Orthodoxy, Catholicism, and Primacy: A Plea for a New Common Approach. (Originally published in Ecumenical Trends, Volume 37, No.
|
|
- Alice Allison
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Orthodoxy, Catholicism, and Primacy: A Plea for a New Common Approach By ADAM A.J. DEVILLE (Adam A.J. DeVille is an Assistant Professor of Theology at the University of St. Francis in Ft. Wayne, Indiana, and editor of Logos: A Journal of Eastern Christian Studies.) (Originally published in Ecumenical Trends, Volume 37, No. 4, April 2008) It is obvious that the forces of division land destruction, both natural and supernatural, do not desire the success of the official international dialogue between the Orthodox and Catholic Church. Whenever the dialogue is on the verge of making progress, it is waylaid by some unforeseen secondary issue. Consider the history. 1 After getting underway in 1980, the dialogue slowly began to zero in on what is universally acknowledged as the stumbling block, viz., papal primacy. Just as this issue was being tackled, the dialogue began to fall apart in the aftermath of the collapse of the Soviet Union and the reemergence from the underground of the suppressed Eastern Catholic Churches in Romania and especially Western Ukraine. The Orthodox Churches demanded the dialogue deal with the issue of these so-called uniate Churches, 2 which it did in the 1993 Balamand Statement. 3 That did not resolve matters to Orthodox satisfaction, however, and the dialogue began to collapse, not meeting again and only in incomplete and abortive fashion until 2000 in Baltimore, a meeting known to have been a complete fiasco. 4 The next five years were marred by recriminations ( proselytism, violations of canonical territory, etc.) and demands that were bandied about with frequency but not always terminological precision, logic, or evidence. Finally, after the election of Benedict XVI, certain hopeful noises were made about a resumption of the dialogue, which did indeed meet again in Belgrade in September That meeting was a quiet success, and ecumenists around the world could be heard collectively to breathe a sigh of relief and utter a prayer of thanksgiving: if a meeting in the Balkans of all places did not fall apart, perhaps there was hope after all. And yet, at the end of that meeting, there was a substantial if little-noticed or - understood conflict. 6 Unlike past conflicts, however, this was an intra-orthodox affair in the face of which the Catholics, led by Walter Cardinal Kasper as head of
2 the delegation, could only watch politely, distantly, and, one suspects, not a little uncomfortably. Once more this fall, when the dialogue met in Ravenna in October 2007, the same intra-orthodox dispute erupted in greater fashion than in Belgrade. Both last year and this, Bishop Hilarion Alfeyev, the Russian Orthodox bishop of Vienna and head of the Russian delegation to the dialogue, objected to what he saw as an attempt in the dialogue to unjustifiably elevate the role and authority of the Ecumenical Patriarch of Constantinople, about whom there is no clear consensus on the part of Orthodox canonists and ecclesiologists, to say nothing of the hierarchs themselves. (The conflict over Constantinople is not a new one. As Joseph Olsr and Joseph Gill recognized in 1951, the Slav Churches, under the aegis of Russia, challenge the theory of the prerogatives of Constantinople, and in practice studiously ignore them. The Oecumenical Patriarchate... defends its traditional practices and refuses to yield to any part of its claims. ) 7 In fact, in both 2006 and 2007, Hilarion has put his finger on a crucial difficulty and major lacuna in Orthodox ecclesiology that has been identified as such for many centuries, but perhaps most acutely in the last eighty-five years. 8 There is no consensus on primacy in general or on particular forms of primacy, such as universal primacy, papal primacy, or the primacy exercised by Constantinople. In the face of such a lacuna, Bishop Hilarion argued that the Orthodox participants are not authorized to invent an ecclesiological model for the Orthodox Church similar to the one existing in the Roman Catholic Church in order that the Patriarch of Constantinople could occupy a place like the one the Pope occupies in the Church of Rome. 9 In another article, Hilarion was even more explicit in saying that Orthodox-Catholic dialogue would be possible only if an ecclesiological model in which the Patriarch of Constantinople occupies the place of an Eastern Pope is not imposed on the Orthodox Church. 10 According to Alfeyev, there has been no such a model in the Orthodox Church, and for instituting it at least the Pan-Orthodox Council is required and the consent of all local Orthodox Churches. 11 Such a seeking of consensus, he said, should take place first within Orthodoxy and after it, if possible, between Orthodoxy and Catholicism. Such a seeking of consensus is necessary because among the Orthodox Churches there is a very considerable divergence of understandings of what primacy is in general, and what any particular primacy exercised by Constantinople may legitimately entail. As Hilarion said, some Orthodox rather regard this primacy as purely honourable, while others give certain coordinating functions to the patriarch of Constantinople and see him as highest court. 12
3 Hilarion is right on all these matters. The real issues about Constantinople s role, its canonical status and the historical changes pertaining thereto, the relationships between it and the other Orthodox patriarchates and Churches in general, and the larger question of primacy, are all far from clearly settled in Orthodox ecclesiology or, especially, practice. 13 Bishop Hilarion s objection was renewed in a stronger way in October 2007 as he led the Russian delegation in walking out of the meeting because a delegation from the Estonian Orthodox Church was admitted an action he was duty-bound to perform in compliance with the wishes of his synod. Moscow claims that the Estonian Church is dependent on it, but Constantinople has recognized a second Church in Estonia to which it has granted autonomy, which is disputed and resented by the Russians. 14 In this instance as in 2006, the flashpoint is the status and authority of Constantinople. Does it have the authority to grant autonomy or autocephaly to other Churches, and if so, is that authority its own exclusive prerogative? Or do other Churches have this authority? Russia clearly thinks other Churches have this authority, and used this argument to grant independence to the Orthodox Church of America in 1970, an act still not recognized by Constantinople or many other Orthodox. 15 Bishop Hilarion, an ecumenically irenic, Western-educated and very substantial Russian theologian, is not advancing here a Russocentric agenda at the expense of a weakened Constantinople. He has, as we noted above, put his finger on a lacuna in Orthodox ecclesiology. That lacuna is a lack of consensus on the question of primacy in all its forms, but especially in its universal form. Some among Constantinople s defenders and apologists have been inclined, over the years, to suggest that the Ecumenical Patriarch has powers of supervision of younger Churches outside the territory of the original, ancient patriarchates, of settling intra-church disputes, of convening global Orthodox councils, and of granting independence to newer and younger Churches. 16 The Ecumenical Patriarch is thus said to act universally as primus inter pares, with more emphasis on primus than some would like. According to Alfeyev, however, there has been no such a model in the Orthodox Church. Some Orthodox, he continued, rather regard this primacy as purely honourable, while others give certain coordinating functions to the patriarch of Constantinople and see him as highest court. The importance of resolving this question was underscored not just by Alfeyev s declarations and actions, but also by Walter Cardinal Kasper, the Catholic co-chairman of the dialogue, who said in an interview two days after the dialogue concluded in 2006 that if the question
