162. Documentation for William Starbuck (22 July 1699 to 17 October 1760) father of Judith Starbuck (10 October 1734 to 25 October 1830)

Transcription

1 162. Documentation for William Starbuck (22 July 1699 to 17 October 1760) father of Judith Starbuck (10 October 1734 to 25 October 1830) William Starbuck was born 22 July 1699, on Nantucket Island, Massachusetts.(1) He died 17 October He was a son of Jethro Starbuck and Dorcas Gayer. He married Anna Folger on 10 September 1720.(2) Anna Folger was born 25 May 1703, on Nantucket Island, Massachusetts.(3) She died 06 September 1748.(4) She was a daughter of Peter Folger 2nd and Judith Coffin.(5) Children of William Starbuck and Anna Folger: i. Nathaniel Starbuck was born 16 August 1722 and died 1755 (lost at sea).(6) ii. Eunice Starbuck was born 07 June 1728, and died 26 April She married Stephen Barnard who was born 14 June 1723.(7) iii. Jethro Starbuck was born 29 January He married first Anna Upham, who was born after He married second Ann Coffin on 07 June 1770, who was born after 1729.(8) iv. Judith Starbuck was born 10 October 1734, on Nantucket Island, Massachusetts. She married Joseph Worth Junior on 06 December 1753 on Nantucket Island, Massachusetts.(9) v. Mary Starbuck was born 15 July 1738 in Nantucket, Massachusetts. Mary Starbuck died after 1783 in Guilford County, North Carolina.(10) She married Joseph Macy on 08 December 1757 in Nantucket, Massachusetts. He was born 04 October 1735 in Nantucket, Massachusetts. He died after 1783 in Guilford County, North Carolina. William Starbuck married second, (28th, 8 mo. 1751) Lydia Coleman, daughter of Jeremiah and Sarah.(11) Lydia Coleman (Pinkham) (Starbuck) died 26th, 8 mo (12) Child of William Starbuck and Lydia Coleman: i. Anna Starbuck was born in 1754.(13) ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL to support the RELATIONSHIP between WILLIAM STARBUCK and his daughter JUDITH STARBUCK 1) National Genealogical Society Quarterly, Volumes 1-85, 1600s-1900s, Volume 76, "Joseph and Lydia (Gorham) Worth of Nantucket, Massachusetts, and Their Wandering Children," p ) The History of Nantucket, County, Island, and Town including Genealogies of First Settlers by Alexander Starbuck, Charles F. Tuttle Company, publishers, Rutland, Vermont, page 807 and 831.

2 3) Nantucket Vital Records to 1850, 5 vols. Boston, , Births, p. 512, Starbuck, William, s. Jethro [dup. Jethero], July 22, [ch. Jethro and Dorcas, C.R. 4. h. Anna (d. Peter Folger and Judith), h. Lydia (d. Jeremiah Coleman and Sarah), s. Jethro and Dorcas (Gayer), P.R. 38.] 4) Nantucket, Mass., Vital Records to 1850, 5 vols. Boston, , Marriages 4:404, Starbuck, William, s. Jethro of N., and Anna Folger, d. Peter dec'd and Judith of N., 9th, 10 mo in N., C.R.4. [William, s. Jethro and Dorcas (Gayer), and Anna Folger, d. Peter and Judith (Coffin), P.R. 38.]. 5) Nantucket Vital Records to 1850, Births, 1:468. Folger, Anna, d. Peter, 25th, 3 mo., [first w. William Starbuck (s. Jethro and Dorcas), d. Peter and Judith (Coffin), 25th 5 mo., P.R. 38.] 6) Nantucket Vital Records to 1850, 5 vols. Boston, , Deaths, p. 540, Starbuck, Anna (Folger), w. William, 6th, 9 mo. 1748, C.R. 4. [first w. William (s. Jethro and Dorcas), d. Peter Folger and Judith (Coffin), P.R. 38.]. 7) Nantucket Vital Records to 1850, 5 vols. Boston, , Births, 2:503, Starbuck, Judith, d. William and Anna, Oct. 10, [w. Joseph Worth (s. Joseph and Lydia), d. William and Anna (Folger) (first w.), 10th, 10 mo., P. R. 38.] 8) Nantucket Vital Records to 1850, Marriages, Volume 4, page 526, Joseph Worth, son of Joseph and Lydia (Gorham) Worth, and Judith Starbuck, daughter of William and Anna (Folger) Starbuck, married Nantucket, 6th 12 mo. called December, Removed from Nantucket ) White, Elizabeth Pearson, John Howland of the Mayflower, Volume 1, The First Five Generations Documented Descendants Through his first child Desire Howland and her husband Captain John Gorham, page 591 through 593, pages 721 and 722, and pages 729 and ) Obituary for Judith Worth, Raleigh Register, Raleigh, North Carolina, 11 Nov. 1830, Marriage and Death Notices in Raleigh Register and North Carolina State Gazette, , by Carrie L. Broughton, State Librarian (1946), page 322 (Part II, Deaths); Nantucket VR 5:615, but gives date newspaper was published instead of actual date of death; The New England Historical and Genealogical Register 100: ) Family Records, Undated Letter c from Margie Loomis to her Aunt Ella Laura Malott Evans ref. Town Clerk Nantucket & Savage; No Author, American Genealogical Record, The Robinson, (Genealogical Record Publishing Company, San Francisco, 1897), Vol. 2, p ) NEHGS Register, Volume 16, page 274, The Folger Family, compiled by William Coleman Folger of Nantucket, a Corresponding Member of the New England Historic-Genealogical Society. 13) Nantucket VR, Births, p. 507, Starbuck, Nathaniel, d. William and Anna [(Folger) (first w.) P.R. 38], 16th 8 mo ) Nantucket VR, Births, p. 498, Starbuck, Eunice, d. William and Anna, 7th, 6 mo [first w. Stephen Barnard (s. Ebenezer and Mary), d. William and Anna (Folger) (first w.), P.R. 38.]; also see The Barnard Family, (www/billputman.com/barnard.pdf). 15) Nantucket VR, Births, p. 501, Starbuck, Jethro, s. William and Anna, Mar. 29, [h. Anna (d. Jonathan Upham and Ruth), h. Ann (Hussey) Coffin, s. William and Anna (Folger) (first w.), P.R. 38.]. 16) Macy, Sylvanus, Macy: Genealogy of the Macy Family from , (Albany: Joel Munsell, 1868.), p Mary Starbuck was a daughter of William Starbuck and Anna Folger, born at Nantucket 1738; married at Nantucket, November 1757; died at

