Incompatibilism (1) Anti Free Will Arguments

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Incompatibilism (1) Anti Free Will Arguments"

Transcription

1 Determinism and Free Will (4) Incompatibilism (1) Anti Free Will Arguments Incompatibilism is the view that a deterministic universe is completely at odds with the notion that persons have a free will. The hard determinists deny that any free will exists, and pessimistic incompatibilists (hard, hard indeterminists) deny both that the universe is determined and that free will exists. Among academic philosophers a minority (12%) hold this view: as against biologists/experimental psychologists/neuroscientists (14%) which proves nothing they may well be right in their view Hard Determinists Hume s arguments that Determinism can be reconciled with Free Will were controversial from the moment that they were written. Baron d Holbach (1770) Man, in running over, frequently without his own knowledge, often in despite of himself, the route which Nature has marked out for him, resembles a swimmer who is obliged to follow the current that carries him along; he believes himself a free agent, because he sometimes consents, sometimes does not consent, to glide with the stream; which, notwithstanding, always hurries him forward; he believes himself the master of his condition, because he is obliged to use his arms under the fear of sinking. It is still important to deal with the strong intuitive, psychological impression that we experience that we do have some control over the choices we make. For d Holbach we are a swimmers in a river (Determinism); we swim against the current for some time, until we tire; and then we will be carried downstream by the current. We are simply deluding ourselves. Other possible candidates for this false consciousness include Random behaviour Luck Bringing the question up to date, in 1998 a satirical film called The Truman Show was released. It was based on the idea that the cast were members of a long-running (13 years) reality TV show living in a gigantic film set. They believe that they are living quite normal lives but in fact the situations in which they find themselves are contrived and their lives are controlled, unknown to them, by the script writers of the show. Perhaps we are in that position. I am exaggerating the point but not attempting to trivialise it Hard Determinism is a wellestablished position to be taken seriously.

2 A Modern Hard Determinist Argument - The Consequence Argument - Peter van Inwagen 1983 If determinism is true, then our acts are the consequences of the laws of nature and events in the remote past. But it is not up to us what went on before we were born, and neither is it up to us what the laws of nature are. Therefore, the consequences of those things (including our present acts) are not up to us. Fatalism restated. Confirmation from Neuroscience? The Libet Experiments The field of neuroscience, studying - and most importantly measuring to gain hard facts mental activity within the brain is a rapidly developing field. It is at relatively early phase of development (the low foot hills of a mountain range) but its findings are extremely important and must be taken seriously The motor cortex is the region of the brain involved in the planning, control, and execution of voluntary movements, in particular, instructions for muscular movements. Since 1964 it has been known that, prior to any muscular activity there is a rise of electrical activity in the motor cortex of the brain which can be measured. This is known as Bereitschaftpotential (or Type II readiness potential) Benjamin Libet ( ) was an American pioneering neuroscientist/experimental psychologist who in 1983 began a series of experiments to test neural activity of voluntary actions. Methods (from Internet) Researchers carrying out Libet s procedure would ask each participant to sit at a desk in front of the oscilloscope timer. They would affix the EEG electrodes to the participant s scalp, and would then instruct the subject to carry out some small, simple motor activity, such as pressing a button, or flexing a finger or wrist, within a certain time frame. No limits were placed on the number of times the subject could perform the action within this period. Libet's experiment: 0 repose 1 (-500 ms) EEG measures Readiness potential 2 (-200 ms) Person notes the position of the dot when decides 3 ( 0 ms) Act

3 During the experiment, the subject would be asked to note the position of the dot on the oscilloscope timer when "he/she was first aware of the wish or urge to act" (control tests with Libet's equipment demonstrated a comfortable margin of error of only -50 milliseconds). Pressing the button also recorded the position of the dot on the oscillator, this time electronically. By comparing the marked time of the button's pushing and the subject's conscious decision to act, researchers were able to calculate the total time of the trial from the subject's initial volition through to the resultant action. On average, approximately two hundred milliseconds elapsed between the first appearance of conscious will to press the button and the act of pressing it. Researchers also analyzed EEG recordings for each trial with respect to the timing of the action. It was noted that brain activity involved in the initiation of the action, primarily centered in the secondary motor cortex, and occurred, on average, approximately five hundred milliseconds before the trial ended with the pushing of the button. Libet found that although conscious awareness of the decision preceded the subject's finger motion by only 200 milliseconds, the rise in the Type II readiness potential was clearly visible at about 550 milliseconds before the flex of the wrist. The subject showed unconscious activity to flex about 350 milliseconds before reporting conscious awareness of the decision to flex. Indeed an earlier slow and very slight rise in the readiness potential can be seen as early as 1.5 seconds before the action. In the early 1980's the results from LIbet experiments were enthusiastically adopted by Hard Determinist incompatibilists to show that human free will does not exist. The fact which cannot be denied that there is a rise in RP caused by unconscious thought (where does this come from?) prior to the agent becoming conscious of the decision undoubtedly strengthens the case.