4 were to remain open, it would in fact cause a permanent difficulty for the international Catholic-Orthodox dialogue. 17 There is, then, consensus at least on what the dividing issue is among the Orthodox, and a recognition of the widespread importance of settling this issue. The reasons for this lack of consensus are several, but need not detain us here. What is important to note here is that for all the papers that have been published lamenting the lack of consensus, and all the calls over the decades for the need to come to a consensus, the plain fact is that Orthodoxy is no closer to a consensus on primacy in any form than it was a century ago. Moreover, as the actions of Bishop Alfeyev show, the prospects of coming to such a consensus any time soon seem slim indeed. One must therefore, respectfully but firmly, ask our Orthodox confreres whether we are all to wait another century or longer before this muchlamented lacuna in Orthodox ecclesiology is filled. I do not think that in good conscience any ecumenist can consent to such a wait, not least when there are alternative methods for proceeding. What I want to draw attention to is a possible method for settling them. I want to suggest that, pace Alfeyev and Kasper, Orthodoxy does not need first to sort out its own internal understanding of universal primacy and the role of Constantinople in order next to come to a consensus between Orthodoxy and Catholicism on the question of papal primacy. I want to suggest, rather, that Orthodoxy and Catholics do this together because universal primacy, which is to say papal primacy, is an open question for all Christians, and we need each other to solve this problem. In 1995, in an unprecedented and justly famous request, the late Pope John Paul II, in his landmark encyclical Ut Unum Sint, asked for help in reconfiguring his office so that it would no longer be an ecumenical stumbling block: as Bishop of Rome I am... convinced that I have a particular responsibility in... acknowledging the ecumenical aspirations of the majority of the Christian Communities and in heeding the request made of me to find a way of exercising the primacy which, while in no way renouncing what is essential to its mission, is nonetheless open to a new situation... This is an immense task, which we cannot refuse and which I cannot carry out by myself. Could not the real but imperfect communion existing between us persuade Church leaders and their theologians to engage with me in a patient and fraternal dialogue on this subject, a dialogue in which, leaving useless controversies behind, we could listen to one another, keeping before us only the will of Christ for his Church? 8
5 That request remains an open invitation, and it seems infinitely more profitable and worthwhile to answer the question together. There is no point in both sides waiting for years and likely decades or centuries to come up with answers which would then have to be re-thought (or at the very least painstakingly synthesized) all over again once they met in dialogue. Working in isolation has not been fruitful for either side, as has been recently recognized by Zizioulas at a symposium (organized by Kasper) in Rome in 2003 on primacy. There he argued that the answer to the question of primacy can only come as a common answer from theology, not from biblical exegesis or history. 19 Zizioulas stressed the importance of coming to a common answer to the question whether and for what theological reasons we need a universal primus, and how we can understand his nature and function. Such theological reasons can emerge from an ecclesiology of communion... This would mean that the justification of the Roman primacy would depend on whether we agree that the Church consists of full local churches united into one Church without losing their ecclesial fullness; and that primacy at all levels is a necessary means to realize and guarantee this balance between the many and the one. 20 Zizioulas s emphasis on solving these problems in common was also underscored by one of his fellow symposiasts in Rome in The Romanian Orthodox theologian and canonist V. Nicolae Dura also argued that the difficulties of sorting out questions of primacy and papacy constitute an area still open for our common work to find satisfactory answers and solutions. 21 Dura went on to propose that in undertaking such common work the whole tradition of the Church, Orthodox and Catholic biblical, liturgical, patristic, historical, and so forth must be taken into account, from the apostolic period up to our time, in order to better discover the principal role of the bishopofrome at the service of the unity of the ecumenical Church. 22 Dura went on to argue that the question of primacy needs a comparative study that can evaluate sine ira et studio all Orthodox and Catholic ecclesiological and canonical data. 23 Zizioulas and Dura have called for a common method and collaborative effort in solving these issues, and I want to underscore the importance of this. Yes, we need to have a clear sense of our own traditions, but these traditions are not static or one-sided but dynamic, the methods for approaching them dialogical. Neither tradition has ever existed in isolation, and neither tradition today can afford to
6 examine problems without the collaboration and input of other Christian traditions. Only by working together on our common problems can we find the mind of Christ. We have already waited too long for unity and wasted too many years hoping for an elusive consensus on primacy to emerge first in one tradition, then another. 24 When there is an open question on the table, posed by Pope John Paul II, that concerns us all, is it not possible, and eminently sensible in practical terms, to respond to that question and so come to a common mind, as Catholics and Orthodox, on the question of universal papal primacy first? The benefit of this approach is twofold: we solve this most vexatious of issues and, in so doing, we have, ipso facto, come to a common mind about the primacy of Constantinople. For the problem of Constantinople s primacy only emerged once the communion between it, as the second see of the so-called pentarchy, and the see of Rome, the first see in Christendom, was broken. At that point, Constantinople was said, if never entirely clearly or authoritatively, to take over some of the primatial responsibilities that Rome is thought to have held in the first millennium. If, in the third millennium, we repair the breach between Constantinople and Rome that is, between Orthodoxy and Catholicism as a whole by resolving the last issue between us, the papacy, then it stands to reason that we will thereby have also resolved the problem of Constantinople s primacy. Constantinople will once more resume its place as the second see of the Christian Church, and the taxis or order of the early Church will be renewed with, no doubt, some important differences for the good of us all, who will thus have come to a common mind about primacy. Let us pray, then, that this intra-orthodox dispute will not derail the dialogue once more. Let us suggest that the dialogue press on to resolve together the question of primacy so that we may come to a mind on this that is truly common and wholly one. We have already been divided for too long; we have already waited too long for the renewal of unity; we have already wasted too many years apart searching for a consensus that still eludes us. Now is the time for holy impatience and a desire to press on towards that full communion that the Holy Spirit wills for the Body of Christ. Notes: 1. Some of the history, together with the early documents of the dialogue, may be located in John Erickson and John Borelli, eds., The Quest for Unity: Orthodox and Catholics in Dialogue (Crestwood: St. Vladimir s Press, 1996).
