THE ADMINISTRATIVE FUNCTIONING OF THE SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST CHURCH - A CATALYST FOR CHANGE. Calvin William Plaatjes

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "THE ADMINISTRATIVE FUNCTIONING OF THE SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST CHURCH - A CATALYST FOR CHANGE. Calvin William Plaatjes"

Anis Miller
6 years ago
Views:

THE ADMINISTRATIVE FUNCTIONING OF THE SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST CHURCH IN SOUTH AFRICA AND THE DISILLUSIONMENT AND ALIENATION OF ITS MEMBERS - A CATALYST FOR

1 THE ADMINISTRATIVE FUNCTIONING OF THE SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST CHURCH IN SOUTH AFRICA AND THE DISILLUSIONMENT AND ALIENATION OF ITS MEMBERS - A CATALYST FOR CHANGE by Calvin William Plaatjes Dissertation presented for the Degree of Doctor oftheology at the University ofstellenbosch Promoter: ProfH J Hendriks March 2007

2 DECLARATION I, the undersigned, hereby declare that the work contained in this dissertation is my own original work and in its entirety or in part submitted it at any university for a degree. Signature: _.<.-~~I13'~~t5:~-- Date: /3,03. rtj7

3 ABSTRACT This dissertation addresses the functioning of the Seventh-day Adventist Church in South Africa and the disillusionment and alienation of its members. Its aim is to uncover what the key factors are in the administrative functioning that has contributed to the disillusionment and alienation ofthe rank and file from the administration of the church. It gives particular attention to five aspects of administration: administrative authority, leadership, power, transition, and organizational structures. The objectives of the study are multifaceted. It wants to sensitize and make the Conference and Union administrations aware ofthe issues that separate them from the rank and file in the church, and how that the present challenges can be solved on a broad consultative basis. Furthermore, the study wants to make recommendations as to how broader representation can be established. Importantly, the study wishes to help the SDA Church administration to maintain a healthy balance between the church as institution and the church as organism. The study is basically exploratory as it seeks to explore the social phenomenon between the administrative functioning and the grassroots ofthe church for the reason ofgaining insight as well as to explain the reason for its existence. It is also hermeneutical in nature as it seeks to establish a proper understanding of the interrelatedness between the administrative functioning and the laity in the church. Empirical enquiry is an important aspect of the study as it employs structured interviews with church boards and survey questionnaires to pastors in order to establish quantitative and qualitative aspects ofthe study. The study made use of a practical-theological methodology. The methodology is a hermeneutical sensitive and correlational dialogue that brings different theological parameters into dialogue with the realities of practice ofministry and the world. Chapter one introduces the study. It outlines the various dimensions ofthe study. Chapters two and three are historical. It deals with the present reality and the identity ofthe church using literary sources. Chapter five deals with the empirical research and gives a description ofthe views of ministers and the church boards concerning the five aspects of administration of the church, which has been researched. Chapters four and six deals with the theoretical-theological aspects ofthe study. Chapter four deals with the tension that exists between the church as institution and the church as organism. Chapter six is a theological evaluation that seeks the will ofgod or His guidance in terms ofthe problem which the church faces. Chapter six describes the way forward by making recommendations and gives some strategies that can be used to realize the goals ofthe study and the church. ii

4 OPSOMMING Die verhandeling ondersoek die denominasionele etos en die administratiewe strukture van die Sewendedag Adventistekerk in Suid-Afrika. Die studie toon aan dat daar ontnugtering en vervreemding by die gewone lede van die kerk ten opsigte van die administratiewe strukture bestaan. Dit gee aandag aan vyfaspekte van administrasie: administratiewe gesag, leierskap, mag, oorgang en organisatoriese strukture. Die doelstellings van die studie is veelvoudig. Dit is poog om die Konferensies en die Unie-administrasies sensitief te maak van die strydpunte wat hulle verwyder van die gewone mense in die kerk. Dit stel voor dat die huidige uitdagings opgelos kan word deur middel van 'n bree konsultatiewe proses. Verder maak die studie aanbevelings oor hoe wyer verteenwoordiging in administratiewe strukture bereik kan word. Die studie wi! die SDA-kerk administrasie van hulp wees om 'n gesonde balans te handhaaf tussen die kerk as organisasie en die kerk as organisme. Die studie is verkennend en hermeneuties van aard. Oit wou vasstel wat die mening van die werkers (predikante) en kerkrade is oordie administratiewe strukture en leierskap in die kerk. Teneindedit vas te stel is 'n omvattende empiriese ondersoek gedoen deur gestruktureerde onderhoude met kerkrade oor die hele land te voeren deur vraelyste aan 'nverteenwoordigende steekproefpredikante te stuur. Die navorsing het gebruik gemaak van 'n prakties-teologiese metodologie. Die metodologie is 'n hermeneuties sensitiewe en korrelatiewe dialoog wat verskillende teologiese parameters in dialoog met die realiteite van die bedieningspraktyk en wereld bring. Hoofstuk een is inleidend en gee 'n oorsig oor die navorsingsontwerp. Hoofstukke twee en drie is histories. Dit behandel die huidige realiteit en die identiteit van die kerk deur gebruik te maak van literere bronne. Hoofstuk vyf handel oor die empiriese ondersoek en gee 'n beskrywing van die menings van predikante en kerkrade oor die vyf aspekte van die administrasie van die kerk wat ondersoek is. Hoofstukke vier en ses handel oar die teoreties- teologiese aspekte van die studie. Vier bespreek die spanning wat altyd bestaan tussen die kerk as organisasie en die kerk as organisme. Ses is 'n teologiese evaluering wat soek na die wi! of leiding van God in terme van die probleem waarmee die kerk worstel. Die laaste hoofstuk maak voorstelle oor die pad vorentoe en stel strategiee voor wat gebruik kan word om doelstellings te bereik. iii