4 Sam Harris Free Will (2012) Sam Harris is a leading neuroscientist, the most prominent hard determinist and critic of the concept of free will. He has a first degree in Philosophy from Stanford followed by a PhD in Neuroscience from UCLA. He makes considerable use of evidence from neuroscience, in particular Libet s work. The main argument in this book an Amazon best seller and available for 5.50 in e-book format - is as follows: He gives prominence to genetic factors in human behaviour. He gives prominence to the high level of neural activity at the unconscious level as shown by the Libet experiments and other later studies He comments on the unstructured, random nature of most of our conscious thought He uses the standard Hard Determinist argument of the fact that we are in a trail of causation of which we may not be aware at the conscious level Our psychological impression that we do have an element of control he puts down to Luck The misfortunes of life such as disorder, crime or being a murder victim be puts down to Bad Luck Harris says the idea of free will "cannot be mapped on to any conceivable reality" and is incoherent. Science "reveals you to be a biochemical puppet." People's thoughts and intentions "emerge from background causes of which we are unaware and over which we exert no conscious control." Every choice we make is made as a result of preceding causes. These choices we make are determined by those causes, and are therefore not really choices at all. Critical Response on Interpretation of the Libet Experiments Neuroscience is a rapidly developing area of study but it is at an early stage of development. Libet s study concerned the linkage between the motor cortex and external muscles. It is focused on an action a willed decision and a simple muscular action. The results surprised Libet back in 1983 (results published in 1985) but the experiments focused on an act of will; they did not zero in on idea formation but clearly demonstrated that this probably took place at an unconscious level. Many further studies are ongoing in this field they confirm that much neural activity concerned with idea formation which takes place in many areas of the brain operates at the unconscious level this in itself is neither surprising nor controversial. But as of now (2018), they do NOT amount to an agreed theory of the brain. Libet himself did not agree with the way his work was interpreted. His views are available on the website. See Extract from Benjamin Libet Mind Time, Harvard University Press 2004

5 Hard Hard Determinism The Impossibilists This school of thought can be thought of as a Radical Fringe Galen Strawson was born in 1952 and so is 66, the son of P. F. Strawson, who we came across in the outline of Compatibilism, and is presently the Professor of Philosophy at the University of Texas, Austin He takes a diametrically opposed view to his father and takes the position that Free Will is not possible on logical grounds. His position is based on what he terms the Basic Argument which he first proposed in 1984, which is outlined below 1. You do what you do, in any given situation, because of the way you are 2. To be ultimately responsible for what you do, you have to be ultimately responsible for the way you are at least in certain crucial mental respects. 3. But you cannot be ultimately responsible for the way you are in any respect at all. 4. So you cannot be ultimately responsible for what you do. What links these statements is the term Causa Sui which means caused by itself. In formal logic causa sui is invalid because it sets up a circular argument or a regress. On the other hand all selfinduced thoughts are causa sui by definition - they appear (note not caused?) by themselves I have put up an article written by Galen Strawson in 1993 on the website where he expands his view. You can judge it yourself. His view is a minority position. Derk Pereboom is Dutch, born in 1957and so 61. He was educated in the US. He is Professor of Philosophy at Cornell University in upper NY State He maintains that due to general facts about the nature of the universe which he derives from a Dutch philosopher of the 17 th Century, Baruch Spinoza, we lack the free will required for the aspect of moral responsibility at issue in the traditional debate. That is, whether our actions are deterministically or indeterministically caused, we will not have the control in action required for our deserving to be blamed or punished for immoral decisions, and to be praised or rewarded for those that are morally exemplary. Guess who judges? Again this is a minority position Saul Slimansky is much younger; he was Galen Strawson s research student at Oxford while reading for a D.Phil. He is currently Professor of Philosophy at the University of Haifa in Israel Illusionism is the position that illusion often has a large and positive role to play in the issue of free will. In arguing for the importance of illusion, I claim that we can see why it is useful, that it is a reality, and why by and large it ought to continue to be so. Illusory beliefs are in place concerning free will and moral responsibility, and the role they play is largely positive. Humanity is fortunately deceived on the free will issue, and this seems to be a condition of civilized morality and personal value Free Will and Illusion (2002) OUP Cop out time minority position

METAPHYSICS. The Problem of Free Will

METAPHYSICS. The Problem of Free Will METAPHYSICS The Problem of Free Will WHAT IS FREEDOM? surface freedom Being able to do what you want Being free to act, and choose, as you will BUT: what if what you will is not under your control? free

More information

Alfred Mele s Modest. Hard Determinism Compatibilism. Libertarianism. Soft Determinism. Hard Incompatibilism. Semicompatibilism.

Alfred Mele s Modest. Hard Determinism Compatibilism. Libertarianism. Soft Determinism. Hard Incompatibilism. Semicompatibilism. 336 Free Will: The Scandal in Philosophy Illusionism Determinism Hard Determinism Compatibilism Soft Determinism Hard Incompatibilism Impossibilism Valerian Model Soft Compatibilism Alfred Mele s Modest

More information

SUPPORT MATERIAL FOR 'DETERMINISM AND FREE WILL ' (UNIT 2 TOPIC 5)

SUPPORT MATERIAL FOR 'DETERMINISM AND FREE WILL ' (UNIT 2 TOPIC 5) SUPPORT MATERIAL FOR 'DETERMINISM AND FREE WILL ' (UNIT 2 TOPIC 5) Introduction We often say things like 'I couldn't resist buying those trainers'. In saying this, we presumably mean that the desire to

More information

Free Will. Christian Wüthrich The Nature of Reality

Free Will. Christian Wüthrich The Nature of Reality Free Will http://philosophy.ucsd.edu/faculty/wuthrich/ 14 The Nature of Reality Congratulations! Today is your day. You re off to Great Places! You re off and away! Oh, the Places You ll Go! From Dr. Seuss,

More information

Causation and Free Will

Causation and Free Will Causation and Free Will T L Hurst Revised: 17th August 2011 Abstract This paper looks at the main philosophic positions on free will. It suggests that the arguments for causal determinism being compatible