7 2. About which see Robert Taft, The Problem of Uniatism and the Healing of Memories : Anamnesis, not Amnesia, Logos: A Journal of Eastern Christian Studies ( ): The Balamand Statement may be found in John Erickson and John Borelli, The Quest for Unity, Details of the difficulties in Baltimore in 2000, the last meeting of the dialogue until 2006, are told by E. Lanne and M. van Parys, Le dialogue catholique-orthodoxe a BaltimoreEmmitsburg, Irenikon 3-4(2000): Catholic World News linked to the comrnunique: ; this is also available on the official website of the Ecumenical Patriarchate: 6. See Moscow Patriarchate s Representative Urges Vatican Not to Impose the Patriarch of Constantinople as an Eastern Pope on the Orthodox World, Europaica Bulletin 106 (4 October 2006) at 7. Joseph Olsr and Joseph Gill, The Twenty-Eighth Canon of Chalcedon in Dispute Between Constantinople and Moscow, in Das Konzil von Chalkedon: Geschichte und Gegenwart, eds., Aloys Grillmeier und Heinrich Bacht, 3 vols. (W\rzburg: EchterVerlag, ), 3: One very initial and inchoate, and ultimately unsuccessful, attempt to look at some of these questions was the Pan-Orthodox Congress in Constantinople of On this, see the fascinating new book of Patrick Viscuso, A Quest for Reform of the Orthodox Church: the 1923 Pan-Orthodox Congress. An Analysis and Translation of its Acts and Decisions (Berkeley, CA: Inter-Orthodox Press, 2006). The Congress did not accomplish much for reasons Viscuso analyzes and discusses, and the issue of primacy was not really discussed again until Alexander Schmemann s important article, now almost half a century old, The Idea of Primacy in Orthodox Ecclesiology, St. Vladimir s Seminary Quarterly 4 (1960): Schmemann s plea also fell on deaf ears. Nicholas Lossky, in 1999, acknowledged that there is still no Orthodox consensus on these questions of primacy, conciliarity; and authority: Conciliarity-Primacy in a Russian Orthodox Perspective, in Petrine Ministry and the Unity of the Church: Toward a Patient and Fraternal Dialogue, ed., James F. Puglisi (Collegeville, MN: The Liturgical Press, 1999): More recently still, the great Greek Orthodox theologian and metropolitan, John Zizioulas, has repeated the importance of consensus on this question in his Recent Discussions on Primacy in Orthodox Theology, in The Petrine Ministry:Catholics and Orthodox in Dialogue, ed. Walter Cardinal Kasper (New York: Newman Press, 2006), Bishop Hilarion Voices His Protest to Cardinal Kasper against Procedure at the Orthodox- Catholic Dialogue, Europaica Bulletin 106 (4 October 2006) at
8 10. Moscow Patriarchate s Representative Urges Vatican Not to Impose the Patriarch of Constantinople as an Eastern Pope on the Orthodox World, Europaica Bulletin Ibid. 12. Ibid. 13. Notwithstanding the plethora of studies on the history, authority, and structure of the Ecumenical Patriarchate. See, e.g., Metropolitan Maximos of Sardes. The Oecumenical Patriarchate in the Orthodox Church (Thessaloniki: Patriarchal Institute for Patristic Studies, 1976); John Meyendorff, The Ecumenical Patriarch, Seen in the Light of Orthodox Ecclesiology and History, Greek Orthodox Theological Review 24(1979): ; and Lewis J. Patsavos, Primacy and Conciliarity: Studies in the Primacy of the See of Constantinople and the Synodal Structure of the Orthodox Church (Brookline, MA: Holy Cross Orthodox Press, 1995). 14. On the issue of Estonia, see Alexander F.C. Webster, Split Decision: the Orthodox Clash over Estonia, Christian Century 113 (5 June 1996): For a more detailed account of these historical developments, see the history chapter of the Orthodox Church of Estonia s official webpage: See also V. Mite, Estonia: Two Branches of Orthodox Church Seeking to Live in One Country, Religioscope (10 May 2002): notes/2002_049_ortho_estonia.htm 15. On the status of the OCA and the debate surrounding it, see, inter alia, Alexander Bogolepov, Towards an American Orthodox Church: the Establishment of an Autocephalous Orthodox Church, rev. ed. (Crestwood, NY: St. Vladimir s Seminary Press, I ve analyzed these powers in more detail in my A Diversity of Polities: Patriarchal Leadership in the Orthodox Churches, The Jurist, forthcoming, Inter-Qrthodox Unity Vital for Ecumenism, Says Cardinal, Ut Unum Sint, nos John ZiziQulas, Recent Discussions on Primacy in Orthodox Theology, Ibid., V. Nicolne Dura The Petrine Primacy : the Role of the Bishop of Rome according to the Canonical Legislation of the Ecumenical Councils of the First Millennium: an Ecclesiological- Canonical Evaluation, in The Petrine Ministry: Catholics and Orthodox in Dialogue, ed. Walter Cardinal Kasper (New York: Newman Press, 2006), 164 (my emphasis).
9 22. Ibid., 186 (my emphasis). 23. Ibid. 24. While Catholic ecclesiology is generally more coherent on the questions of primacy, especially papal primacy, it is important to recall that Catholic theology is far from monolithic or homogenous on this question. It is, in fact, vigorously debated by such as Yves Congar, Joseph Ratzinger, Hermann Pottmeyer, Jean Tillard, Walter Kasper, George Nedungatt, Myriam Wijlens, Gisbert Greshake, and Michael Magee, and most recently, Geoffrey Robinson.