5 DEDICATION This work is dedicated to my study leader Jurgens Hendriks, for his inspiring leadership, for being human, and for being an Incarnational Servant Leader and mentor in a variety ofways

6 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS A sincere word of appreciation and thanks to my wife Millicent. Her support, encouragement and understanding never failed. Our children Clinton and Candice, Elton and Mandy and Lee-Anne deserve special mention for their encouragement and support and for patiently waiting for me to complete my studies. A word ofthanks to Helderberg College for allowing me a Sabbatical and for their financial support. A word ofgratitude is also extended to those conference administrations for allowing me to interview their church boards and the church boards that allowed me to interview them. Appreciation to all pastors who willingly returned their survey forms. Appreciation must also be extended to the Human Sciences Research Council for their generous financial support that assisted towards the completion ofthis study. I purposefully dedicate this work to my mentor and study leader professor H J Hendriks whose guidance and help was of incalculable and inestimable value. I am indebted to him for his encouragement and understanding, but most of all for being a servant leader. His guidance has always been most inspiring, yet he allowed me the freedom to develop my own thinking and to do so in a critical way. Last but not least, I will always be eternally grateful to God who has been gracious and faithful to me. that I am and ever hope to be lowe to His grace. All

7 REVISIONING THE DENOMINATIONAL ETHOS AND ADMINISTRATIVE STRUCTURES OF THE SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST CHURCH IN SOUTH AFRICA TABLE OF CONTENTS DECLARATION / i ABSTRACT / ii OPSOMMING / iii ILLUSTRATIONS, FIGURES & TABLES / xi TERMINOLOGY / xiii ABBREVIATIONS / xiv LINES OF COMMUNICATION AND APPEAL / xv CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Introduction The Research problem Motivation for this study Research desigil,., '..",III ' ".',, Guiding hypothesis,..,,,,..,, Study hypothesis,..,,,..,,..,,, Study objectives ", ",, 6 1,4.3 Research methodology ".".." "." "., " ".,..,,,..,..,, Interviews..".."..""""..,..,..,..,..",..",."..,...,..,..,..""",.. ""..,.."..".."",.."..,..,.. ""..",..,...,..",.. ~ Mailed questionnaires... 1,." _ 11.11, ",.",." """'III" II 11111It ' " Basic concepts Population Sampling frame Pilot study 15 '1 d C tho h Plot stu y,or IS researc... l' OperatlOna lzatlon Practical theological perspective 16 1'.4:9 Practical theology methodology 17

8 4.6.4 The Human Relations theory System theory The nature ofsystems theory Institutionalization The negative side ofinstitutionalization Formalism Rigidness and unadaptableness Selfishness Power Institutionalism Judaism Roman Catholicism Reformation Churches Form and structure Curbing institutionalism Evaluating the Church as Institution Form follows function The church as organism The church as the "Body ofchrist" "Body ofchrist" metaphor in Romans & I Corinthians Body and "Head" metaphors in Ephesians and Colossians The Seventh-Day Adventist Church and its view ofthe Church as Institute and Organism The Church as a Bride The Church as a Temple The Church as the People ofgod The Church as a Body 85 CHAPTER 5 RESEARCH RESULTS 5.1 Introduction The question under view Methodology Research procedures Pilot studies Pastoral surveys Structured interviews Method ofinterviews Study results - structured interviews 90 vii

9 5.3.1 Administrative authority Administrative authority - concentrated 9I Administrative authority - dispersed Leadership Leadership - people oriented Leadership - structure oriented Power Power - vested in top positions Power - shared with "grassroots" Transition Transition - administration open to change Transition - administration maintains status quo Organizational structures Organizational structure - top down Organizational structure - participatory 10I Congregations views ofthe Conferences and Union Congregation's view ofthe Conference Congregations view ofthe Union Pastoral surveys Pastoral surveys - conference administration accumulative results Administrative authority Leadership Power Transition Organizational structures Results - individual basis Cape Conference pastors Administrative authority Leadership Power Transition Organizational structures Trans-Orange Conference pastors Administrative authority Leadership Power Transition Organizational structures 126 viii