More information

Free Will. Christian Wüthrich Metaphysics Fall 2012

Free Will. Christian Wüthrich Metaphysics Fall 2012 Free Will http://philosophy.ucsd.edu/faculty/wuthrich/ 130 Metaphysics Fall 2012 Some introductory thoughts: The traditional problem of freedom and determinism The traditional problem of freedom and determinism

More information

A Coherent and Comprehensible Interpretation of Saul Smilansky s Dualism

A Coherent and Comprehensible Interpretation of Saul Smilansky s Dualism A Coherent and Comprehensible Interpretation of Saul Smilansky s Dualism Abstract Saul Smilansky s theory of free will and moral responsibility consists of two parts; dualism and illusionism. Dualism is

More information

The Mystery of Libertarianism

The Mystery of Libertarianism The Mystery of Libertarianism Conclusion So Far: Here are the three main questions we have asked so far: (1) Is Determinism True? Are our actions determined by our genes, our upbringing, the laws of physics

More information

Libet s Impossible Demand

Libet s Impossible Demand Neil Levy Libet s Impossible Demand Abstract: Libet s famous experiments, showing that apparently we become aware of our intention to act only after we have unconsciously formed it, have widely been taken

More information

The readiness potential was found to precede voluntary acts by about half a second

The readiness potential was found to precede voluntary acts by about half a second Volition and the readiness potential Gilberto Gomes Journal of Consciousness Studies, 6 (8-9), 1999, pp. 59-76. Current address(2006): Laboratory of Language and Cognition UENF, 28013-602 Campos, RJ, Brazil

More information

Comprehensive. Hard Determinism Compatibilism. Compatibilism. Soft Determinism. Hard Incompatibilism. Semicompatibilism. Illusionism.

Comprehensive. Hard Determinism Compatibilism. Compatibilism. Soft Determinism. Hard Incompatibilism. Semicompatibilism. Illusionism. 360 Free Will: The Scandal in Philosophy Illusionism Determinism Hard Determinism Compatibilism Soft Determinism Hard Incompatibilism Impossibilism Valerian Model Soft Compatibilism Comprehensive Compatibilism

More information

Free Will. Course packet

Free Will. Course packet Free Will PHGA 7457 Course packet Instructor: John Davenport Spring 2008 Fridays 2-4 PM Readings on Eres: 1. John Davenport, "Review of Fischer and Ravizza, Responsibility and Control," Faith and Philosophy,

More information

Think by Simon Blackburn. Chapter 3b Free Will

Think by Simon Blackburn. Chapter 3b Free Will Think by Simon Blackburn Chapter 3b Free Will Review of definitions Incompatibilists believe that that free will and determinism are not compatible. This means that you can not be both free and determined

More information

A Compatibilist Account of Free Will and Moral Responsibility

A Compatibilist Account of Free Will and Moral Responsibility A Compatibilist Account of Free Will and Moral Responsibility If Frankfurt is right, he has shown that moral responsibility is compatible with the denial of PAP, but he hasn t yet given us a detailed account

More information

Chapter Six Compatibilism: Mele, Alfred E. (2006). Free Will and Luck. Oxford University Press: Oxford.

Chapter Six Compatibilism: Mele, Alfred E. (2006). Free Will and Luck. Oxford University Press: Oxford. Chapter Six Compatibilism: Objections and Replies Mele, Alfred E. (2006). Free Will and Luck. Oxford University Press: Oxford. Overview Refuting Arguments Against Compatibilism Consequence Argument van

More information

In his pithy pamphlet Free Will, Sam Harris. Defining free will away EDDY NAHMIAS ISN T ASKING FOR THE IMPOSSIBLE. reviews/harris

In his pithy pamphlet Free Will, Sam Harris. Defining free will away EDDY NAHMIAS ISN T ASKING FOR THE IMPOSSIBLE. reviews/harris Defining free will away EDDY NAHMIAS ISN T ASKING FOR THE IMPOSSIBLE Free Will by Sam Harris (The Free Press),. /$. 110 In his pithy pamphlet Free Will, Sam Harris explains why he thinks free will is an

More information

7AAN2011 Ethics. Basic Information: Module Description: Teaching Arrangement. Assessment Methods and Deadlines. Academic Year 2016/17 Semester 1

7AAN2011 Ethics. Basic Information: Module Description: Teaching Arrangement. Assessment Methods and Deadlines. Academic Year 2016/17 Semester 1 7AAN2011 Ethics Academic Year 2016/17 Semester 1 Basic Information: Credits: 20 Module Tutor: Dr Nadine Elzein (nadine.elzein@kcl.ac.uk) Office: 703; tel. ex. 2383 Consultation hours this term: TBA Seminar

More information

FREE WILL Galen Strawson

FREE WILL Galen Strawson Abstract FREE WILL Galen Strawson Free will is the conventional name of a topic that is best discussed without reference to the will. It is a topic in metaphysics and ethics as much as in the philosophy

More information

DOES NEUROSCIENCE UNDERMINE RESPONSIBILITY?