ORTHODOXY ROMAN PAPACY
adam a. j. de ville ORTHODOXY and the ROMAN PAPACY Ut Unum Sint and the Prospects of East-West Unity University of Notre Dame Press Notre Dame, Indiana Introduction The issue of ecclesiology, and not minor
More informationUniversity of Fribourg, 24 March 2014
PRESENTATION by Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk Chairman of the Department of External Church Relations of the Moscow Patriarchate Chairman of the Synodal Biblical-Theological Commission Rector of
More informationBy Adam A.J. DeVille
Michael Whelton, Popes and Patriarchs: An Orthodox Perspective on Roman Catholic Claims, Ben Lomond, CA: Conciliar Press, 2006, 177+pp. ISBN 1-888212-78-0 By Adam A.J. DeVille For nearly forty years, the
More informationThe Russian Orthodox Church and Contemporary Events: Dispelling the Myths
The Russian Orthodox Church and Contemporary Events: Dispelling the Myths The following interview was recently granted by His Eminence, Metropolitan Hilarion (Alfeyev) of Volokolamsk, chairman of the Department
More informationTOWARDS AN ANGLICAN COVENANT. Paul McPartlan
TOWARDS AN ANGLICAN COVENANT Paul McPartlan 1. We know that in everything God works for good with those who love him (Rom 8:28). The Anglican Communion is currently facing grave issues of structural unity
More informationAn Invitation to the Pope by the Œcumenical Patriarch *
The Orthodox Informer For it is a commandment of the Lord not to be silent at a time when the Faith is in jeopardy. Speak, Scripture says, and hold not thy peace... For this reason, I, the wretched one,
More informationThe North American Orthodox-Catholic Theological Consultation. Washington DC, October 28, 2017
A Response to the Joint International Commission for Theological Dialogue between the Roman Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church Document Synodality and Primacy during the First Millennium: Towards
More informationAre the Ratzinger Proposal and Zoghby Initiative Dead? Implications of Ad Tuendam Fidem for Eastern Catholic Identity
Are the Ratzinger Proposal and Zoghby Initiative Dead? Implications of Ad Tuendam Fidem for Eastern Catholic Identity Joel I. Barstad, Ph.D. Revised April 4, 2008 Introduction Is Rome satisfied with Eastern
More informationStructure of the Orthodox Church
Structure of the Orthodox Church PART B Adult Education Series 12/16 23 PART A Church Timeline Early Church Byzantine Church Outline Orthodox Church of America Church Governance Synodal Authority Holy
More informationThe Leadership of the Ecumenical Patriarchate, and the Significance of Canon 28 of Chalcedon
The Leadership of the Ecumenical Patriarchate, and the Significance of Canon 28 of Chalcedon A Statement by the Faculty of the Holy Cross Greek Orthodox School of Theology 1 The Ecumenical Patriarchate
More informationA Universal Ministry of Unity: Prospects and Problems in Roman Catholic-Orthodox Dialogue.
A Universal Ministry of Unity: Prospects and Problems in Roman Catholic-Orthodox Dialogue. Anthony John Gooley B.A. (Psych), B.Th., B.A. Hons I (Theol), Grad Dip Ed School of Humanities Faculty of Humanities
More informationTwo Parallel Worlds An Interview with His Beatitude Sviatoslav
Two Parallel Worlds An Interview with His Beatitude Sviatoslav Saturday, February 13, 2016 On February 12, Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill, the leaders of two Churches, met at the Jose Marti International
More informationLARCUM Luncheon RESPONSES TO UT UNUM SINT By Ronald G. Roberson, CSP
LARCUM Luncheon RESPONSES TO UT UNUM SINT By Ronald G. Roberson, CSP In late September 1997, not long after I began work at the Secretariat for Ecumenical and Interreligious Affairs at the USCCB, I attended
More informationTHE ORTHODOX CHURCH. The Orthodox Church, Its Past and Its Role in the World Today (New York: Pantheon Books, 1963). 143
THE ORTHODOX CHURCH The fact that an Orthodox theologian was asked to speak at your Convention on a subject as general as The Orthodox Church is indeed a sign of our times: the recent developments in the
More informationStructure of the Orthodox Church
Structure of the Orthodox Church PART A Adult Education Series 12/16 1 PART A Church Timeline Early Church Byzantine Church Outline Orthodox Church of America Church Governance Synodal Authority Terms
More informationAlexei Krindatch "The Conundrum of Uniting American Orthodox Church: How to Resolve the Puzzle?"
