Kabani (1994) Vanity Fair ignored any of the important debate within Islam about the rights of women. It distorted every sentence I had uttered the

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Kabani (1994) Vanity Fair ignored any of the important debate within Islam about the rights of women. It distorted every sentence I had uttered the"

Mervyn Casey
5 years ago
Views:

1 Paul Baker

2 Kabani (1994) Vanity Fair ignored any of the important debate within Islam about the rights of women. It distorted every sentence I had uttered the whole Western debate about Muslim women is a dishonest one Al-Hejin (2009) BBC News tends to focus on dress (the veil or hijab) or restrictions of women s rights in its reporting of Muslim women, and focuses on stories from only 8 out of 47 countries which have proportions of Muslims.

3 150 million words of British news Broadsheets: The Business, The Guardian, The Independent & Independent on Sunday, The Observer, The Times & Sunday Times, Daily Telegraph & Sunday Telegraph Tabloids: The Daily Express & Sunday Express, The Daily Mail & Mail on Sunday, Daily Mirror & Sunday Mirror, The People, Daily Star & Sunday Star, The Sun & News of the World

4 Alah OR Allah OR ayatolah OR burka! OR burqa! OR chador! OR fatwa! OR hejab! OR imam! OR islam! OR Koran OR Mecca OR Medina OR Mohammedan! OR Moslem! OR Muslim! OR mosque OR mufti! OR mujaheddin! OR mujahedin! OR mullah! OR muslim! OR Prophet Mohammed OR Q'uran OR rupoush OR rupush OR sharia OR shari'a OR shia! OR shi-ite! OR Shi'ite! OR sunni! OR the Prophet OR wahabi OR yashmak! AND NOT Islamabad AND NOT shiatsu AND NOT sunnily

R1 collocate of Frequency Muslim 1 community 6652 2 world 5081 3 council 3728 4 women 3325

5 R1 collocate of Frequency Muslim 1 community world council women leaders countries cleric country men communities 1646

7 wearing the full veil was bound to make better, positive relations between the two communities more difficult Jack Straw, The Lancashire Evening Telegraph

8 Category The veil Identity words (age, gender and relationships) Reporting and feeling Locations Freedom Oppression Law and order Religion Others Collocates wear, veils, veil, wearing, remove, worn, hijab, full, Straw, cover, Jack, Niqab, faces, face, headscarves, veiled, Straw s, dress, covering, head, headscarf, traditional, burkas, burka, wore, dressed, covered, veiling, burqa, burkha young, men, children, women, people, girls, old, generation, husbands, marry said, saying, feel, asked, call, told, asking, comments, say, ask, talk, revealed, believe, suggested, called, calling, urged, prefer, hope, know, wants, claimed, speak, question, warned, understand British, Britain, country, world, London, English, western, Bosnian, constituency, society, Blackburn, France, Europe, street, Serb, town, French, Arab, community rights, allowed, forced, ban, issue, choose, debate, power, support, help, free, allow, row, required, banned, encourage, campaign, choice, freedom, rape, abuse, attacks, oppressed, oppression, raping, raped, fear, honor, fearful, attacked, bodies, abused, killed, spat, torture law, police, courts, laws, accused Islamic, religious, Sharia, devout, Mosques, extremists get, go, stop, way, role, work, educated, given, lives, living, growing, release, separation, give, good, fact, consequences, make, held, life, working, film, live

9 3,482 concordance lines of Muslim women examined. 1) choosing to wear the veil (or similar terms) 2) being forced to wear the veil 3) demanding to wear the veil. 4) Cases where the veil was described as a right. CHOOSE to WEAR the FORCE to WEAR the RIGHT to WEAR the INSIST on WEAR the DEMAND to WEAR the

10 Forced to wear it Right to wear it Choosing to wear it Demanding to wear it Times Telegraph Sun Mail Express Star Mirror Guardian/Observer Independent Business Total

11 Her fight for the right to wear the veil in class may have divided politicians but there was little support for the teaching assistant Aishah Azmi yesterday among parents at her school in Dewsbury, West Yorkshire. Muslims and non-muslims alike challenged Ms Azmi's demands to wear the veil in class. (The Independent, October 17 th, 2006) stroppy, confrontational battleaxe (The News of The World October 22 nd, 2006) Specialist employment lawyers warned last night that the classroom rebel's vow to go to Brussels would mean a taxpayer-funded bonanza for lawyers while the case took years to rumble through the legal system. (The Express, October 20 th, 2006)