DOES NEUROSCIENCE UNDERMINE RESPONSIBILITY? DOES NEUROSCIENCE UNDERMINE RESPONSIBILITY? Walter Sinnott-Armstrong Duke University COMMON CLAIMS Many smart people see neuroscience as a threat to free will and responsibility. Other smart people think

More information

Kane is Not Able: A Reply to Vicens Self-Forming Actions and Conflicts of Intention

Kane is Not Able: A Reply to Vicens Self-Forming Actions and Conflicts of Intention Kane is Not Able: A Reply to Vicens Self-Forming Actions and Conflicts of Intention Gregg D Caruso SUNY Corning Robert Kane s event-causal libertarianism proposes a naturalized account of libertarian free

More information

Final Paper. May 13, 2015

Final Paper. May 13, 2015 24.221 Final Paper May 13, 2015 Determinism states the following: given the state of the universe at time t 0, denoted S 0, and the conjunction of the laws of nature, L, the state of the universe S at

More information

Free Will and Determinism

Free Will and Determinism Free Will and Determinism Learning objectives: To understand: - The link between free will and moral responsibility The ethical theories of hard determinism, libertarianism and soft determinism or compatilbilism

More information

Can Neuroscience Comment on Whether We Have Moral Responsibility?

Can Neuroscience Comment on Whether We Have Moral Responsibility? Can Neuroscience Comment on Whether We Have Moral Responsibility? Luke Arend Bethel University ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to acknowledge E.R.R.B., J.A., and C.P. for providing comments and conversation

More information

Brain Determinism and Free Will

Brain Determinism and Free Will Etica & Politica / Ethics & Politics, XI, 2009, 2, pp. 57 67 Brain Determinism and Free Will Sergio Filippo Magni Università di Pavia Dipartimento di Filosofia filippo.magni@unipv.it ABSTRACT The article

More information

Syllabus PHI 3501: FREE WILL Spring 2018 COURSE DESCRIPTION

Syllabus PHI 3501: FREE WILL Spring 2018 COURSE DESCRIPTION 01/13 Syllabus Spring 2018 Instructor: Dr. Meeting time: MWF, 4th period (10:40-11:30) Location: 120 Pugh Hall Office: 318 Griffin-Floyd Hall Office Hours: W, 5-6th period (11:45-1:40) F, 5th period (11:45-12:35)

More information

Ending The Scandal. Hard Determinism Compatibilism. Soft Determinism. Hard Incompatibilism. Semicompatibilism. Illusionism.

Ending The Scandal. Hard Determinism Compatibilism. Soft Determinism. Hard Incompatibilism. Semicompatibilism. Illusionism. 366 Free Will: The Scandal in Philosophy Illusionism Determinism Hard Determinism Compatibilism Soft Determinism Hard Incompatibilism Impossibilism Valerian Model Semicompatibilism Narrow Incompatibilism

More information

The Problem of Freewill. Blatchford, Robert, Not Guilty

The Problem of Freewill. Blatchford, Robert, Not Guilty The Problem of Freewill Blatchford, Robert, Not Guilty Two Common Sense Beliefs Freewill Thesis: some (though not all) of our actions are performed freely we examines and deliberate about our options we

More information

The Mystery of Free Will

The Mystery of Free Will The Mystery of Free Will What s the mystery exactly? We all think that we have this power called free will... that we have the ability to make our own choices and create our own destiny We think that we

More information

A Taxonomy of Free Will Positions

A Taxonomy of Free Will Positions 58 Free Will: The Scandal in Philosophy Illusionism Determinism Hard Determinism Compatibilism Soft Determinism Hard Incompatibilism Impossibilism Valerian Model Soft Compatibilism A Taxonomy of Free Will

More information

Kane on. FREE WILL and DETERMINISM

Kane on. FREE WILL and DETERMINISM Kane on FREE WILL and DETERMINISM Introduction Ch. 1: The free will problem In Kane s terms on pp. 5-6, determinism involves prior sufficient conditions for what we do. Possible prior conditions include

More information

Libertarian Free Will and Chance

Libertarian Free Will and Chance Libertarian Free Will and Chance 1. The Luck Principle: We have repeatedly seen philosophers claim that indeterminism does not get us free will, since something like the following is true: The Luck Principle

More information

Unit 3. Free Will and Determinism. Monday, November 21, 11

Unit 3. Free Will and Determinism. Monday, November 21, 11 Unit 3 Free Will and Determinism I. Introduction A. What is the problem? Science! Why? 1. The universe is governed by physical laws 2. People are part of the universe Therefore: People are governed by

More information

Free Will and Determinism

Free Will and Determinism Free Will and Determinism Soft determinism you are free to a certain extent, therefore you are still responsible for your choices. Hard determinism humans are controlled by external forces and have no

More information

David Hume. Walter Terence Stace. Soft Determinism. Dan Dennett

David Hume. Walter Terence Stace. Soft Determinism. Dan Dennett David Hume Walter Terence Stace Soft Determinism Dan Dennett 1 Soft determinism Soft determinism combines two claims: i. Causal determinism is true ii. Humans have free will N.B. Soft determinists are

More information

Free Will and the New Atheism

Free Will and the New Atheism Free Will and the New Atheism Katherin A. Rogers University of Delaware T HE NEW ATHEISTS OFTEN DENY the existence of human free will. I am thinking especially of Sam Harris, who has recently published

More information

Folk Fears about Freedom and Responsibility: Determinism vs. Reductionism

Folk Fears about Freedom and Responsibility: Determinism vs. Reductionism Folk Fears about Freedom and Responsibility: Determinism vs. Reductionism EDDY NAHMIAS* 1. Folk Intuitions and Folk Psychology My initial work, with collaborators Stephen Morris, Thomas Nadelhoffer, and

More information

Hard Determinism, Moral Responsibility and Free Will

Hard Determinism, Moral Responsibility and Free Will Boston University From the SelectedWorks of Hyun G Lee 2015 Hard Determinism, Moral Responsibility and Free Will Hyun G Lee, Boston University Available at: https://works.bepress.com/hyun_lee/4/ Hyun Gu