3 Guilford County, North Carolina. 17) Gorham, Henry S., The Gorham Family. MS. 28 vols New England Historic Genealogical Society, Boston, Massachusetts, 3:352. REFERENCES 1. National Genealogical Society Quarterly, Volumes 1-85, 1600s-1900s, Volume 76, "Joseph and Lydia (Gorham) Worth of Nantucket, Massachusetts, and Their Wandering Children," p. 275; The History of Nantucket, County, Island, and Town including Genealogies of First Settlers by Alexander Starbuck, Charles F. Tuttle Company, publishers, Rutland, Vermont, page 807; Family Records, Undated Letter c from Margie Loomis to her Aunt Ella Laura Malott Evans ref. Town Clerk Nantucket & Savage; No Author, American Genealogical Record, The Robinson, (Genealogical Record Publishing Company, San Francisco, 1897), Vol. 2, p. 200; Macy, Sylvanus, Macy: Genealogy of the Macy Family from , (Albany: Joel Munsell, 1868.), p. 127; The New England Historical and Genealogical Register. (Online database: NewEnglandAncestors.org, New England Historic Genealogical Society, ), (Orig. Pub. New England Historic Genealogical Society, Boston, MA. The New England Historical and Genealogical Register, 162 vols., , page 324, October 1853, A Record of Births, Deaths, and Marriages on Nantucket, Beginning in 1662, William Starbuck ye Son of Jethro Starbuck was borne ye 22: day of July 1699 ); Nantucket Vital Records, Births, p. 512, Starbuck, William, s. Jethro [dup. Jethero], July 22, [ch. Jethro and Dorcas, C.R. 4. h. Anna (d. Peter Folger and Judith), h. Lydia (d. Jeremiah Coleman and Sarah), s. Jethro and Dorcas (Gayer), P.R. 38.] 2. Nantucket, Mass., Vital Records to 1850, 5 vols. Boston, , 4:404, (Hereafter Nantucket VR), Starbuck, William, s. Jethro of N., and Anna Folger, d. Peter dec'd and Judith of N., 9th, 10 mo in N., C.R.4. [William, s. Jethro and Dorcas (Gayer), and Anna Folger, d. Peter and Judith (Coffin), P.R. 38.]; NEHGS Register, Volume 16, page 274, The Folger Family, compiled by William Coleman Folger of Nantucket, a Corresponding Member of the New England Historic-Genealogical Society. 3. Family Records, Undated Letter c from Margie Loomis to her Aunt Ella Laura Malott Evans ref. Town Clerk Nantucket & Savage; No Author, American Genealogical Record, The Robinson, (Genealogical Record Publishing Company, San Francisco, 1897), Vol. 2, p. 200; Macy, Sylvanus, Macy: Genealogy of the Macy Family from , (Albany: Joel Munsell, 1868.), 127; National Genealogical Society Quarterly, Volumes 1-85, 1600s-1900s, Volume 76, Joseph and Lydia (Gorham) Worth of Nantucket, Massachusetts, and Their Wandering Children, p. 275; Nantucket VR, 1:468. Folger, Anna, d. Peter, 25th, 3 mo., [first w. William Starbuck (s. Jethro and Dorcas), d. Peter and Judith (Coffin), 25th 5 mo., P.R. 38.] 4. National Genealogical Society Quarterly, Volumes 1-85, 1600s-1900s, Volume 76, "Joseph and Lydia (Gorham) Worth of Nantucket, Massachusetts, and Their Wandering Children," p. 275; Nantucket VR, Deaths, p. 540, Starbuck, Anna (Folger), w. William, 6th, 9 mo. 1748, C.R. 4. [first w. William (s. Jethro and Dorcas), d. Peter Folger and Judith (Coffin), P.R. 38.].

4 5. Nantucket VR, 1:468. Folger, Anna, d. Peter, 25th, 3 mo., [first w. William Starbuck (s. Jethro and Dorcas), d. Peter and Judith (Coffin), 25th 5 mo., P.R. 38.] 6. Nantucket VR, Births, p. 507, Starbuck, Nathaniel, d. William and Anna [(Folger) (first w.) P.R. 38], 16th 8 mo Nantucket VR, Births, p. 498, Starbuck, Eunice, s. William and Anna, 7th, 6 mo [first w. Stephen Barnard (s. Ebenezer and Mary), d. William and Anna (Folger) (first w.), P.R. 38.]; also see The Barnard Family, (www/billputman.com/barnard.pdf). 8. Nantucket VR, Births, p. 501, Starbuck, Jethro, s. William and Anna, Mar. 29, [h. Anna (d. Jonathan Upham and Ruth), h. Ann (Hussey) Coffin, s. William and Anna (Folger) (first w.), P.R. 38.]. 9. Nantucket VR, 2:503, Starbuck, Judith, d. William and Anna, Oct. 10, [w. Joseph Worth (s. Joseph and Lydia), d. William and Anna (Folger) (first w.), 10th, 10 mo., P. R. 38.] 10. National Genealogical Society Quarterly, Volumes 1-85, 1600s-1900s, Volume 76, Joseph and Lydia (Gorham) Worth of Nantucket, Massachusetts, and Their Wandering Children, p. 281; Macy, Sylvanus, Macy: Genealogy of the Macy Family from , (Albany: Joel Munsell, 1868.), p. 127, Mary Starbuck was a daughter of William Starbuck and Anna Folger, born at Nantucket 1738; married at Nantucket, November 1757; died at Guilford County, North Carolina; Katie Unknown, Children of Nathaniel STARBUCK & Mary Coffin, ( Mary STARBUCK (b. 15 Jul 1738; m. Joseph MACY, s. Joseph and Hannah, 8 Dec 1757 removed from Island. 11. History of Nantucket by Alexander Starbuck, page Nantucket VR, Deaths, p. 484, Pinkham, Lydia, 26th, 8 mo. 1813, C.R. 4. [second w. Theophilas (s. Richard 1st), wid. William Starbuck (s. Jethro), d. Jeremiah Coleman and Sarah (Pratt), 27 th, 8 mo., P.R. 38. Wid. Theophilius, 27th, 8 mo., a. 95 y. 6 m., P.R. 63.]. 13. Nantucket VR, Births, p. 492, Starbuck, Anna, ch. William and Lydia (second w.),, C.R. 4. [w. Paul Paddack (s. Paul and Anna), d. William and Lydia (Coleman) (second w.),, 1754, P.R. 38.].

