." False teachers mold their words at will to suit their own devious teachings. They flatter, confuse, tickle the ear and entertain in order to captivate and control their audience. The false teachers will secretly bring in destructive heresies. The Greek, "hairesis" referred to schools B. They will be destroyed - 2 Peter 2:3b-9 of philosophy, but the New Testament writers used the word to describe religious sects or factions based False teachers may think they are getting away with upon false doctrine and the specific teachings of those their wickedness, but Peter reminds us that they are groups. Peter says the heresies would be brought in already judged and condemned. secretly. The literal meaning of secretly is "to bring in alongside," which is exactly what the false teachers did. 1. Their punishment is sure - 2:3 and 9b They brought the heresies in alongside the truth. God is just and His judgment has always been at work 1. They deny Christ - 2:1 in the world, delivering the godly and punishing the wicked. False teachers will not escape. "Judgment is This verse deals with the responsibility of false teachers. eager to be accomplished in their case and God knows They claim to be redeemed by Christ, but their exactly the punishment and the final judgment they Suzie Klein, 2000, Palos Verdes Estates, CA 90274, all rights reserved

Disciplers Bible Study - 2-2 Peter Lesson 8 will accrue. God s judgment does not sleep and is never late" (Kenneth O. Gangle, The Bible Knowledge Commentary). 2. Examples of judgment - 2:4-6 God is the judge of all, and history shows that God will judge all those who sin against His truth (including false teachers). In this passage we are given three examples of God s righteous judgment. a. The angels who sinned - 2:4 These angels may refer either to those who fell with satan, as recorded in Ezekiel 28:13-19, or to angels who intermarried with mortals, which is one interpretation of Genesis 6:1-4. Either way, the point is that if God judges and punishes evil angels, He will certainly not hesitate to judge and punish ungodly people as well. The fate of the angels was condemnation to hell. The word translated hell is "tartarus," the mythological Greek abyss where the wicked dead were imprisoned and tormented. Peter uses the image of tartarus, which would have been well known to his original readers, to convey the idea of a special place of confinement until the final judgment. There would be no trial. Their doom was sealed! b. The ancient world - 2:5 and Genesis 6-8 God judged evil even when it involved the entire human race except for eight persons, Noah and his family. The ancient world was, corrupt before God, and the earth was filled with violence...all flesh had corrupted their way on the earth (Genesis 6:11-12). Only Noah walked with God. Only Noah found grace in the eyes of the Lord. By faith Noah, being divinely warned of things not yet seen, moved with godly fear, prepared an ark for the saving of his household, by which he condemned the world and became heir of the righteousness which is according to faith (Hebrews 11:7). Only eight people were spared. Do not think you will find safety in numbers. But if by faith you walk with God, even though you may walk alone, you can be sure that God will not destroy the good along with the bad. c. Sodom and Gomorrah - 2:6 and Genesis 19:1-26 The destruction of these two cities is an example to the ungodly. Two thriving cities were reduced to ashes for their sins. Their sin brought condemnation and calamity upon them. 3. The righteous are delivered - 2:7-9 and Genesis 19 The example given is Lot. God s dealing with Lot shows that He knows how to rescue the righteous and punish the unrighteous. A reading of Genesis 19 certainly does not make Lot appear to be a very righteous man, but three times in his letter Peter calls Lot righteous, the Greek "dikaion," literally meaning "just." Peter writes that Lot was, oppressed with the filthy conduct of the wicked... tormented...seeing and hearing their lawless deeds (2 Peter 2:7-8). The state of Lot s soul is not mentioned in Genesis, but Peter makes it clear that the vileness which surrounded him was detestable to him, and this attests to his righteousness. Both Noah and Lot give comfort to believers because God delivered them out of temptations. Christians today also live in a dark and sinful world. Rest assured that God s judgment is not asleep and God s rescuing hand is not too short to reach out and rescue you. II. Ways of False Teachers - 2 Peter 2:10-16 These verses give a description of those who invite the judgment of God upon themselves. In them we find an apt description of the true nature of false teachers. A. They walk according to the flesh - 2 Peter 2:10 Being self-centered they live to indulge their own lust and impure ways. B. They are presumptuous and self-willed - 2 Peter 2:10-11 Their daring audacity leads them to do what even great and powerful angels would not do. They despise authority (the Greek word may refer to either angelic or human authority), and they speak evil of dignitaries. "Dignitaries" is a term referring to angelic powers and may designate either evil angels or good angels. If Peter's reference is to evil angels, the meaning would be that the false teachers had a flippant attitude toward the devil and demons. Jude 9 gives the example of the archangel Michael who contended with the devil but did not dare to bring against him a reviling accusation. Even an archangel did not dare to reproach the devil, but false teachers may have been presumptuously mocking spiritual forces of evil which they did not even understand (2 Peter 2:12).