More information

A New Argument Against Compatibilism

A New Argument Against Compatibilism Norwegian University of Life Sciences School of Economics and Business A New Argument Against Compatibilism Stephen Mumford and Rani Lill Anjum Working Papers No. 2/ 2014 ISSN: 2464-1561 A New Argument

More information

Responsibility and Good Reasons

Responsibility and Good Reasons Responsibility and Good Reasons David Hodgson* I have argued elsewhere that respect for human rights requires a robust notion of responsibility, and that this in turn depends on folk-psychological ideas

More information

PRELIMINARY QUIZ OPTIMISTS AND PESSIMISTS OPTIMISTS AND PESSIMISTS THE REACTIVE ATTITUDES OPTIMISTS AND PESSIMISTS 10/18/2016

PRELIMINARY QUIZ OPTIMISTS AND PESSIMISTS OPTIMISTS AND PESSIMISTS THE REACTIVE ATTITUDES OPTIMISTS AND PESSIMISTS 10/18/2016 PHILOSOPHY A294/H295: FREE WILL IN THOUGHT AND ACTION DR. BEN BAYER Day 10-11: Strawson s Reactive Attitudes Compatibilism PRELIMINARY QUIZ Graded iclicker QUIZ: : Select the best single answer (1) Which

More information

Four Views on Free Will. John Martin Fischer, Robert Kane, Derk Pereboom, and Manuel Vargas

Four Views on Free Will. John Martin Fischer, Robert Kane, Derk Pereboom, and Manuel Vargas Four Views on Free Will John Martin Fischer, Robert Kane, Derk Pereboom, and Manuel Vargas Contents Notes on Contributors Acknowledgments vi viii A Brief Introduction to Some Terms and Concepts 1 1 Libertarianism

More information

Free Will and Responsibility PHI 26 TR 2:20-3:45 Library 303a crn#24111 Spring 2014

Free Will and Responsibility PHI 26 TR 2:20-3:45 Library 303a crn#24111 Spring 2014 Free Will and Responsibility PHI 26 TR 2:20-3:45 Library 303a crn#24111 Spring 2014 Instructor: Tony Dardis Office: 207 Heger email: Anthony.B.Dardis@hofstra.edu Office Hours: TR 1-2 or by appt. Overview

More information

Molinism and divine prophecy of free actions

Molinism and divine prophecy of free actions Molinism and divine prophecy of free actions GRAHAM OPPY School of Philosophical, Historical and International Studies, Monash University, Clayton Campus, Wellington Road, Clayton VIC 3800 AUSTRALIA Graham.Oppy@monash.edu

More information

POWERS, NECESSITY, AND DETERMINISM

POWERS, NECESSITY, AND DETERMINISM POWERS, NECESSITY, AND DETERMINISM Thought 3:3 (2014): 225-229 ~Penultimate Draft~ The final publication is available at http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/tht3.139/abstract Abstract: Stephen Mumford

More information

Free Will, Determinism, and Moral Responsibility: An Analysis of Event-Causal Incompatibilism

Free Will, Determinism, and Moral Responsibility: An Analysis of Event-Causal Incompatibilism Macalester College DigitalCommons@Macalester College Philosophy Honors Projects Philosophy Department July 2017 Free Will, Determinism, and Moral Responsibility: An Analysis of Event-Causal Incompatibilism

More information

moral absolutism agents moral responsibility

moral absolutism agents moral responsibility Moral luck Last time we discussed the question of whether there could be such a thing as objectively right actions -- actions which are right, independently of relativization to the standards of any particular

More information

Hence, you and your choices are a product of God's creation Psychological State. Stephen E. Schmid

Hence, you and your choices are a product of God's creation Psychological State. Stephen E. Schmid Questions about Hard Determinism Does Theism Imply Determinism? Assume there is a God and when God created the world God knew all the choices you (and others) were going to make. Hard determinism denies

More information

Free Won't [This Title Was Predetermined] and philosophy. For religious followers, free will is often considered a paradox. If God is all-seeing and

Free Won't [This Title Was Predetermined] and philosophy. For religious followers, free will is often considered a paradox. If God is all-seeing and A. Student Polina Kukar 12U Philosophy Date Free Won't [This Title Was Predetermined] The concept of free will is a matter of intense debate from the perspectives of religion, science, and philosophy.

More information

THE MORAL ARGUMENT. Peter van Inwagen. Introduction, James Petrik

THE MORAL ARGUMENT. Peter van Inwagen. Introduction, James Petrik THE MORAL ARGUMENT Peter van Inwagen Introduction, James Petrik THE HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHICAL DISCUSSIONS of human freedom is closely intertwined with the history of philosophical discussions of moral responsibility.

More information

Free Will. From the Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Galen Strawson. Philosophical Concept

Free Will. From the Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Galen Strawson. Philosophical Concept From the Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy Free Will Galen Strawson Philosophical Concept Free will is the conventional name of a topic that is best discussed without reference to the will. Its central

More information

Could Anyone Justiably Believe Epiphenomenalism?

Could Anyone Justiably Believe Epiphenomenalism? Could Anyone Justiably Believe Epiphenomenalism? Richard Swinburne [Swinburne, Richard, 2011, Could Anyone Justiably Believe Epiphenomenalism?, Journal of Consciousness Studies, vol 18, no 3-4, 2011, pp.196-216.]

More information

If God brought about the Big Bang, did he do that before the Big Bang?