5 512 JfANTVCKET anrres S'J'J\RRUCK, Thaddeus B.. "m'd. in England," s. Thaddeus and Mary (Brock), -, S 1no. 1787, PJL38. Theodore, s. I Jenry 1 matil'ler, and Abby of N., Jan. 8, 1846, in N. Thomas, s. Jethro, r2th, 10 mo. t7o6. [s. Jethro and Dorcas, c.n.4. h. Rachel (d. Edward Allen and Ann ), s. Jethro and Dorcas (Gayer), P.R.38.l Thomas, ch. Thomas and ~ad i el, 22d, 8 mo. J742. lh. Dinah (d. Benja1ni t1 Trott and Elizabeth), s. Tbornas and Rachel (Allen), 22d, 10 mo., P.R.38.} 'fhomas, h. Eleanor (l.. eonard). h. Rachael (.Beeson). s. Gayer and Rachel (Folger), rotll, 9 1no [i11 New Garden, N.C.]. P.R.38. Thomas, h. Susan ( d. Stephen Macy and Phebe), s. Reuben and An11a (Folger) (second w.), 7th, 3 1no. r784., P.R.38. Thomas, b. Mary P. ( d. Ed111oncl Macy and Eliirnbeth), s. I-Icn ry and Theodal~ ( Uakcr),, 182T, P.k.38. Thomas B., s. Charles R. and Eliza (Barnard),, i830, P..R.38. Thomas l J., "rn'd in Indialllll,'' s. Uria h an<l Lydia ( Macy), 18th, 4 mo. 1804, P.R.38. Trislrrun, s. Nall1fanic] II f dup. Nathaniell J r.. 18th fdup. 2 [won1j), 6 mo [ch. Natbanje! and Dinah, 18th. 6 mo., c.r.4. h. Deboral1 ( d. Samuel Coffin alld ~{i riam). s. NalhanieI Jr. and Dittah (Coffin), 18th, , 1'.n.38.l Tristrain, C'h. Cliristop her and Mary. t3th, S mo. 1767, c.&.4. [h. Miriam (d. David Joy Jr. and Phebe). s. Christopher and Mary (Barnard), l'.r.38.l U riah. ch. Silvanus and i1ary, 18th, I t765, c.1<.4. [h. Lydia (d. Jabez Macy Jr. and Rachel), s. Sylvanus and ~Cary (I-Iowes), P.R.38.) VaJei1ti11e. "m'd in London," s. Reuben and Anna ( Folger) (second \V), 22d, s n10. r79r. P.R.38. vvalter. s. William, inerchant. and Sarah 1'1. of N., Apr. 25, t844, in N. [s. Willian1 and Sarah!\1. (Allen). 25th, l'.b.j8.) W illiam,!l. jdhro 1dup. Jrtl~ro). July 22. 1(9). (ch. Jethro and Dnrcas, c. -4 h. Anna (d. Peter Foli:er anrl Judith), h. Lydia (d. Jemniah Coleman and Sarah), 1. Jetbro and Dorcas (Gayer, P..R.38.J William, s. T homas and Rachel, Apr [h. l\fary (cl. Daniel Folger and Alli l?'a il), s. Thorn as and Rachel (Allen), 8th, 5 mo.. P.R.38. }

6 FoLG~ Ann M-. d. Caleb G. and :\fury (Macy),, 1832.,, P.R.38..\mi Maria [Folger], w. Hemy C. Worth. Sept. I. 18:r7. in N.~ c.r.2. [Folger. d. Samuel B. and Nancy (Hillar), P.R.38.] Anna. d. Peter. 2~ 3 mo [first w. William Starbuck (s. Jethro and Dorcas), d. Peter and Judith (Coffin). 2,Sth. 5 mo. P.R.38.] Anna, ch. Jethro and ~f.ary. 6th, Ir mo. Ij20, C. R,.4. [first w. James ~fitchell of R I., d. Jethro and Mary (Starbuck), P.R.38.) Anna. ch. Peter and Christian, Sept. 17, lj33- {first w. Eliphalet Gardner (s. James and Susanna), d. Peter and Christian (Swain). 28~ 9 mo., P.R.38.] Anna. d. Timothy and.~nna,."\ug [first w. Peleg Coa~eshall (s. Caleb), d T'rmothy cmd..\nna (Chase), 31st, 8 mo., P.R.38.J Anna, second w. Christopher Swain (s. Richard and Elizabeth), d. Zaccbens and Abigail (Coffin), 4th, 7 mo. 17~ P.R.38. Anna, ch. Jethro and Mary, 6th, 9mo C.R.4- [w. Sylvanns Gardner (s. Ebenezer and Ruth), d. Jethro Jr. and Mary (Barnard) (first w.), 6~ 9 mo., P.R.38.] Anna. second w. Reuben Starbuck (s. Thomas and Dinah), d. Owen and Eunice (Smith}, 9~ 11 mo. Ij6o, P.R.38. Anna. ch. Benjamin and Phebe, c.j4- [w. Cotton Gelston (s. Dr. Samuel and Anna), d. Benjamin and Phebe (Worth), 14th, 8 mo. 1763, P.R.38.] Anna, ch. Christopher and Anna (second w.), 17th, 8 mo. 1768, C.J4- [d. Christopher and.anna Uoy) (second w.), P.R.38.).i\nna. ch. William and Ruth, 25th, 3 mo. 17jI, C.R..4. [w. Thomas Coffin (s. Benjamin and Deborah), d. Wllliam and Ruth (Coffin). P.R.38.].Anna, second w. Silas Rand (s. Caleb of Hudson), d. Nathaniel and Mary (W'yer), P.R.38. Anna, w. Benjamin Barnard (s. Thomas and Ruth), cl Seth and Anna (Ramsdell), 27th, 6 mo. Ij82. P.R.38. Anne [Folger. w. 1 Swain, Sept , c.r.2. fw. Capt. Samuel B. Swain, c.r.3..~ Folger, w. Samuel B. Swain (s. Gilbert and Margaret), d. Uriah and Anna (Gardner), P.R.38.] Arnold, ch. George and Sarah, 2d, 3 mo. I 778, c.r.4. [Mar. 4, P.R.38.) Arthur. s. Andrew J., merchant, and Mary of N., Sept. 11, in N. [s. Andrew J. and ~ 1 Iary (Easton),-, 1845, P.R.38.]