Disciplers Bible Study - 3-2 Peter Lesson 8 It is very dangerous to have a flippant attitude toward the devil or any evil power. Christians should never be arrogant or brash in dealing with evil but should humbly rely upon the Lord Jesus (James 4:7 and Jude 9). But "dignitaries" may be a reference to good angels, those who had a part in mediating the law at Mt. Sinai. (See Acts 7:53; Galatians 3:19 and Hebrews 2:2.) Since the false teachers despise authority, it is likely they would also despise the law and those who mediated it, giving good reason for them to speak evil against good angels. C. They are like brute beasts - 2 Peter 2:12-13a Like animals, they are unreasoning and irrational. They act upon instinct and out of fleshly desire rather than rational thinking. Psalm 49:20 (NASB) states that man in his pomp, yet without understanding, is like the beasts that perish. Peter says that false teachers will perish in their own corruption. In the Greek, this is a play on words, "they shall in their destroying be destroyed." In this they will be repaid for the wrong they have done, wrong for wrong. D. They are spots and blemishes - 2 Peter 2:13b They carouse in the daytime. They don t even try to hide their wicked deeds under the cover of darkness. They even continue to join in with Christians, flagrantly flaunting their lies. The feasts referred to were public banquets where the early Christians gathered to celebrate the Lord s Supper (Jude 12). 1 Corinthians 11:20-23 speaks of the abuses at these feasts. E. They are habitual sinners - 2 Peter 2:14a Having eyes full of adultry means that their lust is insatiable. They never stop sinning. Sin has become such a habit that they cannot stop. Their deceit is directed at beguiling or "baiting" unstable souls those who are unsuspecting, not having a solid foundation of faith, perhaps new believers or those not solidly grounded in the word of God. These are the ones most likely to follow false teachers. F. They practice covetousness - 2 Peter 2:14b-16 They specialize in greed. Their hearts are trained in it. Here Peter gives an athletic metaphor, using a word which refers to gymnastic training. The false teachers train themselves in covetousness. They work out in covetousness and practice their greed just as a dedicated athlete works out and trains for his sport. But the false teachers never have enough of it. They are addicted to covetousness and greed. They are accursed children, a Hebrew term denoting certain destruction from the hand of God. 1. They have forsaken the right way - 2:15 They have left the straight and narrow path and gone astray. 2. They follow the way of Balaam - 2:15-16 and Numbers 22-24 Balaam was proverbial for his greed and false teachers imitate him in that. They are also like Balaam in that they claim to be men of God. They profess to be doing what is right. They go against what they know to be the will of God because of their covetousness and they induce others to sin (See Numbers 31:16). Balaam so loved the wages of unrighteousness (2 Peter 2:15) that he was short-sighted and blind (2 Peter 1:9). His donkey saw what he did not see and rebuked him (Numbers 22:22-33) to turn him away from his mad mission to curse the people of Israel. But still Balaam persisted. III. Wiles of False Teachers - 2 Peter 2:17-22 Peter has made it clear that the false teachers will be judged, but their wiles are still a destructive element in the church. Their deceptive ways and misleading words are detrimental to true believers, giving them false hopes and leading them astray. Beyond that, their entanglement in the world will lead to their doom. A. Deception - 2 Peter 2:17-19 The false teachers seem to offer spiritual refreshment, but produce nothing. Their words seem good, but they are empty. 1. They offer empty expectations - 2:17 A well is a promise of water, and a cloud is a promise of rain. Just as a well or clouds without water are deceptive, disappointing, and useless, so are false teachers. They look good and make a good show on the outside, but they are empty on the inside. False teachers are spiritually barren. They do not possess what they pretend to have and they will be judged accordingly. They are men (or women) who choose to walk in darkness, so God has reserved a place of gloomy darkness for them for eternity. 2. They speak empty words - 2:18 False teachers speak words that sound good, but have no substance to them. They are futile, worthless, and without results because there is no truth in them. With their words they attempt to entice baby Christians (those who are new believers or are not grounded in the truth) to be like them in their licentious way of living.