If God brought about the Big Bang, did he do that before the Big Bang? If God brought about the Big Bang, did he do that before the Big Bang? Daniel von Wachter Email: daniel@abc.de replace abc by von-wachter http://von-wachter.de International Academy of Philosophy, Santiago

More information

Answers to Five Questions

Answers to Five Questions Answers to Five Questions In Philosophy of Action: 5 Questions, Aguilar, J & Buckareff, A (eds.) London: Automatic Press. Joshua Knobe [For a volume in which a variety of different philosophers were each

More information

The Platonic tradition and concepts of Freewill

The Platonic tradition and concepts of Freewill The Platonic tradition and concepts of Freewill The existence or otherwise of freewill has been the subject of philosophic exploration for as long as philosophy has existed: and if it exists its nature

More information

De Ethica. A Journal of Philosophical, Theological and Applied Ethics Vol. 1:3 (2014)

De Ethica. A Journal of Philosophical, Theological and Applied Ethics Vol. 1:3 (2014) Shaky Ground William Simkulet The debate surrounding free will and moral responsibility is one of the most intransigent debates in contemporary philosophy - but it does not have to be. At its heart, the

More information

Walter Terence Stace. Soft Determinism

Walter Terence Stace. Soft Determinism Walter Terence Stace Soft Determinism 1 Compatibilism and soft determinism Stace is not perhaps as convinced as d Holbach that determinism is true. (But that s not what makes him a compatibilist.) The

More information

What is the problem?

What is the problem? Unit 3 Freedom What is the problem? Science tells us the universe operates according to consistent and unchanging rules Religion tells us that the universe is subject to the rule of God In either case,

More information

What is the problem?

What is the problem? Unit 3 Freedom What is the problem? Science tells us the universe operates according to consistent and unchanging rules Religion tells us that the universe is subject to the rule of God In either case,

More information

Ted Honderich s Semicompatibilism. Determinism

Ted Honderich s Semicompatibilism. Determinism 278 Free Will: The Scandal in Philosophy Illusionism Determinism Hard Determinism Compatibilism Soft Determinism Hard Incompatibilism Impossibilism Valerian Model Soft Compatibilism Ted Honderich s Determinism

More information

Fischer-Style Compatibilism

Fischer-Style Compatibilism Fischer-Style Compatibilism John Martin Fischer s new collection of essays, Deep Control: Essays on freewill and value (Oxford University Press, 2012), constitutes a trenchant defence of his well-known

More information

Journal of Cognition and Neuroethics

Journal of Cognition and Neuroethics Journal of Cognition and Neuroethics How Not To Think about Free Will Kadri Vihvelin University of Southern California Biography Kadri Vihvelin is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Southern

More information

General Philosophy. Stephen Wright. Office: XVI.3, Jesus College. Michaelmas Overview 2. 2 Course Website 2. 3 Readings 2. 4 Study Questions 3

General Philosophy. Stephen Wright. Office: XVI.3, Jesus College. Michaelmas Overview 2. 2 Course Website 2. 3 Readings 2. 4 Study Questions 3 General Philosophy Stephen Wright Office: XVI.3, Jesus College Michaelmas 2014 Contents 1 Overview 2 2 Course Website 2 3 Readings 2 4 Study Questions 3 5 Doing Philosophy 3 6 Tutorial 1 Scepticism 5 6.1

More information

Chapter 5: Freedom and Determinism

Chapter 5: Freedom and Determinism Chapter 5: Freedom and Determinism At each time t the world is perfectly determinate in all detail. - Let us grant this for the sake of argument. We might want to re-visit this perfectly reasonable assumption

More information

What do Neurosciences Talk About When They Talk About Free Will? Federica Della Grotta

What do Neurosciences Talk About When They Talk About Free Will? Federica Della Grotta RIVISTA INTERNAZIONALE DI FILOSOFIA E PSICOLOGIA DOI: 10.4453/rifp.2015.0011 ISSN 2039-4667; E-ISSN 2239-2629 Vol. 6 (2015), n. 1, pp. 145-160 Ricerche What do Neurosciences Talk About When They Talk About

More information

Department of Philosophy

Department of Philosophy Department of Philosophy Module descriptions 2018/19 Level I (i.e. normally 2 nd Yr.) Modules Please be aware that all modules are subject to availability. If you have any questions about the modules,

More information

Examining the nature of mind. Michael Daniels. A review of Understanding Consciousness by Max Velmans (Routledge, 2000).

Examining the nature of mind. Michael Daniels. A review of Understanding Consciousness by Max Velmans (Routledge, 2000). Examining the nature of mind Michael Daniels A review of Understanding Consciousness by Max Velmans (Routledge, 2000). Max Velmans is Reader in Psychology at Goldsmiths College, University of London. Over

More information

WHY PLANTINGA FAILS TO RECONCILE DIVINE FOREKNOWLEDGE

WHY PLANTINGA FAILS TO RECONCILE DIVINE FOREKNOWLEDGE WHY PLANTINGA FAILS TO RECONCILE DIVINE FOREKNOWLEDGE AND LIBERTARIAN FREE WILL Andrew Rogers KANSAS STATE UNIVERSITY Abstract In this paper I argue that Plantinga fails to reconcile libertarian free will

More information

Compatibilist Objections to Prepunishment

Compatibilist Objections to Prepunishment Florida Philosophical Review Volume X, Issue 1, Summer 2010 7 Compatibilist Objections to Prepunishment Winner of the Outstanding Graduate Paper Award at the 55 th Annual Meeting of the Florida Philosophical

More information

The Consequence Argument

The Consequence Argument 2015.11.16 The Consequence Argument The topic What is free will? Some paradigm cases. (linked to concepts like coercion, action, and esp. praise and blame) The claim that we don t have free will.... Free

More information

Philosophy 1100 Introduction to Ethics. Lecture 3 Survival of Death?