Alexei Krindatch (akrindatch@aol.com) "The Conundrum of Uniting American Orthodox Church: How to Resolve the Puzzle?" Why am I here today to talk about Assembly s work? Work closely with several Assembly
More informationAddress of His Eminence Archbishop Nathaniel WELCOME
Address of His Eminence Archbishop Nathaniel Reverend Fathers and Delegates: to the 77 th Episcopate Congress, July 2009 WELCOME Welcome to the 77 th Annual Episcopate Congress. For many of you this is
More informationCOUNCIL FOR CHRISTIAN UNITY THE GIFT OF AUTHORITY: REPORT TO THE GENERAL SYNOD
GS 1532 COUNCIL FOR CHRISTIAN UNITY THE GIFT OF AUTHORITY: REPORT TO THE GENERAL SYNOD 1. The Gift of Authority (GA) is the most recent of the four agreed statements produced by the second phase of the
More informationMOSCOW AND GREEK ORTHODOX PATRIARCHATES: TWO ACTORS FOR THE LEADERSHIP OF WORLD ORTHODOXY IN THE POST COLD WAR ERA
MOSCOW AND GREEK ORTHODOX PATRIARCHATES: TWO ACTORS FOR THE LEADERSHIP OF WORLD ORTHODOXY IN THE POST COLD WAR ERA The Moscow Patriarchate and the Istanbul Greek Orthodox Patriarchate are both transnational
More informationPre-Ecumenical Uniates Ecumenical Eastern Catholics
Pre-Ecumenical Uniates Ecumenical Eastern Catholics Fr Athanasius McVay THIS presentation is historical, both in its method and in the very fact of its being the first of its kind in the history of these
More informationOrthodoxy in a New Europe: Problems and Perspectives
Occasional Papers on Religion in Eastern Europe Volume 24 Issue 3 Article 3 6-2004 Orthodoxy in a New Europe: Problems and Perspectives Bishop Hilarion Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.georgefox.edu/ree
More informationThe importance of dialogue for the Evangelical Churches in Romania in the context of the expansion of the European Union
The importance of dialogue for the Evangelical Churches in Romania in the context of the expansion of the European Union Daniel Martin Daniel Martin is from Oradea, Romania. After completing his BA at
More informationINTRODUCTION PRELIMINARY CONSIDERATIONS
The HOLY SYNOD of the ORTHODOX CHURCH IN AMERICA A RESPONSE From the HOLY SYNOD of BISHOPS of the ORTHODOX CHURCH in AMERICA to the Common Starting Point for Canonical and Regional Planning of the ASSEMBLY
More informationADDRESS OF THE CHAIRMAN HIS EMINENCE ARCHBISHOP DEMETRIOS OF AMERICA At the 6 th Assembly of Canonical Orthodox Bishops of the United States of
ADDRESS OF THE CHAIRMAN HIS EMINENCE ARCHBISHOP DEMETRIOS OF AMERICA At the 6 th Assembly of Canonical Orthodox Bishops of the United States of America Chicago, IL (September 15, 2015) *** 1. Your Eminences,
More informationAuthority in the Anglican Communion
Authority in the Anglican Communion AUTHORITY IN THE ANGLICAN COMMUNION by The Rev. Canon Dr. Alyson Barnett-Cowan For the purposes of this article, I am going to speak about how the churches of the Anglican
More informationThe Ever-Memorable Confessor Metropolitan Philaret, First Hierarch of the Russian Orthodox Church Abroad ( 1985) Open Letter
The Ever-Memorable Confessor Metropolitan Philaret, First Hierarch of the Russian Orthodox Church Abroad ( 1985) Text II Open Letter To His Eminence, Archbishop Iakovos of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese
More informationKyiv s Birthplace of Orthodoxy in Eastern Europe
ARTICLE Peter Goldring Member of Parliament 1997-2015 July 25, 2016 Kyiv s Birthplace of Orthodoxy in Eastern Europe The significance of the recent message from the press centre of the Kyiv s Patriarchate
More informationThe Impact of Orthodox Theology
The Impact of Orthodox Theology Source: religion-online.org Think of the standard theological debates in Western Christianity: Is conversion a matter of divine grace or human free will? Are theological
More informationTHE FOURTH PRE-CONCILIAR PAN-ORTHODOX CONFERENCE. Decision RULES OF OPERATION OF EPISCOPAL ASSEMBLIES IN THE ORTHODOX DIASPORA. Article 1. Article 2.
THE FOURTH PRE-CONCILIAR PAN-ORTHODOX CONFERENCE THE ORTHODOX CENTER OF THE ECUMENICAL PATRIARCHATE CHAMBÉSY, 6-13 JUNE 2009 Decision RULES OF OPERATION OF EPISCOPAL ASSEMBLIES IN THE ORTHODOX DIASPORA
More informationLecture 6: The World Council of Churches and Orthodoxy
Lecture 6: The World Council of Churches and Orthodoxy The Ecumenical Movement: Origins and Hopes The search in the twentieth century to restore Christian unity has often been called the ecumenical movement
More informationOrthodox Churches: Chalcedonian and Non-Chalcedonian
Orthodox Churches: Chalcedonian and Non-Chalcedonian A resume of some recent contacts Paulos Mar Gregorios Few people are aware that two of the largest separations in the Universal Church took place more
More informationLECTURE BY HIS EMINENCE ARCHBISHOP DEMETRIOS GERON OF AMERICA ORTHODOX THEOLOGY MAY 22, 2018 SCHOOL OF THEOLOGY UNIVERSITY OF THESSALONIKI
1 LECTURE BY HIS EMINENCE ARCHBISHOP DEMETRIOS GERON OF AMERICA 8 TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE OF ORTHODOX THEOLOGY MAY 22, 2018 SCHOOL OF THEOLOGY UNIVERSITY OF THESSALONIKI ORTHODOX DIASPORA: PERSPECTIVES
More informationOrientale Lumen Eastern Catholic Churches: Window between East and West
Orientale Lumen Eastern Catholic Churches: Window between East and West It is a great joy to be with you, dear brothers and sisters, in this atmosphere of Orientale Lumen, this wonderful letter of His
More informationKristin Colberg Assistant Professor of Theology
Kristin Colberg Assistant Professor of Theology Full Publications List Books Colberg, Kristin. Vatican I and Vatican II: Councils in the Living Tradition (Collegeville: Liturgical Press, 2016). Colberg,
More informationLiturgical Orientation: the Position of the President at the Eucharist
Liturgical Orientation: the Position of the President at the Eucharist Neil Xavier O Donoghue Priest of the Roman Catholic Church, Vice Rector of Redemptoris Mater Archdiocesan Missionary Seminary, Dundalk,
More informationContend Earnestly for the Faith Part 10
Contend Earnestly for the Faith Part 10 I now feel compelled instead to write to encourage you to contend earnestly for the faith that was once for all entrusted to the saints. Jude 1:3b NET The Ecumenical
More informationJOHANNES QUASTEN AWARD Cardinal Walter Kasper
JOHANNES QUASTEN AWARD 2014 Cardinal Walter Kasper Presentation by Msgr Paul McPartlan, Acting Dean of the School of Theology and Religious Studies, CUA 6 November 2014 Your Eminences, Provost Morozowich,
More informationORTHODOX BRETHREN 209
ORTHODOX BRETHREN "Let God see and judge!" The shout resounded in the ears of the dumbfounded congregation as it watched him shake the dust from his feet and leave the church. The man who uttered this
More informationCatholic Identity Then and Now
Catholic Identity Then and Now By J. BRYAN HEHIR, MDiv, ThD Any regular reader of Health Progress would have to be struck by the attention paid to Catholic identity for the past 20 years in Catholic health
More informationAct of Canonical Communion signed in Moscow
Act of Canonical Communion signed in Moscow The Act of Canonical Communion between the Russian Orthodox Church in Russia and abroad was signed at Moscow s Christ the Savior Cathedral on Thursday morning.