Disciplers Bible Study - 4-2 Peter Lesson 8 3. They make empty promises - 2:19 False teachers promise freedom but deliver only bondage because they are in spiritual bondage themselves. Jesus said that whoever commits sin is a slave of sin. And a slave does not abide in the house forever, but a son abides forever. Therefore if the Son makes you free, you shall be free indeed (John 8:34b-36). Freedom does not come from empty words and immoral living. Freedom is found only in God s Son, Jesus Christ. Have you found true freedom in Christ, or are you still living in slavery to sin? B. Doom - 2 Peter 2:20-22 In the last verses of this chapter, Peter depicts the terrible danger of apostasy. It is difficult to determine whether he is referring to false teachers or their victims but what he says would apply to both. This is a serious warning to anyone who has been exposed to the lifegiving truth of the gospel. Peter is speaking about people who had a definite knowledge of Jesus Christ, had come to associate with other believers, and had probably joined in a church. But they rejected that knowledge to return to the entanglements of the world. The end result is an even deeper corruption than they had at first. These people deserve a harsher punishment than those who have never heard the gospel. In fact, they would have been better off never to have known the gospel at all! Apostasy is worse than ignorance. This is illustrated by Jesus' words in Luke 12:47-48. That servant who knew his master s will, and did not prepare or do according to his will, shall be beaten with many stripes. But he who did not know, yet committed things worthy of stripes, shall be beaten with a few. For everyone to whom much is given, from him much will be required; and to whom much has been committed, of him they will ask the more. Those who have the opportunity to escape the pollutions of the world through knowledge of the Lord and Savior Jesus Christ and yet turn back to the world are like dogs returning to their own vomit and freshly washed pigs returning to wallow in the mire. Application 1. How discerning are you of the truth? Are you blown to and fro by the windy doctrine of every television preacher, enticed by an entertaining sermon, and swayed by the spurious use of language? Will you become more discriminating through serious study of God s true word? Will you keep a sharp eye and ear for warning signs of heresy as Peter has described? 2. How firmly are you entrenched in your faith? How are you putting into action the truths you are learning in God's word so you may have confidence in your own steadfastness? 3. Are you walking the narrow path of God's perfect will? Who can you encourage to walk that path with you?