7 STAJmU~ Th~ s.. Jethro and Dol-cas of Shcxbom in N 67 and Raebel -.\II~ d. Edward (Allin) and.aim of Sherborn in N..., ~ 10 mo..., "called December." 1726, in N..., cir 4 {Thomas, s.. J cthro and Dorcas (Gayer), and R3CheI _'\II~ d. Edward and Ann (Colermm)., P.ll.:;8.] Thomas, s. Thomas and Rachel of Sherborn in N... and Dinah Trot, <L Benjamin dec"d and Prisnllai of Sherborn in N..., 1oth. 12 mo, -'cad.ed December/" 1j61., in Sherborn in N~ cit 1 f~s.. Thomas and~ (Allen).,andDinah Tro~ d.. Benjamin and Elmbetb {Norton), P.ll.38.] Thomas 2d [int.. Jr. J and Snsanna [mt_ Susa:i] Macy,. Oct o5- (Thomas., s. Reuben and Anna (Folger) (second w.),. and Susan Macy, d. Stephen anc. Phebe (Swain). P.Jt.38.] Thomas, single,. 24, marina, b. N..., s. Henry and Theodat~ and ~iary P. 1vlacy, 2:.?., b. N..., d. Edmund M. [int. omits M.] and~ all of N., Junes , in N_ fthomas, s. Henry 3lld Thcodate (Baker), and Mary P. Macy, d.. Edmund W. and Elizabeth (Macy). P.JL.38.] Tristram, s. Nathaniel and Dinah of Sherborn in N.., and Deborah Coffin, d. Samuell and Miriam of Sherborn in N., Ioth, IZ mo., 64.called February,"' in N., c:..j4. [Tristram,. s. Nathaniel Jr. and Dinah (Coffin), and Deborah C~ cl. Samuel and Miriam (Gardner), P i~8.] Tris~ s. Ottis [ tophe] r and Mary of Sherborn in N.. and Miriam Joy, d. David and Phebe dec d of Sherburn in N., 2d., 12 mo. Ij9Q, in Sherborn in N., c R 1 [Tristram, s. Christopher and Mary (Barnard), and Miriam Joy, d. David Jr. and Phebe (Coffin),. P..L38.] U~ s. Silvanus and Mary of Sherborn in N., and Lydia l1acy~ d. Jabez and Rachel both dec d of Sherborn in N., 28th, 12 mo. 1786, in Sherborn in N., CR.4- [Uriah, s. Sylvanus and Mary (Howes), and Lydia Macy, d. Jabez Jr. and Rachel (Cartwright),-, II mo., umoved to Ohio and elsewhere," P.R.38.] William, s. J cthro of N.,. and Anna Folger, d. Peter dee' d and Judith of N., 9th. 10 mo. Ij20, in N., c.b4. [William, s. Jethro and Dorcas (Gayer), and Anna Folger, d. Peter and Judith (Coffin), P.R.J8.] 'Villiam. s. Jethro and Dorcas dec'd of Sherborn in N., and Lydia Coleman, d. Jeremiah dec d and Sarah of Sherborn in N., 28th., 8 mo., 'called October," 1j51, in Sherborn in N., CJ4. [William, s. Jethro and Dorcas (Gayer), and Lydia Coleman, d. Jeremiah and Sarah (Pratt), P.R.38.) J..n.tentJon not recorded.. tfor detailed lntormatlon see record ot consort.

8 NANTUCKET DE1\THS ST ARBUCJt, Abigail, w. Samuel ( s. Paul and Anri), d. Benjamin arney and Lydia (Starbuck), i8th, I I rno. r801 l? in England]. P.R.38. Albert, s. BeJtjamin ancl H epsabeth (Coffin),, "young,".p.r.38. Albert W., Jan. 7, 1844, G.R.3. [h. Mary Ann (Joy). s. Simeon and Tau1er (Allen) (l\1:yrick) (second w.).-. I mo. 1845, P.~.38. ) Alice Vaughn, w. Daniel,, 1827, in Milford Haven, Wales, P.R.38. Ann (Tibbetts) 1 w. Paul, 29th, 7 mo c.a.4. L first w. Paul (s. Nathaniel Jr. and Dinah), d. Ephraim Tibhelts and Rose ( Austin), P.a.38.) Ann ( see Anna (Uph<Un ) Starbuck). Ann, second w. Jethro, 28th. 5 mo. I8l4. c.r.4- [second w. J ethro (s. William and Anna), wid. Francis Coffin (s. Richard and Ruth), d. Jonathan H ussey aud Hepzibah (Starbuck), P.R.38. wid. Jethro, a. 70 y. 7 m.. P.n.63.J Ann, d. J oseph, Nov. '1 1, 18r9, a. l y. 2 m., P.R.63. Ann Maria, d. Tho1nas and Susan (Macy),, "you11g," P.R.38. Aon Pa tten of England, first w. Paul, 13th, 3 mo. r813, P.K.38. {a. 26, P.n.63.} Anna (Folger), w. William, 6th. 9 mo. 1748, c.-... (fint w. William (s. Jethro and Dorcas), d. Peter Fol.:cr and Judilb (Coffin), P.L38.) Anna, d 1. Je1hro and Anna. i1th, 9 1no. 1704, C.R.4. Anna (Upha m ), w. J ethro, 28th. 3 mo. 176g, c.r.4- [Ann, ftrst w. J ethro (s. William and Anna), d. Jonathan Upham and Rum (Swain) ( Coffin) (seco11d w.), P.R.38.J Anna, second w. Reuben (s. Thomas and Dinah), d. Owen Folger and E~111ice (Smith), 16th, 3 mo. t837,.p. 1~.38. [wid. Re uben, d. Owen Folger dec'<l, a. 76 y. 4 m.,.p.n.62.] Barnebas, 2 rst, 9 mo. 1732, C.R.4- [Barnabas, s. Nathaniel and Mary (Coffin), a. 6o, P.n.38.] Barnebas, ch. Silvanus and Mary, I 1th, r2 mo. r78t, C. R.4- [ Barnabas, single, s. Sylvan us and 1\1ary ( H owes), --, 1782, " in HaUfax jail in the war," P.R.38. Barnabas, 12th, l T mo. 1781, P.u.63.] Benjamin [ dup. h. Dinah], ch. Nathaniel and Dinah. lost at sea.-, 3 mo, 1731, C..R.4- [h. Dinah (Coffin ), s. Nathaniel Jr. and Dinah (Coffin}, 16th, 2 mo., P.n.38. t6th, 2 mo,, P.R.63.)