More informationThe Russian Orthodox Church and Contemporary Events: Dispelling the Myths
The Russian Orthodox Church and Contemporary Events: Dispelling the Myths Part two of two. Part one. Question: In the post-soviet period, parallel structures of other Orthodox Churches have appeared in
More informationKristin Colberg Assistant Professor of Theology
Kristin Colberg Assistant Professor of Theology Full List of Publications Publications "Hospitality," Abbey Banner, Fall, 2016. "A Community of Disciples: How the Church Benefits from the intentional Community
More informationAn Exercise of the Hierarchical Magisterium. Richard R. Gaillardetz, Ph.D.
An Exercise of the Hierarchical Magisterium Richard R. Gaillardetz, Ph.D. In Pope John Paul II s recent apostolic letter on the male priesthood he reiterated church teaching on the exclusion of women from
More information3. WHERE PEOPLE STAND
19 3. WHERE PEOPLE STAND Political theorists disagree about whether consensus assists or hinders the functioning of democracy. On the one hand, many contemporary theorists take the view of Rousseau that
More informationPope Benedict, influenced by Vatican II, can shape its implementation
VATICANII-BENEDICT Oct-12-2005 (1,900 words) Backgrounder. With photo posted Oct. 11. xxxi Pope Benedict, influenced by Vatican II, can shape its implementation By John Thavis Catholic News Service VATICAN
More informationRecord of Conversation of M.S. Gorbachev and John Paul II. Vatican, December 1, 1989
Record of Conversation of M.S. Gorbachev and John Paul II Vatican, December 1, 1989 For the first several minutes the conversation was one-on-one (without interpreters). Gorbachev: I would like to say
More informationTheological Foundations for Eparchial Pastoral Councils: An Eastern Perspective By Rev. Ronald G. Roberson, CSP 2004
Theological Foundations for Eparchial Pastoral Councils: An Eastern Perspective By Rev. Ronald G. Roberson, CSP 2004 The Christian East is widely recognized as representing a way of living out the Christian
More informationA Church in Dialogue. Catholic Ecumenical Commitment
A Church in Dialogue Catholic Ecumenical Commitment Celebrating the 50 th Anniversary of the Second Vatican Council s Decree on Ecumenism, Unitatis Redintegratio, 1964-2014. Canadian society is characterized
More informationNova et Vetera From 30Days Interview with Cardinal Darío Castrillón Hoyos by Gianni Cardinale
Nova et Vetera From 30Days Benedict XVI has signed and published the document that liberalizes the use of the Roman Missal edited by Pope John XXIII in 1962. An interview with Cardinal Darío Castrillón
More informationTHE HOMILIES OF SAINT GREGORY THE GREAT
Theodosia Gray THE HOMILIES OF SAINT GREGORY THE GREAT On the Book of the Prophet Ezekiel in ENGLISH TRANSLATION Introduction by Bishop Chrysostomos Edited by Presbytera Juliana Cownie The Homilies of
More informationANGLICAN - ROMAN CATHOLIC INTERNATIONAL COMMISSION (ARCIC)
FULL-TEXT Interconfessional Dialogues ARCIC Anglican-Roman Catholic Interconfessional Dialogues Web Page http://dialogues.prounione.it Source Current Document www.prounione.it/dialogues/arcic ANGLICAN
More informationVatican II and the Church today
Vatican II and the Church today How is the Catholic Church Organized? Equal not Same A Rite represents an ecclesiastical, or church, tradition about how the sacraments are to be celebrated. Each of the
More informationC a t h o l i c D i o c e s e o f Y o u n g s t o w n
Catholic Diocese of Youngstown A Guide for Parish Pastoral Councils A People of Mission and Vision 2000 The Diocesan Parish Pastoral Council Guidelines are the result of an eighteen-month process of study,
More informationThe Bishop as Servant of Catholic Renewal
The Bishop as Servant of Catholic Renewal A Pastoral Letter to the People of the Ecumenical Catholic Communion from Peter Elder Hickman, Presiding Bishop Where the Bishop is, there let the multitude of
More informationThe World Council of Churches and the Interfaith Movement
NUMBER I IN THE SERIES Contributions to a Theology of Anti Ecumenism The World Council of Churches and the Interfaith Movement Metropolitan Cyprian of Oropos and Fili NUMBER I IN THE SERIES Contributions
More informationWORLD COUNCIL OF CHURCHES International Inter-Orthodox Consultation on
WORLD COUNCIL OF CHURCHES International Inter-Orthodox Consultation on The Ecumenical Movement in Theological Education and in the Life of Orthodox Churches Sibiu, Romania, 9-12 November 2010 COMMUNIQUE
More informationREPORT OF THE CATHOLIC REFORMED BILATERAL DIALOGUE ON BAPTISM 1
REPORT OF THE CATHOLIC REFORMED BILATERAL DIALOGUE ON BAPTISM 1 A SEASON OF ENGAGEMENT The 20 th century was one of intense dialogue among churches throughout the world. In the mission field and in local
More informationReceptive Ecumenism as a Catholic Calling: Catholic Teaching on Ecumenism from Blessed Pope John Paul II to His Holiness Pope Francis
Receptive Ecumenism as a Catholic Calling: Catholic Teaching on Ecumenism from Blessed Pope John Paul II to His Holiness Pope Francis Prof. Dr Paul D. Murray Professor of Systematic Theology and Dean &
More informationThe Theological Premises and Canonical Consequences of Church Synodality as Reflected in the Ravenna Document
International Journal of Orthodox Theology 5:2 (2014) urn:nbn:de:0276-2014-2053 59 Cristian Vasile Petcu The Theological Premises and Canonical Consequences of Church Synodality as Reflected in the Ravenna
More informationTable of Contents. Church History. Page 1: Church History...1. Page 2: Church History...2. Page 3: Church History...3. Page 4: Church History...