12 Term burqa niqab hijab veil jilbab headscarf Adjectival collocates all-enveloping, all-covering, tent-like, all-encompassing, full-length, obligatory, (not) welcome, full, compulsory, unnecessary, wrong, traditional, pale, black, white, blue, Afghan, Muslim (not) desirable, full, controversial, black, Muslim full-length, obligatory, contrary, compulsory, full, grey, traditional, correct, blue, black, bad, green, special, Muslim, white full, full-length, all-enveloping, all-encompassing, full-body, obligatory, discreet, facial, Muslim, compulsory, divisive, black, thin, Islamic, traditional, blue, white, heavy, different, long, religious full-length, all-embracing, flowing, loose, full, traditional, black, Islamic, Muslim Islamic-style, floral, traditional, obligatory, coloured, pink, black, Islamic, Muslim, white, green, essential, red, blue, simple, Arab, important, small, religious, own

13 The Express (November 9 th, 2007) Summary of case 88 word quote from salon owner 14 word quote from Bushra Noah: Bushra, who has been rejected for 25 hairdressing jobs, insisted: Wearing a headscarf is very important in my religion. I could have fitted in.

14 Right after that, the misery began. Khalid tried to control her and force her to wear the hijab, the headscarf worn by devout Muslim women. (The Observer, April 23 rd, 2006) Muslim women are being forced to cover up in a number of countries as part of a political backlash against growing freedoms (The Guardian, October 13 th, 2006) Wearing a headscarf is a symbol of women's subjugation and those apologists, be they Muslims or so-called liberals, who want us to believe that Muslim women are given a choice of wearing the headscarf forget about the very strong sense of tradition coupled with intense intimidation by male relatives. (The Independent, December 30 th, 2003, letters)

15 Insult to men: It seems to me that the real offence conveyed by the wearing of the full veil by Muslim women lies in the implication that no man can look on any woman without being consumed by unholy lust. The Times (August 30 th, 2005) Health: A growing number of Muslim women who wear the head-to-toe veil are being treated for rickets. The Express (October 6 th, 2006)

16 Threatens British way of life: Anyone sincerely wishing to integrate into the British way of life would never wear such an alien and threatening outfit The Express (July 19 th, 2007) A cover for terrorism: This was the moment two armed robbers disguised as Muslim women in burkas were about to pounce. (The Mirror, June 3 rd, 2002)

17 elaborately-veiled Muslim women gliding along New Bond Street in London The Mail (August 9 th, 2008) waddling around a 21st-century supermarket (The Mail November 10 th 2005) sailing along The Guardian (January 22 nd, 2004)

18 eyes peeping from yards of leg-tangling, windblown drapery Maybe, inside all that dark material, they are brimming with selfesteem The Guardian (January 22 nd, 2004) I love soft furnishings, I tell my laughing flatmates. But that doesn't mean I want to be one medieval costume fabric prisons (The Mail November 10 th 2005)

19 We let shroud-swishing zombies flout OUR standards of freedom and tolerance every day. The Sun (June 24 th 2009) Julie Birchill the living shroud... Who wants to wake from an operation to see a swaddled figure in the next bed? The Express (September 8 th, 2006) How long before non-muslim women are compelled to dress like bats to enter certain parts of certain British cities? The Mail on Sunday (July 16 th, 2006) Peter Hitchens

Even if hijab-wearing is a genuine choice, does that make it obligatory for us to

What we would not ban, we do not have to condone.

niqab to veil their faces, that is their right.

20 Even if hijab-wearing is a genuine choice, does that make it obligatory for us to respect it? Any more than hijab-wearers respect women who wear shamefully little? What we would not ban, we do not have to condone. The Guardian (January 22 nd, 2004) If Muslim women in Lancashire want to use the niqab to veil their faces, that is their right. But their MP is entitled to voice his concern that wearing it restricts his constituents' full participation in British society. The Observer (October 8 th, 2006)

21 It is Labour that allows misguided Muslim women to think it is OK for them to wear a veil at school or, even more ludicrously, in court. (The Sun, July 3 rd, 2007). As we sleepwalk into a New Labour police state, fashion fascist Jack Straw's denunciation of the right of Muslim women to wear the veil is racist and must be challenged. (The Express, October 11 th, 2007, letters.)

22 Negative positions range from accepting the right to wear the veil (but not respecting the wearer) to expressions of mocking hatred and rage. Contradictory discourses in left-leaning press (women s rights?) Veil presented as an issue and not resolved: My week is over. I am confused. I saw my burqa as a prison imposed by the frailties of men. But I also hated the judgmental stares and the hostility. The week was a strange window into a different culture, but I have no answers. (Daily Mail November 10 th, 2005)

Corpus linguistics Islam in the UK Press. Professor Tony McEnery Lancaster Univeristy

Corpus linguistics Islam in the UK Press Professor Tony McEnery Lancaster Univeristy Corpus Linguistics An empirical form of analysis based on using collections of very large, naturally occurring language