9 ll'antucicet BIRTHS scy1 STAaauciij l\1ary W., w. George Wiuslo\v ( s. Joseph and Betsey),-a. Paul and Mary (Alle.11) ( Ray) (secoud w.), 4th, 9 mo. 1814, P.u.38. Matilda, c.h. Silvanus and Mary, 16th, ro nlo. 1n2, c.n4. [ d. Sylvanus and Mary ( l Iowes ~. P.R.38.] Matthew, ch. Edward and Oan1an s, -, 1 mo C.R.4. [h. Rose (d. Shubael BarnaJ d and Susanna), h. L ydia (d.. Benjamin Barney Jr. and Jemima), h, Anna ( d. Richard Swain an(! Anna), b. Dinah (d. Enoch?vlacy anu Anna of N.C.), "By the last 2 \Vives there were no chu.," s. Ed~ \Va rel. and Damaris (~forth ) (first w.), P,R.38.] ~ latlhew, Oct. 28, 18c3 1 c.r.3. [h. l\1ary Ann (d. Dr. l\ij. T. i\ilorlon and l\1ary) ("no chn. tj1at lived"), h. Catharine (d. Christopher Wyer and l'riscilla), s. Joseph and Sally (Gardner), P.R.38.] Miriam, ch. Christopher and M.ary, 19th, 1 I mo. 1752, c.1t.4. rd. Christopher and Mary (Ban1ard). P.R.38. l M oses, ch. SilvauL11; and Mary, 19th, 2 mo. 1770, C.R-4- [11. Bethiah ( d. Perez Waterman a:nd Abigail), s. Sylvanus and n1ary (Howes),, 1769, P.ll.38.l Moses Jr., ''m'd. at Cohasset/' s. A'!oses and Betbiah (~latcr~ man)., J>_R.38. Nancy E., cl Charles R_ and Eliza (Ilarnard), 9th, 6 mo. 1847, P.R.38. l\7athatliel, h. l\iiary ( d. Tristran1 Coffin rst and Dionis). s. Edward and Catharine Reynolds,, 1636 [? in J)over, N.H.}. P.JL38. Nathaniel, s. \Valliam and Anna ((Folger) (fint w.).1.38.), 16ch, 8 mo K athan1ej, c 1. oseph and Ruth, 20th, 6 mo C.R.4. [h. Et1nice ( d. Peter Banta rd a11d Anna), h. Sally Fullington, h. :Patience (wid. Elihu tiiiller, d. Robert Coffin), s. Joseph and Ru tit (Macy), P.R.38.] Nathaniel, ch. Jethro and Anna, --- [rec. baforl! ch. b. 25th, 9!TIO. 1757), C.R-4. Natl1aniel, ch. 01ristopher and Mary, 6th, 3 mo C.R.4. [s. Christopher and Mary (Barnard), 3d, 6 mo.. P.R.38.] Nath(anie1U, s. Nathfanie]li, Aug. 9, r668. [Nathaniel Jr., h. Dinah (d. Jaines Coffin and Mary). s. Nathaniel and Mary (Coffin), 9th, 8 :no., J>.R.38.] Obed. ch. William and Mary, 3d. It tlle> , c.r.4. [s. \IV11- liarn and rrfary (Folger), P. ~.38. l Obed, ch. Jethro aud Anna. ~sd, 7 mo. 1766, c.r.4.

10 JllAXTCCltET llllthi STARBUCK, Elizabeth [ dup. Elisabeth J, ch, Rel1ben and Elizabeth [sic, Ruth], 24-th, 4 nio. i 81z, c.r.4. [Eliza, third w. George Rule. d. Reuben and Ruth (Coffin) (second w.), P.R.38.) Elizabeth Aun, v.. Wyman Dradbury (s. Charles and Mary), w. Dr. Charles F. Robinson, d. T homas and Susan (l\iiacy), 30th, 6 mo. 1817, P.t<.38. Elizabeth D. [Starbuck]. w. Capt. Wfill!alm l-l Caswell, Oct , Q.R.3. [Starbuck, w. W 11l1am H Caswell (s. J oh11 R. and Eliza), d. Josiah and Nancy (Damard), P.a.38.) Elizabeth R., w. Roland F. Coffin (s. Eieiediab and Sally), d. Obed and Eunice (Paddack),, P.R.38. Elfa F rancis, d. Charles J., farmer, anc\ :Mary Ann of l'i., 1'1ar , in N. [d. Charles and ~Iary Ann (Pittnan), -, 2 mo., P.R.38.] Ellen, w. Edwin Swain (s. Obed and Eunice), d. George and Elizabeth (Swain), 26th. 7 mo. i837, P.R.38. E llen F rancis. d. W [illialm C., n1erchanr, and Lydia G. [ (1'vlltd1ell) (~lyrick ) P.R.38. J of N., Oct. 18, J. ~3. in N. E sther, w. I-lun1phr~y Varney of Dover {"also m'd. her sister''), d. Edward and Catl1arine Reynolds,, P.R.38. Eunice, ct. 1'\ath[anie]ll,.l'\pr. 1, i:674, [\v. George Gardner (s. J ohn and Priscilla), d. Kathaniel and ~1ary (Coffin), rst. 4 mo.. P,R.38. J E unice. d. Jethro rdup. Jethero], Feb. 4, r7or. [ cl. Jethro an<l Dorcas, 4th, r2 mo. r7or...z, c.r.4- Elizabeth [sic],'" Daniel P inkhan1 (s. Richard and Mary), ";.Jo chn.," d. J ethro and.dorcas (Gayer). 17or, P.R.38. l Eunice, d. William and Anna. 7th, 6 mo. 17~ I fint w. Stephen Barnard (1. Ebtneur and ~lary), d. William and Anna (Folger) (fir5t w.). r.1.38.) Eunice, ch. Kathaniel and Eunice, 241:.h, 1 2 mo. i774 c.n.4. [\v. Timothy Barnard ( s.?vfatthew and Deborah). ci. Nathaniel and Eunice (Ba.rnard), P.R.38.) Eunice. ch. Matthew and Lydin {second \V. ), 20th, 5 1no. 1780, c. R,4. [w. 'fhaddeus Gardner (s, W illiarn and Susanna), d. Matthew and Lydia (Barney) (second w.), P.tt.38. ] Eunice, w. Thonlas neeson, d. Gayer and Rachei ( Folger), 27t]l, 11 mo (in Ne'v Gardeo, N.C.), P.:a.3$. E unice, w. William Hadwen (s. James and?vlary). d. Joseph and Sally (Gardner), 29th, 12 n , 'P.R.38.