Church History Church History Table of Contents Page 1: Church History...1 Page 2: Church History...2 Page 3: Church History...3 Page 4: Church History...4 Page 5: Church History...5 Page 6: Church History...6
More informationTHE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF AMERICA School of Theology and Religious Studies
THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF AMERICA School of Theology and Religious Studies TRS 664A Theology of the Church (3 Credit Hours) Christopher Ruddy, Associate Professor Pangborn G024 MWF 11:10 a.m. 12:00 p.m.
More informationMr. President, 2. Several of the themes included on the agenda of this General Assembly may be
Mr. President, 1. The Holy See is honoured to take part in the general debate of the General Assembly of the United Nations for the first time since the Resolution of last 1 July which formalized and specified
More informationThe Papal Visit to Greece*
Ignorance? Or a confusion of criteria? Or hypocrisy? Or all of these together? The Papal Visit to Greece* A Colossal Ecclesiastical and Historical Blunder Metropolitan Cyprian of Oropos and Fili President
More informationEAST WEST CONFERENCE AT MINSTER ABBEY SATURDAY 20 SEPTEMBER 2014
EAST WEST CONFERENCE AT MINSTER ABBEY SATURDAY 20 SEPTEMBER 2014 Thank you very much Mother Nikola and Sr Benedict. I am delighted to be part of this ecumenical gathering. I come with a sense of humility
More informationGeneral Introduction
General Introduction The splits, conflicts, disunity, enmity and competition among the Churches have tarnished the image of the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church founded by Jesus Christ in the course
More informationThe Canonical Status of the Patriarch of Constantinople in the Orthodox Church
Holy Trinity Cathedral - Ecclesiology The Canonical Status of the Patriarch of Constantinople in the Orthodox Church Archbishop Gregory (Afonsky) The Russian canonical school of the 19 th and 20 th centuries
More informationVolume 5, Number 4 Summer, 2011
Happenings! SSJC Workshop: Baptismal Catechesis East/West Saturday, October 1, 10 a.m. -12:30 p.m. at St. Paul Greek Orthodox Church, 4949 Alton Pky, Irvine, 92604. Discover how the churches in the East
More informationFOR CRITICAL ISSUES LAITY. Developments since Vatican II The Vatican Council IL The Extraordinary Synod of 1985 insisted
23 CRITICAL ISSUES LAITY FOR By LEONARD DOOHAN I 987 IS THE YEAR of the laity. Dioceses throughout the world are using this time to launch renewal programmes, layformation programmes, lay-ministry training
More informationRelevant Ecclesial Documents Concerning Adult Faith Formation
Relevant Ecclesial Documents Concerning Adult Faith Formation Paul VI, Apostolic Exhortation Evangelli Nuntiandi, December 8, 1975. All rights reserved. This was a breakthrough document in many ways. It
More information"Christian Unity Under the Lordship of Jesus Christ: A New Vision of Catholicity?"
Quaker Religious Thought Volume 106 106-107 combined Article 12 1-1-2006 "Christian Unity Under the Lordship of Jesus Christ: A New Vision of Catholicity?" Paul Anderson panderso@georgefox.edu Follow this
More informationChristian Scriptures: Testimony and Theological Reflection 5 Three Classic Paradigms of Theology 6
Contributors Abbreviations xix xxiii Introducing a Second Edition: Changing Roman Catholic Perspectives Francis Schüssler Fiorenza xxv 1. Systematic Theology: Task and Methods 1 Francis Schüssler Fiorenza
More informationEXPLANATORY NOTE. Letter of His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI to Chinese Catholics. 27 May 2007
EXPLANATORY NOTE Letter of His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI to Chinese Catholics 27 May 2007 By his Letter to Bishops, Priests, Consecrated Persons and Lay Faithful of the Catholic Church in the People s
More informationThe Church s Foundational Crisis Gabriel Moran
The Church s Foundational Crisis Gabriel Moran Before the Synod meeting of 2014 many people were expecting fundamental changes in church teaching. The hopes were unrealistic in that a synod is not the
More informationPlease go to to learn about the saints. At this website you can sign up for an delivery for the Saint of the Day.
Website www.stedwardbowie.com Newsletter October 21, 2018 Father Scott Holmer, Pastor Maureen Curtis, Director of Religious Education (301) 249-9199 Monday through Friday 9:00am to 2:00pm (301) 249-9599
More informationThe Orthodox Are Coming! Nicolai N. Petro
Page 1 of 7 SEARCH English The Orthodox Are Coming! Archive Nicolai N. Petro About New Europe Review Broadcasting Board of Governors International Broadcasting Bureau Voice of America Publisher and Editors
More informationNOTES CONCERNING THE BISHOP'S CONFERENCE, GRAN NORWAY AUGUST
Oslo, 19 July 2017 Bishop Roald Nikolai NOTES CONCERNING THE BISHOP'S CONFERENCE, GRAN NORWAY AUGUST 4-6 2017 The following is intended as a general introduction to the main issues at the gathering. WHY
More informationCanadian Conference of Catholic Bishops - New Ecclesial Movements & Associations Tuesday, September Last Updated Friday, March
Introduction Throughout the history of the Church, the Holy Spirit has continually raised up ecclesial movements and associations as instruments in the Church for spreading the Good News of Jesus Christ.