Philosophy 1100 Introduction to Ethics. Lecture 3 Survival of Death? Question 1 Philosophy 1100 Introduction to Ethics Lecture 3 Survival of Death? How important is it to you whether humans survive death? Do you agree or disagree with the following view? Given a choice

More information

Moral Obligation. by Charles G. Finney

Moral Obligation. by Charles G. Finney Moral Obligation by Charles G. Finney The idea of obligation, or of oughtness, is an idea of the pure reason. It is a simple, rational conception, and, strictly speaking, does not admit of a definition,

More information

An Argument for Moral Nihilism

An Argument for Moral Nihilism Syracuse University SURFACE Syracuse University Honors Program Capstone Projects Syracuse University Honors Program Capstone Projects Spring 5-1-2010 An Argument for Moral Nihilism Tommy Fung Follow this

More information

DETERMINISM is the view that all events without exception are effects or, a little

DETERMINISM is the view that all events without exception are effects or, a little DETERMINISM is the view that all events without exception are effects or, a little more carefully, that every event is fully caused by its antecedent conditions or causal circumstances. The conditions

More information

TWO ACCOUNTS OF THE NORMATIVITY OF RATIONALITY

TWO ACCOUNTS OF THE NORMATIVITY OF RATIONALITY DISCUSSION NOTE BY JONATHAN WAY JOURNAL OF ETHICS & SOCIAL PHILOSOPHY DISCUSSION NOTE DECEMBER 2009 URL: WWW.JESP.ORG COPYRIGHT JONATHAN WAY 2009 Two Accounts of the Normativity of Rationality RATIONALITY

More information

College Tutor (Adjunct), St. Catherine s and Worcester Colleges, University of Oxford,

College Tutor (Adjunct), St. Catherine s and Worcester Colleges, University of Oxford, peter.v.forrest@gmail.com pvforrest.wordpress.com PETER V. FORREST AREAS OF SPECIALIZATION Philosophy of Mind, Philosophy of the Cognitive Sciences AREAS OF COMPETENCE Metaphysics, Epistemology, Philosophy

More information

Am I free? Free will vs. determinism

Am I free? Free will vs. determinism Am I free? Free will vs. determinism Our topic today is, for the second day in a row, freedom of the will. More precisely, our topic is the relationship between freedom of the will and determinism, and

More information

Predictability, Causation, and Free Will

Predictability, Causation, and Free Will Predictability, Causation, and Free Will Luke Misenheimer (University of California Berkeley) August 18, 2008 The philosophical debate between compatibilists and incompatibilists about free will and determinism

More information

Bad Luck Once Again. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research Vol. LXXVII No. 3, November 2008 Ó 2008 International Phenomenological Society

Bad Luck Once Again. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research Vol. LXXVII No. 3, November 2008 Ó 2008 International Phenomenological Society Philosophy and Phenomenological Research Vol. LXXVII No. 3, November 2008 Ó 2008 International Phenomenological Society Bad Luck Once Again neil levy Centre for Applied Philosophy and Public Ethics, University

More information

1st Proofs Not for Distribution.

1st Proofs Not for Distribution. 6 CONSCIOUSNESS, FREE WILL, AND MORAL RESPONSIBILITY Gregg D. Caruso In recent decades, with advances in the behavioral, cognitive, and neurosciences, the idea that patterns of human behavior may ultimately

More information

Of Cause and Effect David Hume

Of Cause and Effect David Hume Of Cause and Effect David Hume Of Probability; And of the Idea of Cause and Effect This is all I think necessary to observe concerning those four relations, which are the foundation of science; but as

More information

What would be so bad about not having libertarian free will?

What would be so bad about not having libertarian free will? Nathan Nobis nobs@mail.rochester.edu http://mail.rochester.edu/~nobs/papers/det.pdf ABSTRACT: What would be so bad about not having libertarian free will? Peter van Inwagen argues that unattractive consequences

More information

WHAT MORAL RESPONSIBILITY REQUIRES WILLIAM SIMKULET

WHAT MORAL RESPONSIBILITY REQUIRES WILLIAM SIMKULET WHAT MORAL RESPONSIBILITY REQUIRES BY WILLIAM SIMKULET Submitted to the graduate degree program in Philosophy in the Graduate Faculty of the University of Kansas in partial fulfillment of the requirements

More information

The Self and Other Minds

The Self and Other Minds 170 Great Problems in Philosophy and Physics - Solved? 15 The Self and Other Minds This chapter on the web informationphilosopher.com/mind/ego The Self 171 The Self and Other Minds Celebrating René Descartes,

More information

DRAFT. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Skepticism About Moral Responsibility First published Thu Jan 18, 2018

DRAFT. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Skepticism About Moral Responsibility First published Thu Jan 18, 2018 pdf version of the entry Skepticism About Moral Responsibility https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2018/entries/skepticism-moral-responsibility/ from the Spring 2018 Edition of the Stanford Encyclopedia

More information

Philosophical Perspectives, 14, Action and Freedom, 2000 TRANSFER PRINCIPLES AND MORAL RESPONSIBILITY. Eleonore Stump Saint Louis University