11 Sol STAIBUCIC, Hephzibah, ch. Silvanus and Nlary, 3d. 7 mo. t758, <:.){.4. [Hepsabe.th, second w. David Baroard (s. Peter and Anna), d. Silvanus and l\ifary (Howes), 7th, 3 mo., r,r.38.) 1-Iepsabelb. w. Clapp (s. Katbaniel of Pa.), d. T haddeus an cl Ma ry ( Brock),, P.R.38. H ezekiah. ch. Thon1as and Rachel, toth, 2 mo (h. Mary ( cl. Jolin Thurstoo and "Nlary of R.L), h. Juclith (d.. Paul l\ f acy and Bethiah of New Garden, N.C.), s. 1'homas and 'Rachel (Allen), ["Removed to Nev./ Garden in ti85,'' u rslt.ttt against Hezekiah's familyl P.R.38.) Hezekiah, ch. Hezel(jah and Mary, 14th, TO mo. 1782, c.r,4. (b. Hussey, s. }lezekiah and l\ilary (Thurston) (firs.t w.), 1.lc38.j. H orace. s. J.f atthew, 1nerchant, and Catharine of N., Nov. 2, 1845, in N. {s. Nlatthew and Catharine (Wyer) (second \V.). 2d, TI mo. 1846, P~.38.J Hows, ch. Silvanu,5 and Mary. i st, 7 mo c.r.4. [ Howes, s. Sylvanus and Mary (Howes). I>.lt.38.J James B., h. lvfaria C. (Silvea) of Fayal, s. Henry and T beodate (Baker), 24th. 4 mo. 1819, P.R.38. James C., h. l\ilargarct G. (<l. George F. Drown and J udith ), b. Sarah W. (cl. James Thwing of Cambridge), s. F rederick anrl Chloe ( Fiatch) (of F alrnouth), -. 6 mo. 1825, l'.k3s. James E.. s. Joseph I-1., tinplate worker, and Mary of N., Aug. 12, in N. LJames F., i;. Joseph l-i. and Mary C. (Coleman ), P.tt.38.] Jen1ima, d. Jethro. 2d, 5 n (d. Jethro and Dorcas, c.r-4. \V. Silvanus Allen (s. Edward and Ann), d. Jethro and Dorcas (Gayer). l>.r.38.) Jethro, s. K atbaniell, Dec.. r4, 167 I. [b. Dorcas ( d. William Gayer and Dorcas), s. Nathaniel and Mary (Coffin), r4th, I2 11\0" P.R.38.} Jethro, William and Anna, )lar. 29, [h. Anna (cl. Jonarhan Upham and Ruth), h. Ann (Hussey) Coffin, L William and Anna (Fol~r) (first w.), r.a.js.j Jethro, ch. Jethro and Anna, 25th, 9 mo. 1757, c.it.4- [Jethro J r.. h. Elizaheth (d. W illiam Starbuck and Mary), s. Jethro and Anlia ( Upharn) (first \v.), P.R.38.] Jethro, ch. Hezekiah and Mary, J 4th, S 1no. l i8s, c.r.4- [h. --- Mills, s. liezekiah and ~lary (Thurston), P.R.38.]

12 llantvclt&t lllthi STAUUCK~ Judah, ch. Thomas and Dinah, 17th, t2 mo. r771, c.r.4;. [first h. Mary (d. Seth Coffin and S usanna) (''No chn. ' ) s. Thon1as and Djnah (T-rott) i>.r.~8. } Judith. d. William and Anna. Oct (w. Joseph Worth (. Joseph and Lydia), d. William and Anna (Folger) (fint w.), 10th, 10 mo., P.a.38.J Judith, ch. William and Mary, 10th, 9 nlo. t762, C.ll.4. fw. Ejjakitn and Bartlett Coffin (sons of Benjatnin and '.Rebeci:a ). d. vvilliam and Mary (Folger), P.R.38.] Judith, ch. Christophe1 anti Mary, i5th, IO 1no CJl.4. f w. Zaccheus Macy (s. Richard and 11'1iriam (Coffin )), d. ChristopheT an<l!l!ary (Barnard ). P,R.J8.) Judith. di. Edward and Lydia, J l s t, 5 n , c.r.4. [seco.nd w. Eli~ha Folger Jr. ~ Edward and Dainaris), d. E:dward Jr. and Lydia (Macy, P.R.38.J J udith F., first w. J ohn and (s. Ebenezer and Eunice), d. J osiah and Nancy ~Ba rnard ), lst, l mo. 1819, J>.~.38. J ulia Maria M., d. W[ill1aln1 C., nterchant, and Lydia [ (!\{itch. ejl) (Myrick) P.R.38.) of N., Aug. 6, 1&46, in N. Kezia, ch. \ lftllia1n and l\iary, 1s t, 41no. 1754, C.l<4. [w. Ebenezer Jenkins (s. Peter and Abigail) ("No chn."), d. William and ~Ia ry ( Folger), i>.n.38. J KiinbaJ, ch. V/illiam and l\'lary, 22d, r u , C.R4. (h. :.\{ary (Coffin ) Starbuck, s. \~ i lliam and ]\.ofary (Folger ). P. R.~8. J Laban, ch. Williruu and Mary, 25th, 11 mo. i7<56, c.n4. [s. vvitliam and Ntary (Folger). P.R.38.) Latharn. s. Het.ekiah aud [? 1 Tary (Thurstoll) ( first '" ) 1, ---, P.R.38. Levi. ch.1'hotnas and Dinah, 9th, io n10. t 769, C.R.4. [h. Elizabeth (cl. Willi11rn RantsdcU ai1j Ruth). s.. Thomas and Dinah (Trott), l'.r.38.] Levi, h. 1{ary Marion of Providence, R.L, s. Charles R. and E liza (Barnard) ("1 dr."), -, r mo. 1828, 1>,R.38. Lucretia, ch. Samuel and Lucretia, 7th, 4 mo. 1787, c.r4. [d. S:unttcl and Lucretia ( Folger). P.R.38. ] Lucretia, ch. Samuel and Lucretia, roth. 3 ruo. 1788, C.li.4- [ d. S an1t1el and Lucretia (Fol~er ), P.n.38.] Lucretia, c11. Samuel and Lucretia, 23d. 2 mo. 1790, C..R-4. [d. ~;:11n ucl and Lucretia (Folger). P.n.38.] Lucretia. Brst w. Elihu Swaio (s. Tristran1 a11d Rachel). d. Simeon and Judith (Folger) (first \v.), 19th. 10 mo l',r.38.