More informationChristian Denominations
Apostolic Succession Topic Coptic Orthodox Protestant Roman Catholic This is an important part of Orthodox belief and ensures continuity with the church that Christ founded. Bible - Composition of Accept
More informationFifty Years after the Second Vatican Council Assessing Ecumenical Relations from the Perspective of the World Council of Churches
bs_bs_banner Fifty Years after the Second Vatican Council Assessing Ecumenical Relations from the Perspective of the World Council of Churches Konrad Raiser Konrad Raiser was the fifth general secretary
More informationLUMEN GENTIUM. An Orthodox Critique of the Second Vatican Council s Dogmatic Constitution on the Church. Fr. Paul Verghese
LUMEN GENTIUM An Orthodox Critique of the Second Vatican Council s Dogmatic Constitution on the Church. Fr. Paul Verghese Definition and Scope This paper does not presume to deal with all aspects of this,
More information18. The Vatican II sect vs. the Catholic Church on partaking in non-catholic worship
18. The Vatican II sect vs. the Catholic Church on partaking in non-catholic worship 234 Pope Pius XI, Mortalium Animos (# 10), Jan. 6, 1928: this Apostolic See has never allowed its subjects to take part
More informationMINUTES OF ASSEMBLY V
MINUTES OF ASSEMBLY V The Assembly of Canonical Orthodox Bishops of the United States of America convened its fifth annual meeting September 16-18, 2014 in Dallas, Texas at the Grand Hyatt Hotel at the
More informationThe Church. Communion. Comm. Union
The Church Comm Communion Union ECCLESIOLOGY Chapter 4: The Church formed through Word and Sacrament Word of God = a person: Jesus Christ = full, entire Good News Is mediated to us by the Holy Spirit Is
More informationRCIA Significant Moments from the Past Session 25
RCIA Significant Moments from the Past Session 25 The Church will receive its perfection only in the glory of heaven, at the time of Christ s glorious return. Until that day, the Church progresses on her
More informationThe Catholic Orthodox Dialogue: A Catholic Ecumenical and Ecclesiological Perspective
653878TDR0010.1177/0012580616653878The Downside ReviewNichols research-article2016 Article The Catholic Orthodox Dialogue: A Catholic Ecumenical and Ecclesiological Perspective The Downside Review 2016,
More informationThe Orthodox Church in Eastern Europe in the Twentieth Century
The Orthodox Church in Eastern Europe in the Twentieth Century Bearbeitet von Christine Chaillot 1. Auflage 2011. Taschenbuch. XVIII, 464 S. Paperback ISBN 978 3 0343 0709 3 Format (B x L): 15 x 22,5 cm
More informationThe problem of unity of the Church. Workshop Ekklesiologie ökumenisch. Berlin, June 10-13, 2010
The problem of unity of the Church Archimandrite Dr Cyril Hovorun Workshop Ekklesiologie ökumenisch Berlin, June 10-13, 2010 Among the major ecclesiological problems on the modern agenda I would stress
More informationA STATEMENT OF PRINCIPLES IN A TIME OF CRISIS. The Church
A STATEMENT OF PRINCIPLES IN A TIME OF CRISIS Priests of the Society of St. Pius V present the principles which are the basis for their work The Church 1. The changes following the Second Vatican Council
More informationEcumenical Patriarch Bartholomew addresses the Gathering (Synaxis) of the Heads of Orthodox Churches
Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew addresses the Gathering (Synaxis) of the Heads of Orthodox Churches Istanbul, Turkey 10/10/2008 His All Holiness Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew addressed the leaders
More informationCan a Pope and a Patriarch Lead us towards Greater Unity?
John George Huber Can a Pope and a Patriarch Lead us towards Greater Unity? Ecumenism is not static, but it is always in a dynamic change as the different actors vary and individuals dialogue with others.
More informationREFORMATION Sunday: Moving beyond the fifth centenary. Holy Trinity Parish October 29, 2017 John Borelli
REFORMATION Sunday: Moving beyond the fifth centenary Holy Trinity Parish October 29, 2017 John Borelli REFORMATION Sunday: Moving beyond the fifth centenary FIFTH CENTENARY October 31, 2017 Common Commemoration
More informationWhat Do We Make of the Western Rite?
What Do We Make of the Western Rite? When I first stepped into a Western Rite parish, I nearly walked out in the middle of the service. What is this? It is so western! This can t be Orthodox These were
More informationUOCC Delegation to Ukraine KYIV, UKRAINE On February 19, 2015, the Ukrainian Orthodox Church of
UOCC Delegation to Ukraine KYIV, UKRAINE On February 19, 2015, the Ukrainian Orthodox Church of Canada delegation continued its visitation to Kyiv, The delegation of the UOCC, joined by the UOC of the
More informationPapism, the Hagiorite Fathers, and the Aftermath of the Balamand Union 1
Papism, the Hagiorite Fathers, and the Aftermath of the Balamand Union 1 [Translated from the Greek by Patrick G. Barker] I Fifteen years ago, because of the impending establishment of diplomatic relations
More informationCourse Syllabus TRH2452H Modern Orthodox Theology (15th to 21st c) Trinity College Toronto School of Theology May - June (Summer) 2016
Instructor Information Course Syllabus TRH2452H Modern Orthodox Theology (15th to 21st c) Trinity College Toronto School of Theology May - June (Summer) 2016 Instructor: Dr Paul Ladouceur Office Location:
More informationThe Trinity The Pontifical College Josephinum Master of Arts in Pastoral Studies Deacon John Fulton, PhD
Introduction The Trinity The Pontifical College Josephinum Master of Arts in Pastoral Studies Deacon John Fulton, PhD Belief in the Triune God Father, Son, and Holy Spirit is the essence of Christian belief.
More informationTEOLOGIA. Dr. Iustin Popovici, The Canonic Law of the Romanian Orthodox Church...
Dr. Iustin Popovici, The Canonic Law of the Romanian Orthodox Church in force and its springs. Critical analysis based on the Holy Canons (Dreptul Canonic al Bisericii Ortodoxe Române în vigoare și izvoarele
More informationAntiochian Orthodox Christian Archdiocese of North America 52 nd Convention Boston, Massachusetts July 19-26, 2015
Antiochian Orthodox Christian Archdiocese of North America 52 nd Convention Boston, Massachusetts July 19-26, 2015 Department of Inter-Orthodox and Inter-Faith Relations Very Rev. Olof H. Scott, Chair
More informationRunning head: NICENE CHRISTIANITY 1
Running head: NICENE CHRISTIANITY 1 Nicene Christianity Brandon Vera BIBL 111-02 February 5, 2014 Prof. Robert Hill NICENE CHRISTIANITY 2 Nicene Christianity To deem that the ecumenical councils were merely
More informationA Study in Pursuit of Reconciliation within the Body and Bride of Christ
A Study in Pursuit of Reconciliation within the Body and Bride of Christ And your ancient ruins shall be rebuilt; you shall raise up the foundations of many generations; you shall be called the repairer
More information