10 5.5.3 Southern Hope Conference pastors Administrative authority Leadership Power Transition Organizational structures Results ofkwazulu Natal Free-State and Transvaal Conference pastors Pastoral Surveys - Union level ofadministration Administrative authority Leadership Power Transition Organizational structures Pastoral surveys - The average accumulative responses ofpastors concerning the Conference and Union administration Contemporary Adventism in South Africa 144 CHAPTER 6 THEOLOGICAL EVALUATION 6.1 Introduction Methodology Church organization building The General Conference Reorganization 190 I Historical theological basis for organization A Functional ecclesiology Ecclesiological discussions Conference with World Council ofchurches Walter Douglas - nature and function ofthe church Richard Rice - "People ofgod" and "Body ofchrist" Raoul Dederen - nature and scope ofthe church, its mission and government Hierarchical church structure Theological evaluation ofthe five areas ofadministration Leadership The Old Testament and servant leadership New Testament and servant leadership - authority and power Christ example ofleadership Jesus way to servanthood 164 ix

11 6.7.2 Organizational structures The Problems ofwineskins Church structure to reflect its nature Structure in the early church Administration and organization - Biblical examples Organizational principles Church organization - authority and power Administrative authority and power Power in the Lord's Prayer Authority in thenew Testament church The New Testament and hierarchical structures Organizational structures above the local church structure Paul and authority Transition Jesus and change The New Testament church in transition Transition themes in the Bible 188 CHAPTER 7 RECOMMENDATIONS 7.1 Introduction Administrative authority Recommendations - Administrative authority Leadership '" 202 7A Power '" Transition Organizational Structure Merger Issues 214 APPENDIX A - Format ofstructured interviews 217 APPENDIX B - Formatof pastoral surveys 221 APPENDIX C - SAU Progress report to the special session APPENDIX D - Facsimile - TOC withdrawal ofpermission to conduct structured interviews 232 BIBLIOGRAPHY.233 x

12 ILLUSTRATIONS, FIGURES AND TABLES Chapter 1 Figure 1 - Moberg's five stages life cycle ofa church 3 Table 1 - Population table ofpastors and churches 12 Table 2 - Sampling frame/representative frame 13 Table 3 - Sample ofchurch boards chosen to be interviewed 14 Chapter 2 Table 4 - Average number ofservice points 29 Figure 2 - Tithe & offeringenvelope.40 Chapter 5 Table 5 - Response persentage ofpastors 113 Structured Interview Illustration 1 - Administrative authority is concentrated in a few, who act on behalfofthe majority 91 Illustration 2 - Administrative authority is dispersed; the Conference solicits inputand assistance from congregation 92 Illustration 3 - The leadership is people orientated; the wishes and feelings ofmembers come first 93 Illustration 4 - The leadership is structure orientated; the organization and its functions take first preference 94 Illustration 5 - Power in the organization is vested in those in the top positions ofthe Conference 96 Illustration 6 - Power is shared with those at "grassroots" level ofthe church 97 Illustration 7 - The administration is always open to change and promotes innovation for change 98 Illustration 8 - The administration sees change as a threat and therefore, maintains the status quo 99 Illustration 9 - The organizational structures operate on a top down relationship. The bottom ofthe organization is expected to carry out what is passed down to them.1 00 Illustration 10 - The organizational structure operates on a participatory basis; the leadership atthe top sees those at "grassroots" as part ofthe administrative process 101 Illustration II - Question Does the Conference contribute to the effectiveness ofyour church? 102 Illustration 12 - Question Is theconference leadership visible enough atgrassroots level ofthe church? 103 Illustration 13 - Question Would you describe the Conference as bureaucratic, insisting on "red tape"? 104 Illustration 14 - Question Do you think that the Conference serves the church in an enabling way? 105 Illustration 15 - Question Does the Conference serve as an effective resource centre? 106 Illustration 16 - Question Does the Union contribute to the effectiveness ofyour church? 108 Illustration 17 - Question Is the Union leadership visible enough at grassroots level ofthe church? Illustration 18 - Question Would you describe the Union as bureaucratic, insisting on "red tape"? xi

100

101

102

103

104

105

106

107

108

109

110

111

112

113

114

115

116

117

118

119

120

121

122

123

124

125

126

127

128

129

130

131

132

133

134

135

136

137

138

139

140

141

142

143

144

145

146

147

148

149

150

151

152

153

154

155

156

157

158

159

160

161

162

163

164

165

166

167

168

169

170

171

172

173

174

175

176

177

178

179

180

181

182

183

184

185

186

187

188

189

190

191

192

193

194

195

196

197

198

199

200

201

202

203

204

205

206

207

208

209

210

211

212

213

214

215

216

217

218

219

220

221

222

223

224

225

226

227

228

229

230

231

232

233

234

235

236

237

238

239

240

241

242

243

244

245

246

247

248

249

250

251

252

253

254

255

THE MISSIONAL LIFE OF CONGREGATIONS OF THE SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST CHURCH IN THE FREE STATE

THE MISSIONAL LIFE OF CONGREGATIONS OF THE SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST CHURCH IN THE FREE STATE by Marthinus Theunis Steyn Venter 2011150949 Dissertation presented as requirement for the degree Doctor Philosophiae,