Philosophical Perspectives, 14, Action and Freedom, 2000 TRANSFER PRINCIPLES AND MORAL RESPONSIBILITY. Eleonore Stump Saint Louis University Philosophical Perspectives, 14, Action and Freedom, 2000 TRANSFER PRINCIPLES AND MORAL RESPONSIBILITY Eleonore Stump Saint Louis University John Martin Fischer University of California, Riverside It is

More information

Compatibilism vs. incompatibilism, continued

Compatibilism vs. incompatibilism, continued Compatibilism vs. incompatibilism, continued Jeff Speaks March 24, 2009 1 Arguments for compatibilism............................ 1 1.1 Arguments from the analysis of free will.................. 1 1.2

More information

Journal of Cognition and Neuroethics

Journal of Cognition and Neuroethics Journal of Cognition and Neuroethics Is Neuroscience Relevant to Our Moral Responsibility Practices? Joseph M. Vukov Fordham University Biography Joe Vukov is a PhD candidate in the philosophy department

More information

MANIPULATION AND INDEPENDENCE 1

MANIPULATION AND INDEPENDENCE 1 MANIPULATION AND INDEPENDENCE 1 D. JUSTIN COATES UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO DRAFT AUGUST 3, 2012 1. Recently, many incompatibilists have argued that moral responsibility is incompatible with causal determinism

More information

BOOK REVIEW: Gideon Yaffee, Manifest Activity: Thomas Reid s Theory of Action

BOOK REVIEW: Gideon Yaffee, Manifest Activity: Thomas Reid s Theory of Action University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Faculty Publications - Department of Philosophy Philosophy, Department of 2005 BOOK REVIEW: Gideon Yaffee, Manifest Activity:

More information

Free Will and Will to Power

Free Will and Will to Power Free Will and Will to Power by Mike Hockney Published by Hyperreality Books Copyright Mike Hockney 2014 The right of Mike Hockney to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted in accordance

More information

About free-will. UPPSALA UNIVERSITET Teologiska institutionen Tros- och livsåskådningsvetenskap E

About free-will. UPPSALA UNIVERSITET Teologiska institutionen Tros- och livsåskådningsvetenskap E UPPSALA UNIVERSITET Teologiska institutionen Tros- och livsåskådningsvetenskap E E-uppsats i religionsfilosofi 15hp Handledare: Mikael Stenmark HT 2012 About free-will In search for a philosophical and

More information

Philosophy 203 History of Modern Western Philosophy. Russell Marcus Hamilton College Spring 2014

Philosophy 203 History of Modern Western Philosophy. Russell Marcus Hamilton College Spring 2014 Philosophy 203 History of Modern Western Philosophy Russell Marcus Hamilton College Spring 2014 Class #23 Hume on the Self and Free Will Marcus, Modern Philosophy, Slide 1 Mindreading Video Marcus, Modern

More information

FRANKFURT-TYPE EXAMPLES FLICKERS AND THE GUIDANCE CONTROL

FRANKFURT-TYPE EXAMPLES FLICKERS AND THE GUIDANCE CONTROL FRANKFURT-TYPE EXAMPLES FLICKERS AND THE GUIDANCE CONTROL By Zsolt Ziegler Submitted to Central European University Department of Philosophy In partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of

More information

Courses Taught ( )* Thomas Nadelhoffer

Courses Taught ( )* Thomas Nadelhoffer Dickinson College (2006-present): Courses Taught (2006-2011)* Thomas Nadelhoffer Neuroethics (Fall 2011): In recent decades neuroscientists have made progress toward understanding the neural bases of human

More information

Philosophy Courses Fall 2011

Philosophy Courses Fall 2011 Philosophy Courses Fall 2011 All philosophy courses satisfy the Humanities requirement -- except 120, which counts as one of the two required courses in Math/Logic. Many philosophy courses (e.g., Business

More information

4AANA004 Metaphysics I Syllabus Academic year 2015/16

4AANA004 Metaphysics I Syllabus Academic year 2015/16 School of Arts & Humanities Department of Philosophy 4AANA004 Metaphysics I Syllabus Academic year 2015/16 Basic information Credits: 15 Module Tutor: Robyn Repko Waller Office: 707 Philosophy Building

More information

The belief in the existence of an omniscient, omnipotent and benevolent God is inconsistent with the existence of human suffering. Discuss.

The belief in the existence of an omniscient, omnipotent and benevolent God is inconsistent with the existence of human suffering. Discuss. The belief in the existence of an omniscient, omnipotent and benevolent God is inconsistent with the existence of human suffering. Discuss. Is he willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is not omnipotent.

More information

THE ASSIMILATION ARGUMENT AND THE ROLLBACK ARGUMENT

THE ASSIMILATION ARGUMENT AND THE ROLLBACK ARGUMENT THE ASSIMILATION ARGUMENT AND THE ROLLBACK ARGUMENT Christopher Evan Franklin ~Penultimate Draft~ Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 93:3, (2012): 395-416. For final version go to http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1468-0114.2012.01432.x/abstract

More information

Freedom and Determinism

Freedom and Determinism Freedom and Determinism A N I NTRODUCTION James Petrik O n June 14, 1494, the grand mayor of St. Martin de Laon declared that the penalty for a case of infanticide in which the victim had been suffocated

More information

*Please note that tutorial times and venues will be organised independently with your teaching tutor.

*Please note that tutorial times and venues will be organised independently with your teaching tutor. 4AANA004 METAPHYSICS Syllabus Academic year 2016/17. Basic information Credits: 15 Module tutor: Jessica Leech Office: 707 Consultation time: Monday 1-2, Wednesday 11-12. Semester: 2 Lecture time and venue*:

More information