13 NANTUCltft a&itdi 505 ST>.alUCK, Lydia, d. Reuben and Alina ( Folger) lsecond,v.), 2d, 8 mo. i8oo, P.R.38. Lydia, ch. Tristrarn and l\lf irian1, r6th, I2 mo. r8og, C.R.4. [ w. "V.7illlam 1-I. Gifford (s. J onathan and Love), d. Tristrain and :.V!iria.Ju (Joy), P.R.38.) Lydia,"' Charles W..Bunker (s. Andrew and Nancy). d. John and Sophia Horton (second w.), [? 10 Qbjo], l'.r.js. Ly<lia A. [dup. R.), w. James F. Athearn (s. James and Lydia), d. Lt:vi and Elizabeth (Ramsdell), 27111, 3 mo P.R.38. Lydia A., w. George H. Crocker (s. George and Eliza H.), d. Charlei; 'R. and Eliza (Barnard), 8th, t 1no. 1839, J>.R.38. Lydia R. (sec Lydia A.). Lytlia \N_ d. William C. and Lydia (Mitchell) ( J\1 yrick), , F. R.38. }.i!arcus, Oct. 24, t839, G.R,3, [h. Mary 14. (cl. Uriah Gardner 'fnck and lylary). s. George and Elizabeth (Swain), ~4 th, IO rno. 1840, P.R.38.] ~1ar i a, '" Benjamin Marshall (s. Cha rles and (-1:epsabeth), d. 01arlcs and Elizabeth Casey.. P.R.38. ~Iaria. d. San111cl and Lucretia (Folger),, P.n Jarie-tta (see Mary Abby), n Iartha 1\.. >v. David G. Balihvi.u of 13oston, w. Fenton, 4. William and ~a ra h ~ 1 C (Allen), 11 th, S n , P.n.38. ~'fa rtha Hard)' (sec ~ ifartha I-lardy Dcfriezc). 1\hiry, d. Nathfanielll,.'.\iar. 30, r663. [first w. jan1cs Gardner (s. Richard and Sarah), d. Nathaniel and Mary (Co f~ fin). 30th, , P.R.38.] 1' 1 Iary. cl. Xath[anie ]ll Jr. (dup. omits Jr.l, Dec. 31. r6gz. [ch. Nalhanicl an<l Dinah. C.R.4. \V. Jethro Folger [q.v.]. <l. Nathaniel Jr. and Dinah (Coffin ), 10 th, 12 1no., P.1c38.] ~lary, cl. Jethro. 8th. 7 mo. t715. rd. Jethro aud l)orcas, <:.'R.4. w. Richard l\llitchell of R..I., d. Jethro and Dorcas (Gayer). P.R.38. J l\ifary. ch. Paul and Ann, 2d, c.r.4. [w. Richard Coffin (s, Richard aad Ruth), w. Isaac l(elley of Sru atoga, N.Y., d. Paul and Ann (Tibbetts) (first v.r.). 1'.n.38.] 1\fary. ftwinl ch, Tristram and Deborah. 30th, 4 mo. 1735, c.n.4. [\V. Thomas!\ l acy 3d, second w. Abishai Gardner (s. Robert aud J cdida). w. J arnes 1vfitche11, tv.rin d. Tris t rs tn and Deborah ( Coffin ). :e."r.j8. J lfarv. d. W(iltialm nd Ann. 5qlt. rs (w. J~h )facy (s. Jowph nd Hannah),d. William nd Anna (Folger) (first w.), P.a.38.)

14 ~ANTUCKET DEATHS Pmx:iLur, Jenaima, twin d. Paul and Jemima, Sept. 5, 1765, P.R..58- Jemnna, w. Peleg, -, 8 mo. 18o9, c.r 4 [w. Peleg Jr., d. Daniel Chadwick and Hannah (Meader), 31st, 8 mo., P i38. 31st, 8 mo~ P.Jt.63.] Jcnmna, w. Paul (s. Tbeophilas and Deborah), d. Graftoo Gardner Sr. and Abigail (Coffin), I~ II mo. 182o, P.R.38. [wid. Pa~ a. 82 y. 3 m., P.R.63.] Jemima, second w. Jonathan (s. John and Abigail), wid. James Coffin (s. Jonathan and Hepsabeth), d. John Swain and Mary (Swett), 9th, 12 mo. r822, P.R.38. Jethro, h. Susanna (d. Benjamin Coffin and Rebecca), s. Theophilasand Deborah (Paddack) (firstw.), 23d, 6mo. 1820, P.R.38. [a. 74 Y 7 m., P.R.63.J Job~ single, s. Shubael and Anna (Long), 13th, II mo. 1811, P.R.38. [ s. Shubael dee' d and Anna, 22d, 1 I mo., P.R.63.] John, h. Susan ( d. J aines Coffin and Priscilla), h. Mary ( wid. Timothy Coleman, cl. John Bunker and Mary), s. Solomon and Eunice (Gardner), 20th, 9 mo. 1817, P~R.38. [a. 78 y. 9 m., p.r.63.] John, h. Merab (d. Ouistopher Bunker and Dinah), s. Tristram and Lydia (C.offin), "killed by a whale/' -, 8 mo. 1824, P.R.38.. John H., s. John C. and Avis (Folger), 5th, 12 mo. 1832, a. 15, P.~38. Jonathan,. h. Hannah (Brown) Coffin, h. Margaret (Arthur) Rawson, s. Richard 1st and Mary (Coffin},, 1735, P.R.38. Joseph S., b. N., s. George and Eunice, fever, Oct. I, 1846, a. 4. 'in N. [Joseph Starbuck Pinkham, s. George G. and Eunice H., Oct. 2, G.R.3.] Judith, Jan. 19, 1816, c.r.2. [w. Matthew (s. Richard and Miriam), d. Jacob Morris and Judith, P.R.38. a. 58 y. 8 m., P.R.63.] Lurana, d. Paul and Jemima, Dec. 5, 1768, P.R.58. Lydia, wid. Bethuel, -, 4 mo. 1810, c.r.4 [w. Capt. Bethuel, Apr. 5, a. 43, G.R.I. w. Bethuel (s. Jonathan), wid. Cromwell Bunker ( s. George), d. Jonathan Ramsdell Jr. and Priscilla. (Coffin), 6th, 4 mo., P.a.38. wid. Bethuel, 6th, 4 mo., P.R..63. consumption, Apr. 4, P.R.64.] Lydia, 26th, 8 mo. 1813, c.r.4 [second w. Theophilas (s. Richard 1st), wid. William Starbuck (s. Jethro), d. Jere miah Coleman and Sarah (Pratt), 27th, 8 mo., P.R.38. wid. Theophilus, 27t1t, 8 mo., a. 95 y. 6 m., P.R.63.] ~~ ~~~~