Disciplers Bible Study - 1-2 Peter Lesson 22 QUESTIONS All questions are based on the New King James Version of the Bible. DAY ONE: Read all lesson notes and references. 1. What encouragement did you receive from Noah and Lot? 2. What signs would help you to recognize a false teacher? 3. What was new or helpful to you in the notes, references, or lecture? DAY TWO: Read all of 2 Peter 3. READING: 2 Peter 3 [Open NKJV] [Open NIV] 4. a. Find three important facts that Peter wants his readers to know. Give verses. b. (Personal Question) What warning from this text will help you be more faithful in your relationship with Christ? 5. a. What was destroyed in the past and how? Give verse. b. What will be destroyed in the future and how? Give verses. 6. Underline day of judgment, day of the Lord, and day of God. Do you think these all refer to the same event? Why or why not? DAY THREE: Read 2 Peter 3:1-7 and Genesis 1. READING: 2 Peter 3:1-7; 1 Peter 1:5; 1 Peter 1:7; 1 Peter 4:7; 1 Peter 4:13; 1 Peter 5:1; 1 Peter 5:4; Genesis 1 [Open NKJV] [Open NIV] 7. a. What is the purpose of both this letter and an earlier one also written by Peter? b. Why did Peter feel a need to give his readers these reminders? 8. a. Describe the scoffers (mockers).

Disciplers Bible Study - 2-2 Peter Lesson 8 b. What rhetorical question would they ask? Why? c. (Thought Question) Why is this an important question? Find references to Christ s second coming in 1 Peter 1:5, 7; 4:7,13 and 5:1,4 to help with your answer. 9. a. What do you learn about God s word from 2 Peter 3:5-7 and from Genesis 1? b. (Personal Question) Using the previous question s verses, how will you apply them to your own life? DAY FOUR: Read 2 Peter 3:8-10. READING: 2 Peter 3:8-10; Isaiah 2:12; Isaiah 13:6; Joel 2:1-2; Joel 2:11; Obadiah 1:15; 1 Corinthians 1:7-8; 1 Thessalonians 5:2-4 [Open NKJV] [Open NIV] 10. Name one thing we should not forget. Give verse. 11. a. Why does God delay His judgment? b. (Personal Question) Are you thankful that God delays His judgment? Explain your answer. 12. a. What does Peter teach about the day of the Lord? b. From the following verses, what more do you learn about the day of the Lord? Isaiah 2:12 Isaiah 13:6 Joel 2:1-2 and 11 Obadiah 1:15

Disciplers Bible Study - 3-2 Peter Lesson 22 1 Corinthians 1:7-8 1 Thessalonians 5:2-4 DAY FIVE: Read 2 Peter 3:11-13. READING: 2 Peter 3:11-13; Isaiah 60:19-21; Revelation 21:3; Revelation 21:27; Romans 8:19-25; 1 Corinthians 15:51-55; Revelation 21:1-8 [Open NKJV] [Open NIV] 13. In light of all you have learned about the day of the Lord, what sort of person ought you to be? Give verse. 14. a. What does Peter exhort you to look for? b. What will happen on that day? 15. a. What do believers have to look forward to? b. Why will righteousness dwell in the new earth? Isaiah 60:19-21 Revelation 21:3 and 27 c. According to the following verses, what else do believers have to look forward to? Romans 8:19-25 1 Corinthians 15:51-55 Revelation 21:1-8 DAY SIX: Read 2 Peter 3:14-18. READING: 2 Peter 3:14-18; John 14:27; Romans 5:1; Ephesians 2:14; Colossians 1:20; 2 Peter 1:3-4; Ephesians 4; 1 Peter 2:2 [Open

Disciplers Bible Study - 4 - NKJV] [Open NIV] 2 Peter Lesson 8 16. From the following verses, how can a person find peace (2 Peter 3:14)? John 14:27 Romans 5:1 Ephesians 2:14 Colossians 1:20 17. How can anyone ever hope to be without spot and blameless (2 Peter 3:14)? See 2 Peter 1:3-4. 18. a. Who else had written letters concerning the same matters Peter has written about? b. How did Peter want his readers to regard these letters? c. What had some people done with those letters? d. How does Peter describe those people? Give verse. 19. Why does Peter want his readers to be on their guard? 20. a. What is Peter s final exhortation? b. How can you do this in practical ways? See Ephesians 4 and 1 Peter 2:2 to help with your answer. c. (Heart Question) How will you respond to Peter's warnings and advice in his epistle?