15 NA:l'f1~CICllT 81RTHI STASBUC1t,1Albert W., Oct'. 3, \811, G..R.3. [first h. 1'lary Ann (cli\ifoscs Joy and Dellor<lh), s. Simeon and Tan1er (Allen) (Myrick) (second 'v,), P.R. 38.] Albert W. Jr., s. AJbert '\\f. an<l Mary Ann (Joy)., P.n.38. Ale..-.-ander, ch. U riah and Lydia, 19t11, 9 mo. 1787, C.R4. fh. Olive Elliott of.nliss., s. Uriah and Lydia (Alfacy), J.n.38.l Alexander. h. Ella ~1. ( \ i\/arren) of \ 1 Valtham, s. Frederick and Chloe (Batch) (t::>f Faln1outh),, 1842 f sic, dup. Nov. 6, 1841 L P.R.38. Alexander B., "' Charles. R. an r.1 Eliza ( Barnard), 25th, 12 mo. t845, P.R.38. Alfred, s. \Villiam and Silrah ~1. (Allen), 29th, l mo. 1838, P.R.38. Alice, ch. Da niel aj.1d Alice,. 16tb, 8 mo. 1783, c..a4. [d. Daniel and Alice (Vaughn), J Alin.ira. "" Paul Bunker (~. R~ ub~n an<l Abigail), d. Charles and Elizabeth (Clark) (second w.),. P.R.38. Ann. ch. Paul and i\nn, 22d t736 1 c.tt.4. [\v, Reuben Pinkham (s. Thcophil.as and Deborah), w. Thon1as Sn1ith of ~.Y., d. Paul and Ann (1'ibberts) (first w.), I'.R.38.J Ann I.Starbuck], \I/. John l lkldl!ll, Apr. 22, 1794, c. R.3. [Starbuck, w. John fi. Riddell (s. Satnucl and Judith), d. Reuben an<i Anna (Folge1r) (second w.), 23,1, 4 mo., 'P.R.38. ] A1u1. w. J ohn S1nith, d. Charles and Eliza (Allen),, i&!5, l'.r.38. Ann. w. Rev. Zebulon Iltttler. ti. J ohn and Abigail ( Woodbury) (Calif), l'.r.38. Ann. d. Nathan iel and M1ary (Coffin ),, P.R.38. Ann E., d. Frederick P.. 1mariner, and Eliz(abetlh _'\.., of N. f Frededc P. ancl Elizabeth A. (Brown), r.r.38.], Oct. 6, J847. in N. Ann Maria, d. Thomas and Susan ( lviacy). l ath. 4 n , P.R.38. Ann Patten [ ] first w. Paul ( s. Jethro a11d Ann), --, 1787, in E ngland, P."R.38.Anna, cl. )./athf anie)ll J r. (dup. Natl1aniel, omits Jr.]. 12th, 9 n10. i716. (ch. :-.lathaniel and Dinah, C.R-4. w. Peter Ba1 nard (s. Nathaniel! and Judith), d. Nathaniel Tr. and Dinah (Coffin). l>.r.38. Anna. ch. William and Ly1~ ia (S«ond w.), c.a... fw. Paul Padclac:k (s. Paul and Anna), d. William and Lydia (Coleman) (Kcond w ). 1754,..38.)

16 WILLIAM STARBUCK (#162), FATHER OF JUDITH STARBUCK Again, I voice my concern about grouping numbers of footnotes together (1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 13, 14, 15); it is confusing as to which footnote refers to which fact. Do you have a source for the death of child #1, Nathaniel, lost at sea? This seems to be such a common and unfortunate fate for many people in coastal areas of New England in early days. You do not have a footnote for three of William s children, Nathaniel, Jethro and Anna. What are the sources for their names and information? Regarding footnote #2: This undated family letter by itself is not a proof; it does reference the Town Clerk of Nantucket and Savage, but does it refer to some specific document that you were able to obtain? Is the letter in your possession? If you know the location of the letter, be sure to say so in your footnote. Regarding footnote #3: Does this source refer to any specific document(s)? An unauthored source is immediately suspect as a proof, unless it leads you to some concrete record. Regarding footnotes #4 and 14: I haven t seen the Macy book, but are actual documents referred to? If it is just a narrative based on family lore, then it is a secondary source, not a proof. Just a word about the National Genealogical Society Quarterly citations: Those old publications are an accurate source when they refer to actual records. Sometimes the authors ramble on about their own ancestors and engage in flights of fancy about their virtues, etc., but when they refer to records, they are very nice sources indeed! If actual records are referred to, you might want to mention it! Regarding footnote #5: Again, as mentioned in Anna s report, if this marriage record exists as stated in the Nantucket records, including the parents names, you have an excellent proof of the parentage of both William Starbuck and Anna Folger! Regarding footnote #12: As with footnote #5, this is just the kind of proof needed. CONCLUSION: BASED ON THE VITAL RECORDS OF NANTUCKET, YOUR DOCUMENTATION PROVES THE PARENTAGE OF BOTH WILLIAM STARBUCK AND ANNA FOLGER, AS WELL AS THEIR DAUGHTER, JUDITH STARBUCK.